How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Most of these pans are one casting and nothing can be done about it. Three of these five are not. On a tube pan the floor or the center column can be made as a separate piece, which turns getting the cake out from a wrestling match into lifting one part away from another, and it introduces a seam that batter can find. Both halves of that trade are published here, and two makers argue opposite sides of it.
E-Gtong separates its base on a springform latch and states a precision fit that stops batter leaking. Chicago Metallic lifts out the center tube instead. Fox Run separates the bottom and clears 572 degrees F. E-far refuses the seam in writing and gives the reason. Nordic Ware keeps its pan whole and adds two more pieces to the purchase, a base and a twist locking lid.
What the table cannot tell you is whether a seam that is advertised as leak proof stays leak proof. Nobody publishes a tolerance, a gasket or a test, and no listing here offers a replacement base or center tube, so a two piece pan with a lost or warped floor is a ring of metal. The one pick that names its mechanism is also the only one that addresses the objection the one piece pans raise, which is the most useful sentence on this page.
The Pans That Come Apart
E-Gtong Names the Latch and Answers the Objection
E-Gtong is the only pick here that says how its base is held. Its first bullet states a springform latch design for effortless release while maintaining the cake’s shape, which is a named mechanism rather than the bare phrase two piece. That matters because a latch is a thing you can see working, and the other two separating pans leave you to discover how theirs is fastened.
Its third bullet then answers the one real argument against a seam. It states a precision fit base and side wall that prevent batter from leaking during baking, with no burnt drips and no mess in the oven, which is the exact worry the one piece pans on this page publish. It states 304 food grade stainless steel, 10 in, dishwasher permission, and publishes 10.23 x 10.23 x 3.34 in and no weight.
Chicago Metallic Lifts Out the Center Instead
Chicago Metallic takes the other half of the pan apart. Its construction bullet states an innovative two piece design where a removable center tube allows effortless cake removal, and adds built in feet that enable proper air circulation when cooling cakes upside down. It is the only pick here that publishes a cooling provision built into the pan rather than a cone you balance on a bottle.
It publishes 9.5 inches in diameter by 4 inches high, a 16 cup capacity, heavy weight carbon steel with a silicone based nonstick coating, and 1.0 lb, the lowest published weight among these five. Its care line asks for a hand wash to maintain the coating, so the pan that comes apart most cleanly is also the one whose pieces should not go in a machine.
A Removable Bottom at the Highest Temperature
Fox Run Separates the Base and Clears 572 Degrees
Fox Run publishes the plainest version of the separating bottom. Two bullets say the same thing twice: a two piece design for easy cake removal, and a bottom that can be separated from the rest of the pan. Its last line adds the figure nobody else approaches, a stated use up to 572 degrees F, against 450 degrees F from E-far and no figure at all from the other three.
It is also the only separating pan here cleared for a dishwasher and a hand wash in the same sentence, in stainless steel described as long lasting and food safe. It publishes 1.4 lb. What it never does is name the mechanism or address leaking, so it asks you to accept a seam on the strength of the material and the temperature alone.
Where the Published Figures Disagree
Two of the five file dimensions their own text cannot support. Nordic Ware files 5.02 x 5.02 x 3.05 in for a pan it states holds 12 cup, which no 12 cup bundt pan could measure, and the figure is the more suspect because the purchase also contains a base and a lid. E-far files 5.6 x 10.8 x 10.4 in against its own stated 10 x 4 in, where the 4 has become a 10.4.
The others hold up. Chicago Metallic states 9.5 by 4 inches and files 9.5 x 4.0 x 4.0 in. Fox Run states 10.87 x 5 in and files 10.88 x 10.88 x 5.0 in, which is the same pan with the diameter written twice. E-Gtong states 10 in and files 10.23 in twice with a 3.34 in height. This page uses each maker’s own sentence wherever the two disagree.
The Pans That Do Not Come Apart
E-far Argues Against the Seam
E-far is the only pick that treats being one piece as a feature and says why. Its crafted bullet states a single piece design with no worries about batter leaking through the bottom, a mirror finished surface for clean release, a center cone 1 inch higher than the sides so the cake can cool on a bottle, and rolled edges for strength and grip. Its size slot reads 1 Piece.
It backs that with the fullest set of permissions here: food grade stainless steel with no coating to flake, oven safe up to 450 degrees F, dishwasher safe, and cleared for a pressure cooker, an air fryer and a freezer as well. It publishes 10 x 4 inches, a 16 cup capacity and 1.55 lb. Nothing can be mislaid, and nothing can be lifted away either.
Nordic Ware Adds Pieces Rather Than Removing Them
Nordic Ware answers the question from the other direction. The pan is a formed aluminum casting that does not separate, and the listing instead names its included components outright: cake pan, base and lid, with a twist to lock cake keeper over the top. So the purchase has three pieces and none of them is a part of the pan, which is the opposite arrangement to the two piece tube pans.
It publishes 12 cup and 1.78 lb, the highest published weight here, and that figure covers all three components rather than the pan alone. Its listing is the terse kind: seven short lines with no temperature, no washing instruction and no size in the maker’s own words, only the 12 Cup pan capacity slot, which leaves its unusable dimension fields as the only measurement on offer.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
You want the base off and the seam explained. E-Gtong states a springform latch and a precision fit base and side wall that prevent batter leaking. It states 10 in, 304 stainless steel and dishwasher permission, and publishes no weight.
You want the center out and a way to cool it. Chicago Metallic states a removable center tube and built in feet for cooling upside down, with 9.5 by 4 inches, 16 cup and 1.0 lb. Its coating asks for a hand wash.
You bake hot and want the floor to lift away. Fox Run states a two piece design with a bottom that separates, cleared to 572 degrees F, hand wash and dishwasher safe, at 10.87 x 5 in and 1.4 lb. It never names the mechanism.
You do not want a seam at all. E-far states a single piece design with no worries about batter leaking through the bottom, 10 x 4 inches, 16 cup, 450 degrees F, 1.55 lb, and clearance for a pressure cooker, an air fryer and a freezer.
You want somewhere to keep the cake afterward. Nordic Ware lists three components, a cake pan, a base and a lid, with a twist to lock keeper, at 12 cup and 1.78 lb for all three. Its dimension fields cannot be the pan.
What We Could Not Verify
Six things a reader buying for the parts would want, and no listing among these five supplies.
- A replacement base or center tube for either two piece pan, or any statement that one exists.
- How the Chicago Metallic and Fox Run pieces are held together, since neither names a latch, a lip or a thread.
- Any leaking claim from Chicago Metallic or Fox Run, where both one piece picks raise the seam as the objection.
- A weight for E-Gtong, where the other four publish one from 1.0 lb to 1.78 lb.
- What the Nordic Ware pan actually measures, since its fields of 5.02 x 5.02 x 3.05 in cannot hold 12 cup.
- A washing instruction from Nordic Ware, on the one purchase here with three pieces to wash.