The deciding specification is what each maker will commit to about washing, because three say dishwasher safe and one of those recommends handwashing anyway.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
I compared the published washing claim against the coating it has to protect, plus any pre bake step, material, published and stated sizes, loaf count, weight and temperature across five baguette baking trays using only the listings' own text.
A food grade stainless steel three loaf pan the maker states has no paint coating on the surface, published at 0.94 lb with a title figure of 15 x 10 in, evenly and densely arranged perforations, and a bullet stating you can clean it with a sponge by hand or wash it in a dishwasher.
A heavy weight aluminum three loaf pan published at 9 x 16 x 1 in and 0.86 lb, stated at 16 x 9 x 1.5 inches, with a two layer nonstick coating, a stated instruction to apply a light coating of oil or line with parchment before baking, and a bullet stating dishwasher safe while recommending handwashing to preserve the coating.
A carbon steel three loaf pan stated at 0.8mm thickness with a food grade silicone coating the maker calls non Teflon, published at 1.18 lb with 15 x 11 in in its size field, a stated temperature limit of 446 degrees Fahrenheit, dishwasher safe, and a butter brush before first use.
A heavy duty carbon steel pan published at 12.59 x 14.96 x 0.85 in and 0.57 lb that bakes four baguettes rather than three, with dense uniform perforations, a food grade nonstick coating that is not named, and smooth burr free edges the maker states make cleaning easier. No dishwasher claim.
A food grade silicone and fiberglass perforated form published at 6.97 x 5.28 x 0.55 in and 0.28 lb, stated microwave and oven safe, with a non stick surface the maker says makes cleaning simple and quick, and a size field of 17.7 x 3.4 inch its dimension fields do not support.
| Model | Brand | Size (Capacity) | Weight | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AYCCNH Stainless Steel French Baguette Bread Pan | AYCCNH | 1 Steel Pan | 0.94 lb | Best for having no coating to protect |
| Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick Perforated ... | Chicago Metallic | 3 Loaves | 0.86 lb | Best for a maker that tells you the trade |
| Baguette Pans for Baking 15" x 11" | Hesanzol | 15" x 11" | 1.18 lb | Best for a dishwasher claim with no caveat |
| EAMQXERTOI Baguette Bread Pan | EAMQXERTOI | 15.08 x 12.99 x 0.87 Inches | 0.57 lb | Best for four loaves at once |
| FETESUR Silicone Perforated Baking Form Sandwich Mol... | FETESUR | 17.7 x 3.4 inch | 0.28 lb | Best for silicone instead of steel |
A food grade stainless steel three loaf pan the maker states has no paint coating on the surface, published at 0.94 lb with a title figure of 15 x 10 in, evenly and densely arranged perforations, and a bullet stating you can clean it with a sponge by hand or wash it in a dishwasher.
A heavy weight aluminum three loaf pan published at 9 x 16 x 1 in and 0.86 lb, stated at 16 x 9 x 1.5 inches, with a two layer nonstick coating, a stated instruction to apply a light coating of oil or line with parchment before baking, and a bullet stating dishwasher safe while recommending handwashing to preserve the coating.
A carbon steel three loaf pan stated at 0.8mm thickness with a food grade silicone coating the maker calls non Teflon, published at 1.18 lb with 15 x 11 in in its size field, a stated temperature limit of 446 degrees Fahrenheit, dishwasher safe, and a butter brush before first use.
A heavy duty carbon steel pan published at 12.59 x 14.96 x 0.85 in and 0.57 lb that bakes four baguettes rather than three, with dense uniform perforations, a food grade nonstick coating that is not named, and smooth burr free edges the maker states make cleaning easier. No dishwasher claim.
A food grade silicone and fiberglass perforated form published at 6.97 x 5.28 x 0.55 in and 0.28 lb, stated microwave and oven safe, with a non stick surface the maker says makes cleaning simple and quick, and a size field of 17.7 x 3.4 inch its dimension fields do not support.
AYCCNH is stainless steel with, in its own words, no paint coating, and states a sponge or the dishwasher with no reservation. Chicago Metallic states dishwasher safe and then recommends handwashing to preserve its two layer nonstick. Hesanzol states dishwasher safe with no caveat over a silicone coating it calls non Teflon. EAMQXERTOI and FETESUR state only that they are easy to clean.
“One listing permits the dishwasher and then advises against it.”
Lush Food & Drink
Three say so. AYCCNH states that you can clean it with a sponge by hand and also wash it in a dishwasher, with nothing held back. Hesanzol states dishwasher safe as part of its material bullet. Chicago Metallic states dishwasher safe for convenience and then recommends handwashing to preserve the nonstick coating. EAMQXERTOI and FETESUR never mention a dishwasher at all.
