On a weeknight the tray is not the point. The point is how many trips you make to the grill and how many things come back to the sink. So the figures that decide this page are the stated depth, which controls whether you can marinate in the tray you carry, the stated footprint, and the number of pieces in the set.
Stated depths run from 0.1 inches for the Tovolo pair to 2.8 inches for the Outset station. Published weights run from 1.03 pounds for the Outset, the lightest of the five, to 4.06 pounds for the Tiangrid stainless set, the heaviest of the five. Footprints run from 10.5 by 10.5 inches to 18.1 by 14.5 inches.
| Specification |
Tovolo |
Outset |
Cuisinart CPK-210 |
ECOIOU |
Tiangrid |
| Stated tray footprint |
10.5 by 10.5 inches |
17.7 by 11 inches |
18.1 by 14.5 inches |
17.5 by 11 inches |
15.75 by 9.65 inches |
| Stated depth |
0.1 inches |
2.8 inches |
0.6 inches in a bullet, 0.8 in the field |
2 inches |
2.76, 1.97 and 1.18 inches |
| Published weight |
1.7 pounds |
1.03 pounds |
2.0 pounds |
3.88 pounds |
4.06 pounds |
| Weight in the maker’s own words |
not published |
1.03 pounds |
not published |
not published |
not published |
| Pieces you have to wash |
Two trays |
One tray |
Two trays |
Two trays and a lid |
Four pieces |
| Stated material |
BPA free melamine |
Polypropylene |
Shatter resistant melamine |
BPA free melamine |
Stainless steel with a bamboo board |
| Lid stated |
not published |
not published |
not published |
Yes, a tight lid |
not published |
| Stated dishwasher use |
Yes, both trays |
Yes |
Yes, both trays |
Yes |
Yes, every part |
| Nesting or stacking stated |
Trays separate and nest |
not applicable, one tray |
Trays nest together |
Trays nest |
Trays are stackable |
| Extra feature stated |
Ridges, grooves and a textured bottom |
Skewer notches and a side compartment |
not published |
Textured base and raised edges |
Bamboo board, 11.8 by 7.9 inches |
| Color coding stated |
Black and white |
not published |
Black and red |
Black and red |
not published |
| Oven or heat limit stated |
not published |
not published |
not published |
not published |
not published |
The table cannot tell you how a melamine tray holds up after a season of hot meat landing on it, because no listing here publishes a heat limit and nothing was measured. It cannot tell you the usable volume of a deep tray either, since depth is published and capacity is not. Nor does any of the five state how much weight its tray will carry before it flexes.
Depth Decides How Many Dishes You Wash
From 0.1 inches to 2.8
The Tovolo pair states 0.1 inches of depth. That is a flat plate with ridges, and it is exactly right for carrying four burgers out and four burgers back. It is not a marinating vessel. The Outset station states 2.8 inches, deep enough to hold a marinade with the food in it, and it is a single tray rather than a pair.
Between them, ECOIOU states 2 inches and the Cuisinart states 0.6 inches in its own bullet. The Tiangrid set publishes three separate depths, 2.76 inches and 1.97 inches for its two deep trays and 1.18 inches for the shallow one, so the same set covers both jobs. That is the only pick here that publishes a depth for each piece.
Marinating in the tray you carry
The weeknight argument for a deep tray is that the marinating dish and the carrying dish become one object. ECOIOU states a 2 inch red prep tray deep enough for steaks or kabobs, with a tight lid so nothing leaks on the way out. That is one tray and one lid instead of a bowl, a plate and a sheet of foil.
The Outset takes the same idea further and drops the second tray entirely. It states a single polypropylene station carried with one hand, with notches that hold bamboo or metal skewers and a side compartment for sauces and tools. Nothing here nests with it, because there is nothing to nest, and after dinner there is one thing in the sink.
