The deciding specification is what arrives besides the turntable, because two of these five are decorating kits of 71 and 78 pieces, one is a carrier whose listing states accessories are not included, and one is a bare plate with sizing circles etched into it.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
I compared the piece counts each listing publishes, the tips, bags, spatulas and scrapers named, the turntable diameter and bearing, any guides marked on the plate, the cleaning notes and the published weights, across five cake turntables using only each maker's own published text.
Seventy-eight pieces around a 12 inch aluminum alloy turntable on stainless steel ball bearings the maker states are silent, including 12 piping tips, a cream icing nozzle, 50 disposable bags, a reusable silicone bag, two couplers, a cake leveler, a pie server, two spatulas, a decorating pen and three stainless scrapers.
Seventy-one pieces around an 11 inch plate on a hidden ball bearing, with 12 numbered piping tips, 50 disposable and 2 reusable bags, one coupler, three scrapers described as rounded, straight and toothed, and the only published spatula lengths here: a 12.5 inch angled and a 10.6 inch straight.
A revolving 12 inch aluminum turntable with a non-slip pad included and hand washing stated as the only cleaning route, published at 12 by 12 by 5 inches. Its title also names a cast iron base, which none of its five feature bullets mentions, and its published weight field cannot be this product.
A food grade PP cake carrier that doubles as a turntable, stated at 12 inches across with an 11 inch cake tray and 6.1 inches of height for a 10 inch cake, with a double collapsible handle, a 3-lock closure, and a base that holds 11 cupcakes or five sections of snacks. Accessories are not included.
A bare 11 inch plate on hidden ball bearings, and the only listing here with etched concentric circles at 7, 8 and 9 inches to center a cake layer before frosting. In black food-contact friendly plastic the maker states is wiped or rinsed clean, at 0.57 pounds.
| Model | Brand | Size (Capacity) | Weight | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 78PCS Cake Supplie With 12Inch Aluminum Alloy Rotati... | AOSHIDINGSHUO | 78pcs Aluminum Cake Decor Kit | 5.07 lb | Best for a leveler and a pie server too |
| Kootek 71 Cake Decorating Kit Baking Supplies Tools ... | Kootek | not published | 1.6 lb | Best for two spatulas with published lengths |
| Ateco Revolving Cake Decorating Stand | Ateco | 12-Inch | Not listed | Best for a plate with a non-slip pad |
| BSTKEY Portable Cake Carrier with Lid and Handle | BSTKEY | not published | 1.73 lb | Best for carrying the finished cake |
| Bonsicoky Cake Stand 11 Inch Rotating Cake Turntable | Bonsicoky | 11 Inch | 0.57 lb | Best for centering circles etched in the plate |
Seventy-eight pieces around a 12 inch aluminum alloy turntable on stainless steel ball bearings the maker states are silent, including 12 piping tips, a cream icing nozzle, 50 disposable bags, a reusable silicone bag, two couplers, a cake leveler, a pie server, two spatulas, a decorating pen and three stainless scrapers.
Seventy-one pieces around an 11 inch plate on a hidden ball bearing, with 12 numbered piping tips, 50 disposable and 2 reusable bags, one coupler, three scrapers described as rounded, straight and toothed, and the only published spatula lengths here: a 12.5 inch angled and a 10.6 inch straight.
A revolving 12 inch aluminum turntable with a non-slip pad included and hand washing stated as the only cleaning route, published at 12 by 12 by 5 inches. Its title also names a cast iron base, which none of its five feature bullets mentions, and its published weight field cannot be this product.
A food grade PP cake carrier that doubles as a turntable, stated at 12 inches across with an 11 inch cake tray and 6.1 inches of height for a 10 inch cake, with a double collapsible handle, a 3-lock closure, and a base that holds 11 cupcakes or five sections of snacks. Accessories are not included.
A bare 11 inch plate on hidden ball bearings, and the only listing here with etched concentric circles at 7, 8 and 9 inches to center a cake layer before frosting. In black food-contact friendly plastic the maker states is wiped or rinsed clean, at 0.57 pounds.
AOSHIDINGSHUO publishes 78 pieces around a 12 inch aluminum turntable, including a cake leveler and a pie server. Kootek publishes 71 around an 11 inch plate, with a 12.5 inch angled and a 10.6 inch straight spatula. Ateco publishes a turntable, a non-slip pad and hand washing only. BSTKEY publishes a carrier and states accessories are not included. Bonsicoky etches 7, 8 and 9 inch circles into the plate.
“One arrives with 78 pieces. One says accessories are not included.”
