Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Organization

Best Knife Drawer Inserts That Publish the Opening They Need

The deciding specification is the minimum drawer interior each maker states, which is not the same figure as the height of the insert itself.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

Compared the sixteen knife insert listings on the fact sheet by the drawer opening each manufacturer says it requires, alongside its own published size.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. Utoplike In-drawer Knife Block Bamboo Kitchen Knives...
    Best for a stated opening on all three sides

    Utoplike In-drawer Knife Block Bamboo Kitchen Knives...

    Asks for more than 17.1 by 12.7 inches and over 2.3 inches of height.

    • Utoplike
    • 16 Holder
    • 2.4 lb
  2. NIUXX Knife Drawer Organizer
    Best for twenty knives and a stated clearance

    NIUXX Knife Drawer Organizer

    Twenty slots plus a rod, on a published 16.7 by 11.8 inch minimum.

    • NIUXX
    • 20 Holder
    • 2.47 lb
  3. MAD SHARK 2-in-1 Knife Holder Drawer
    Best for knives and cutlery under one lid

    MAD SHARK 2-in-1 Knife Holder Drawer

    Publishes its own size and the 15 by 9 by 2.8 inch drawer it needs.

    • MAD SHARK
    • 10 holder
    • 3.3 lb
  4. Joseph Joseph DrawerStore Knife Organizer
    Best for a shallow run with short blades

    Joseph Joseph DrawerStore Knife Organizer

    Blades up to 9 inches and a stated minimum drawer height of 3 inches.

    • Joseph Joseph
    • Compact
    • 0.6 lb
  5. Bambüsi Knife Drawer Organizer 16 Slot In-Drawer Kni...
    Best for a maker that explains the trade

    Bambüsi Knife Drawer Organizer 16 Slot In-Drawer Kni...

    States a 17 inch drawer holds 11 knives and a 22 inch drawer all 16.

    • Bambüsi
    • 17" x 5.3" x 2"
    • 2.5 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
Utoplike In-drawer Knife Block Bamboo Kitchen Knives... Utoplike 16 Holder 2.4 lb Best for a stated opening on all three sides
NIUXX Knife Drawer Organizer NIUXX 20 Holder 2.47 lb Best for twenty knives and a stated clearance
MAD SHARK 2-in-1 Knife Holder Drawer MAD SHARK 10 holder 3.3 lb Best for knives and cutlery under one lid
Joseph Joseph DrawerStore Knife Organizer Joseph Joseph Compact 0.6 lb Best for a shallow run with short blades
Bambüsi Knife Drawer Organizer 16 Slot In-Drawer Kni... Bambüsi 17" x 5.3" x 2" 2.5 lb Best for a maker that explains the trade

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for a stated opening on all three sides

Utoplike In-drawer Knife Block Bamboo Kitchen Knives...

Asks for more than 17.1 by 12.7 inches and over 2.3 inches of height.

  • For it
  • Publishes the required opening on all three axes: an inner size larger than 17.1 inches deep by 12.7 wide, and a height greater than 2.3 inches
  • Publishes its own size separately, 16.6 by 12.2 by 1.8 inches, so the clearance gap is visible rather than implied
  • Carved grooves and angled handle support published, with the maker stating knives cannot shoot out of the back of the block if the drawer is slammed
  • Publishes that the design keeps knife tips from pointing up, which is the safety detail a drawer insert exists for
  • Against it
  • Its dimension fields read 12.2 by 16.6 by 2.0 inches against the maker's own 16.6 by 12.2 by 1.8, so the height disagrees by two tenths
  • It needs 12.7 inches of width, which is more than half the listings in this pool ask for
  • Publishes 2.4 pounds and no statement about washing it
2 Best for twenty knives and a stated clearance

NIUXX Knife Drawer Organizer

Twenty slots plus a rod, on a published 16.7 by 11.8 inch minimum.

