How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Capacity is the first figure a buyer looks for and one of these five does not publish it. Youeon states 68 oz, Freshmage 52 oz, Tessco 50 oz and GoodCook 5 cup. SOLIGT gives no total volume for its glass jars, only a 3.93 by 6.69 inch size and a 3 oz figure for the dressing container that sits at the bottom of the stack.
The size and weight fields are thinner than that. Freshmage publishes all three dimensions, at 7.6 by 7.6 by 7.4 inches, and 1.4 pounds for its two pack. Youeon and Tessco publish a size string only, 9.5 by 6.8 by 3.8 inches and 6.9 by 6.9 by 3.9 inches. GoodCook gives 7 by 7 by 7 inches and no weight, and the four SOLIGT glass jars come to 4.63 pounds.
What the table cannot show is how much of each bowl the divider leaves for leaves, because none of the five publishes the volume below it. Two other candidates were set aside as the wrong tool for this page: a set of ten single compartment prep bowls with no divider and no dressing cup, and a five piece produce keeper with colanders, which stores washed fruit rather than a built salad.
Where the Dressing Goes
Three ounces at the bottom of a jar
SOLIGT is the only pick that puts the dressing underneath the salad. Its wide mouth mason jar is divided into three separate spaces by two layers of small plastic containers, with the 3 oz container at the base and the leaves above it. Nothing mixes until the jar is poured out, which is also why this is the one listing that claims a keeping time, up to five days in the refrigerator.
Youeon reaches the same 3 oz figure through a different arrangement. Its sauce container sits in the middle compartment of a removable tray above the bowl and carries a leakproof lid of its own. Both makers state a volume, which is more than Freshmage or Tessco do, and 3 oz is a figure that suits a thick dressing rather than a thin vinaigrette.
Two ounces that nest, and two cups nobody measured
GoodCook publishes the smallest stated dressing volume of the three that give one, at 2 oz, and it is the only one built to nest. The five cups stack into each other when the set is put away, which is the difference between a drawer of loose cups and a single column. Two ounces covers one serving of a thin dressing and little more.
Freshmage and Tessco both include a dressing holder and neither says how much it holds. Freshmage describes a sauce container in the middle of the bowl. Tessco describes a removable dressing container inside a double layer build. Both are real parts and neither is a number, so anyone choosing on dressing volume is left with the three listings that publish one.
One Container or a Week of Them
The five and six bowl sets
GoodCook and Tessco are bought by the week rather than by the bowl. GoodCook counts twenty five pieces in total: five bowls, five removable three compartment trays, five nesting 2 oz dressing cups and five lids. Tessco supplies six bowls at 50 oz each, in three colors with two of every color, and a reusable fork packed with each one.
The colors and the write on lid do the same job by different means. Tessco separates lunches by color, so two people can share one set without labeling anything. GoodCook uses a lid you can write on and erase, which records the date rather than the owner. Neither publishes a weight, so neither can be judged on how heavy a loaded week of bowls becomes.
The two and three bowl packs
Freshmage and Youeon are closer to a single container you keep refilling. The Freshmage two pack of 52 oz bowls weighs 1.4 pounds and is round, published at 7.6 inches across and 7.4 inches high. The Youeon three pack of 68 oz bowls weighs 2.16 pounds and is the flatter shape, 9.5 by 6.8 by 3.8 inches by its own size string.
Those shapes point at different bags. A bowl 7.4 inches high stands up in a tote and wastes room in a flat lunch bag, while a container 3.8 inches high slides into a backpack sleeve and will not stand on a desk. The SOLIGT jars are published at 6.69 inches high and are glass, so they want a bag that does not get dropped.
Lids, Heating and What the Listings Commit To
Four closures, four mechanisms
No two of the five close the same way. Youeon states a built in silicone seal with a four sided latch. Tessco states a rubberized sealing ring with locking clips. Freshmage states tight locks and argues directly against lids that seal on a rubber rim. SOLIGT uses a plastic mason lid with removable silicone rings on both the lid and the dressing container.
GoodCook is the outlier, because its lid is described for labeling rather than for sealing. The listing calls it a write on and erase lid and states the set is microwave, freezer and top rack dishwasher safe, but it names no gasket, no clip and no latch. For a bowl that travels with dressing already in it, that silence is the thing to weigh.
What each maker will state about heat and cleaning
Three of the five make a heating claim. GoodCook states microwave, freezer and top rack dishwasher safe. Tessco states microwave, freezer and dishwasher safe. Youeon states microwave, dishwasher and refrigerator safe and then excludes the lid by name, which is the most specific instruction any of these five listings gives about its own limits.
Freshmage and SOLIGT say nothing about either. Freshmage names no plastic at all, only food grade safe material, and SOLIGT sells the one container here you would assume survives a dishwasher without being told. Silence is not a warning, but it is not a permission either, and it is why both lost ground on the material and heating criterion.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
The Sunday batch prepper. GoodCook, for five bowls, five removable three compartment trays, five nesting 2 oz dressing cups and a lid you can date and wipe clean. It is the only set of the five that addresses which day a given bowl belongs to.
A household packing two or three lunches. Tessco. Six bowls at 50 oz in three colors, two of every color, so nobody has to label anything, and a reusable fork packed with each bowl rather than one shared with the kitchen drawer.
The big appetite. Youeon, at 68 oz with a removable four compartment tray, a 3 oz sauce container and a salad spoon. It is also the only pick that tells you exactly which part of it cannot go in the microwave.
The commuter who shakes the salad. Freshmage. A round 52 oz bowl published at 7.6 inches across, with three compartments, a sauce cup in the middle and a lid built on locks rather than on a rubber rim.
The cook who prefers glass. SOLIGT. A wide mouth mason jar split into three spaces by two plastic inner containers, with the 3 oz dressing at the base, and the only keeping claim in this group at up to five days.
What We Could Not Verify
Six things a buyer would want that no listing on this page answers.
- The volume left in each bowl once the topping divider is in place, which no maker publishes.
- The dressing container volume for Freshmage and for Tessco, both of which include one.
- What plastic Freshmage and GoodCook use, beyond the phrase food grade.
- A published weight for either the GoodCook or the Tessco set.
- Whether the SOLIGT glass jars are dishwasher or microwave safe, since that listing makes no claim.
- What the GoodCook embossed markings measure in, and how fine the increments are.