How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A pickle weight is usually one lump of glass, which leaves very little to say about parts. What changes the question is that this pool is not only weights: it also holds fermenting lids, airlocks, grommets and a stainless coil, and one listing in it is sold as a component rather than as a product. That is the rarest thing on this shelf and it decides this page.
Three of these five are glass rather than steel, which the keyword does not suggest and the pool cannot help. Only one pick puts stainless steel into the brine. The five separate cleanly on parts even so: a component on its own, the same component with its coils, a kit that names three seals, and two single pieces of glass with the grip cast in.
What the table cannot tell you is where a perished silicone airlock comes from. None of these five sells one, and the single component purchase here is lids with their airlocks already fitted rather than the airlock alone. Three of the five are glass despite what the keyword implies, and two publish a figure that cannot be used, so the ranking here rests on what each maker names rather than on what it measures.
The Only Part You Can Buy on Its Own
Trellis + Co. Sells the Lids Without the Coils
One listing in this pool is not a product at all in the usual sense. The Trellis lids-only variation is three 316 stainless fermentation lids with waterless silicone airlocks, and its first bullet states in capitals that it does not include the PickleHelix coils or a mason jar. That is a component offered on its own, which is what access to parts actually means on a shelf like this.
It publishes 0.22 lb, the lightest figure here and exactly what three lids ought to weigh, with fields of 5.0 by 9.0 by 1.5 in. It states the lids fit most wide mouth canning and mason jars, and that the one-way valves are maintenance-free with no water to top off during a long ferment. It holds nothing down, so a weight has to come from elsewhere.
The Coil That Changes Length
The full Trellis kit is the same lids plus three PickleHelix coils, and the coil is the only part on this page stated to change shape. Its bullet states that the coils are extremely durable, adjust automatically to changing ferment volumes and compress down to the mere thickness of a glass weight if necessary. A ferment settles as it works, and a spring follows it down.
The same bullet states that the coil is easily removed for a quick bite and will not displace brine and cause overflows the way a glass weight does, which is a specific argument against the other four picks here. It publishes 0.85 lb and 316 stainless steel in the brine. Its dimension fields read 15.0 by 10.0 by 10.0 in, which cannot describe three lids and three springs, and the height was flagged.
Seals Named Piece by Piece
Honeydak Names the Ring, the Grommet and the Airlock
Honeydak is the only listing here that takes its own seal apart in writing. Its contents bullet names six jars, six stainless lids with silicone rings, six weights, six airlocks, six silicone grommets, six label stickers and a marking pen. A later bullet divides the work between them: the rings and grommets provide the seal, while the grommets and airlocks regulate airflow.
It then states that the airlocks are easy to install and remove and that the silicone components are easy to clean and dishwasher-safe along with the lids, which makes it the most serviceable of the five on paper. What it never does is say what the fermenting weights themselves are made of, having named glass for the jars and stainless steel for the lids in the same breath.
What a Waterless Valve Removes
Both Trellis listings publish the same argument about the seal, and it is about upkeep rather than hardware. They state that a conventional airlock holds a pool of standing water directly over the food and that theirs does not, being one-way valves they describe as maintenance-free with no need to top off the water during long ferments. They add that this lets jars stack in a cupboard.
Honeydak publishes the opposite approach without the comparison: grommets and airlocks that regulate airflow and relieve pressure, with no statement about water either way. So of these five, two state that their seal needs no servicing, one names its sealing parts without saying whether they do, and two have no seal at all because they are weights rather than systems.
The Weights With Nothing to Separate
Masontops Forms the Grip Into the Glass
Masontops answers the parts question by having none. Its removal bullet states that you pinch a patented handy finger grip and lift the pebble out, and that grip is formed into the same piece of soda lime glass as the weight itself. There is no joint, so nothing loosens and nothing is lost, and there is also nothing to replace if the grip chips.
It states the glass is the same food-safe soda lime glass as mason jars, non-porous and clear, and that the pebbles are handwashable or can go in the top rack of a dishwasher. It publishes 3.31 lb for a pack of eight with no figure for a single pebble. Its dimension fields read 100 by 100 by 50, which the fact sheet reads as millimeters rather than inches.
Glolaurge and a Weight Field of 700 lb
Glolaurge takes the same one-piece approach for a different jar. It is the only pick published for Weck jars and gallon jars rather than wide mouth mason jars, stating a 3.43 inch diameter and a built-in lift handle that works when the weight is wet or slippery. Each weight is stated at 11 to 13 oz, and the pack holds two.
Its weight field reads 700.0 lb, which the fact sheet notes twice: once against the maker’s own 11 to 13 oz each, and once as a grams figure sitting in a pounds slot. Read that way it is a plausible figure for two glass discs. The lesson for a reader is the one this whole page turns on: read the maker’s sentence before the field, because the sentence is usually the one that survives.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
You already own the weights. The Trellis lids-only purchase is three 316 stainless lids with waterless silicone airlocks and states it excludes the coils and the jar. It publishes 0.22 lb and fields of 5.0 by 9.0 by 1.5 in.
You want a weight that follows the ferment down. The Trellis kit adds three PickleHelix coils, stated to adjust to changing volumes and compress to the thickness of a glass weight, in 316 stainless at 0.85 lb.
You want every seal named. Honeydak lists jars, lids, rings, weights, airlocks, grommets, stickers and a pen, states the airlocks install and remove easily, and clears the lids and silicone for a dishwasher on 24 oz jars.
You want nothing that can come apart. Masontops is one piece of soda lime glass with a patented finger grip, handwashable or top rack, supplied eight to a pack at 3.31 lb for the set.
You ferment in Weck or gallon jars. Glolaurge states a 3.43 inch diameter, 11 to 13 oz each and a built-in lift handle, supplied two to a pack. Its 700.0 lb weight field cannot be used.
What We Could Not Verify
Six things a reader buying for access to parts would want, and no listing among these five supplies.
- A replacement silicone airlock, ring or grommet sold on its own by any of the five.
- A coil diameter, free length or compressed length for the PickleHelix, which is described and never measured.
- The material of the Honeydak fermenting weights, where glass and stainless steel are named for the jars and the lids.
- A figure for one Masontops pebble, since the 3.31 lb covers a pack of eight.
- Whether the Trellis lids-only purchase fits the same jars as the coils it excludes.
- Whether any of the glass weights here will fit the jars another of them is sold for.