Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

How to season a cast iron Dutch oven

Season the lid underside and the rim, not just the interior, then store the pot with the lid propped open. A closed pot traps moisture and is why most of them rust.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

Seasoning a Dutch oven is the same chemistry as seasoning a skillet, with one difference that decides whether it works: you have to season the lid as well, and then store the pot so the two are not sealed against each other. A pot is a closed container, and a closed container holds moisture. Our Best Dutch Ovens compares the published figures of five of them.

Only bare cast iron gets seasoned. If your pot has a smooth colored glass cooking face it is enameled, and oil baked onto enamel does not bond; it discolors the interior and can craze the finish. Enameled pots are the majority of what is sold for indoor cooking, so check before you start. The pots that do need seasoning are camp ovens, plain black pots with a matte iron interior, and anything second-hand that has been stripped.

Three surfaces, not one

A skillet has a cooking face and an outside. A Dutch oven has the interior, the exterior, the underside of the lid and the rim where they meet, and all four need the same thin coat. The two that get forgotten are the ones that matter most.

The underside of the lid is the coldest surface in the pot while food cooks, so steam condenses on it and runs back down. An unseasoned lid interior is where a Dutch oven starts rusting, often while the base still looks perfect. The rim is the other one: it is a narrow flat ledge that collects the water dripping off the lid, and it is the part a cloth skates over.

The cycle

Wash the pot and lid with hot water, dish soap and a brush or scraper, then dry both with heat on a burner or in a warm oven until they are too warm to hold. A large casting holds water in its rim channel long after a towel has stopped finding any, and a damp pot in a hot oven steams rather than bonding.

Put about a teaspoon of neutral oil on a cloth and work it over every surface of both pieces: inside, outside, base, handles, lid top, lid underside, and the rim. Then take a dry cloth and wipe all of it off again until nothing looks glossy. The thin rule is unforgiving in a pot because the interior walls drain: oil left high on a wall runs to the bottom and sets there as a soft, sticky film.

Bake both pieces separately at 450 degrees Fahrenheit for one hour, lid upside down so nothing pools in it, with a tray underneath. Then switch the oven off and leave them inside to cool. A Dutch oven is a heavy casting and cooling it in open air after a full hour at temperature is what stresses handles and rims. Three thin cycles give a pot a surface you can braise in.

Storing it is half the job

Never put a seasoned Dutch oven away with the lid closed. A sealed pot keeps whatever moisture remains against the iron for however long it sits in the cupboard, and that is the single biggest cause of a rusty pot. Store it with the lid ajar, upside down across the rim, or with a folded paper towel or a wine cork between lid and pot. Any of those is enough.

Weight is why this gets skipped. Our guide lists pots at 12.5 lb and 14.61 lb, with capacities from 3.6 to 7 quarts, and a pot at that weight is a two-handed object that gets heat dried last, if at all. Deciding in advance where it will live with the lid propped is more useful than any amount of good intention at the sink.

What good looks like, and what went wrong

A properly seasoned pot is an even dull dark brown going to black, matte rather than shiny, and slightly lighter in the corner where the wall meets the base. Tackiness anywhere means too much oil in that spot: scrub it back and run one more thin cycle.

Two problems are specific to pots. A sticky ring around the inside wall, a finger’s width up from the base, is drained oil that never converted, and it is the classic sign of a coat that was too generous. And a lid that has rusted while the pot has not means the lid was either left out of the seasoning or the pot was stored closed, which are the two halves of the same oversight.

Cooking is what finishes it

A Dutch oven earns its surface faster than a skillet because of what it is used for. Browning meat before a braise, frying in deep fat and baking bread all put hot oil against the whole interior for a long time, which is exactly what builds a layer. Three oven cycles and a couple of real braises will take a bare pot further than a week of empty rounds.

The exception is the food the pot is best at. Long tomato braises, wine reductions and anything acidic strip seasoning while they cook, so a bare iron pot used mainly for ragu will need its layer refreshed regularly. If that is most of your cooking, the honest answer is that an enameled pot suits the job better, because its glass surface is inert and needs no layer at all. Our Best Enameled Cast Iron Skillets compares the published figures of five of them.

Common questions

Do I need to season the lid of a cast iron Dutch oven?

Yes, and the underside especially. The inside of the lid is the coldest surface while food cooks, so steam condenses on it, and an unseasoned lid interior is usually where a pot first rusts. Bake the lid upside down so no oil pools in it.

Can I season an enameled Dutch oven?

No. Enamel is fused glass and oil will not bond to it, so baking oil on just discolors the interior and risks crazing the finish. Enameled pots need no seasoning at all, which is one of their advantages for long acidic cooking.

Why does my Dutch oven keep rusting even though I season it?

Almost certainly because it is stored with the lid closed. A sealed pot holds the last of the moisture against the iron for as long as it sits in the cupboard. Store it with the lid ajar, or put a paper towel or a cork between lid and rim.

What is the sticky ring around the inside of my pot?

Oil that drained down the walls and never converted. The interior of a pot slopes, so a generous coat on the wall ends up as a soft film a finger's width above the base. Scrub that band back and run one more cycle with the surface wiped matte first.

How many seasoning rounds does a bare Dutch oven need?

Three thin cycles give a surface you can braise in, and after that the cooking does the work. Browning meat, deep frying and baking bread all put hot oil against the whole interior for a long time, which builds a layer faster than empty oven rounds.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about dutch ovens