How the Five Compare on the Numbers
The five picks publish different sets of figures. Collive publishes a 0.47 inch height and a 5.34 pound weight. KitchenClouds publishes a 0.5 inch height, a 17.3 inch width, and a 28 inch depth. KIMODE publishes a 0.47 inch height. HappyTrends publishes a 0.47 inch height and a 5.55 pound weight. StepRite publishes a 0.4 inch height and a 0.55 pound weight. Only KitchenClouds publishes a width and a depth.
Weight separates the picks that publish it. StepRite states 0.55 pounds, Collive states 5.34 pounds, and HappyTrends states 5.55 pounds. KitchenClouds and KIMODE do not publish a weight, so they cannot be placed on that scale. The height figures cluster tightly: 0.4 inch, 0.47 inch, and 0.5 inch. The difference between the smallest and largest published height is 0.1 inch.
The table does not tell you how any mat feels underfoot, how much it compresses, or how long it lasts. No pick publishes a load rating, a compression figure, or a warranty length. The height figures are close enough that the gap between 0.4 inch and 0.47 inch is unlikely to be the deciding factor. What the table does show is which makers publish a full set of figures and which do not.
What the Published Thickness Figures Mean
The 0.4 inch and 0.47 inch group
StepRite publishes a 0.4 inch height, the smallest figure among the five picks. Collive, KIMODE, and HappyTrends each publish a 0.47 inch height. The difference between 0.4 inch and 0.47 inch is 0.07 inch. All four of these mats are two-piece sets, so the published height applies to each mat in the set. None of the four publishes a width or depth for the individual mats.
StepRite also publishes a 0.55 pound weight, the smallest figure among the five picks. Collive publishes 5.34 pounds and HappyTrends publishes 5.55 pounds. KIMODE does not publish a weight. A reader comparing StepRite and HappyTrends on weight alone is looking at a difference of 5 pounds between the two stated figures.
The 0.5 inch single mat
KitchenClouds publishes a 0.5 inch height, the largest figure among the five picks. It is also the only pick that publishes a width and a depth: 17.3 inches and 28 inches. That makes it the only pick whose footprint can be checked against a specific space before purchase. It is a single mat, not a set, so it covers one standing area rather than two.
KitchenClouds does not publish a weight. The maker states the mat is made of soft PVC foam with a diamond-shaped non-slip bottom and a beveled edge. The care instructions state the surface wipes clean with a wet cloth, a vacuum, or a sweep. The maker also states that water under the mat may cause slippage and that creases can be removed with a hairdryer on a warm setting.
How the Sets Differ in Coverage
Sets with a long and a short mat
Collive, KIMODE, and StepRite each pair a longer mat with a shorter one. Collive and KIMODE state the same sizes: 17.3 by 47 inches and 17.3 by 29 inches. StepRite states 17.3 by 47 inches and 17.3 by 30 inches. The short mat in the StepRite set is 1 inch longer than the short mat in the Collive and KIMODE sets, based on the stated sizes.
Collive publishes a 5.34 pound weight for its set. KIMODE does not publish a weight. StepRite publishes a 0.55 pound weight for its set. The difference between the Collive and StepRite stated weights is 4.79 pounds. All three sets state a non-slip backing, and Collive and KIMODE state a beveled edge or textured top.
The set with two equal mats
HappyTrends pairs two mats of the same stated size: 17.3 by 39 inches each. That differs from the other three sets, which pair a long mat with a short one. A reader who wants two mats of equal length has one option among the five picks. HappyTrends publishes a 5.55 pound weight, the largest figure among the five picks, and a 0.47 inch height.
The maker states the PVC material is phthalate-free, latex-free, and odor-free. The mat has a beveled edge and a non-slip backing. The care instructions state the mat can be rinsed with cold water or wiped with a damp cloth and then air dried. The maker also states the mat should be opened fully and placed on a flat surface.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
Buyer who wants two mats of equal length. HappyTrends is the only pick that pairs two mats of the same stated size, 17.3 by 39 inches each. It publishes a 5.55 pound weight and a 0.47 inch height. The maker states the material is phthalate-free and latex-free.
Buyer who needs a published width and depth. KitchenClouds is the only pick that publishes a width and a depth, 17.3 inches and 28 inches. It is a single mat with a 0.5 inch height. It does not publish a weight, so it cannot be compared on that figure.
Buyer who wants a two-piece set with a published weight. Collive publishes a 5.34 pound weight and a 0.47 inch height. The set states sizes of 17.3 by 47 and 17.3 by 29 inches. The maker states the surface is waterproof and oil proof.
Buyer who wants a lightweight two-piece set. StepRite publishes a 0.55 pound weight and a 0.4 inch height, the smallest figures among the five picks. The set states sizes of 17.3 by 47 and 17.3 by 30 inches. The maker states the backing grips tile, wood, ceramic, and marble.
Buyer who wants a two-piece set with a 0.47 inch height and no published weight. KIMODE publishes a 0.47 inch height and states sizes of 17.3 by 47 and 17.3 by 29 inches. It does not publish a weight. The maker states the non-slip bottom works on hard and carpet floors.
What We Could Not Verify
Several figures that would help a buyer compare these mats are not published by the makers. The list below records what was missing from the fact sheet.
- No pick publishes a load rating or a compression figure for the foam or PVC.
- No pick publishes a warranty length.
- KitchenClouds and KIMODE do not publish a weight.
- Collive, KIMODE, HappyTrends, and StepRite do not publish a width or depth for the individual mats in their sets.
- StepRite does not state the material used in its mats.
- No pick publishes a water resistance rating, only a general statement that the surface is water resistant or waterproof.