Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Baking

Best Baguette Baking Trays for Lifting a Hot Pan

Not one of these five pans has a handle, so the deciding specification becomes what the maker says about the edge you grip and how much pan there is to balance.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

I compared every edge and corner description, published weights, the maker's own size wording, channel counts, metals and washing instructions across five baguette pan listings, using only each maker's own text.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. EAMQXERTOI Baguette Bread Pan
    Best for a pan you handle with a cloth

    EAMQXERTOI Baguette Bread Pan

    The only one of the five that calls its edges burr free and says why, stating smooth burr free edges for easy cleaning and then repeating that smooth edges make cleanup easier. EAMQXERTOI bakes four baguettes on heavy duty carbon steel with a food grade nonstick coating, and its own bullet states 15 by 13 by 0.87 inches. Its published weight of 0.57 lb is low for a four channel pan, which also makes it the easier of the two four loaf pans here to bring out of an oven. It publishes no oven temperature and nothing about a dishwasher.

    • EAMQXERTOI
    • 15.08 x 12.99 x 0.87 Inches
    • 0.57 lb
  2. Pavsrmy Baguette Bread Pan
    Best for knowing your oven will take it

    Pavsrmy Baguette Bread Pan

    Pavsrmy is the only one of the five that publishes an oven requirement, stating the pan measures 15 by 13 inches and fits large home ovens of at least 1.2 cu ft. It describes a rounded corners design, heavy duty carbon steel rated to 446 F, a BPA free nonstick coating and hand washing for best results, and it bakes four loaves. At a published 1.0 lb it is the heaviest of the five, which is the trade for four channels in thick steel. Nothing in the listing describes the edge finish itself.

    • Pavsrmy
    • Large
    • 1 lb
  3. Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick Perforated ...
    Best for putting the pan in the machine

    Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick Perforated ...

    The only pick stating dishwasher safe, with the caveat that hand washing preserves the two layer nonstick coating and that oil or parchment helps release. Chicago Metallic is also the only pan here in heavy weight aluminum rather than carbon steel, and it states 16 by 9 by 1.5 inches for three full size loaves at 0.86 lb. Its published height field reads 1.0 inch, which contradicts the 1.5 inches in its own title and features, so the maker's wording is used here. It says nothing about its edges.

    • Chicago Metallic
    • 3 Loaves
    • 0.86 lb
  4. Gicyiit Baguette Bread Pan
    Best three loaf pan for a normal oven

    Gicyiit Baguette Bread Pan

    Gicyiit states 15 by 9.5 inches for three loaves in thickened carbon steel, rated to 446 F, with a BPA free food grade nonstick coating and hand washing recommended. It argues its three slot design fits most home ovens better than a wider pan, which is the practical reason to prefer it over a four channel tray if your oven is ordinary. At 0.8 lb it sits in the middle of the five by published weight. It also states that a smooth crimping design ensures safe handling, which is the third of only three references to the rim on this page.

    • Gicyiit
    • 3 Loaves Baguette Baking Pan
    • 0.8 lb
  5. KITESSENSU Nonstick Baguette Pans for French Bread B...
    Best for lifting out with one cloth

    KITESSENSU Nonstick Baguette Pans for French Bread B...

    The lightest of the five at a published 0.46 lb, and at a stated 15 by 6.3 inches it is narrow enough to bring out folded in one cloth. KITESSENSU bakes two loaves, describes curved grooves that shape the base of the loaf and evenly distributed pores, and states a ten year warranty, which no other listing here offers. It also argues that you no longer need proofing baskets or cloths. What it does not publish is the metal, an oven temperature, a washing instruction or anything about the edge.

    • KITESSENSU
    • 2Loaf 15" x 6.3"
    • 0.46 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
EAMQXERTOI Baguette Bread Pan EAMQXERTOI 15.08 x 12.99 x 0.87 Inches 0.57 lb Best for a pan you handle with a cloth
Pavsrmy Baguette Bread Pan Pavsrmy Large 1 lb Best for knowing your oven will take it
Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick Perforated ... Chicago Metallic 3 Loaves 0.86 lb Best for putting the pan in the machine
Gicyiit Baguette Bread Pan Gicyiit 3 Loaves Baguette Baking Pan 0.8 lb Best three loaf pan for a normal oven
KITESSENSU Nonstick Baguette Pans for French Bread B... KITESSENSU 2Loaf 15" x 6.3" 0.46 lb Best for lifting out with one cloth

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for a pan you handle with a cloth

EAMQXERTOI Baguette Bread Pan

The only one of the five that calls its edges burr free and says why, stating smooth burr free edges for easy cleaning and then repeating that smooth edges make cleanup easier. EAMQXERTOI bakes four baguettes on heavy duty carbon steel with a food grade nonstick coating, and its own bullet states 15 by 13 by 0.87 inches. Its published weight of 0.57 lb is low for a four channel pan, which also makes it the easier of the two four loaf pans here to bring out of an oven. It publishes no oven temperature and nothing about a dishwasher.

