How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Three of these five publish a rectangular outside and say what it is. Chicago Metallic states 13.5 by 9.5 by 2.25 inches rim to rim. MICHELANGELO states 16.5 by 11.5 by 2.3 inches. AMZ-UTHHF states 15.6 by 11.6 by 2.8 inches in its title and 15.5 by 11.6 inches in its text. Those are the figures a small oven is measured against.
The other two are different objects. Granite Ware is round with a cover, published as 9.25 by 5.5 in and holding up to 3 lbs of poultry. bajindan is an enamel pan with a domed lid and a removable rack that publishes no shape figure in words at all, leaving dimension fields of 7.99 by 13 by 4.72 in as the only numbers.
What the table cannot tell you is the usable floor on three of these five. Only Chicago Metallic and MICHELANGELO publish an interior, so for AMZ-UTHHF, Granite Ware and bajindan the outside figure is all there is, and the wall thickness and the slope of the sides come out of it before anything is roasted.
Shape, and Why It Comes First
The Three Rectangles
Chicago Metallic is the smallest of the three at a stated 13.5 by 9.5 by 2.25 inches, and it is the only listing in this pool that states its figure is rim to rim, so the reader knows where the measurement was taken. AMZ-UTHHF is 15.6 by 11.6 by 2.8 inches. MICHELANGELO is 16.5 by 11.5 by 2.3 inches.
On a small oven shelf those three inches between the Chicago Metallic and the MICHELANGELO are the whole decision, because a shelf that takes one will not take the other with the door shut. All three use the corners, which is the structural advantage a rectangle has over the round pan here, and all three come with a rack and no lid.
Round, and Unstated
Granite Ware is the round one. Published as 9.25 by 5.5 in, it holds up to 3 lbs of poultry with the lid on, which is one small chicken. In a very small oven that is the point: a round covered pan fits where a 16 inch rectangle cannot, and the cover does the work a bigger pan would do with foil.
bajindan publishes no shape figure in its own words. It is called a 16 Inch pan, its fields read 7.99 by 13 by 4.72 in, and nothing in the text explains what the 16 inches measures. For a page about fitting a small oven that is the least useful position in the group, and it is the one thing this listing leaves out.
Handles, Interiors and the Figures Behind the Figure
The Pan Is Wider Than the Pan
MICHELANGELO publishes something no other listing here does: 16.7 in of total width with the handles on, against a 16.5 inch pan. That is the number an oven cavity actually refuses, and it is the reason the same listing tells you to measure your oven before ordering.
The other four publish a pan figure and stop. Chicago Metallic, AMZ-UTHHF and MICHELANGELO all describe handles or a rack with handles, so all three are wider in use than on paper. Granite Ware and bajindan are lidded pans where the lid, not the handles, is the extra, and neither publishes a figure for it either.
Two Publish What Is Inside
Chicago Metallic states an inner cooking surface of 12.75 by 9.875 inches against its 13.5 by 9.5 inch outside, which is an unusually honest pair of figures. MICHELANGELO states an interior of 14.6 by 10.6 by 2.2 inches against a 16.5 by 11.5 by 2.3 inch pan.
Those are the only two interiors in this group, and together with the handle width they make MICHELANGELO and Chicago Metallic the two best documented pans here. AMZ-UTHHF, Granite Ware and bajindan all publish an outside or a field figure and leave the usable floor to be guessed from the photographs.
Lids, Racks and Heat
What Arrives With the Pan
Four of the five include a rack. Chicago Metallic supplies a flat fold out handle rack coated in the same nonstick as the pan. MICHELANGELO supplies a removable V rack. AMZ-UTHHF supplies a stainless rack. bajindan supplies a removable rack and a domed lid, which makes it the only pick here with both.
Granite Ware supplies a cover and publishes no rack, so food sits in the drippings under a lid. For one small bird that is a different cooking method rather than a shortcoming, and the listing is clear about the scale it is meant for: up to 3 lbs of poultry.
Oven Ceilings, Including One Published Twice
MICHELANGELO states 600 degrees Fahrenheit and adds the longest compatibility list in this pool: induction, gas, ceramic, halogen, electric and glass cooktops as well as open flame. AMZ-UTHHF states 450 degrees Fahrenheit, which is the lowest published figure here and worth knowing before a high heat roast.
bajindan publishes two different ceilings. Its title states 932 degrees Fahrenheit heat resistance and its feature text states oven safe up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, or 260 Celsius. Both are published, nothing reconciles them, and a reader should plan around the lower one. Chicago Metallic and Granite Ware publish no ceiling at all.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
A small oven you have measured. Chicago Metallic, a rectangular pan stated 13.5 by 9.5 by 2.25 inches rim to rim with a 12.75 by 9.875 inch inside and a fold out rack. No weight and no oven ceiling are published.
A pan with nothing on it to flake. AMZ-UTHHF, rectangular at a stated 15.6 by 11.6 by 2.8 inches in uncoated food grade stainless, 450 degrees Fahrenheit, dishwasher safe. Its two stated sizes differ slightly.
Roasting then finishing the gravy. MICHELANGELO, 16.5 by 11.5 by 2.3 inches with a 14.6 by 10.6 by 2.2 inch interior, 16.7 in across the handles, six cooktop types and 600 degrees Fahrenheit. Hand wash only.
One chicken and very little shelf. Granite Ware, a round covered roaster stated 9.25 by 5.5 in at 1.33 lb, taking up to 3 lbs of poultry. No rack, and its two size figures disagree.
A domed lid over a small turkey. bajindan, enamel carbon steel with a moisture lock lid and a removable rack for a turkey up to 12 lbs. It publishes no shape figure and two different oven ceilings.
What We Could Not Verify
These are the figures this comparison went looking for and could not source from the listings themselves.
- Any shape figure in the bajindan feature text, and what its 16 Inch name measures.
- Which bajindan oven ceiling applies, the 500 in the text or the 932 in the title.
- Whether the Granite Ware 9.25 by 5.5 in figure is a diameter and a height.
- A published weight for Chicago Metallic.
- An oven ceiling for Chicago Metallic and Granite Ware.
- A width with handles for four of the five.