Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Cookware

Best Roasting Pans for a Narrow Pantry Shelf

The deciding specification is the published height, because that is the figure the shelf above closes on, and only one of these five says its pans stack.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

I compared the published height against each maker's own stated size, plus the interior, the package figure, lid and rack contents, weight, oven ceiling and material across five roasting pans using only the listings' own text.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. CHICAGO METALLIC Roaster Broiler With Rack
    Best for a low shelf gap

    CHICAGO METALLIC Roaster Broiler With Rack

    A carbon steel roaster published at 9 x 13 x 2.25 in whose own bullets state 13.5 x 9.5 x 2.25 inches rim to rim and a 12.75 x 9.875 in inner cooking surface, with a flat fold out handle rack, a named nonstick coating inside and out, a 0.4 mm vessel gauge and a stated dishwasher, oven and metal utensil instruction.

    • Chicago Metallic
    • 13-Inch-by-9-Inch
    • Weight not listed
  2. 3-Pack Turkey Roasting Pans 17/15/13Inch Spotted Ena...
    Best for three pans in one slot

    3-Pack Turkey Roasting Pans 17/15/13Inch Spotted Ena...

    Three enamel steel pans stated at 13.4 x 8.7 x 2.2 in, 15 x 9.9 x 2.6 in and 16.5 x 11 x 3 in, published together at 13.4 x 17 x 3 in and 7 lb, rated to 932 degrees Fahrenheit, with the only bullet in this pool that says the design stacks for small or crowded cabinets.

    • Granite bowl
    • 17/15/13inch
    • 7 lb
  3. bajindan 16 Inch Enamel Roasting Pan with Lid & Rack...
    Best for a lid that seals

    bajindan 16 Inch Enamel Roasting Pan with Lid & Rack...

    An enamel carbon steel roaster published at 7.99 x 13 x 4.72 in and 1.76 lb with a domed moisture lock lid, a removable rack, silicone handle covers and cleaning sponges, stated oven safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit and 260 degrees Celsius in a bullet that its own title contradicts.

    • bajindan
    • 16 inch
    • 1.76 lb
  4. 16 Inch Roasting Pan with Lid - Covered Oval Roaster...
    Best for a published interior

    16 Inch Roasting Pan with Lid - Covered Oval Roaster...

    An enamel carbon steel oval roaster published at 12 x 16 x 6 in and 3.79 lb, the only pick here that states an interior as well, at 15 x 10.5 x 3.5 in, with a fitted lid, carbon steel loop handles and a stated dishwasher or wipe down instruction.

    • VANKUTL
    • 16 Inch
    • 3.79 lb
  5. Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Rack & Handles
    Best for no coating at all

    Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Rack & Handles

    A food grade stainless steel roaster published at 11.6 x 15.6 x 2.8 in and 1.98 lb, stated at 2 lb in its own bullet, with a stainless rack, no coating of any kind, a stated 450 degrees Fahrenheit ceiling and a dishwasher safe surface.

    • AMZ-UTHHF
    • Large
    • 1.98 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
CHICAGO METALLIC Roaster Broiler With Rack Chicago Metallic 13-Inch-by-9-Inch not published Best for a low shelf gap
3-Pack Turkey Roasting Pans 17/15/13Inch Spotted Ena... Granite bowl 17/15/13inch 7 lb Best for three pans in one slot
bajindan 16 Inch Enamel Roasting Pan with Lid & Rack... bajindan 16 inch 1.76 lb Best for a lid that seals
16 Inch Roasting Pan with Lid - Covered Oval Roaster... VANKUTL 16 Inch 3.79 lb Best for a published interior
Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Rack & Handles AMZ-UTHHF Large 1.98 lb Best for no coating at all

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for a low shelf gap

CHICAGO METALLIC Roaster Broiler With Rack

A carbon steel roaster published at 9 x 13 x 2.25 in whose own bullets state 13.5 x 9.5 x 2.25 inches rim to rim and a 12.75 x 9.875 in inner cooking surface, with a flat fold out handle rack, a named nonstick coating inside and out, a 0.4 mm vessel gauge and a stated dishwasher, oven and metal utensil instruction.