  • For it
  • The only listing describing smooth burr free edges, and it says so twice
  • Four loaf capacity at a published 0.57 lb
  • States its own size, 15 by 13 by 0.87 inches
  • Heavy duty carbon steel with a food grade nonstick coating
  • Against it
  • Publishes no oven temperature rating
  • Says nothing about a dishwasher
  • Its size field and its bullet give slightly different figures
2 Best for knowing your oven will take it

Pavsrmy Baguette Bread Pan

Pavsrmy is the only one of the five that publishes an oven requirement, stating the pan measures 15 by 13 inches and fits large home ovens of at least 1.2 cu ft. It describes a rounded corners design, heavy duty carbon steel rated to 446 F, a BPA free nonstick coating and hand washing for best results, and it bakes four loaves. At a published 1.0 lb it is the heaviest of the five, which is the trade for four channels in thick steel. Nothing in the listing describes the edge finish itself.

  • For it
  • The only listing publishing a minimum oven size, 1.2 cu ft
  • Rounded corners described
  • Carbon steel rated to 446 F
  • Four loaves, with a BPA free nonstick coating
  • Against it
  • The heaviest of the five at 1.0 lb
  • Nothing published about the edge finish
  • Hand washing recommended rather than a dishwasher

Who should skip this: Skip this if you want to put it straight in the dishwasher: the listing says it is not dishwasher safe.

3 Best for putting the pan in the machine

Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick Perforated ...

The only pick stating dishwasher safe, with the caveat that hand washing preserves the two layer nonstick coating and that oil or parchment helps release. Chicago Metallic is also the only pan here in heavy weight aluminum rather than carbon steel, and it states 16 by 9 by 1.5 inches for three full size loaves at 0.86 lb. Its published height field reads 1.0 inch, which contradicts the 1.5 inches in its own title and features, so the maker's wording is used here. It says nothing about its edges.

  • For it
  • The only pick stated dishwasher safe
  • Heavy weight aluminum rather than carbon steel
  • States 16 by 9 by 1.5 inches for three full size loaves
  • Two layer nonstick coating described
  • Against it
  • Its published height field of 1.0 inch contradicts its own 1.5 inches
  • Nothing published about the edge or corners
  • Hand washing still advised despite the dishwasher claim
4 Best three loaf pan for a normal oven

Gicyiit Baguette Bread Pan

Gicyiit states 15 by 9.5 inches for three loaves in thickened carbon steel, rated to 446 F, with a BPA free food grade nonstick coating and hand washing recommended. It argues its three slot design fits most home ovens better than a wider pan, which is the practical reason to prefer it over a four channel tray if your oven is ordinary. At 0.8 lb it sits in the middle of the five by published weight. It also states that a smooth crimping design ensures safe handling, which is the third of only three references to the rim on this page.

  • For it
  • States three slots fit most home ovens better than a wider pan
  • Thickened carbon steel rated to 446 F
  • States 15 by 9.5 inches, and weighs 0.8 lb
  • BPA free food grade nonstick coating
  • Against it
  • Calls its crimping smooth but publishes no rim width or fold
  • Hand washing recommended, no dishwasher claim
  • Publishes no channel width or channel depth
5 Best for lifting out with one cloth

KITESSENSU Nonstick Baguette Pans for French Bread B...

The lightest of the five at a published 0.46 lb, and at a stated 15 by 6.3 inches it is narrow enough to bring out folded in one cloth. KITESSENSU bakes two loaves, describes curved grooves that shape the base of the loaf and evenly distributed pores, and states a ten year warranty, which no other listing here offers. It also argues that you no longer need proofing baskets or cloths. What it does not publish is the metal, an oven temperature, a washing instruction or anything about the edge.

  • For it
  • The lightest of the five at 0.46 lb
  • Narrow at a stated 15 by 6.3 inches, so one cloth lifts it
  • A stated ten year warranty, the only one of the five
  • Curved grooves described as shaping the base of the loaf
  • Against it
  • Publishes no metal at all
  • Publishes no oven temperature rating
  • Publishes no washing instruction

Our verdict

None of these five listings mentions a handle, so the edge is what you hold. EAMQXERTOI is the only pan describing smooth burr free edges, at 15 by 13 inches and 0.57 lb for four loaves. Pavsrmy states rounded corners and is the heaviest of the five at 1.0 lb. Chicago Metallic is the only aluminum pan and the only one called dishwasher safe. KITESSENSU is the lightest of the five at 0.46 lb.