  • For it
  • Publishes both figures in one place: the insert at 16.5 inches deep by 11.8 wide by 2 high, and the drawer it needs at more than 16.7 by 11.8 with a height greater than 2
  • Twenty slots published, plus a place for one sharpening rod, the highest slot count here
  • Publishes a blade length limit, under 10.4 inches, which most listings in this pool leave out
  • Publishes 2.47 pounds with removable slots for cleaning
  • Against it
  • The stated drawer depth, 16.7 inches, is only two tenths more than the insert itself, which leaves no margin for a drawer stop
  • Its dimension fields read 11.8 by 17.0 by 2.0 inches while the maker says 16.5 deep, so the depth disagrees
  • No washing statement published
3 Best for knives and cutlery under one lid

MAD SHARK 2-in-1 Knife Holder Drawer

Publishes its own size and the 15 by 9 by 2.8 inch drawer it needs.

  • For it
  • Publishes its own size at 14.56 by 8.66 by 2.67 inches and the drawer it needs at 15 by 9 by 2.8 inches, the clearest pairing in this pool
  • A clear lid published over the tray, so the insert doubles as a silverware organizer
  • Ten knife slots published alongside cutlery compartments, so one insert covers two jobs
  • The stated clearance leaves a margin on all three sides rather than the two tenths some listings allow
  • Against it
  • Publishes 3.3 pounds, the heaviest of these five, for a 10 slot insert
  • Ten slots is the lowest capacity here apart from the nine knife Joseph Joseph
  • No blade length limit published, so how long a knife may be is unstated

Who should skip this: Skip this if weight matters: at 3.3 lb it is the heaviest of the five published weights.

4 Best for a shallow run with short blades

Joseph Joseph DrawerStore Knife Organizer

Blades up to 9 inches and a stated minimum drawer height of 3 inches.

  • For it
  • Publishes a blade limit and a drawer limit together: blades up to 9 inches and drawers with a minimum height of 3 inches
  • Publishes its own dimensions plainly as 15.5 by 5.5 by 3 inches, and the two figures agree with the fields
  • Publishes 0.6 pounds, the lightest of these five, so it lifts out with one hand for cleaning
  • At 5.5 inches wide it asks for the least width of these five, which suits a narrow run
  • Against it
  • Holds up to 9 knives, the lowest published capacity in this shortlist
  • The 3 inch minimum drawer height is the highest requirement of these five, so a low drawer rules it out
  • No sharpener slot and no cutlery compartment published
5 Best for a maker that explains the trade

Bambüsi Knife Drawer Organizer 16 Slot In-Drawer Kni...

States a 17 inch drawer holds 11 knives and a 22 inch drawer all 16.

  • For it
  • The only listing in this pool to publish how capacity changes with the drawer: a 17 inch drawer holds 11 knives, a 22 inch drawer fits all 16
  • Publishes its own size as 17 by 5.3 by 2 inches and asks you to leave room above the 2 inch base for the handles
  • One piece construction joined with wood dowels and published as arriving with no assembly
  • Publishes 2.5 pounds and states the weight is what keeps it from sliding in the drawer
  • Against it
  • The required clearance above the base is described in words rather than given as a figure
  • Sixteen slots only work in a 22 inch drawer, which is longer than most kitchen runs
  • No washing statement and no blade length limit published

Who should skip this: Skip this if you want to put it straight in the dishwasher: the listing says it is not dishwasher safe.

Our verdict

An under-cabinet run is a fixed opening, and most of these listings publish only their own dimensions, which is the wrong figure: knife handles sit above the base. Five makers publish the opening instead. Utoplike asks for more than 17.1 inches deep by 12.7 wide and over 2.3 inches high on a base only 1.8 inches tall. NIUXX asks for 16.7 by 11.8 and over 2 inches. MAD SHARK, Joseph Joseph and Bambusi all publish a required clearance too.