Because both statements are true of a nonstick pan. Chicago Metallic states a two layer nonstick coating and a dishwasher safe pan, and then states that handwashing is recommended to preserve that coating, adding that parchment gives extra nonstick assurance. It is the only listing on this page that connects washing to the life of the surface, which makes it the most useful bullet here even though it reads as a contradiction.
It is the one with least to lose. AYCCNH states food grade stainless steel with no paint coating on the surface, so there is nothing for a machine to strip or for a scourer to scratch. The trade is that release depends on the polish and the perforations rather than a coating, and the listing offers only a claim of easy release with no oil or parchment instruction to fall back on.
Two ask for something. Chicago Metallic states that for best results you apply a light coating of oil or line with parchment paper before baking. Hesanzol states that you brush a thin layer of butter on the pan before first use. Those are different commitments: one is every bake and one is once. AYCCNH, EAMQXERTOI and FETESUR publish no pre bake step at all.
FETESUR publishes 0.28 lb, the lightest of these five, as the only silicone pan here. EAMQXERTOI publishes 0.57 lb, Chicago Metallic 0.86 lb and AYCCNH 0.94 lb. Hesanzol publishes 1.18 lb, the heaviest of these five, which is consistent with the 0.8mm carbon steel and strengthened edge its own bullet describes.
On two of the five, yes. Chicago Metallic publishes 9 x 16 x 1 in and states 16 x 9 x 1.5 inches, which differ only on the third figure. AYCCNH publishes 10 x 1 x 1 in and Hesanzol 15 x 0.98 x 0.98 in, both of which repeat a near one inch value twice and are placeholders. EAMQXERTOI publishes three separate sets of figures, and FETESUR's size field and fields describe objects of different sizes entirely.
Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.
A baguette pan is a perforated sheet with dough baked onto it, and the thing standing between an easy wash and a ruined pan is the coating. Nineteen listings sit in this pool. Most of them claim easy cleaning and only some of them will name a dishwasher, and one of the three that does immediately advises against using it.
Three of these five state dishwasher safe. Two state only that the pan is easy to clean. Their coatings are a two layer nonstick, a food grade silicone described as non Teflon, an unnamed food grade nonstick, silicone over fiberglass, and on one pan no coating at all. Published weights run from 0.28 lb to 1.18 lb.
| Specification | AYCCNH | Chicago Metallic | Hesanzol | EAMQXERTOI | FETESUR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dishwasher stated | Yes, by sponge or in the machine | Yes, though handwashing is recommended | Yes | not published | not published |
| Cleaning claim published | A smooth surface, stated easy to clean | A two layer nonstick, with oil or parchment advised for clean release | Thickened carbon steel stated to ease baking and cleaning | Smooth burr free edges for easy cleaning | A non stick surface stated to make cleaning simple and quick |
| Coating stated | None, and explicitly no paint coating | A two layer nonstick coating | A food grade silicone coating, stated non Teflon | A food grade nonstick coating, not named | Silicone with fiberglass |
| Step before or during each bake | not published | Apply a light coating of oil, or line with parchment | Brush a thin layer of butter before first use | not published | not published |
| Material stated | Food grade stainless steel | Heavy weight aluminum | Carbon steel, stated at 0.8mm | Heavy duty carbon steel | Food grade silicone with fiberglass |
| Dimension fields published | 10 x 1 x 1 in | 9 x 16 x 1 in | 15 x 0.98 x 0.98 in | 12.59 x 14.96 x 0.85 in | 6.97 x 5.28 x 0.55 in |
| Size in the maker’s own words | 15 x 10 in, in the title | 16 x 9 x 1.5 inches | 15 x 11 in, in the size field | 15 x 13 x 0.87 inches in a bullet, and 15.08 x 12.99 x 0.87 in the size field | 17.7 x 3.4 inch, in the size field |
| Loaves stated | Three | Three | Three | Four | not published |
| Weight published | 0.94 lb | 0.86 lb | 1.18 lb | 0.57 lb | 0.28 lb |
| Temperature stated | not published | not published | 446 degrees Fahrenheit | not published | Microwave and oven safe, with no figure |
| Perforation described | Evenly and densely arranged holes | A perforated design for air circulation | Stated good breathability | Dense uniform holes across the tray | Perforations to let steam escape |
What the table cannot tell you is how many washes a nonstick baguette pan survives. Not one of the five says. What Chicago Metallic does say is that handwashing preserves the coating, which is the closest thing in this pool to an admission that a dishwasher costs the coating something, and the other two dishwasher claims come with no such caveat.