“There is no handle, so the rim is the handle.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Nobody publishes a handle All five of these listings describe a flat perforated tray. Not one mentions a handle, a grip, a tab or a rolled lip, so the edge is what you end up holding.
Three listings describe the edge EAMQXERTOI states smooth burr free edges, Pavsrmy states rounded corners and Gicyiit states a smooth crimping design for safe handling. Chicago Metallic and KITESSENSU leave the edge unmentioned.
Weights run from 0.46 to 1.0 pounds KITESSENSU publishes 0.46 lb for two channels and Pavsrmy 1.0 lb for four. The heavier pans are heavier because they carry more loaves.
One maker states the oven it needs Pavsrmy states its 15 by 13 inch pan fits large home ovens of at least 1.2 cu ft. No other pick on this page publishes an oven requirement.
One listing contradicts its own title Chicago Metallic states 1.5 inches in its title and features while its height field reads 1.0 inch. The maker's wording is the one used here.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 30% What the maker says about the edge you gripWith no handle anywhere among the five, the rim is the handle. EAMQXERTOI states smooth burr free edges and repeats the claim against cleaning. Pavsrmy states rounded corners and Gicyiit states a smooth crimping design for safe handling. Chicago Metallic and KITESSENSU say nothing about either, so there is no published reason to prefer those two on grip alone.
  2. 25% How heavy the empty pan isThis is the only figure every one of the five publishes, and it is what your wrists feel at the oven door. KITESSENSU is the lightest of the five at 0.46 lb, then EAMQXERTOI at 0.57, Gicyiit at 0.8, Chicago Metallic at 0.86 and Pavsrmy at 1.0. None of them publishes a loaded weight.
  3. 20% How far apart your hands have to bePavsrmy and EAMQXERTOI both state 15 by 13 inches, Chicago Metallic 16 by 9, Gicyiit 15 by 9.5 and KITESSENSU 15 by 6.3. A narrow pan can come out on one folded cloth and a wide one cannot, which is the practical consequence of channel count.
  4. 15% Whether the pan will fit the oven at allPavsrmy is the only listing publishing a requirement, at least 1.2 cu ft of oven. Gicyiit states its three slot pan fits most home ovens better than wider trays, and KITESSENSU says a big or small oven will do. The other two publish nothing, which on a 13 inch pan is worth knowing.
  5. 10% What happens at the sinkChicago Metallic is the only pick stated dishwasher safe, and it still advises hand washing for the coating. Pavsrmy and Gicyiit both recommend hand washing. EAMQXERTOI ties cleaning to its edge finish instead. KITESSENSU publishes no cleaning instruction at all.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

Not one of these five listings mentions a handle, a grip, a lip or a tab. A perforated baguette pan is a flat sheet of pressed metal and every maker here sells it as one, so there is nothing to carry it by. What you actually grip is the edge, and three of the five describe that edge in writing while the other two say nothing about it at all. That is where this page starts.

The other half of carrying a pan is how much of it there is. These run from a two channel pan at 0.46 lb to a four channel pan at 1.0 lb, and from 6.3 inches across to 13, which changes how far your hands are apart when the pan comes out of the oven. The table gives the maker’s own size wording, because several fields disagree with it.

Specification EAMQXERTOI Pavsrmy Chicago Metallic Gicyiit KITESSENSU
Loaf channels Four Four Three Three Two
Edge or corner described Smooth and burr free Rounded corners not published Smooth crimping not published
Size in the maker’s words 15 x 13 x 0.87 in 15 x 13 in 16 x 9 x 1.5 in 15 x 9.5 in 15 x 6.3 in
Published weight 0.57 lb 1.0 lb 0.86 lb 0.8 lb 0.46 lb
Published height field 0.85 in 0.86 in 1.0 in 0.98 in 0.91 in
Metal stated Heavy duty carbon steel Heavy duty carbon steel Heavy weight aluminum Thickened carbon steel not published
Oven temperature stated not published 446 F not published 446 F not published
Oven size stated not published At least 1.2 cu ft not published Fits most home ovens Big or small oven
Washing stated Smooth edges make cleanup easier Hand wash recommended Dishwasher safe, hand wash advised Hand wash recommended not published
Coating described Food grade nonstick BPA free nonstick Two layer nonstick BPA free food grade nonstick Nonstick surfaces
Guarantee stated not published not published not published not published Ten years

What the table cannot tell you is how the rim is actually formed. A burr free edge, a rounded corner and a smooth crimping are the only three descriptions here, and none of those makers publishes a rim width, a fold or a rolled lip. Nobody states how much of the edge is free of perforations, which is the part your thumbs would sit on. Every judgement about grip below is drawn from an adjective.