Lush Food & Drink
It depends how much of the kit is tools. Both kits here are dominated by consumables: Kootek's 71 pieces include 50 disposable piping bags and 2 reusable ones, and AOSHIDINGSHUO's 78 include 50 disposable bags and one reusable silicone bag. The tools are what differ, and AOSHIDINGSHUO adds a cake leveler, a pie server, a decorating pen and a tip cleaning brush.
Kootek, and it is the only one. It states a 12.5 inch angled spatula and a 10.6 inch straight spatula, both stainless steel, for crumb layers and smooth surfaces. AOSHIDINGSHUO includes a cream spatula and an offset spatula and gives no length for either. The three other purchases include no spatula at all.
Two state 12 inches and two state 11. AOSHIDINGSHUO and Ateco both publish 12 inch turntables, and Ateco's published fields confirm it at 12 by 12 by 5 inches. Kootek states an 11 inch diameter and Bonsicoky an 11 inch plate. BSTKEY publishes both figures for its carrier: 12 inches across overall, with an 11 inch cake tray inside it.
Bonsicoky does, and it is the only one. Its listing states etched concentric circles at 7, 8 and 9 inches on the surface, so a layer can be placed centrally before frosting begins. AOSHIDINGSHUO and Ateco both publish a non-slip base or pad instead, which stops the stand moving rather than helping place what sits on it.
Two publish an instruction and both are brief. Ateco states handwash only, which on an aluminum turntable with a cast iron base is the right answer and the only one it gives. Bonsicoky states the plastic plate is simple to wipe down and that a rinse is all it needs. The two decorating kits and the carrier publish no cleaning instruction of any kind.
Ateco's weight field is flagged in the fact sheet as far too light for an object of 12 by 12 by 5 inches, which is what its own fields state. The listing describes an aluminum turntable on a cast iron base, so the real figure would be among the heavier on this page rather than the lightest. Nothing here is ranked using it.
Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.
Six live pages on this pool already rank turntables by weight, height, base width, bearing and cleaning. For somebody buying their first one, the question is different: what else comes in the box. Two of these five are decorating kits built around a turntable, and three are the turntable, or something near it, on its own.
AOSHIDINGSHUO counts 78 pieces and Kootek 71. Ateco supplies a 12 inch aluminum plate and a non-slip pad. Bonsicoky supplies an 11 inch plastic plate with sizing circles on it. BSTKEY supplies a cake carrier that doubles as a turntable and says in its own package line that accessories are not included.
| Specification | AOSHIDINGSHUO | Kootek | Ateco | BSTKEY | Bonsicoky |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pieces stated | 78 | 71 | a stand and a pad | one carrier, accessories excluded | one plate |
| Plate diameter stated, in | 12 | 11 | 12 | 12 overall, 11 cake tray | 11 |
| Piping tips stated | 12, plus a cream nozzle | 12, numbered | not published | not published | not published |
| Piping bags stated | 50 disposable, 1 silicone | 50 disposable, 2 reusable | not published | not published | not published |
| Spatulas stated | a cream and an offset, no lengths | 12.5 in angled, 10.6 in straight | not published | not published | not published |
| Scrapers stated | 3 stainless, plus a silicone one | 3: rounded, straight, toothed | not published | not published | not published |
| Bearing stated | stainless ball bearings, silent | a hidden ball bearing | not published | not published | hidden ball bearings |
| Guides marked on the plate | not published | not published | not published | not published | etched circles at 7, 8 and 9 in |
| Grip stated | a non-slip base | not published | a non-slip pad | not published | not published |
| Other items named | a cake leveler, a pie server, a decorating pen, a cleaning brush | a coupler, an e-book, a pattern chart, video tutorials | a non-slip pad | a lid, a collapsible handle, a 3-lock, a cupcake tray | not published |
| Cleaning stated | not published | not published | handwash only | not published | wipe down, or rinse |
| Material stated | aluminum alloy | not published | aluminum turntable | food grade PP | food-contact friendly plastic |
| Published weight, lb | 5.07 | 1.6 | flagged as impossible | 1.73 | 0.57 |
| Published dimension fields, in | not published | 10.91 x 10.91 x 2.52 | 12 x 12 x 5 | 12 x 12 x 6 | not published |
What the table cannot tell you is how much cake any of these plates will carry. No listing in this pool publishes a load limit, a maximum cake weight or a bearing rating, so a plastic plate at 0.57 pounds and an aluminum one at 5.07 are compared on their own mass rather than on what they can hold. Neither kit publishes a cleaning instruction either.
AOSHIDINGSHUO publishes the fuller list. Around a 12 inch aluminum alloy turntable it names 12 piping tips, a cream icing nozzle, 50 disposable piping bags, a reusable silicone bag with two ties, two couplers, a cake leveler, a cream spatula, an offset spatula, a silicone decorating pen, a silicone scraper, a tip cleaning brush and three stainless steel scrapers, plus a pie server.