  • For it
  • Publishes 2.25 in in its fields and states the same figure in a bullet
  • States 13.5 x 9.5 x 2.25 inches rim to rim, so the outside is on record
  • The only pick that states an inner cooking surface at 12.75 x 9.875 in
  • States a 0.4 mm vessel gauge, the only material thickness figure on this page
  • Against it
  • Its dimension fields and its own bullet disagree by half an inch on both plan figures
  • Its weight field carries a figure far too light to be a carbon steel pan
  • Publishes no oven temperature ceiling at all
2 Best for three pans in one slot

3-Pack Turkey Roasting Pans 17/15/13Inch Spotted Ena...

Three enamel steel pans stated at 13.4 x 8.7 x 2.2 in, 15 x 9.9 x 2.6 in and 16.5 x 11 x 3 in, published together at 13.4 x 17 x 3 in and 7 lb, rated to 932 degrees Fahrenheit, with the only bullet in this pool that says the design stacks for small or crowded cabinets.

  • For it
  • The only listing in this pool whose bullet says the design stacks for crowded cabinets
  • States three pans separately at 13.4 x 8.7 x 2.2 in, 15 x 9.9 x 2.6 in and 16.5 x 11 x 3 in
  • Publishes 13.4 x 17 x 3 in for all three together, which supports the stacking claim
  • States 932 degrees Fahrenheit for the enamel steel
  • Against it
  • Publishes 7 lb, the heaviest figure on this page, and that is for three pans
  • Publishes no dimension fields of its own, only the carton and the bullet
  • No lid and no rack with any of the three pans

Who should skip this: Skip this if weight matters: at 7 lb it is the heaviest of the five published weights.

3 Best for a lid that seals

bajindan 16 Inch Enamel Roasting Pan with Lid & Rack...

An enamel carbon steel roaster published at 7.99 x 13 x 4.72 in and 1.76 lb with a domed moisture lock lid, a removable rack, silicone handle covers and cleaning sponges, stated oven safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit and 260 degrees Celsius in a bullet that its own title contradicts.

  • For it
  • Publishes 1.76 lb, the lightest weight on this page
  • Includes a domed lid, a removable rack, silicone handle covers and cleaning sponges
  • States 500 degrees Fahrenheit and 260 degrees Celsius as a matched pair
  • States a vitreous enamel coating and names scratch resistance
  • Against it
  • Its title states 932 degrees Fahrenheit and its bullet states 500 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Publishes no size in its own words, so its 7.99 x 13 x 4.72 in fields cannot be checked
  • Publishes no figure for the lid, so what the dome adds is unknown
4 Best for a published interior

16 Inch Roasting Pan with Lid - Covered Oval Roaster...

An enamel carbon steel oval roaster published at 12 x 16 x 6 in and 3.79 lb, the only pick here that states an interior as well, at 15 x 10.5 x 3.5 in, with a fitted lid, carbon steel loop handles and a stated dishwasher or wipe down instruction.

  • For it
  • The only pick that publishes both an exterior and an interior, 16 x 12 x 6 in and 15 x 10.5 x 3.5 in
  • Repeats its exterior figures in its own bullet as well as its fields
  • Includes a fitted lid and states what it is for
  • States enamel inside and outside over a carbon steel core
  • Against it
  • Publishes 6 in of height, the largest gap this page asks of a shelf
  • Publishes no figure for the lid, so the 6 in may or may not include it
  • Includes no rack, so food sits in its own fat unless you add one
5 Best for no coating at all

Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Rack & Handles

A food grade stainless steel roaster published at 11.6 x 15.6 x 2.8 in and 1.98 lb, stated at 2 lb in its own bullet, with a stainless rack, no coating of any kind, a stated 450 degrees Fahrenheit ceiling and a dishwasher safe surface.

  • For it
  • Publishes 11.6 x 15.6 x 2.8 in in its fields and its title agrees
  • States 2 lb in a bullet beside a published 1.98 lb field, which is close agreement
  • The only pick with no coating of any kind, stated as food grade stainless steel
  • States free of PFOA, PTFE, lead and BPA
  • Against it
  • States 450 degrees Fahrenheit, the lowest oven ceiling published on this page
  • No lid, so it cannot trap moisture the way two of these five can
  • Its bullet states 15.5 x 11.6 in while its title and fields state 15.6 x 11.6 in

Our verdict

Chicago Metallic publishes 2.25 in and repeats 13.5 x 9.5 x 2.25 in in its own bullet. AMZ-UTHHF publishes 11.6 x 15.6 x 2.8 in. The Granite bowl set states three pans at 2.2 in, 2.6 in and 3 in and publishes 13.4 x 17 x 3 in for all three boxed, the only stacking claim in the pool. bajindan publishes 4.72 in with a lid at 1.76 lb. VANKUTL publishes 6 in outside and 15 x 10.5 x 3.5 in inside.