No Pan Here Has a Handle

What the Listings Describe Instead

Every one of these five pans is a perforated tray, and the features they list are about airflow, coating and channel count. EAMQXERTOI lists six features and none is a handle. Pavsrmy lists five and none is a handle. Chicago Metallic, Gicyiit and KITESSENSU are the same. If a handle is the thing you need, this whole category does not supply it.

That is not a gap in the data so much as a fact about the product. A baguette pan sits on an oven rack with loaves proofing in its channels, and a raised handle would stop a second pan sliding above it. So the honest version of the question is what you hold when there is nothing to hold, and the answer is the edge and whatever oven glove you own.

Three Makers Describe the Edge You Hold

EAMQXERTOI is the only listing here that names the edge twice and gives a reason, stating smooth burr free edges for easy cleaning and repeating that smooth edges make cleanup easier. Burr free is a manufacturing claim about the cut line of pressed steel, and it is the closest thing on this page to a statement about handling a bare pan with a cloth.

Pavsrmy describes a rounded corners design and states it protects your hands, which is a claim about shape rather than finish. Gicyiit is the third, stating that a smooth crimping design ensures safe handling. Chicago Metallic and KITESSENSU say nothing: both describe coatings, perforations and metal and leave the edge unmentioned, so there is no published basis for preferring either of those two on grip.

Weight and Reach, the Two Things You Feel

From 0.46 Pounds to a Full Pound

Published weights give the only hard comparison on this page. KITESSENSU is the lightest of the five at 0.46 lb, EAMQXERTOI follows at 0.57 lb, Gicyiit at 0.8 lb, Chicago Metallic at 0.86 lb, and Pavsrmy is the heaviest of the five at 1.0 lb. Those are empty pans, and none of these makers publishes a loaded figure or a dough capacity.

A tenth of a pound sounds trivial until the pan is at oven temperature and held on outstretched arms. Pavsrmy at 1.0 lb carries four loaves and Chicago Metallic at 0.86 lb carries three, so the heavier pan is also the fuller one. KITESSENSU at 0.46 lb carries two. On published figures the lighter pans are lighter because they hold less.

How Far Apart Your Hands Have to Be

Reach matters as much as mass when there is no handle. Pavsrmy and EAMQXERTOI both state 15 by 13 inches, so both hands are 13 inches apart with the loaves running away from you. Chicago Metallic states 16 by 9 inches, Gicyiit 15 by 9.5 and KITESSENSU 15 by 6.3, which is a narrow enough pan to lift with a single cloth folded across it.

Only three of the five say anything about the oven this has to come out of. Pavsrmy states that the pan fits large home ovens of at least 1.2 cu ft, which is the one published constraint on this page. Gicyiit states its three slot design fits most home ovens better than a wider pan, and KITESSENSU says only that it suits a big or small oven.

What Happens After the Pan Comes Out

Which of These Can Go in a Machine

Chicago Metallic is the only listing here stating that the pan is dishwasher safe, and it immediately advises hand washing to preserve the nonstick coating and suggests oil or parchment before baking. It is also the only pan here made of heavy weight aluminum rather than carbon steel, and it names all three loaf channels in its heat conduction claim.

Pavsrmy and Gicyiit both recommend hand washing and state their pans withstand 446 F. EAMQXERTOI does not mention a dishwasher but ties its cleaning claim back to the edge, stating smooth edges make cleanup easier, which is the only place on this page where the edge and the washing up appear in the same sentence. KITESSENSU publishes nothing about cleaning at all.

Where One Listing Disagrees With Itself

Chicago Metallic states 16 by 9 by 1.5 inches in its own title and again in its features, while its published height field reads 1.0 inch. Half an inch of channel depth is the difference between a loaf that holds its shape and one that spreads, so the gap matters. The maker’s own wording is used above and the field is noted here rather than ranked.

EAMQXERTOI does the same thing in miniature. Its feature bullet states 15 by 13 by 0.87 inches, its size line reads 15.08 by 12.99 by 0.87 inches, and its separate dimension fields give 12.59 by 14.96 by 0.85 inches. That is one pan described three times with three answers, so this page quotes the bullet and records the other two here rather than ranking on any of them.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

Handling a bare pan without a cloth. EAMQXERTOI is the only pick naming its edge, stating smooth burr free edges twice and tying them to cleaning. It bakes four loaves at a stated 15 by 13 by 0.87 inches and weighs 0.57 lb, which is light for a four channel pan in carbon steel.