“The base is two inches. The handles are not.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

The insert height is not the clearance Utoplike publishes a 1.8 inch base and asks for a drawer over 2.3 inches high. Bambusi publishes a 2 inch base and asks you to leave room above it for the handles. NIUXX publishes 2 inches and asks for more than 2. The handles are the reason.
Five listings publish the opening, eleven do not Both Utoplike blocks, NIUXX, MAD SHARK, Joseph Joseph, Bambusi and Rev-A-Shelf state a drawer size. SpaceAid publishes 2.5 inches high and the instruction to measure your drawer height first, and leaves the figure to you.
Widths run from 1.97 inches to 22 madesmart publishes a field of 1.97 inches and a stated 15 by 8 by 2 inch mat. GHWIE publishes 3.0 by 15.6 by 1.6. Rev-A-Shelf publishes 18.5 by 22 by 2 for 55 slots. The pool covers a single narrow dock to a full two-tier tray.
Only two publish a blade length limit NIUXX publishes slots for blades under 10.4 inches. Joseph Joseph publishes blades up to 9 inches. Rev-A-Shelf publishes steak knives up to 14 inches. Everybody else publishes a slot count and lets you guess what fits in it.
Nobody publishes a slot depth Every listing publishes an overall height and not one publishes how deep a slot is, which is the figure that decides whether a wide chef's knife bolster drops in or sits proud.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 35% Published drawer minimumThe only figure that answers whether it goes in the run you already have
  2. 20% Published insert sizeRead against the minimum, because the gap between them is the handles
  3. 15% Published blade limitTwo of these five state one and it decides whether your chef's knife fits
  4. 15% Published slot countCapacity is the reason to buy, once the fit is settled
  5. 15% Published weightHeavy stays put, light lifts out for cleaning

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

An under-cabinet run is a fixed set of openings, which makes a knife insert one of the few kitchen purchases that is genuinely a measuring job. The trouble is that almost every listing in this pool publishes the wrong figure for it. An insert’s own height tells you how tall the block is. It does not tell you how tall the drawer has to be, because the knife handles sit above the block in the grooves.

Five listings publish the opening instead, and the gap between the two figures is the point. Utoplike publishes a 1.8 inch base and asks for a drawer higher than 2.3 inches. NIUXX publishes a 2 inch block and asks for more than 2. MAD SHARK publishes 2.67 inches and asks for 2.8. Joseph Joseph publishes 3 inches and asks for 3. Bambusi publishes 2 inches and asks in words for more.

Published specification Utoplike sixteen slot NIUXX twenty slot MAD SHARK two in one Joseph Joseph compact Bambusi sixteen slot
Drawer minimum published Over 17.1 x 12.7 in, height over 2.3 in Over 16.7 x 11.8 in, height over 2 in At least 15 x 9 x 2.8 in Minimum height 3 in 17 in for eleven knives, 22 in for sixteen
Insert size in the maker’s words 16.6 x 12.2 x 1.8 in 16.5 x 11.8 x 2 in 14.56 x 8.66 x 2.67 in 15.5 x 5.5 x 3 in 17 x 5.3 x 2 in
Dimension fields 12.2 x 16.6 x 2.0 in 11.8 x 17.0 x 2.0 in 8.66 x 14.56 x 2.67 in 5.5 x 15.5 x 3.0 in 5.3 x 17.0 x 2.0 in
Published slot count Sixteen Twenty plus a rod Ten plus cutlery Nine Sixteen
Published blade limit not published Under 10.4 in not published Up to 9 in not published
Published weight 2.4 lb 2.47 lb 3.3 lb 0.6 lb 2.5 lb
Published material Bamboo Bamboo Not named beyond a clear lid Not named Bamboo, wood dowels
Cleaning note published not published Removable slots not published not published not published
Handle support published Carved grooves, angled support not published not published not published Room above the base for handles

The row this table cannot fill is the slot depth. Every listing publishes an overall height and not one publishes how deep a groove is, which is what decides whether a chef’s knife with a full bolster drops in or sits proud of the block. That figure would matter more than any of the others, and it does not exist anywhere in this pool.

The Two Figures and the Gap Between Them

Half an Inch of Handle

Utoplike is the clearest case on the sheet. Its sixteen knife block is published at 16.6 by 12.2 by 1.8 inches, and the same listing asks for a drawer with an inner size larger than 17.1 inches deep by 12.7 wide and a height greater than 2.3 inches. That is half an inch of height the block does not use, and the listing explains what it is for: carved grooves and angled handle support so fingers can get to the knives.