AYCCNH is the only pick here made of stainless steel and it makes a point of it, stating that there is no paint coating on the surface and that no harmful substance is released at high temperature. It then states that the smooth surface can be cleaned with a sponge by hand or washed in a dishwasher, with no reservation attached.
That is the cleanest answer on the page and it is not free. Without a coating, release depends entirely on the perforations and the polish, and the listing offers only a claim of easy release. The other four pans all put something between the dough and the metal, and all four of those things are the part a dishwasher wears out.
Chicago Metallic states dishwasher safe for convenience, though handwashing is recommended to preserve the nonstick coating, and adds that lining with parchment adds an extra layer of nonstick assurance. Read as a whole, that bullet is an instruction to hand wash a pan it is permitted to machine wash.
Hesanzol states dishwasher safe as part of a material bullet and never mentions handwashing, on a pan with a food grade silicone coating it describes as non Teflon. Those two are the same claim with opposite framing, and the second gives a buyer no way to know whether the coating is more or less robust than the first.
Two of the five ask for something beyond the pan. Chicago Metallic states that for best results you apply a light coating of oil or line with parchment paper before baking, for clean release and simple cleanup. Hesanzol states that you brush a thin layer of butter on the pan before first use for better effect.
Those are not the same instruction. Oil or parchment before every bake is a recurring step, and butter before first use is a seasoning pass done once. Both are honest and both undercut the word nonstick a little. AYCCNH, EAMQXERTOI and FETESUR publish no pre bake step at all.
EAMQXERTOI states smooth burr free edges for easy cleaning, and repeats in a second bullet that smooth edges make cleanup easier. That is a claim about the rim rather than the baking surface, and its food grade nonstick coating is described without being named. It never mentions a dishwasher.
FETESUR states food grade silicone and fiberglass for durability and easy cleaning, and separately that a non stick surface makes cleaning simple and quick. Silicone is the material on this page least likely to be harmed by a machine, and the listing still declines to say so. At 0.28 lb it is also the lightest pan here by a wide margin.
AYCCNH publishes 10 x 1 x 1 in, and its own title says 15 x 10 in. A pan that bakes three loaves is not one inch across in two directions, so two of its three fields are placeholders and the title carries the only figures worth having. Hesanzol does the same thing, publishing 15 x 0.98 x 0.98 in against a size field of 15 x 11 in.
In both cases the pattern is identical: one real figure and two identical near one inch values. This page uses the maker’s own statement in each case, 15 by 10 in for AYCCNH and 15 by 11 in for Hesanzol, and reports the field sets as what they are. Neither listing acknowledges the discrepancy.
EAMQXERTOI publishes 12.59 x 14.96 x 0.85 in in its fields, states 15.08 x 12.99 x 0.87 Inches in its size field, and states measures 15 x 13 x 0.87 inches in a bullet. All three describe the same pan and no two agree. The third figure is nearly stable at 0.85 in and 0.87 in; the plan figures wander by half an inch.
FETESUR is worse in a different way. Its fields publish 6.97 x 5.28 x 0.55 in and its size field says 17.7 x 3.4 inch, which cannot be the same object in any orientation. A 17.7 in silicone form and a 6.97 in one are different products, and the listing gives no way to tell which arrives.
No coating to protect. AYCCNH is stainless steel with, in its own words, no paint coating, and states you can clean it with a sponge or in the dishwasher. It publishes 0.94 lb and bakes three loaves, and its 10 x 1 x 1 in field set is a placeholder against a stated 15 x 10 in.
The most honest cleaning bullet. Chicago Metallic publishes 9 x 16 x 1 in and 0.86 lb, states 16 x 9 x 1.5 inches in a bullet, and states dishwasher safe while recommending handwashing to preserve its two layer nonstick. Oil or parchment before baking.
Dishwasher safe with no caveat. Hesanzol publishes 1.18 lb, the heaviest here, with a food grade silicone coating it calls non Teflon, 0.8mm carbon steel, a stated 446 degrees Fahrenheit limit, and butter on the pan before first use.
Four loaves and smooth edges. EAMQXERTOI publishes 12.59 x 14.96 x 0.85 in and 0.57 lb, bakes four baguettes rather than three, and states burr free edges for easy cleaning. It never mentions a dishwasher and publishes three different sets of figures.
Silicone instead of steel. FETESUR publishes 6.97 x 5.28 x 0.55 in and 0.28 lb in food grade silicone with fiberglass, stated microwave and oven safe, with a non stick surface and easy cleaning. Its size field says 17.7 x 3.4 inch, which its fields do not support.
These are the things I went looking for in the five listings and did not find.
