How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Seven listings sit on the fact sheet for this pool and two of them are not on the page. Easy Fermenter describes its lid as durable food safe plastic and never names the material of the leak proof gasket, which on a page about silicone is the one sentence that would have mattered. Fermentaholics fits a 110 mm gallon jar rather than a wide mouth mason jar, so it is answering a different question.
What decides this page is which part of the lid is actually silicone. Masontops, OAKDOLCHE and Mfacoy each describe a one piece cap made of silicone, so on those three the silicone is the lid. JILLMO and Xelyra both publish stainless steel lids with BPA free plastic airlocks and silicone rings or grommets, so the silicone is a gasket sitting between two harder parts.
Two rows in that table need reading slowly. Mfacoy publishes 3.31 by 3.31 by 0.1 in, and a tenth of an inch cannot hold the one way valve and the date tracker the same listing describes, so that third figure is a lid face rather than a lid. JILLMO arrives as a pack of four, so its dimension fields were moved to the package row. What no listing states anywhere is how thick the silicone is, or how soft.
What Actually Touches the Ferment
Three Caps Where the Silicone Is the Whole Lid
Masontops states that its Pickle Pipes are made of premium quality food safe silicone, that they are BPA free and contain no phthalates, and that they can go into the dishwasher along with the wide mouth jars. It is a one piece waterless valve with nothing to assemble and nothing to lose, and the listing calls the low profile a storage feature in its own right.
OAKDOLCHE states 100 percent food grade silicone, free of harmful substances, and safe for direct contact with sauces, pickles, baby food, beverages and all kinds of food. That is the broadest food contact claim in the pool, and OAKDOLCHE is also the only listing here that names refrigeration and freezing. Mfacoy states 100 percent BPA free silicone and adds that its lids will not crack or warp.
Two Kits Where the Silicone Is Only a Seal
JILLMO publishes a different build entirely. Four stainless steel lids arrive with seals, four BPA free airlocks and four silicone grommets, so three materials share one jar and only the grommet is silicone. Xelyra is assembled the same way, from stainless steel lids, BPA free plastic airlocks and food grade silicone rings and grommets, and it supplies six complete sets rather than four.
Neither listing claims the silicone touches the ferment, and on a jar of sauerkraut it largely does not: the brine sits under a steel lid while the grommet seals the airlock stem. That is not a worse design, and on a long ferment a real airlock is the whole point. It does mean the food grade silicone wording in both listings is about a seal and not about a surface.
Where the Published Figures Run Out
Only Two of the Five Publish a Weight
Mfacoy publishes 0.24 lb and JILLMO publishes 0.6 lb. Masontops, OAKDOLCHE and Xelyra publish no weight at all. The Masontops figure that does sit in the data is too near zero to be four silicone caps and was dropped rather than quoted here, and no bullet in that listing puts a mass on the product either, so the gap is real and not a reading error.
Three of the five having no mass figure is not much of a loss on a lid. It matters more that the two figures do not measure the same thing: the JILLMO 0.6 lb covers four steel lids with four airlocks and four grommets, while the Mfacoy 0.24 lb covers silicone caps. Set side by side those two numbers describe the build, not the lid.
A Carton, a Jar Mouth, and a Lid Face
The JILLMO dimension fields describe the box. They were moved to a package row and read 3.38 by 3.38 by 1.18 in for the pack of four, and the first of those numbers is also the figure the maker states in words, since it says standard wide mouth jars measure 3.38 in, or 86 mm. OAKDOLCHE gives the same jar mouth as 86 mm and publishes no dimensions of its own.
Easy Fermenter, which is not on the page, shows the same pattern with a package of 4.5 by 4 by 5.5 in. Masontops is the one pick whose three fields survive, at 0.5 by 3.3 by 3.3 in, and even there the listing never says which of the three is the height. Xelyra publishes no dimension and no weight, so its size rests on the wide mouth standard it names.
Care, Spares, and the Part That Sets the Rule
Four Dishwasher Sentences, Four Different Scopes
Masontops says the Pickle Pipes can go into the dishwasher along with the jars. OAKDOLCHE says dishwasher safe for peace of mind. Mfacoy calls its lids dishwasher safe inside the same bullet that claims the silicone. Fermentaholics, which is not on the page, is the only listing in the pool that lists every component by name as dishwasher safe: lid, gasket, grommet and airlock.
JILLMO does the opposite and is the more useful sentence for it. It tells buyers to wash the plastic airlocks with warm water only and not to boil them, which is a limit on one part of a kit whose lid is steel. Xelyra says its set is simple to assemble and easy to rinse after each batch, then stops. Not one of the five gives a temperature.
What Happens When a Grommet Splits
Only one of the five answers that. JILLMO includes extra silicone grommets and states a one year replacement for damaged small parts, which on a four component kit is the difference between a dead set and a two minute repair. Xelyra names the same four component types on every jar and says nothing whatever about spares, replacements or where a new ring would come from.
The one piece caps do not have the problem to solve. Masontops, OAKDOLCHE and Mfacoy each survive as one object or fail as one object, and none of the three publishes a warranty, a spare or a replacement route. That is the honest trade behind a silicone cap: fewer parts to lose, and nothing at all to replace on the day the valve stops venting.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
A first jar of sauerkraut. Masontops, for a one piece food safe silicone cap with a waterless self venting valve, no phthalates, dishwasher safe alongside the jars, and a low profile the maker presents as a cupboard and drawer feature.
Four jars of different things at once. OAKDOLCHE, for 100 percent food grade silicone rated for direct contact with sauces, pickles, baby food and beverages, an 86 mm wide mouth fit, colors that tell one jar from another, and fridge and freezer use.
Losing track of when a batch started. Mfacoy, for a date tracker set into a silicone lid that also carries the one way valve, with 100 percent BPA free silicone, a dishwasher safe claim, and a stated promise the lid will not crack or warp.
Long ferments with a real airlock. JILLMO, for four stainless steel lids with seals, four BPA free airlocks and four silicone grommets, a stated 8 oz to 64 oz jar range, spare grommets and a one year replacement on small parts.
Six jars running on a shelf. Xelyra, for six complete sets of steel lid, food grade silicone ring, plastic airlock and grommet, each lid carrying a date tracker, covering wide mouth jars from 4 oz to 64 oz.
What We Could Not Verify
Every figure above comes from the maker’s own listing text. These are the things we went looking for and could not source in any of them.
- Not one of the five publishes a thickness or a hardness for the silicone, so how much a cap will stretch over a wide mouth rim is unknown before it arrives.
- Masontops, OAKDOLCHE and Xelyra publish no weight at all, and the one weight figure in the Masontops data is too near zero to describe four caps.
- OAKDOLCHE and Xelyra publish no dimensions of any kind, so the height each adds above the jar rim cannot be compared against the Masontops and Mfacoy figures.
- Only JILLMO and Xelyra state which jar sizes they cover. Masontops, OAKDOLCHE and Mfacoy say wide mouth and leave the range open.
- None of the five gives a water temperature or a dishwasher cycle, and JILLMO’s instruction not to boil the airlocks is the only heat limit published anywhere in the pool.
- Only JILLMO publishes a route to a spare part, so on the other four the cost of one split ring or one failed valve is not answerable from the listing.