Surface Area Against Counter Space
Stated footprints
The Cuisinart CPK-210 states 18.1 by 14.5 inches, the largest stated surface of the five, and that is a lot of counter for a Tuesday. The Outset and ECOIOU trays state 17.7 by 11 inches and 17.5 by 11 inches, within half an inch of each other. Tiangrid states 15.75 by 9.65 inches per tray, the smallest of the long rectangles.
Tovolo is the outlier on shape. It states 10.5 by 10.5 inches, a square rather than a rectangle, which fits a narrow counter run that a seventeen inch tray will not. For one or two people it is the pick that costs least counter, and for a family sized tray of chicken thighs it is the pick that runs out of room first.
Where the fields and the bullets disagree
The Cuisinart CPK-210 publishes a height field of 0.8 inches and states 0.6 inches in its own durable construction bullet. Neither figure changes what the tray is for, and the disagreement is worth naming because it shows the fields are entered loosely. This page quotes the bullet as the maker’s own sentence and shows both in the table.
Tiangrid is the odder case. Its title states a 4 Pcs set and its first bullet calls it a 3-In-1 Set, then lists four items: two deep stainless trays, a shallow serving tray and a bamboo cutting board. The item list is consistent with four and the phrase is not, so this page counts the pieces listed rather than the label.
Material, Pieces and Cleanup
Melamine, polypropylene and stainless
Three of the five are melamine. Tovolo states BPA free melamine that resists stains, odors and flavors. Cuisinart states shatter resistant melamine that will not get hot to the touch under finished meat. ECOIOU states 100 percent melamine with the same claim. None of the three states a temperature at which that stops being true.
Outset states polypropylene, and Tiangrid states stainless steel trays with a bamboo cutting board. The stainless set is the only one that could take a hot pan, though its own listing never says so. It is also the only pick with a wood component, and the listing says the trays are dishwasher safe without singling out the bamboo board.
How many pieces come back dirty
This is the figure a weeknight actually turns on. Outset gives you one tray. Tovolo and Cuisinart give you two. ECOIOU gives you two trays and a lid. Tiangrid gives you four pieces, one of which is a bamboo board that most people will not put in a machine whatever the listing says.
All five state dishwasher safe, which for once is unanimous, and Tiangrid states that every part of the set is. The trade is simply volume: a four piece stainless set is the most capable thing on this page and also the most washing up, and a single polypropylene station is the least of both. Pick the end of that trade you want on a Wednesday.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
Two people, narrow counter. The Tovolo pair states 10.5 by 10.5 inches and 0.1 inches of depth, with ridges and a textured bottom, in black and white melamine. It publishes 1.7 pounds and both trays are stated dishwasher safe.
One tray, one trip, one wash. The Outset station states 17.7 by 11 by 2.8 inches and 1.03 pounds in its own bullet, the lightest of the five. It adds skewer notches and a side compartment, and is carried one handed in polypropylene.
A full tray of food. The Cuisinart CPK-210 states 18.1 by 14.5 inches, the largest stated surface here, in shatter resistant melamine with color coded black and red trays that nest. It publishes 2.0 pounds and states 0.6 inches of depth.
Marinating and carrying in one dish. ECOIOU states 17.5 by 11 by 2 inches with a tight lid and raised edges, in BPA free melamine. It publishes 3.88 pounds for two trays and a lid, and states the trays nest for storage.
Stainless, and a board with it. The Tiangrid set states two deep trays at 2.76 and 1.97 inches, a shallow tray at 1.18 inches and an 11.8 by 7.9 inch bamboo board. It publishes 4.06 pounds, the heaviest of the five.
What We Could Not Verify
These are the figures a weeknight cook would want, and that none of these listings supplies.
- A heat limit for any of the three melamine picks, despite the claim that they stay cool under grilled meat.
- A load rating for any of the five, so tray flex under a whole chicken is unknown.
- Usable volume for the deep Outset, ECOIOU and Tiangrid trays, published only as a depth.
- Whether the Tiangrid bamboo board is dishwasher safe, since only the set as a whole is named.
- The stainless grade of the Tiangrid trays, which the listing never states.
- Any stated thickness for the melamine trays, so none of the shatter claims can be compared.