Four loaves and a big oven. Pavsrmy states 15 by 13 inches, rounded corners, carbon steel to 446 F and, unusually, a minimum oven size of 1.2 cu ft. At 1.0 lb it is the heaviest of the five, and it is the only listing that tells you in advance whether your oven will take it.

Putting the pan in the dishwasher. Chicago Metallic is the only pick stating dishwasher safe, though it advises hand washing for the coating. It is heavy weight aluminum, states 16 by 9 by 1.5 inches for three loaves, and its published height field of 1.0 inch contradicts that wording.

Three loaves in an ordinary oven. Gicyiit states 15 by 9.5 inches, thickened carbon steel to 446 F and that its three slot design fits most home ovens better than wider pans. At 0.8 lb with hand washing recommended, it is the straightforward middle choice here.

Lifting with one hand. KITESSENSU is the lightest of the five at 0.46 lb and states 15 by 6.3 inches for two loaves, narrow enough to take out on a single folded cloth. It carries a stated ten year guarantee, and it publishes no metal, no temperature and nothing about washing.

What We Could Not Verify

All of this is from the makers’ own listing text. These are the questions it leaves unanswered.

  • Not one of the five listings mentions a handle, a grip, a tab or a rolled lip of any kind.
  • No maker publishes a rim width, or how much of the edge is free of perforations.
  • Two of the five say nothing at all about the edge or the corners.
  • No listing publishes a loaded weight or a dough capacity, only the weight of the empty pan.
  • Chicago Metallic’s published height field of 1.0 inch contradicts the 1.5 inches in its own title.
  • KITESSENSU publishes no metal, no oven temperature and no cleaning instruction.

Frequently asked questions

Do any baguette baking trays have a carry handle?+

None of these five does. Every listing describes a flat perforated tray and sells it on airflow, coating, channel count and metal, and not one mentions a handle, a grip, a tab or a rolled lip. There is a practical reason: a raised handle would stop a second pan sliding onto the rack above. So the question becomes what you hold instead, and only three of the five makers describe the edge you end up gripping.

Which of these is easiest to lift out of the oven?+

On published figures, KITESSENSU. It is the lightest of the five at 0.46 lb and states 15 by 6.3 inches for two loaves, narrow enough to come out on one folded cloth. EAMQXERTOI is next at 0.57 lb, and it is the only listing describing smooth burr free edges. Pavsrmy is the heaviest of the five at 1.0 lb and is also 13 inches across, so both hands are far apart with four hot loaves in front of you.

What does a burr free edge mean on a baking pan?+

It is a claim about how the pressed steel was finished: a burr is the rough ridge left where sheet metal is cut, and a burr free edge has been smoothed off. EAMQXERTOI is the only one of the five to use the phrase, and it states smooth burr free edges for easy cleaning, then repeats that smooth edges make cleanup easier. No maker publishes a rim width or a fold, so there is nothing to check the claim against.

Is a three loaf pan easier to handle than a four loaf pan?+

Published figures point that way, though no maker says so directly. Chicago Metallic states 16 by 9 inches at 0.86 lb for three loaves and Gicyiit 15 by 9.5 inches at 0.8 lb, against 15 by 13 inches for the two four loaf pans. The narrower pan puts your hands closer together. Gicyiit is the only maker to make an argument of it, stating its three slot design fits most home ovens better than a wider pan.

Can any of these go in the dishwasher?+

Chicago Metallic is the only listing here that states dishwasher safe, and it adds that hand washing is recommended to preserve the nonstick coating and that parchment or a light oiling helps release. Pavsrmy and Gicyiit both recommend hand washing without mentioning a machine. EAMQXERTOI mentions cleaning only in connection with its smooth edges. KITESSENSU publishes no cleaning instruction at all, which is worth knowing given its ten year warranty.

Does the published height field tell you how deep the channels are?+

Not reliably. The five height fields sit within a tenth of an inch of each other, at 0.85 for EAMQXERTOI, 0.86 for Pavsrmy, 0.91 for KITESSENSU, 0.98 for Gicyiit and 1.0 for Chicago Metallic, which is the thickness of the whole pressed tray rather than the depth of one groove. Chicago Metallic's own title says 1.5 inches against the 1.0 inch in its height field, and no maker on this page publishes a channel width or a groove depth at all.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.