How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A small kitchen changes the choice because the published width and depth decide how much counter and drawer space a rolling pin takes. The AMUZHI is 1.26 by 12.8 inches and 0.4 pounds. The KARRYOUNG is 1.57 by 18.0 inches and 0.53 pounds. The Amazon Basics is 1.57 by 17.0 inches and 0.66 pounds. The Farberware is 2.5 by 17.5 inches and 1.04 pounds. The BIDFUL is 2.75 by 17.32 inches and 1.17 pounds. Those figures are the ones that decide the pick.
Weight follows the same order. The AMUZHI is the lightest of the five at 0.4 pounds. The KARRYOUNG is 0.53 pounds. The Amazon Basics is 0.66 pounds. The Farberware is 1.04 pounds. The BIDFUL is 1.17 pounds. A lighter pin is easier to lift from a drawer and easier to set down on a crowded counter. The manufacturer does not publish a height for the BIDFUL, the AMUZHI, or the KARRYOUNG.
The table does not tell you how a pin feels in the hand, how a wood grain looks, or whether a coating wears. It also does not tell you the barrel length for three of the five, because the makers do not publish it. The figures are the published ones, and the missing ones are marked as not published rather than filled in.
What the Published Footprint Decides
Width and drawer fit
The AMUZHI is 1.26 by 12.8 inches, the smallest published footprint of the five. That width is narrower than the KARRYOUNG and the Amazon Basics at 1.57 inches, the Farberware at 2.5 inches, and the BIDFUL at 2.75 inches. A narrow pin slides into a shallow drawer beside a spatula. A wider pin needs its own slot or a crock on the counter.
The depth matters too. The AMUZHI is 12.8 inches deep, which is shorter than the KARRYOUNG at 18.0 inches, the Farberware at 17.5 inches, the BIDFUL at 17.32 inches, and the Amazon Basics at 17.0 inches. A 12.8 inch pin fits across a narrow drawer. An 18.0 inch pin may not. The manufacturer does not publish a height for the AMUZHI, so the drawer clearance is not stated.
Weight and handling
The AMUZHI is 0.4 pounds, the lightest of the five. The KARRYOUNG is 0.53 pounds. The Amazon Basics is 0.66 pounds. The Farberware is 1.04 pounds. The BIDFUL is 1.17 pounds. A lighter pin is easier to lift and easier to store on a hook. A heavier pin presses dough with less effort, which the makers of the Farberware and the OXO state as a benefit.
The AMUZHI is a one-piece 304 stainless steel roller with a seamless barrel. The maker states the light hollow design saves wrist strength. The KARRYOUNG is solid rubber wood with a tapered French shape. The Amazon Basics is acacia wood with a tapered French shape. The Farberware is hardwood with a 10 inch barrel and ergonomic handles. The BIDFUL is stainless steel with four removable rings.
What Each Pin Does That the Others Do Not
Adjustable thickness and rings
The BIDFUL is the only one of the five that publishes removable thickness rings. The rings are 1/16, 1/8, 1/4, and 3/8 inch, which the maker lists as 2mm, 3mm, 6mm, and 10mm. The maker states the rings help achieve a desirable dough thickness for pizza, pies, biscuits, breads, dumplings, pasta, or pancakes. The pin is 2.75 by 17.32 inches and 1.17 pounds.
The Fulimax also publishes four rings at 1/16, 1/8, 1/4, and 3/8 inch, but its published weight is not in the fact sheet, so it is not one of the five. The AMUZHI, the KARRYOUNG, the Amazon Basics, and the Farberware do not list rings. For a baker who wants one pin to do several thicknesses, the BIDFUL is the pick with the published rings.
Chilling and dough temperature
The AMUZHI states the whole roller can be cooled in the fridge first, which the maker says is perfect for flaky croissants and crisp pie crusts. The OXO also states the metal pin can be chilled, but its published depth is 20.5 inches, which is longer than the AMUZHI at 12.8 inches. For a small kitchen, the AMUZHI gives the chilling feature in the smaller published footprint.
The KARRYOUNG, the Amazon Basics, and the Farberware do not publish a chilling instruction. The Farberware is hardwood, and the maker recommends wiping it clean and treating it with food-grade mineral oil. The Amazon Basics is acacia wood and hand wash only. The KARRYOUNG is rubber wood and wipe clean. Wood pins are not listed as freezable by their makers.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
If your drawer is narrow. The AMUZHI is 1.26 by 12.8 inches and 0.4 pounds, the smallest published footprint of the five. It is the one to check first when counter and drawer space are tight.
If you want a tapered French pin. The KARRYOUNG is 1.57 by 18.0 inches and 0.53 pounds. The Amazon Basics is 1.57 by 17.0 inches and 0.66 pounds. Both are wood and tapered, and both are lighter than the Farberware and the BIDFUL.
If you roll large sheets. The Farberware states a 10 inch barrel and is 2.5 by 17.5 inches and 1.04 pounds. The OXO states a 12 inch length for large crusts, but its published depth is 20.5 inches, so it is not one of the five for a small kitchen.
If you want one pin for several thicknesses. The BIDFUL is 2.75 by 17.32 inches and 1.17 pounds, and it publishes four removable rings at 1/16, 1/8, 1/4, and 3/8 inch. It is the only one of the five with published rings.
If you chill dough. The AMUZHI states the whole roller can be cooled in the fridge first. It is 1.26 by 12.8 inches and 0.4 pounds, so the chilling feature comes in the smallest published footprint of the five.
What We Could Not Verify
Several figures are not published by the makers, and I did not fill them in.
- The manufacturer does not publish a height for the BIDFUL, the AMUZHI, or the KARRYOUNG.
- The manufacturer does not publish a barrel length for the BIDFUL, the Amazon Basics, or the KARRYOUNG.
- The manufacturer does not publish the diameter of the AMUZHI barrel.
- The manufacturer does not publish a storage case or sleeve for any of the five.
- The manufacturer does not publish a weight for the Fulimax, the Ultra Cuisine, or the OXO in the fact sheet.
- The manufacturer does not publish a dishwasher instruction for the AMUZHI.