Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

How do you can food in mason jars?

Canning in mason jars means packing prepared food into clean jars, covering it with liquid where the recipe calls for it, and processing the sealed jars in a boiling water bath for high acid foods.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

Canning in mason jars means filling clean jars with prepared high acid food, such as pickles, jam, fruit or tomatoes, leaving the headspace the recipe specifies, and processing the closed jars in a boiling water bath. The jar has to be one the maker describes as suitable for canning, and the lid has to be a two piece metal lid and band or a glass lid with a rubber gasket and clips, because a hinged clamp lid with a silicone gasket is a storage seal, not a canning seal.

This site has not tested any jar, and nobody at Lush has canned in these products. What follows is what the makers state about their jars and what that means for a water bath setup.

What water bath canning actually involves

Water bath canning is for high acid foods: pickles, relishes, fruit, jams, jellies, and acidified tomatoes. You fill the jars, wipe the rims, apply the lids, set them on a rack in a pot of boiling water with the water covering the jars, and boil for the time the recipe gives. Low acid foods such as plain vegetables, meat, and stock need a pressure canner, not a water bath, and no jar choice changes that.

Two things matter in the jar itself. The first is a seal the process can complete: a flat metal lid with a band, or a glass lid held by a rubber gasket and clips. The second is glass that tolerates the heat and the temperature change, which is why makers of canning jars describe their glass as heat tempered. The Best Pickling Jars for Small Batches and Bulk guide compares five jars, and only some of them are described for canning at all.

Jars whose makers describe them for canning

The ComSaf 32 oz Wide Mouth Mason Jars 2 Pack is the clearest case in that guide. ComSaf states that each jar holds 32 oz, that the mouth is 3 in wide, and that the split type lids and bands help create an airtight seal for daily storage and water bath canning. The same listing tells you to use proper water bath steps and to avoid sudden temperature changes. The pack weighs 2.12 lb and includes two jars, two lids and bands, and two labels.

The Miuyhji 16 oz Wide Mouth Glass Mason Jars, 6 Pack is the other pick described for canning. Miuyhji states that the jars come with metal lids and bands, that the glass is heat tempered, and that the jars are microwave safe without lids and bands, refrigerator safe under the freezing fill line, and dishwasher safe. The listing also states embossed measurement markings and a wide mouth. Miuyhji does not publish the jar’s width, height, or weight.

Both of those are two piece metal lid systems, which is the closure a boiling water bath is built around. If you are canning a small batch of pickles or jam, the 16 oz size gives you more jars per batch and the 32 oz size gives you fewer, larger jars. Neither maker publishes a maximum fill line beyond the general instruction to leave headspace as the recipe directs.

Jars that are storage jars, not canning jars

Three picks in the pickling guide use hinged clamp lids with silicone gaskets: the Anwoi 32OZ Wide Mouth Glass Storage Jars, the SAJKUERO 32 oz Pickling Jars, and the Muxryla 32 oz Pickling Jars. Those lids make a leak proof, airtight storage seal, and all three makers describe them that way. None of the three publishes a statement that the jar and lid are intended for water bath canning, and a clamp lid with a rubber gasket cannot be processed the way a metal two piece lid is.

That does not make them useless. They are good for refrigerator pickles, fermented vegetables, dry goods, and opened jars. SAJKUERO states 32 oz per jar and a wide mouth, and the set of four weighs 5.73 lb. Muxryla states a 3.74 in wide opening and includes replacement gaskets, labels, and a marker. Anwoi states a 3.74 in wide mouth and a set size of 6.7 x 7.3 in for the four pack, which is the packed size, not the jar’s own footprint.

Read the maker’s bullets to the end before assuming a jar is for canning. Anwoi, SAJKUERO, and Muxryla each list canning or pickling in the product title or feature text, but the closure they describe is a hinged lid with a gasket, and none of them publishes water bath processing instructions. Use them for the fridge, not the boiling pot.

Glass lid jars and the gasket and clip method

WECK is the exception worth knowing. The WECK Tulip Jars 1 Liter, 2 with Glass Lids appears in the Best Sourdough Starter Jars for Tracking a Rise guide, and WECK states that the jars are made for home canning, that they seal with a glass lid, a rubber gasket, and small stainless steel clips, and that they are dishwasher and microwave safe. WECK publishes a width of 4.5 in, a height of 7.0 in, and a weight of 1.0 lb.