“Two include a lid and neither says what it adds.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Height published 2.25 in, 2.8 in, 4.72 in and 6 in, with a three pan set whose pans are stated at 2.2 in, 2.6 in and 3 in.
Words against fields Chicago Metallic states 13.5 x 9.5 in in a bullet while its fields say 9 x 13 in. AMZ-UTHHF states 15.5 x 11.6 in against fields of 11.6 x 15.6 in.
Interior stated Only VANKUTL and Chicago Metallic state an inside figure, at 15 x 10.5 x 3.5 in and 12.75 x 9.875 in.
Weight published 1.76 lb, 1.98 lb, 3.79 lb, and 7 lb for a set of three. Chicago Metallic's weight field is too light to be real.
Oven ceiling 932, 500 and 450 degrees Fahrenheit, and two of the five publish none. One listing publishes two different figures.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 30% The published heightA pantry shelf gap is fixed and the height is what closes on it. These five publish 2.25 in, 2.8 in, 4.72 in, 6 in and a three pan set stated at 2.2 in, 2.6 in and 3 in.
  2. 25% Whether the maker repeats the figure in wordsA field value can be anyone's typing. Chicago Metallic, VANKUTL and the Granite bowl set all state their figures in bullets, and Chicago Metallic's bullet disagrees with its own fields.
  3. 20% Whether a lid is included and accounted forA lid changes the height and both lidded picks publish one figure without saying which. bajindan and VANKUTL describe their lids at length and measure neither.
  4. 15% Whether anything states that it stacksThree pans that nest into 3 in of shelf is a different purchase from three pans that do not. Only the Granite bowl set makes that claim, and its carton figure supports it.
  5. 10% Material and the washing instructionCarbon steel with a coating, enamel over steel, or uncoated stainless. AMZ-UTHHF is the only pick with no coating at all, and four of the five name the dishwasher.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

A narrow pantry is a stack of fixed gaps. A roasting pan goes in on its base and the shelf above either clears it or it does not, and the figure that decides that is the height, with whatever lid sits on top. Thirty one listings sit in this pool and most of them lead with a length, because length is what sells a turkey pan.

These five publish a height that can be read. They run 2.25 in, 2.8 in, 4.72 in and 6 in, with a three pan set whose pans are stated at 2.2 in, 2.6 in and 3 in and whose whole boxed set publishes 3 in. Two of the five include a lid and neither says what the lid adds.

Specification Chicago Metallic Granite bowl bajindan VANKUTL AMZ-UTHHF
Dimension fields published 9 x 13 x 2.25 in not published 7.99 x 13 x 4.72 in 12 x 16 x 6 in 11.6 x 15.6 x 2.8 in
Size in the maker’s own words 13.5 x 9.5 x 2.25 in rim to rim 13.4 x 8.7 x 2.2 in, 15 x 9.9 x 2.6 in and 16.5 x 11 x 3 in not published 16 x 12 x 6 in 15.5 x 11.6 in
Height figure to clear a shelf 2.25 in 2.2 in, 2.6 in and 3 in 4.72 in 6 in 2.8 in
Interior stated separately 12.75 x 9.875 in cooking surface not published not published 15 x 10.5 x 3.5 in not published
Package figure published not published 13.4 x 17 x 3 in for all three pans not published not published not published
Lid included not published not published Domed moisture lock lid Lid included not published
Rack included Flat fold out handle rack not published Removable roasting rack not published Stainless steel rack
Stacking stated not published Stackable design for small or crowded cabinets not published not published not published
Weight published not published 7 lb for three pans 1.76 lb 3.79 lb 1.98 lb, and 2 lb in a bullet
Oven ceiling stated not published 932 degrees Fahrenheit 500 degrees Fahrenheit and 260 degrees Celsius in a bullet, 932 degrees Fahrenheit in the title not published 450 degrees Fahrenheit
Material stated Carbon steel, 0.4 mm vessel gauge Enamel steel, PFOA and PTFE free Enamel carbon steel with vitreous enamel Carbon steel with enamel inside and out Food grade stainless steel, no coating
Washing instruction Dishwasher, oven and metal utensil safe not published Dishwasher safe Dishwasher or wipe down Dishwasher safe
Pans in the box One Three One One One

What the table cannot tell you is how much a lid adds. bajindan and VANKUTL both include one, and both publish a single height figure without saying whether the lid is inside it or on top of it. VANKUTL states 6 in for the pan and 3.5 in for the interior, which leaves 2.5 in of wall and lid unaccounted for and no statement of which is which.