Bambusi makes the same point in prose rather than in numbers. It publishes a 17 by 5.3 by 2 inch block and then asks you to leave room above the 2 inch base for the handles. No figure, which is a gap, but the instruction is unambiguous and it is the only listing here that explains the physics rather than just stating a requirement.

Where the Margin Runs Out

NIUXX publishes the tightest pairing in the pool. The block is stated at 16.5 inches deep by 11.8 wide by 2 high, and the requirement is a drawer interior bigger than 16.7 deep by 11.8 wide with a height greater than 2. Two tenths of an inch on the depth, nothing at all on the width, and a height requirement that equals the block. A real drawer has a back panel and a runner stop.

MAD SHARK is the opposite and publishes the most generous margin: an insert of 14.56 by 8.66 by 2.67 inches and a required interior of at least 15 by 9 by 2.8. Nearly half an inch of depth, a third of an inch of width and just over a tenth of height. On a page about fitting a fixed opening, that margin is worth more than two extra knife slots.

What Else the Fit Figures Decide

Blade Length Is a Separate Question

Two of these five publish a blade limit. NIUXX publishes twenty slots for blades less than 10.4 inches in length. Joseph Joseph publishes suitability for blades up to 9 inches. Elsewhere in the pool, Rev-A-Shelf publishes 55 slots for standard steak knives up to 14 inches. Everybody else publishes a slot count and leaves the blade to your judgement.

That matters because a slot count is not a capacity if your knives do not fit it. A 9 inch limit excludes a 10 inch chef’s knife, which is a common size, and Joseph Joseph is the only pick here that says so before you buy. Utoplike, MAD SHARK and Bambusi publish nothing about blade length at all, and Bambusi’s capacity depends on the drawer rather than on the knives.

Capacity That Depends on the Drawer

Bambusi publishes something no other listing in this pool does: capacity as a function of the opening. A 17 inch drawer holds 11 knives, and a 22 inch drawer fits all 16. Its own block is 17 inches long, so the extra five slots are only reachable in a drawer five inches longer than the block, which is an unusual and honest thing to print.

Read against the rest of the pool it is also a warning. Rev-A-Shelf publishes 55 slots across an 18.5 by 22 by 2 inch two-tier tray and says it is made for 12.5 to 18.5 inch wide drawers, trimmed to fit. High slot counts in this category assume a large drawer, and the under-cabinet runs that need this page most are not large.

The Eleven Listings That Leave You Measuring

Close, But No Requirement

SpaceAid publishes an insert 2.5 inches high, states its size as 15 by 5.9 by 2.5 inches, and then prints in capitals the instruction to measure your drawer height first. That is a listing that understands the problem and declines to solve it. madesmart publishes 15 by 8 by 2 inches and says it accommodates most standard kitchen drawers, which is a claim without a figure.

OXO publishes fields of 16.45 by 5.6 by 2.5 inches and a single sentence about saving countertop space. GHWIE publishes 3.0 by 15.6 by 1.6 inches for a seven knife dock. Both are small enough that the fit is unlikely to be a problem, and neither tells you the one thing this page is about.

The Magnetic Alternatives

Two listings answer a narrow drawer differently. ROYAL CRAFT WOOD publishes two seven slot blocks joined by built-in side magnets, and states plainly that they can be separated to fit narrower drawers, which is a genuine answer to a fixed opening. Its published fields, 3.5 by 15.55 by 1.8 inches, describe the carton rather than a block.

Lifewit publishes magnets inside the slots so knives stay put when the drawer is pulled, with fields of 9.06 by 16.54 by 1.97 inches against its own 11.6 by 16.5 by 2, and capacity for 16 knives and 1 sharpener. Neither publishes a required opening, so neither can be ranked here, and both are worth a look if the drawer you have is narrower than everything above.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

You have measured the drawer inside and out. Utoplike publishes the requirement on all three axes, more than 17.1 by 12.7 inches and over 2.3 inches high, against a block of 16.6 by 12.2 by 1.8. Sixteen slots with angled handle support.

A wide run and a lot of knives. NIUXX publishes twenty slots plus a sharpening rod for blades under 10.4 inches, and a required interior of more than 16.7 by 11.8 inches. Two tenths of depth margin, so measure carefully.

