Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

Can you use a waffle maker to make grilled cheese?

Yes, a waffle maker makes an excellent grilled cheese, pressing and toasting the sandwich between its hot plates so the bread crisps with a waffle pattern and the cheese melts; butter the outside, do not overfill, and watch it, since it works much like a sandwich press.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

Yes, a waffle maker makes a very good grilled cheese, because it works much like a sandwich press: it presses the sandwich between two hot plates and toasts both sides at once, crisping the bread, with a waffle pattern, while the heat melts the cheese inside. You butter the outside of the bread, put the cheese between the slices, close the waffle maker on it, and in a few minutes you have a crisp, melty grilled cheese. The keys are to butter the outside for crisping, not to overfill with cheese so it does not ooze out everywhere, and to watch it. Any of the waffle makers in our best waffle makers guide can double as a grilled cheese press.

Why it works

A waffle maker is essentially a double sided press with hot plates, which is exactly what makes a good grilled cheese. Pressing the sandwich between two heated surfaces toasts both sides of the bread simultaneously and drives heat into the middle to melt the cheese, the same way a dedicated panini or sandwich press does. The ridged plates give the bread a crisp, patterned surface and little pockets that hold butter and crisp up nicely. So although it is made for waffles, the waffle maker’s design, hot plates that press food, is well suited to grilled cheese, which is why it is one of the most popular non waffle uses for the appliance.

How to make it

Making grilled cheese in a waffle maker is simple. Preheat the waffle maker. Butter the outside of two slices of bread, the sides that will touch the plates, and put your cheese, and any other fillings, between the unbuttered sides to form a sandwich. Place the sandwich in the waffle maker and gently close the lid, pressing lightly but not forcing it. Let it cook for a few minutes until the bread is crisp and golden and the cheese has melted, checking as it goes since timing varies with the maker. Then lift it out, let it cool for a moment, and you have a crisp, patterned grilled cheese ready to eat.

Butter the outside for crispness

Buttering the outside of the bread is the key to a crisp, golden grilled cheese, just as in a pan. The butter on the outside surfaces crisps and browns against the hot plates, giving the sandwich its appealing crunch and color and helping it release from the plates. You can use butter or a little oil, or even mayonnaise on the outside, which some people prefer for crisping. Do not butter the inside, where the cheese goes. Greasing the plates lightly as well can help prevent sticking, especially if the non stick is worn. The buttered outside is what turns a pressed sandwich into a proper crisp grilled cheese.

Do not overfill with cheese

The main thing to manage is the cheese oozing out. If you pile in too much cheese or fillings, they melt and squeeze out of the sides as you press the sandwich, making a mess on the plates that burns and is hard to clean. Use a moderate amount of cheese, enough to melt and fill the sandwich but not so much that it overflows when pressed, and keep any other fillings modest. Press the lid gently rather than clamping it hard. Some cheese escaping is normal and can crisp into tasty edges, but a lot of overflow is messy, so err on the side of less filling for a clean result.

Cleaning up afterward

Because melted cheese and butter are involved, clean the waffle maker after making grilled cheese, ideally once it has cooled but while any residue is still soft. Wipe the plates with a damp cloth or paper towel to lift off melted cheese and grease, and for stuck on cheese, lay a damp cloth over the closed plates for a few minutes to loosen it before wiping. Never submerge the waffle maker, and avoid abrasive scrubbers on the non stick plates. Cleaning promptly after grilled cheese keeps the plates in good condition and ready for the next use, waffle or sandwich, and stops cheese baking on and smoking next time.

The short answer

So yes, a waffle maker makes an excellent grilled cheese, working like a sandwich press to toast and crisp the bread on both sides while melting the cheese, with an appealing waffle pattern. Preheat it, butter the outside of the bread for crispness, keep the cheese and fillings moderate so they do not ooze out everywhere, press the lid gently, and watch it until the bread is golden and the cheese melted. Clean the plates afterward while the residue is soft. It is one of the best non waffle uses for a waffle maker, turning out a crisp, melty grilled cheese in minutes.

Common questions

Can you make grilled cheese in a waffle maker?

Yes, and it makes a very good one. The waffle maker works like a sandwich press, pressing the sandwich between two hot plates so both sides of the bread crisp, with a waffle pattern, while the heat melts the cheese inside. Butter the outside of the bread, keep the cheese moderate so it does not ooze out, press the lid gently, and cook a few minutes until golden and melted. It is one of the best non waffle uses for the appliance.

How do you make grilled cheese in a waffle maker?

Preheat the waffle maker, butter the outside of two slices of bread, and put cheese between the unbuttered sides to form a sandwich. Place it in the maker, gently close the lid, and cook for a few minutes until the bread is crisp and golden and the cheese melted, checking as it goes. Lift it out and let it cool briefly. Keep the cheese moderate so it does not overflow, and clean the plates afterward while the residue is soft.

Should you butter the bread for waffle maker grilled cheese?

Yes, butter the outside surfaces that touch the plates, just as in a pan. The butter crisps and browns against the hot plates, giving the sandwich its crunch and color and helping it release. Some people use oil or mayonnaise on the outside instead for crisping. Do not butter the inside where the cheese goes, and greasing the plates lightly as well helps prevent sticking, especially if the non stick is worn.

Why does the cheese ooze out in a waffle maker?

Because there is too much cheese or filling, so it melts and squeezes out of the sides as you press the sandwich, making a mess that burns on the plates. Use a moderate amount of cheese, enough to fill the sandwich but not overflow when pressed, keep other fillings modest, and press the lid gently rather than clamping hard. A little escaping cheese can crisp into tasty edges, but err on the side of less filling for a clean result.

How do you clean a waffle maker after grilled cheese?

Let it cool but clean it while the residue is still soft. Wipe the plates with a damp cloth or paper towel to lift off melted cheese and grease, and for stuck on cheese, lay a damp cloth over the closed plates for a few minutes to loosen it before wiping. Never submerge the waffle maker, and avoid abrasive scrubbers on the non stick plates. Cleaning promptly keeps the plates in good condition and stops cheese baking on and smoking next time.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about waffle makers