The Height Is the Figure a Shelf Closes On

Four Publish One Height, One Publishes Three

Chicago Metallic publishes 2.25 in in its fields and repeats it in a bullet that gives 13.5 x 9.5 x 2.25 inches rim to rim. AMZ-UTHHF publishes 2.8 in in its fields and in its own title. bajindan publishes 4.72 in in its fields only. VANKUTL publishes 6 in in its fields and again in a bullet. All four are single figures for a single object.

The Granite bowl set is the exception and the interesting one. Its bullet states three pans at 13.4 x 8.7 x 2.2 in, 15 x 9.9 x 2.6 in and 16.5 x 11 x 3 in, and its package publishes 13.4 x 17 x 3 in for all three together. The largest of the three pans is stated at 3 in and the box publishes 3 in, so the three pans genuinely nest, which is the claim its own bullet makes.

A Lid Adds Height and Nobody Publishes How Much

bajindan describes a tightly fitted domed lid that seals in moisture, and VANKUTL describes a lid that stops heat and moisture escaping. Neither listing publishes a figure for the lid. Both publish a single height, 4.72 in and 6 in, and neither says whether that figure is the pan alone, the pan with the lid seated, or the pan with the lid on and the dome standing proud.

VANKUTL gives the only clue in the pool. It states an exterior of 16 x 12 x 6 in and an interior of 15 x 10.5 x 3.5 in, so 2.5 in sits between the two somewhere. That could be base thickness and rim, or it could be the lid dome. The listing does not say, and a pantry shelf does not care which of those it is.

Where the Published Figures Disagree With Themselves

Chicago Metallic’s Fields Against Its Own Bullet

The Chicago Metallic dimension fields say 9 x 13 x 2.25 in. Its own bullet says the pan measures 13.5 x 9.5 inches, and a second bullet says outer rim to rim is 13.5 x 9.5 x 2.25 inches with an inner cooking surface of 12.75 x 9.875 inches. The two plan figures differ by half an inch each and the height is the same in both.

This page uses the maker’s own sentence, because a rim to rim measurement stated twice in two bullets is a deliberate statement and a field value is not. In a narrow pantry the half inch matters: 13.5 in of shelf depth is a different question from 13 in. The height, which is the figure the shelf above closes on, is not in dispute.

bajindan Publishes Two Different Oven Ceilings

The bajindan title says 932 degrees Fahrenheit heat resistant. Its own bullet says the enamel carbon steel body is oven safe up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit and 260 degrees Celsius. Those are not close to each other, and a buyer reading only the title would set an oven a long way above what the bullet permits.

A second bajindan bullet adds that the silicone handle covers must be slid off before the pan goes into a high heat oven, which suggests the lower figure describes the assembled product and the higher one the bare enamel. The listing never says that. This page quotes both figures and treats neither as settled.

What Else Comes Home in the Box

Racks, Lids, Handles and Sponges

Three of the five include a rack. Chicago Metallic states a flat fold out handle rack coated with the same nonstick as the pan. bajindan states a heavy duty removable rack that lifts meat clear of the fat. AMZ-UTHHF states a stainless steel rack that lifts food above grease. VANKUTL includes a lid instead of a rack, and the Granite bowl set includes neither.

bajindan also includes silicone handle covers and cleaning sponges, which is four categories of object for one purchase and four things to store. For a narrow pantry that is worth knowing before the box arrives. The Granite bowl set is the opposite proposition: three bare pans, no lid, no rack and a bullet that says they stack.

Material and Washing

AMZ-UTHHF is the only pick with no coating at all, stating food grade stainless steel free of PFOA, PTFE, lead and BPA. Chicago Metallic states carbon steel with a named nonstick coating inside and out and a 0.4 mm vessel gauge, which is the only material thickness figure anywhere in these five listings. The other three are enamel over steel.

Four of the five state a washing instruction and all four name the dishwasher. Chicago Metallic goes furthest, stating dishwasher, oven and metal utensil safe in one line. The Granite bowl set publishes no washing instruction at all, which for three enamel pans sold as easy to clean in the title is a gap rather than an omission.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

A shelf gap you have already measured. Chicago Metallic publishes 2.25 in twice, in its fields and in a bullet, and states 13.5 x 9.5 in rim to rim. It is the pick to buy when the shelf above is the binding constraint and you want the figure confirmed in words.

