Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

What is the difference between an electric smoker and a gas smoker?

An electric smoker heats with an electric element and plugs into a socket, giving set and forget convenience and steady low heat, while a gas smoker burns propane for heat, running hotter and anywhere without power but needing more attention and fuel; both smolder wood chips for flavor.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

The core difference is how they make heat: an electric smoker uses an electric heating element and plugs into a socket, while a gas smoker burns propane from a tank to heat the cabinet. That one difference drives everything else. The electric smoker gives steady, set and forget convenience and runs at low temperatures, but needs mains power. The gas smoker runs hotter, works anywhere without electricity, and lights instantly, but needs fuel and more attention to hold a steady temperature. Both smolder wood chips for smoke flavor, so the taste is similar; it is the heat source and the way you tend them that differ. The vertical smokers in our best vertical smokers guide come in both styles.

The heat source

In an electric smoker, an element much like the one in an oven heats the cabinet, and a thermostat holds the temperature you set by switching the element on and off. In a gas smoker, a propane burner provides the heat, controlled by a gas valve you adjust, with the flame warming the cabinet and the wood chips above it. The electric smoker’s heat is regulated automatically; the gas smoker’s is set by the burner flame and needs manual adjustment and watching. This is the root of all the other differences between the two, from convenience to temperature range to where you can use them.

Convenience and control

Electric smokers win on convenience. You set a temperature and the thermostat holds it automatically, so you can leave it largely alone for hours, and many have digital controls, timers, and even remote features. A gas smoker needs you to set the burner and then watch and adjust it to keep the temperature steady, as it has no automatic thermostat, so it demands more of your attention. For a beginner or someone who wants to walk away during a long cook, the electric smoker’s set and forget nature is a big draw, while the gas smoker rewards a cook who likes to tend their fire.

Temperature range

Gas smokers reach higher temperatures than most electric smokers. The propane burner can drive the cabinet hotter, which lets a gas smoker crisp poultry skin, cook at higher heat when wanted, and recover temperature faster after the door is opened. Electric smokers are generally limited to lower maximum temperatures, which is fine for classic low and slow barbecue but can struggle to crisp skin or cook hot. If you want the flexibility of higher heat, gas has the edge, while if you only ever cook low and slow, the electric smoker’s range is perfectly adequate and its steadiness is an asset.

Power and portability

The need for electricity is a defining practical difference. An electric smoker must be near a power outlet, which ties it to places with mains power and makes it unsuitable for camping, tailgating, or remote use. A gas smoker needs no electricity, only a propane tank, so it works anywhere, which suits outdoor events, campsites, and places without a convenient socket. The flip side is that gas means buying, storing, and swapping propane tanks and never running out mid cook, while electric just needs plugging in. Where you will use the smoker often decides which makes sense.

Flavor and running cost

In flavor the two are close, because both rely on smoldering wood chips for the smoke, not on the heat source, so a well run electric and a well run gas smoker produce similar smoky results. Some enthusiasts feel gas gives a slightly more traditional feel, but the wood does the flavoring in both. On running cost, electric smokers are cheap and simple to run on household power and cycle their element efficiently, while gas smokers cost whatever propane costs and burn fuel continuously, though neither is expensive for the cooking they do. The choice rarely comes down to flavor or cost, but to convenience, temperature, and power.

Which to choose

Choose an electric smoker if you value convenience, want set and forget low and slow cooking, always have power where you smoke, and like digital control and minimal fuss. Choose a gas smoker if you want higher temperatures, the freedom to smoke anywhere without electricity, instant heat, and do not mind tending it and managing propane. Neither is better overall; they suit different cooks and situations. Many people pick the electric for its ease, while those who smoke away from power or want more heat and direct control prefer gas. Match the heat source and its trade offs to how and where you cook.

The short answer

So an electric smoker heats with an element and a thermostat, offering steady, set and forget low and slow cooking but needing mains power, while a gas smoker burns propane, running hotter and working anywhere without electricity but needing more attention and fuel. Both smolder wood chips, so the smoky flavor is similar. Pick electric for convenience and automatic control where power is handy, and gas for higher heat, portability, and tending it yourself. The decision comes down to convenience versus flexibility and where you will actually be smoking.

Common questions

What is the main difference between an electric and gas smoker?

The heat source. An electric smoker uses an electric element and a thermostat and plugs into a socket, holding a low temperature automatically for set and forget cooking. A gas smoker burns propane from a tank, running hotter and working anywhere without power, but needing manual adjustment and more attention. Both smolder wood chips for flavor, so the smoky taste is similar; the difference is how they heat and how much you tend them.

Is an electric or gas smoker more convenient?

Electric, clearly. You set a temperature and the thermostat holds it automatically, often with digital controls and timers, so you can leave it alone for hours. A gas smoker has no automatic thermostat, so you set the burner and then watch and adjust it to keep the heat steady, demanding more of your attention. For beginners or anyone who wants to walk away during a long cook, the electric smoker is far more convenient.

Does a gas smoker get hotter than an electric one?

Yes. A propane burner can drive the cabinet to higher temperatures than most electric smokers reach, so a gas smoker can crisp poultry skin, cook hotter when wanted, and recover temperature faster after the door opens. Electric smokers are usually limited to lower maximum temperatures, which is fine for low and slow barbecue but less able to crisp or cook hot. For high heat flexibility, gas has the edge.

Can you use a gas smoker without electricity?

Yes, that is one of its advantages. A gas smoker runs on a propane tank and needs no mains power, so it works at campsites, tailgates, and anywhere without a socket. An electric smoker must be near a power outlet, which ties it to places with electricity. The trade off is that gas means buying, storing, and swapping propane tanks, while electric just needs plugging in. Where you cook often decides which suits you.

Do electric and gas smokers taste different?

Not much. Both flavor food by smoldering wood chips, and the wood does the smoking, not the heat source, so a well run electric and a well run gas smoker give similar smoky results. Some enthusiasts feel gas has a slightly more traditional feel, but the difference is small. The choice between them usually comes down to convenience, temperature range, and whether you need to smoke away from mains power, rather than flavor.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about vertical smokers