Explainer
What is the difference between a vertical electric smoker and a pellet grill?
A vertical electric smoker heats a tall cabinet with an electric element and burns wood chips or bisquettes for smoke, while a pellet grill burns wood pellets in a hopper-fed fire pot and cooks on a wide, low chamber.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
A vertical electric smoker is a tall cabinet heated by an electric element, with smoke coming from wood chips or bisquettes placed on a tray or burner. A pellet grill is a low, wide chamber heated by wood pellets that an auger feeds into a fire pot, so the pellets are both the heat source and the smoke source.
The two shapes follow from that. A vertical cabinet stacks racks above a small heat source, so it holds a lot of food in a small footprint. A pellet grill spreads one or two racks over a long body, which suits grilling at higher heat as well as smoking. The picks below come from our guides to Best Vertical Smokers for Ribs and Whole Turkeys and Best Pellet Grills and Smoke Tubes for Backyard Cooks.
How each one makes heat and smoke
On the electric side, the Charbroil Analog Electric Smoker lists a 1200 watt heating element and an insulated cooking chamber, and it carries a wood chip tray for the smoke. The Bradley Smoker 6-Rack Outdoor Electric Smoker is fully automatic and, per the maker, lets you load bisquettes and smoke for up to 9 hours. Neither needs pellets fed from a hopper, because the element supplies the heat and the wood is added separately.
A pellet grill works the other way. The Z GRILLS 7002C uses a PID 3.0 controller with an LCD screen that auto-tunes fuel and airflow, and it holds 28 lbs of pellets in its hopper. The Traeger Pro 22 runs a Digital Pro Controller from 180 degrees Fahrenheit to 450 degrees Fahrenheit within plus or minus 15 degrees, and its 18 lb hopper feeds the fire pot. The pellets are the fuel, so the controller manages heat and smoke together.
That difference shapes what you can do. An electric cabinet holds a set temperature and adds smoke from a tray, so the smoke is a flavor step you control separately. A pellet grill ties smoke output to the burn, which means a long low cook produces steady smoke and a hot cook produces less. The Pit Boss Navigator 3-Series, a vertical pellet smoker, sits between the two ideas: it is a cabinet, but it burns pellets from a 50 lb hopper and runs 130 degrees Fahrenheit to 420 degrees Fahrenheit on a digital controller.
Cooking space and how the racks stack
Vertical cabinets are built to stack food. The Masterbuilt 40-inch ThermoTemp lists 960 square inches of cooking space across four chrome-coated racks, and the maker states it fits up to 16 chickens, 6 turkeys, 8 pork butts or 8 racks of ribs. The Bradley lists 6 racks with 11 by 13 inches of cooking space each. The Charbroil lists 544 square inches over 3 chrome-plated grates, and the Realcook Charcoal BBQ Smoker lists 636 square inches over 2 cooking racks.
Pellet grills spread out instead. The Z GRILLS 7002C lists 697 square inches of grilling space, and the Traeger Pro 22 lists 572 square inches, which the maker says fits up to 24 burgers, 5 racks of ribs or 4 whole chickens. The Pit Boss vertical pellet smoker lists 1,118 square inches over 5 porcelain-coated steel racks, the largest cooking area on either fact sheet, and it shows what a cabinet can do when the fuel is pellets rather than an element.
The practical result: a tall cabinet gives you several shallow levels, which suits ribs laid flat, whole birds and multiple items at once. A wide pellet grill gives you one or two deep levels, which suits a big cut plus sides, or a full grate of burgers. If you routinely cook for a crowd in a small yard, the stacked cabinet wins on space per square foot of patio.
Temperature range and control
Published ranges differ by model, not by category. The Charbroil electric smoker has an adjustable dial and a door-mounted temperature gauge, and the maker does not publish a temperature range for it. The Masterbuilt propane vertical smoker, which shares the cabinet shape, lists an adjustable dial up to 375 degrees Fahrenheit. The Bradley publishes a smoke duration of up to 9 hours but no temperature range in its listed features.
On the pellet side the numbers are explicit. The Traeger Pro 22 covers 180 degrees Fahrenheit to 450 degrees Fahrenheit within plus or minus 15 degrees. The Pit Boss Navigator 3-Series covers 130 degrees Fahrenheit to 420 degrees Fahrenheit. The Z GRILLS 7002C uses its PID 3.0 controller to hold temperature when outside conditions shift, and it includes 2 meat probes so you can read internal temperature without lifting the lid.
Read those figures for what they are. A pellet grill’s top end lets it grill as well as smoke, which an electric cabinet generally does not claim. An electric cabinet’s strength is a steady low heat with smoke added on top, and the Charbroil backs that with an insulated chamber and dual door latches. If your cooking stays under 300 degrees Fahrenheit, both designs will hold it; if you want to sear or roast hot, the pellet grill’s published ceiling matters.