Kootek’s 71 covers the same ground with different emphasis: 12 numbered tips, 52 bags of which 50 are disposable, offset and straight spatulas whose lengths it publishes, three scrapers it distinguishes as rounded, straight and toothed, one quick-change coupler, and an e-book with a pattern chart and video tutorials. It is the only listing here that supplies instruction rather than only tools.
BSTKEY is not really a turntable and it is honest about it. The product is a portable cake carrier in food grade PP with a lid, a double collapsible handle for one-handed carrying and a 3-lock closure, and the listing states that as a cake turntable it is convenient for display and decoration. Its final line reads that accessories are not included.
What it publishes instead is a full set of figures: 12 inches in diameter overall, 11 inches for the cake tray, 6.1 inches high, room for a 10 inch cake, 11 cupcakes on the reversed base, or five sections of snacks. That is more measurement than either kit gives, and it is the only listing here that carries the cake anywhere.
AOSHIDINGSHUO states professional quality stainless steel ball bearings and adds a claim nothing else makes: silent when rotating. Kootek states a hidden ball bearing with 360 degree rotation clockwise and counterclockwise. Bonsicoky states hidden ball bearings and makes the point that matters, that the spin works either way whether the baker is left or right handed.
Ateco and BSTKEY publish nothing about the mechanism. On Ateco that is consistent with the rest of a five bullet listing that says almost nothing, and on BSTKEY it is consistent with a carrier that happens to turn. So of the three purchases sold primarily as turntables, all three describe the bearing, and the two that are something else do not.
Bonsicoky publishes the one feature on this page aimed at the cake rather than the stand: etched concentric circles at 7, 8 and 9 inches on the surface, stated to help center cake layers precisely for even frosting. On an 11 inch plate those three rings cover the common layer sizes, and no other listing in this pool marks anything on its surface at all.
The alternative approach is to stop the stand moving instead. AOSHIDINGSHUO states a non-slip base that prevents sliding on any surface, and Ateco gives a non-slip pad its own bullet. Those keep the base still while the plate turns, which is a different problem from placing a layer in the middle of it.
Ateco publishes dimension fields of 12 by 12 by 5 inches and a weight field the fact sheet flags as far too light for an object that size. The listing describes an aluminum turntable, and its title adds a cast iron base, so the true figure would be among the heavier on this page rather than the lightest thing in the pool.
That is the one weight on this page that cannot be used, and it matters because weight is what a turntable base is for: a light stand walks across a counter under a palette knife. The other four figures are plausible and span a wide range, from 0.57 pounds of plastic to 5.07 pounds of aluminum with 78 accessories.
Ateco’s product title reads Revolving Cake Decorating Stand, Aluminum Turntable and Cast Iron Base with Non-Slip Pad. Its five feature bullets read: revolving cake decorating stand for cake decorating; aluminum turntable; non-slip pad included; 12 inch diameter turntable; handwash only. Cast iron appears nowhere among them.
On a stand whose selling point is a heavy base, that is the feature a buyer would most want confirmed, and the listing confirms it only in its name. Combined with a weight field that cannot be believed, it means the one thing Ateco offers over the plastic plates here is the one thing it never documents in its features.
You are starting from nothing. AOSHIDINGSHUO publishes 78 pieces around a 12 inch aluminum turntable on silent stainless ball bearings, including a cake leveler, a pie server, a decorating pen and three stainless scrapers, at 5.07 pounds.
You want to be taught as well as equipped. Kootek publishes 71 pieces around an 11 inch plate, with a 12.5 inch angled and a 10.6 inch straight spatula, three named scrapers, a quick-change coupler, and an e-book with a pattern chart and video tutorials.
You already own the piping bags. Ateco publishes a 12 inch aluminum turntable with a non-slip pad and handwash only, at 12 by 12 by 5 inches. Its cast iron base is named in the title and in none of its bullets, and its weight field cannot be used.
The cake has to leave the house. BSTKEY publishes a food grade PP carrier stated at 12 inches across, an 11 inch tray, 6.1 inches high, for a 10 inch cake or 11 cupcakes, with a collapsible handle and a 3-lock lid. Accessories are not included.
You want help centering the layer. Bonsicoky publishes an 11 inch plate on hidden ball bearings with etched circles at 7, 8 and 9 inches, in plastic stated to wipe or rinse clean, at 0.57 pounds. Nothing else arrives with it.
These are the figures the five listings do not publish, or publish in a form that cannot be used, and nothing above has been supplied in their place.
