How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Every one of these five listings uses the word nonstick, and it means three different things. Two describe a food grade coating applied over steel, with hand washing to protect it. Two describe uncoated stainless steel using nonstick language and name no coating anywhere. One of those two supplies 50 paper liners, which is a mechanism rather than a surface.
The consequence shows up in the oven row. The three coated pans are rated at 450 degrees F, which is the usual ceiling for a nonstick coating. The uncoated 304 stainless pick publishes 500 degrees F and adds a pressure cooker. Nobody explains the relationship and the pattern holds across the pool.
What the table cannot settle is how thick any coating is or how many coats it has. Not one listing in this pool publishes either figure, which means a coated pan’s durability is entirely a matter of the washing instruction and the scratch resistance claim that comes with it.
The Two Pans With a Real Coating
Farberware Explains Its Own Claim
Farberware’s second bullet is the most carefully written sentence in this pool. The pan is responsibly made without PFAS, PFOA, lead or cadmium, and then, rather than leaving that absolute, the listing states that the design does not involve intentionally adding any of those substances to the interior nonstick coating, since they may otherwise be present in the environment.
That is a hedge and it is also honesty: it tells you what the maker controls. The rest of the listing is thin. Oven safe to 450 degrees F, heavy duty construction stated to resist warping and reduce hot spots, fields of 9.5 by 9.5 by 3.0 inches, no weight, no washing instruction and no material named under the coating.
ZeroPone Names the Coating and the Base
ZeroPone publishes a food grade non stick coating over double layer carbon steel stated not to rust, with stainless steel spring latches and a removable honeycomb textured base described as spreading heat evenly. It states its own size, 9 inch diameter and 2.6 inch height, and 450 degrees Fahrenheit, and it publishes 0.68 lb.
It also states hand wash only, to protect the coating, which is the cost of that surface. And it states that the material heats quickly and evenly in the microwave or oven. This page reports that claim as the maker’s without repeating it as advice, on a pan made of carbon steel with steel latches.
Coated in Three Sizes, or Not Coated at All
Wilton Publishes Every Pan and Every Rule
Wilton is the only coated pick here that gives you three pans and measures all of them: 8 by 2.6 inches, 9 by 2.75 inches and 10 by 2.75 inches. It states a nonstick coating, describes it as scratch resistant, states the set is made without PFAS, and rates the pans oven safe up to 450 degrees F, with extended handles for lifting a loaded pan.
Its care bullet is the strictest on this page: hand wash in warm soapy water before first use and after each use, and avoid abrasive cleaners or metal utensils to protect the nonstick finish. A scratch resistant coating that bans metal utensils is a coating you are being asked to look after, and the listing is straightforward about it.
E-Gtong Calls Bare Steel Nonstick
E-Gtong publishes food grade 304 stainless steel, oven safe up to 500 degrees F, pressure cooker compatible and dishwasher safe, with a reinforced removable base. Its third bullet then describes a leak proof and non stick design that prevents batter leaking, suitable for water bath baking and thick caramel recipes. No coating is named anywhere in the listing.
There is nothing wrong with polished stainless steel releasing a cheesecake reasonably well, and the 500 degrees F figure is the highest in this pool precisely because there is no coating to protect. What the listing should not be read as promising is a coated surface. Its dimension fields, 0.39 inches on all three axes, are a placeholder, and its own words give 9 inches.
Paper Instead of a Surface
Fifty Liners, Measured to Match
Pvyzendola takes the fourth position available. Its surface bullet describes a leak resistant, nonstick style structure, which is a phrase rather than a coating, and its next bullet supplies 50 silicone oil paper liners to support cleaner release and keep the base easier to wipe. The liners are the nonstick, and they are consumable.
It is also the most precisely measured pan on this page. Two size options are published to three decimal places: 8.858 by 2.559 inches with 8.661 inch liners, or 10.236 by 2.559 inches with 9.449 inch liners. Those figures are conversions from metric, which is why they are so fine, and they at least tell you which liner belongs to which pan.
What Is Missing From Both Steel Listings
Neither uncoated pick publishes a washing instruction beyond E-Gtong’s dishwasher line, and Pvyzendola publishes no oven temperature at all, which on a stainless pan sold for oven and pressure cooker use is the one figure a baker needs. Its fields, 2.6 by 9.0 by 2.75 inches, match neither of its two published sizes exactly.
Both are lighter on paper than the coated pans, at 0.55 lb and 0.8 lb against 0.68 lb for the coated ZeroPone, and two of the three coated picks publish no weight at all. On this pool weight is the least reliable figure and the surface claim is the one worth reading twice.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
A coating with a base that bakes evenly. ZeroPone, a 9 inch pan stated 2.6 inches high in double layer carbon steel with a food grade nonstick coating, stainless latches and a honeycomb textured removable base, 450 degrees Fahrenheit, hand wash only, at 0.68 lb.
Knowing what the coating excludes. Farberware, a 9 inch nonstick pan published at 9.5 x 9.5 x 3.0 in and oven safe to 450 degrees F, stated made without PFAS, PFOA, lead or cadmium with the scope of that claim spelled out.
Three coated pans and three measurements. Wilton, 8 by 2.6, 9 by 2.75 and 10 by 2.75 inch pans with extended handles, made without PFAS, scratch resistant and oven safe to 450 degrees F, hand washed with no abrasives or metal utensils.
Liners rather than a coating. Pvyzendola, a stainless pan at 8.858 by 2.559 inches or 10.236 by 2.559 inches described as a nonstick style structure, supplied with 50 silicone oil paper liners cut to 8.661 or 9.449 inches, at 0.55 lb.
The hottest oven and no coating to lose. E-Gtong, a 9 inch pan in food grade 304 stainless steel published oven safe to 500 degrees F, pressure cooker compatible and dishwasher safe, at 0.8 lb, with a reinforced removable base.
What We Could Not Verify
Every figure above comes from the maker’s own listing text. These are the things we went looking for and could not source in any of them.
- No listing publishes a coating thickness or a number of coats.
- Two listings describe an uncoated steel pan as nonstick without naming any coating.
- Three of the five publish no list of substances their surface is free of.
- Pvyzendola publishes no oven temperature, on a pan sold for oven and pressure cooker use.
- E-Gtong’s dimension fields read 0.39 inches on every axis, so only its own words give a size.
- No listing publishes a capacity in cups, so the sizes cannot be compared by volume.