Three pans, one slot. Granite bowl states pans at 2.2 in, 2.6 in and 3 in and publishes 13.4 x 17 x 3 in for all three boxed, with a bullet that says the stackable design suits small or crowded cabinets. At 7 lb for the set it is the heaviest figure here.

A lid that seals, and shelf room to spare. bajindan publishes 7.99 x 13 x 4.72 in at 1.76 lb, the lightest weight on this page, with a domed lid, a removable rack and silicone handle covers. Read its bullet rather than its title for the oven ceiling.

A published interior, not just an outside. VANKUTL publishes 12 x 16 x 6 in outside and states 15 x 10.5 x 3.5 in inside, which is the only pick here that lets you work out what will actually fit in the pan. It needs 6 in of shelf gap.

No coating to worry about. AMZ-UTHHF publishes 11.6 x 15.6 x 2.8 in and 1.98 lb, states 2 lb in its own bullet, and states food grade stainless steel with no coating and a 450 degrees Fahrenheit ceiling. A shallow pan that goes in the dishwasher without a nonstick surface to protect.

What We Could Not Verify

These are the things I went looking for in the five listings and did not find.

  • Neither bajindan nor VANKUTL publishes a figure for its lid, so what the lid adds to the height is unknown.
  • bajindan publishes 932 degrees Fahrenheit in its title and 500 degrees Fahrenheit in a bullet, and never reconciles the two.
  • Chicago Metallic’s dimension fields and its own rim to rim bullet disagree by half an inch on both plan figures.
  • The Chicago Metallic weight field carries a figure far too light to be a carbon steel pan, so this page treats the weight as not published.
  • The Granite bowl set publishes no washing instruction and no oven ceiling for the individual pans, only 932 degrees Fahrenheit for the enamel steel.
  • No listing in this pool publishes the height of the pan with its rack stored inside it, which is how a rack actually travels.

Frequently asked questions

Which of these needs the least shelf gap?+

Chicago Metallic publishes 2.25 in, and it is the only pick that states the figure twice, in its fields and in a bullet giving 13.5 x 9.5 x 2.25 inches rim to rim. AMZ-UTHHF publishes 2.8 in in both its fields and its title. The Granite bowl set states pans at 2.2 in, 2.6 in and 3 in, but you are buying three of them rather than one.

Does the three pan set really save space?+

Its own bullet says the stackable design suits small or crowded cabinets, and unusually for this pool the published figures support it. The three pans are stated at 2.2 in, 2.6 in and 3 in deep, and the package publishes 13.4 x 17 x 3 in for all three together. A box published at the same 3 in figure as the largest pan means they nest rather than sit side by side.

Do the published heights include the lid?+

No listing says. bajindan publishes 4.72 in and VANKUTL publishes 6 in, and both describe a lid at length without giving it a figure. VANKUTL is the only one that narrows it down: it states 16 x 12 x 6 in outside and 15 x 10.5 x 3.5 in inside, so 2.5 in sits between the two, but nothing says whether that is wall, base or lid dome.

Why does one pan publish two different oven ceilings?+

The bajindan title states 932 degrees Fahrenheit heat resistant and one of its own bullets states oven safe up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit and 260 degrees Celsius. A separate bullet says the silicone handle covers must be removed before high heat use, which hints that the lower number covers the assembled pan and the higher one the bare enamel. The listing never says so, so treat 500 degrees Fahrenheit as the working figure.

Which of these is the lightest to lift down from a high shelf?+

bajindan publishes 1.76 lb, the lightest weight on this page, with AMZ-UTHHF at 1.98 lb and a bullet stating 2 lb, and VANKUTL at 3.79 lb. The Granite bowl set publishes 7 lb, the heaviest figure here, but that is three pans in one box rather than one object. Chicago Metallic's weight field is not usable and this page does not quote it.

Is an uncoated pan better for a pantry?+

It is better for stacking. AMZ-UTHHF states food grade stainless steel with no coating, free from PFOA, PTFE, lead and BPA, and a smooth surface that is dishwasher safe. A nonstick pan like the Chicago Metallic roaster has a named coating inside and out, and anything stacked on top of it is sitting on that coating. The enamel picks sit between the two.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.