The WECK method differs from the metal lid method. You fill the jar, seat the rubber gasket on the glass lid, clip it down, process it, and remove the clips once the jar has cooled and the lid has pulled down. WECK does not publish a processing time in the listing, so follow the recipe you are using and the jar maker’s own canning guidance. The size is stated as 1 liter, which is how WECK publishes it.

The order of steps that matters

Start with clean jars and a pot deep enough to cover them by an inch or two of water, with a rack on the bottom so the glass does not sit directly on the heat. Wash the jars in hot soapy water or run them through the dishwasher, and keep them hot until you fill them. Prepare the food from a tested recipe, because the acid level and the processing time are what make water bath canning safe, and neither is something you can judge by eye.

Fill one jar at a time, leaving the headspace the recipe states, and run a nonmetal tool around the inside to release trapped air. Wipe the rim clean, apply the lid and band until it is fingertip tight, and set the jar on the rack in the boiling water. Start counting the processing time when the water returns to a full boil, then turn off the heat, let the jars sit in the pot a few minutes, and lift them out onto a towel to cool undisturbed.

After the jars are cool, check each seal. A metal lid should be concave and should not flex when pressed. A WECK jar should have a lid that has pulled down against the gasket. Any jar that did not seal goes in the refrigerator and gets eaten first. Label the jars with the contents and the date, and store them somewhere cool and dark.

Matching the jar to the job

For a first batch, a small jar is easier to manage and easier to check. The Miuyhji 16 oz jars give you six jars with metal lids and bands, and Miuyhji states the glass is heat tempered and the jars are dishwasher safe. For larger batches of pickles, the ComSaf 32 oz jars give you two jars with split type lids and bands, and ComSaf states they are for water bath canning. The ComSaf listing also notes that the smooth jars do not include measurement marks, so measure your brine separately.

Keep the storage jars for the refrigerator. The Anwoi, SAJKUERO, and Muxryla jars are airtight and leak proof, which is exactly what you want for refrigerator pickles and fermented vegetables that stay cold. The WECK tulip jars sit between the two worlds: WECK states they are made for canning, and the glass lid, gasket, and clip closure is a different system that you should learn before you use it.

Whatever jar you choose, the recipe and the processing method do the preserving. The jar holds the food and takes the heat. Pick a jar whose maker states it is for canning, use a closure the process can seal, and follow a tested recipe for the food inside.

Common questions

Can you water bath can in jars with hinged clamp lids?

A hinged clamp lid with a silicone gasket makes a storage seal, not a canning seal. Anwoi, SAJKUERO, and Muxryla each describe their jars as airtight and leak proof, and none of them publishes water bath processing instructions for that closure. Use those jars for refrigerator pickles and fermented vegetables, and use a jar with a two piece metal lid or a glass lid with a gasket and clips for water bath canning.

What is the difference between a mason jar and a pickling jar?

A mason jar usually means a glass jar with a threaded neck that takes a flat metal lid and a screw band. A pickling jar can mean the same thing, or it can mean a jar with a hinged clamp lid and a rubber gasket. The ComSaf and Miuyhji jars in the pickling guide use metal lids and bands. The Anwoi, SAJKUERO, and Muxryla jars use hinged lids.

Do you have to sterilize jars before canning?

Wash the jars in hot soapy water or run them through the dishwasher, and keep them hot until you fill them. For recipes that process for ten minutes or more, that is generally enough. For shorter processing times, follow the recipe's instruction on sterilizing. The makers in these guides state that their jars are dishwasher safe, including ComSaf, Miuyhji, and WECK.

How much headspace should you leave in a mason jar?

The headspace is set by the recipe, not by the jar, and it varies with the food: jams and jellies usually take less than pickles or whole fruit. None of the makers in these guides publishes a headspace figure for canning, so take it from the tested recipe you are following. Leave the amount the recipe states, then wipe the rim before you apply the lid.

Can you reuse metal canning lids?

Flat metal lids are meant for one processing. The sealing compound softens with use, and a lid that has already sealed once may not seal again. Bands can be reused as long as they are not rusted or bent. ComSaf notes that lids are consumable parts over time. WECK rubber gaskets are also replaceable, and Muxryla includes extra replacement gaskets in its set.

Can you can in the oven instead of a water bath?

Oven canning is not a water bath process and does not heat the food the way a boiling water bath does. The makers in these guides describe water bath canning, and ComSaf specifically tells you to use proper water bath steps and to avoid sudden temperature changes. Dry oven heat on glass jars is a different stress than boiling water, and no maker here publishes oven canning instructions.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about pickling jars