How the Five Compare on the Numbers
An apartment counter is width times depth and nothing else, so the figure that decides this is the footprint each maker states in its own words. Ortarco publishes 4.3 by 4.3 inches. Criusia publishes 11 by 7. Hudgan publishes 10.8 by 6.7. ARTAWEIN publishes 13.77 by 7.1 and stands 29.3 inches tall. ProKeeper publishes no size in words at all.
Three of these five publish a size that disagrees with their own dimension fields. Hudgan states 10.8 by 6.7 by 6.7 inches against fields of 7.5 by 11.5 by 7.5. ARTAWEIN states 13.77 by 7.1 by 29.3 against 7.1 by 14.2 by 27.9. Ortarco states three equal sides and its fields give 4.3 by 4.7 by 4.3.
What the table cannot tell you is how many onions any of these holds. Not one of these five publishes a produce weight or a count, so capacity is a list of foods rather than a figure. On a counter where the container has to earn its footprint, that is the number a reader would trade the others for.
Two Keepers for One Onion
Four Inches Square
Ortarco publishes the smallest footprint on this page at 4.3 by 4.3 inches, and states it fits most sizes of onion. It is BPA free PP with a see through lid, dishwasher safe, and stated to stop odor spreading through a refrigerator or a room. It publishes 0.07 pounds, which is the lightest thing on this fact sheet.
Its own figures do not quite agree. The bullet and the size field both say 4.3 by 4.3 by 4.3 inches, and the dimension fields say 4.3 by 4.7 by 4.3. That is a tenth of the difference the other disagreements on this page involve, and on a 4 inch box it changes nothing a counter would notice.
A Keeper With No Published Size
ProKeeper publishes no size in words anywhere in its listing. Its fields read 3 by 5 by 5 inches and its bullets describe an airtight seal for chopped or halved onions, freshness preservation and a compact design, with 0.29 pounds. So the one thing it is sold on, being compact, is the one thing it never measures.
It is also the only pick here for a cut onion rather than a whole one. Ortarco states it fits most whole onions, and the three bins hold produce loose. ProKeeper states chopped or halved, which is a different job and explains why an airtight seal appears in its bullets and in nobody else’s.
Two Near Identical Bins, Two Sets of Figures
Ten Point Eight by Six Point Seven, or Eleven by Seven
Hudgan and Criusia publish nearly the same product: two clear stackable bins with bamboo lids, built in handles, a wide front opening and non slip feet. Hudgan states 10.8 by 6.7 by 6.7 inches. Criusia states 11 by 7 by 7. Those are close enough that a counter would not notice and far enough that they are not the same mold.
Where they part is the fields. Criusia publishes 7 by 11 by 7 inches, the same three numbers its bullet gives, reordered. Hudgan publishes 7.5 by 11.5 by 7.5, which is not its stated figure in any order. This page uses each maker’s own sentence and leaves the Hudgan fields alone.
One Says Not the Dishwasher
Hudgan publishes the clearest washing rule on this fact sheet and it is a prohibition: wash with warm soapy water, but do not put it in the dishwasher. Criusia publishes no washing instruction at all on what is otherwise the same object in the same materials.
The weights are the other difference, and it is large. Hudgan publishes 1.07 pounds and Criusia 3.35 for two bins each. Nothing in either listing explains a gap of that size between two clear plastic bins of the same stated dimensions, and neither publishes a wall thickness to account for it.
The Floor Standing One
Twenty Nine Inches Tall and Sixteen Pounds
ARTAWEIN publishes a different kind of object: a solid pine bin standing 29.3 inches high on a footprint of 13.77 by 7.1 inches, with distinct compartments for potatoes, onions and a garlic drawer, at 15.94 pounds. It arrives fully assembled and its surfaces are stated to wipe clean.
Its fields read 7.1 by 14.2 by 27.9 inches against that stated 13.77 by 7.1 by 29.3, so two of the three numbers differ. The height is the one that matters in an apartment, because 29.3 inches is a piece of furniture rather than a counter object and the two figures put it either side of that.
The Only Air Circulation Claim
ARTAWEIN is also the only pick that ties its compartments to air. The listing states the distinct compartments promote optimal air circulation and preserve vegetable quality for longer, which is the argument for an open wooden bin over a sealed plastic box.
The two keepers argue the opposite. Ortarco states it prevents odor spreading through a refrigerator or a room, and ProKeeper states an airtight seal that keeps odors in. So on this page the ventilation question splits by object rather than by maker: the bin breathes and the keepers do not.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
The counter has room for one onion. Ortarco publishes 4.3 by 4.3 by 4.3 inches of BPA free PP with a see through lid, dishwasher safe, stated to fit most sizes of onion and to stop odor spreading, at 0.07 pounds.
Half an onion goes back in the fridge. ProKeeper publishes an airtight BPA free keeper for chopped or halved onions at 0.29 pounds, with fields of 3 by 5 by 5 inches and no size stated in words anywhere.
You want two bins and a washing rule. Hudgan publishes two clear polyethylene bins at a stated 10.8 by 6.7 by 6.7 inches with bamboo lids, built in handles, straight stackable sides, and a plain instruction not to use a dishwasher.
You want the fields and the sentence to agree. Criusia publishes two PET bins at 11 by 7 by 7 inches, the same three numbers its dimension fields give, with natural bamboo lids, built in handles and non slip bottoms, at 3.35 pounds.
The vegetables live outside the cupboard. ARTAWEIN publishes a solid pine bin 29.3 inches tall on a 13.77 by 7.1 inch footprint, with separate potato and onion compartments and a garlic drawer, fully assembled, at 15.94 pounds.
What We Could Not Verify
Every figure above is a maker’s own published number or sentence, taken from the listing itself. These are the things we went looking for across all sixteen listings on this fact sheet and could not find.
- A produce weight or an onion count from any of these five, so capacity is a list of foods.
- Any size stated in words by ProKeeper, whose only figures are its dimension fields.
- Why Hudgan publishes 1.07 pounds and Criusia 3.35 for two bins of the same stated size.
- Whether the ARTAWEIN bin is 29.3 inches tall, as its own words say, or 27.9, as its fields say.
- A wall thickness from either of the two clear bins.
- A washing instruction from ProKeeper or Criusia, two of these five.