How the Five Compare on the Numbers
The five picks here are the ones with the most published figures on the fact sheet. Diameter is the clearest split. ZeroPone and Nordic Ware publish a single 9 inch pan. Fensiden publishes a set of 4, 7, 9 and 10 inches. PETITS DESSERTS publishes a set of 4, 7, 9 and 11 inches. Hikolvol publishes a set of 4, 7 and 9 inches. That is the first decision: one pan or a set.
Height is the second split, and fewer makers publish it. ZeroPone publishes 2.6 inches. Nordic Ware publishes 3.1 inches. Fensiden publishes 2.5 inches for the set. PETITS DESSERTS and Hikolvol do not publish a height for their individual pans. Weight is published for four of the five, and ZeroPone is the lightest at 0.68 pounds.
| Specification |
ZeroPone |
Fensiden |
Nordic Ware |
PETITS DESSERTS |
Hikolvol |
| Published sizes |
9 inch |
4, 7, 9, 10 inch |
9 inch |
4, 7, 9, 11 inch |
4, 7, 9 inch |
| Published height |
2.6 inches |
2.5 inches |
3.1 inches |
not published |
not published |
| Published weight |
0.68 pounds |
2.78 pounds |
0.75 pounds |
2.5 pounds |
2 pounds |
| Published capacity |
not published |
not published |
10 cups |
not published |
not published |
| Oven safe limit |
450 F |
450 F |
not published |
450 F |
450 F |
| Material |
Carbon steel |
Carbon steel |
Carbon steel |
Carbon steel |
Carbon steel |
| Latch material |
Stainless steel |
not published |
not published |
not published |
Stainless steel |
| Silicone protector |
No |
Yes |
No |
No |
Yes |
| Extra accessories |
None listed |
Silicone protector |
None listed |
Cake tester, slicer |
Parchment sheets |
The table does not tell you how any pan bakes. Nobody at Lush has used these pans, and no maker publishes a browning result. It also leaves out interior diameters for four of the five picks, and it leaves out an oven safe figure for Nordic Ware. Treat the table as a size and material record, not a performance record.
Single Pans Against Sets
What a single pan gives you
ZeroPone and Nordic Ware each publish one 9 inch pan. ZeroPone lists 0.68 pounds and a 2.6 inch height. Nordic Ware lists 0.75 pounds, a 3.1 inch height and a 10 cup capacity. If your recipes are written for one 9 inch pan, either fits that job, and the published height is the figure that separates them.
A single pan also takes less cabinet space. The published weights are close, so storage is a wash between these two. The real difference is the capacity figure. Nordic Ware publishes 10 cups, and ZeroPone does not publish a capacity at all. If a recipe is written in cups rather than inches, the Nordic Ware figure is the one you can check against it.
What a set gives you
Fensiden, PETITS DESSERTS and Hikolvol each publish a set. Fensiden covers 4, 7, 9 and 10 inches. PETITS DESSERTS covers 4, 7, 9 and 11 inches. Hikolvol covers 4, 7 and 9 inches. The 4 inch pan in each set suits a single serving, and the 9 inch pan suits a standard cheesecake.
The sets differ in published weight. Hikolvol lists 2 pounds for three pans. PETITS DESSERTS lists 2.5 pounds for four pans. Fensiden lists 2.78 pounds for four pans. The Fensiden set is the heaviest published figure here, and it is also the only set that publishes a 10 inch pan rather than an 11 inch pan.
Materials, Latches and Care
Published materials
Carbon steel is published for all five picks. ZeroPone describes double layer carbon steel and a stainless steel latch. Hikolvol also publishes a stainless steel latch. Nordic Ware publishes a charcoal finish and states its nonstick surface is made without PFOA. The other makers describe a nonstick coating without naming a PFOA position on this sheet.
Coating claims are not the same as coating results. No maker here publishes a release test or a number of baking cycles. What is published is the material and the care instruction. ZeroPone, PETITS DESSERTS and HIWARE recommend hand washing. The other picks do not publish a cleaning instruction on this sheet.
Latches and bases
Every pick publishes a spring latch and a removable base. ZeroPone describes a honeycomb texture base. Fensiden describes a textured base for uniform heat conductivity. Nordic Ware publishes a sturdy buckle and a removable band. PETITS DESSERTS and Hikolvol describe a lock and unlock latch with a removable bottom.
None of these descriptions is a measurement. They are maker statements about design. The published figures that matter for fit are still diameter and height, and for the Nordic Ware pan, the 10 cup capacity. Everything else is a description of how the pan is put together.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
You bake one standard cheesecake. The ZeroPone 9 inch pan publishes a 9 inch diameter, a 2.6 inch height and a 0.68 pound weight. It is the lightest published pan here and the simplest single pan pick.
You want a deep pan with a published capacity. The Nordic Ware pan publishes a 3.1 inch height and a 10 cup capacity, the only capacity figure in this group. It publishes the largest height among the five picks.
You bake several sizes and want a 10 inch pan. The Fensiden set publishes 4, 7, 9 and 10 inch pans and includes a silicone protector for water bath baking. It is the heaviest published set here at 2.78 pounds.
You want the largest published pan. The PETITS DESSERTS set publishes an 11 inch pan, the only one in this group, along with 4, 7 and 9 inch pans and a cake tester and slicer.
You want a compact three pan set. The Hikolvol set publishes 4, 7 and 9 inch pans at 2 pounds, with a silicone protector and 50 parchment sheets. It is lighter than the other two sets.
What We Could Not Verify
Several figures are missing from the fact sheet. We list them rather than estimate.
- Individual pan heights for the Fensiden, PETITS DESSERTS and Hikolvol sets are not published.
- An oven safe temperature for the Nordic Ware pan is not published.
- A weight for the Farberware pan is not published, so it was left out of the five picks.
- Interior diameters for the ZeroPone, Fensiden, PETITS DESSERTS and Hikolvol pans are not published.
- A capacity in cups for any pan except Nordic Ware is not published.
- Latch material for the Fensiden, Nordic Ware and PETITS DESSERTS pans is not published.