Fuel, refills and cleanup
Pellet grills carry their fuel onboard. The Z GRILLS 7002C has a 28 lb hopper with a view window so you can check the pellet supply without lifting the lid, plus a hopper cleanout for swapping flavors. The Traeger Pro 22 has an 18 lb hopper with a clean-out door. The Pit Boss vertical pellet smoker has a 50 lb hopper, a rear access grease drawer and a rapid igniter. Bigger hoppers mean fewer refills on a long cook, and the makers publish those capacities plainly.
Electric cabinets handle fuel differently. The Charbroil uses a wood chip tray, an aluminized steel water pan and a grease tray, all removable for cleaning. The Bradley uses bisquettes and an easy-to-clean stainless steel interior with a smoke diffuser system that the maker says prevents black rain from dripping onto food. The Masterbuilt adds a removable water bowl to add moisture and catch drippings, plus a woodchip tray and an adjustable air damper.
Cleanup follows the fuel. Pellets leave ash in the fire pot that has to be emptied, and grease collects in the body. Chips and bisquettes leave ash in a small tray that lifts out. Neither is hard, but the pellet grill asks you to manage a hopper and a burn pot, while the electric cabinet asks you to load a tray and, on some models, refill a water pan.
Adding smoke to a grill you already own
If the real question is smoke rather than a new cooker, a tube or box is the cheap route, and our pellet grill guide covers several. The LIZZQ Premium Pellet Smoker Tube measures 12 inches long and 2.16 inches wide, weighs 0.5 lb, and the maker states it produces smoke for up to 5 hours and works in any gas, electric or charcoal grill. The Napoleon PRO Stainless Steel Smoker Pipe measures 12 inches by 1.75 inches by 1.75 inches and fills with wood chips or pellets.
The Weber Premium Universal Smoker Box measures 9.8 by 4.5 by 2 inches and weighs 1.46 lb, and the maker says it fits most sizes of grill and lets you add chips while in use. These accessories do not change how a cooker makes heat; they add smoke to whatever heat you already have. That makes them a sensible add-on for an electric cabinet with a small chip tray, or for a gas grill that has no smoke source at all.
Weigh the two designs on the figures above. A vertical electric smoker stacks racks in a tall cabinet and adds smoke from chips or bisquettes. A pellet grill feeds pellets to a fire pot and spreads its cooking area wide, with a published temperature ceiling that reaches grilling heat. Pick the shape that matches how you cook, then check the maker’s published capacity and range for the model you are considering.
Common questions
Does a vertical electric smoker need pellets?
No. A vertical electric smoker gets its heat from an electric element and its smoke from wood chips, bisquettes or a similar wood product placed on a tray or burner. The Charbroil Analog Electric Smoker lists a 1200 watt heating element and a wood chip tray. The Bradley Smoker 6-Rack Outdoor Electric Smoker uses bisquettes and the maker states it smokes for up to 9 hours.
Can a pellet grill hold a low smoking temperature?
Yes, within the range the maker publishes. The Traeger Pro 22 runs from 180 degrees Fahrenheit to 450 degrees Fahrenheit within plus or minus 15 degrees, and the Pit Boss Navigator 3-Series runs 130 degrees Fahrenheit to 420 degrees Fahrenheit. The Z GRILLS 7002C uses a PID 3.0 controller to hold temperature when outside conditions change.
Which shape holds more food?
It depends on the model, not the category. The Pit Boss Navigator 3-Series, a vertical pellet smoker, lists 1,118 square inches over 5 racks. The Masterbuilt 40-inch ThermoTemp lists 960 square inches over four racks. The Z GRILLS 7002C pellet grill lists 697 square inches and the Traeger Pro 22 lists 572 square inches.
Do I need a water pan with either design?
Only if the maker includes one. The Masterbuilt 40-inch ThermoTemp has a removable water bowl to add moisture and catch drippings, and the Charbroil Analog Electric Smoker has an aluminized steel water pan. The pellet grills on our fact sheet do not list a water pan among their published features.
Can I add smoke to a grill I already own?
Yes. The LIZZQ Premium Pellet Smoker Tube is 12 inches long and the maker states it produces smoke for up to 5 hours in any gas, electric or charcoal grill. The Weber Premium Universal Smoker Box measures 9.8 by 4.5 by 2 inches and the maker says it fits most sizes of grill and lets you add chips while in use.
How long does a hopper of pellets last?
The makers publish hopper capacity, not burn time. The Z GRILLS 7002C holds 28 lbs of pellets, the Traeger Pro 22 holds 18 lbs, and the Pit Boss Navigator 3-Series holds 50 lbs. The Traeger maker states its hopper holds enough pellets for long cooks, but no run time in hours is published for any of the three.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.