One drawer for knives and cutlery. MAD SHARK publishes 14.56 by 8.66 by 2.67 inches against a required 15 by 9 by 2.8, with a clear lid over the tray. At 3.3 pounds it is the heaviest of these five.

A narrow drawer and short blades. Joseph Joseph publishes 15.5 by 5.5 by 3 inches, blades up to 9 inches and a minimum drawer height of 3. At 0.6 pounds it is the lightest of these five and the easiest to lift out.

You want to know what you are trading. Bambusi publishes 17 by 5.3 by 2 inches, states that a 17 inch drawer holds 11 knives and a 22 inch drawer all 16, and asks you to leave room above the base for the handles.

What We Could Not Verify

Every figure above is a manufacturer’s own published number or sentence. These are the things we went looking for across all sixteen listings and did not find.

  • A slot depth on any listing, which is the figure that decides whether a wide bolster drops fully into a groove.
  • A numeric clearance above the base from Bambusi, which asks for room for the handles without saying how much.
  • A blade length limit for Utoplike, MAD SHARK or Bambusi, where two of the five picks publish one.
  • A resolved height for Utoplike, whose dimension field reads 2.0 inches against the maker’s own 1.8.
  • A washing statement from four of these five picks, with only NIUXX mentioning removable slots.
  • A required drawer opening from either magnetic insert in this pool, which are the two products most likely to suit a narrow run.

Frequently asked questions

Why is the drawer minimum a different figure from the insert height?+

Because the knives sit above the insert. Utoplike publishes a base 1.8 inches tall and asks for a drawer over 2.3 inches high, a difference of half an inch that is the handles resting in the carved grooves. Bambusi publishes a 2 inch base and asks in plain words for room above it for the handles. If you measure a drawer against the insert dimension alone, the drawer closes on a handle rather than on the block.

Which of these needs the least drawer?+

Joseph Joseph on width and Bambusi on width, MAD SHARK on depth. Joseph Joseph publishes 15.5 by 5.5 by 3 inches, so 5.5 inches of width is all it asks for, though its 3 inch minimum height is the highest requirement in this shortlist. MAD SHARK publishes a required 15 by 9 by 2.8 inches, the lowest depth requirement of the five. Utoplike's 16 slot block asks for the most on two axes, more than 17.1 by 12.7 inches.

How much margin do these makers leave?+

Not much, and one leaves almost none. NIUXX publishes an insert 16.5 inches deep and a drawer requirement of more than 16.7, which is two tenths of an inch of margin for a drawer that also has a back panel and a stop. MAD SHARK publishes 14.56 inches deep against a required 15, which is nearly half an inch. Utoplike publishes 16.6 inches against 17.1, which is half an inch. Measure the inside of the drawer, not the front.

Which listings will not tell you what drawer they need?+

Eleven of the sixteen. SpaceAid comes closest without doing it, publishing an insert 2.5 inches high and the instruction to measure your drawer height first. madesmart publishes 15 by 8 by 2 inches and says it accommodates most standard kitchen drawers. OXO publishes fields of 16.45 by 5.6 by 2.5 and no requirement at all. GHWIE publishes 3.0 by 15.6 by 1.6 inches and calls itself space saving.

Do any of these hold a sharpener as well as knives?+

Three in the pool do. NIUXX's 20 slot block publishes room for 20 knives and one sharpening rod. Its own 16 slot listing publishes 16 knives and a knife sharpener. Lifewit publishes 16 knives and 1 sharpener in a magnetic plastic insert. Among the picks here, only the NIUXX 20 slot does, and neither Utoplike, MAD SHARK, Joseph Joseph nor Bambusi publishes a place for one.

Is a magnetic insert a better answer for a shallow drawer?+

It is a different answer and this pool does not let you compare them on height. Lifewit publishes a magnetic design in the slots and fields of 9.06 by 16.54 by 1.97 inches, with its own words giving 11.6 by 16.5 by 2. ROYAL CRAFT WOOD publishes two 7 slot blocks joined by side magnets that separate to fit narrower drawers. Neither publishes a required drawer opening, which is what this page ranks by.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.