How the Five Compare on the Numbers
The five picks split into two published footprints. The American Metalcraft STONE13 and the Gyreuni 13 inch set are both published as 13.0 by 13.0 inches, which is the least space any pick takes on a counter or shelf. The Gyreuni 15 inch rectangle is published as 15.0 by 12.0 inches, and the Old Stone and Loftern steel are both published as 14.0 by 16.0 inches. That is the first figure to check against your own shelf.
Weight separates them further. The American Metalcraft stone is 2.7 pounds, the Gyreuni 13 inch set is 6.46 pounds, the Gyreuni 15 inch rectangle is 7.1 pounds, the Old Stone is 10.0 pounds, and the Loftern steel is 13.6 pounds. If the stone will live in a low cupboard, the published weight is the figure you will feel every time you bake.
The table does not tell you how any of these bake. Nobody at Lush has used them, and no figure here comes from a test. It also does not tell you whether a stone will fit your specific oven rack, only what the maker publishes. Measure your shelf and your oven before you choose, and treat the published width and depth as the figures that decide the purchase.
Footprint and Storage in a Small Kitchen
The two 13.0 by 13.0 inch picks
The American Metalcraft STONE13 and the Gyreuni 13 inch set are both published as 13.0 by 13.0 inches. That is the least counter or shelf space any of the five takes. The American Metalcraft stone is 2.7 pounds, so it is also the easiest of the five to lift down from a high shelf or up from a low cupboard. The Gyreuni set is 6.46 pounds, more than twice as heavy, but its published contents include a serving rack, a peel, a cutter and parchment.
If your kitchen has one narrow shelf and nothing else, the published footprint is the figure that matters most. Both picks fit the same 13.0 by 13.0 inch square. The difference is what arrives with them and what you have to store alongside. The Gyreuni set adds a rack, a peel, a cutter and parchment to the same footprint, which is more to store but fewer separate purchases.
The 15.0 by 12.0 inch rectangle
The Gyreuni 15 inch rectangle is published as 15.0 by 12.0 inches and 7.1 pounds. A rectangle uses the corners of a rectangular shelf or oven rack that a round stone leaves empty. If your storage is a rectangular cupboard or a sheet pan slot, this shape is the one to check first. It is 2.0 inches wider and 1.0 inch less deep than the 13.0 by 13.0 inch picks, so it suits a wider, shallower space.
The published set includes a 12 by 17 inch oak peel, a steel cutter and 10 sheets of parchment, but no serving rack. The maker states the cordierite stone is heat safe up to 1472 degrees Fahrenheit. At 7.1 pounds it sits between the two 13.0 by 13.0 inch picks and the two 14.0 by 16.0 inch picks on weight, so it is a middle option on both shape and heft.
What Each One Does That the Others Do Not
A rack, a dishwasher claim, and a steel
The Gyreuni 13 inch set is the only pick whose published contents include a serving rack. The maker states the rack is there to keep you from being scalded by a hot stone, and that the stone doubles as a stand when placed in the opposite direction. No other pick publishes a rack. That is a storage item you do not have to buy separately, though it is also one more thing to find a place for.
The American Metalcraft STONE13 is the only pick published as dishwasher safe. The Gyreuni 15 inch listing states the opposite for its stone, telling you never to use soap or detergent and to scrub with a brush under warm water. The Old Stone and Loftern listings do not publish a dishwasher claim either way. If you want the least hand washing, the American Metalcraft claim is the one to note.
Bread, vegetables and a pre-seasoned plate
The Old Stone is published as suitable for bread, pastries and vegetables as well as pizza, and its maker states the cordierite withstands heat up to 1450 degrees Fahrenheit. It is 14.0 by 16.0 inches and 10.0 pounds. That published footprint gives more usable baking surface than the three smaller picks, which suits a kitchen where the stone will do more than pizza and the shelf can take the size.
The Loftern steel is published as pre-seasoned and ready to use, and as compatible with ovens, grills and pizza ovens. It is 14.0 by 16.0 inches, the same published footprint as the Old Stone, but 13.6 pounds, the heaviest of the five. Carbon steel is published as resistant to warping and cracking. The maker does not publish a maximum temperature, so no heat limit can be compared.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
If you have one narrow shelf and lift with care. The American Metalcraft STONE13 is published as 13.0 by 13.0 inches and 2.7 pounds, the lightest of the five, and it is the only pick published as dishwasher safe. It is the stone alone, with no peel or rack in the set.
If you want the tools in the same box. The Gyreuni 13 inch set is published as 13.0 by 13.0 inches and 6.46 pounds, and its contents include a serving rack, a 12 by 17 inch oak peel, a cutter and parchment. It is the only pick with a published rack.
If your storage is wider than it is deep. The Gyreuni 15 inch rectangle is published as 15.0 by 12.0 inches and 7.1 pounds. It uses the corners of a rectangular shelf that a round stone leaves empty, and its set includes a peel, a cutter and parchment.
If the stone will also bake bread and vegetables. The Old Stone is published as 14.0 by 16.0 inches and 10.0 pounds, with a stated heat limit of 1450 degrees Fahrenheit and a published list of uses beyond pizza. It needs a larger shelf than the three smaller picks.
If you want a steel rather than a stone. The Loftern steel is published as 14.0 by 16.0 inches and 13.6 pounds, pre-seasoned and ready to use, and compatible with ovens, grills and pizza ovens. It is the heaviest of the five, so check that you can lift it comfortably.
What We Could Not Verify
Several figures the makers do not publish would change how these five compare. None of the missing figures below were estimated or filled in.
- The KitchenStar 16 inch set does not publish a height, so its thickness cannot be compared with the five picks.
- The American Metalcraft STONE13 does not publish a maximum temperature, so its heat limit is unknown.
- The Loftern steel does not publish a maximum temperature, so its heat limit is unknown.
- The Chef Pomodoro steel does not publish a maximum temperature, so its heat limit is unknown.
- The ThermiChef steel does not publish a dishwasher-safe or hand-wash instruction.
- No listing publishes the interior dimensions of the ovens the stones are stated to fit, so fit in a specific oven cannot be confirmed from the sheet.