Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

Cuisinel vs Lodge cast iron: which one do you need?

This is a pan against a pan with a glass lid. The Cuisinel weight includes that lid, so the figures do not compare straight across, but its taller wall does.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

The honest answer to this comparison is that you are not really choosing between two skillets. You are choosing between a skillet and a skillet with a lid, because the Cuisinel pan in our guide is sold as a 12 inch pan with a glass cover and a silicone handle holder, and the Lodge pans are sold as pans. Everything that looks like a difference in the figures traces back to that. Our Best Cast Iron Skillets for Searing, Baking and Frying compares the published figures of five of them.

Read the weights carefully

Cuisinel publishes 11.35 lb for its 12 inch pan. Lodge publishes 7.5 lb for its 12 inch pan. That looks like a enormous gap for two pans of the same stated size, and it is not a fair comparison: the Cuisinel figure is the shipped product, which includes a glass lid, and glass is heavy. The iron itself is far closer than 11.35 against 7.5 suggests.

This is worth knowing in general, not just here. A published weight is the weight of whatever is in the box, so any pan sold with a lid, a handle cover, a scraper or a second pan will read heavier than a bare one, and comparing those numbers directly tells you about the bundle rather than about the pan. The smaller Lodge in our guide is published at 5.35 lb and is sold as 10.25 inch, which is the cleanest like-for-like figure in the set.

Published height is the one figure that does compare straight across, and it favors the Cuisinel: 3 in against 2.25 in for the Lodge of the same stated size. A taller wall genuinely changes what a pan can do.

What the lid is worth

A lid on a cast iron skillet is more useful than it sounds, and it is the reason to pick this pan. It turns the skillet into a shallow braiser: you can brown and then cover and let something finish, which is otherwise a job for a Dutch oven. It holds steam for vegetables, keeps splatter off the hob when shallow frying, and keeps food warm at the table.

Being glass rather than iron matters both ways. You can see in without lifting it, which is the whole appeal, but glass has a lower heat limit than the pan does, so a glass-lidded skillet cannot go under a broiler with the lid on and should not go into a very hot oven covered. Check the cover’s own rating rather than the pan’s.

The silicone handle holder in the Cuisinel bundle addresses the real nuisance of cast iron, which is that the handle is part of the casting and gets exactly as hot as the pan. The Lodge pans in our guide also ship with a handle holder, one with a hot handle holder and one with a silicone one, so that is not a point of difference between them.

What is identical

Both are bare, pre-seasoned cast iron, so both work from the first evening, both rust if stored damp, both improve with cooking, and both can be stripped and rebuilt indefinitely. Both have a cast handle that needs a cloth. Both take metal utensils. The care routine is the same for either, and our guide on how to clean a cast iron skillet after use applies to both without modification.

Neither brand publishes a surface roughness figure, so claims about one arriving smoother than the other are not supported by the specifications. If you want a very smooth cooking face, that is a reason to buy bare iron and sand it, not a reason to pick between these.

Which one do you need

Take the Cuisinel if you want one pan that browns and then braises, if you shallow fry often and dislike cleaning the hob afterwards, or if the taller 3 in wall suits what you cook. You are buying a lid and a deeper pan, and that is a real functional gain over a plain skillet.

Take the Lodge if you want the lightest 12 inch iron pan of the two, if you finish dishes under a broiler or in a hot oven where a glass lid cannot follow, or if you already own lids that fit. At 7.5 lb for a 12 inch pan it is the more manageable object, and the 10.25 inch Lodge at 5.35 lb is the easiest of all of them to handle one-handed.

If what appeals about the Cuisinel is the covered cooking rather than the skillet, the better buy may not be a skillet at all. A Dutch oven does covered braising properly, with an iron lid that has no temperature limit and a depth a skillet cannot match. Our Best Dutch Ovens compares the published figures of five of them.

Common questions

Why is the Cuisinel so much heavier than the Lodge?

Because the published figure is for everything in the box. Cuisinel's 11.35 lb for a 12 inch pan includes a glass lid, while Lodge's 7.5 lb for a 12 inch pan is the pan. Glass is heavy, so the iron itself is much closer than those two numbers suggest.

Is a lid on a cast iron skillet actually useful?

Yes, more than people expect. It lets you brown and then cover something to finish, which turns the skillet into a shallow braiser, and it keeps splatter off the hob when shallow frying. The limit is that glass has a lower heat ceiling than the pan, so it cannot follow the pan under a broiler.

Which has deeper sides?

The Cuisinel, at 3 in published against 2.25 in for the Lodge of the same stated size. Height is the one figure here that compares straight across, and a taller wall holds liquid better and spits less.

Do both come pre-seasoned?

Yes, and both ship with a handle holder as well, so neither needs an oven session before the first meal and neither leaves you holding a bare cast handle. Keep the first few meals fatty while the factory layer is still thin.

Is one of them smoother to cook on?

Neither publishes a surface roughness figure, so the specifications do not support that claim in either direction. A genuinely smooth iron surface is something you create by sanding bare iron before seasoning it.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about cast iron skillets