Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Baking

Best Chocolate Molds That Stack With Their Lids On

The deciding specification is whether a lid comes with the mold, because a deep drawer is only worth having if trays can be stacked loaded, and three of these five publish a lid while only one publishes what the lid measures.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

I compared whether each purchase includes a lid, what the lid is made of and whether its size is published, the stacking claims, the mold size stated in words against the dimension fields, the cavity count and the heat range across five chocolate mold purchases, using only each maker's own listing text.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. AIERSA Silicone Gummy Molds
    Best for a lid with a published size

    AIERSA Silicone Gummy Molds

    Two 32 cavity square trays, each with its own lid, and the only listing in this pool that publishes a lid dimension at all. Its last bullet gives the mold as 7.48 by 4.01 by 0.7 inches and then a lid size beginning 7.63 inches, which is also the figure sitting in the depth slot of its dimension fields, so the fields are describing the lid where the mold should be. The lid's purpose is stated rather than implied: it locks in the flavor, keeps the contents fresh longer, and lets you stack the trays in the freezer while you work. Food grade silicone, microwave, oven, dishwasher and refrigerator safe, with a heat range of -40 F to 446 F, and a pipette included. The lid material is never named.

    • AIERSA
    • regular
    • 0.66 lb
  2. Silicone Square Ice Cube Trays with Lids 2 Pack
    Best for two hard lids and two trays

    Silicone Square Ice Cube Trays with Lids 2 Pack

    Two silicone trays of fifteen cavities each with two hard PP plastic lids, published at 7 by 5 by 1.1 inches per tray, and the only listing here that names the lid material and then limits it: the bullet states plainly that the plastic lids are not heat resistant while the trays work from -40 to 464 degrees. For stacking in a drawer a hard lid is the better surface, because a loaded tray can sit on it without pressing into the cavities below. The cubes are published at 1.4 inches square and the maker gives release tricks, including putting the tray in warm water first. Its dimension fields were read as a carton at 5.0 by 7.0 by 1.1 inches, which is consistent with two trays and their lids.

    • Szxc
    • 2 SET SKY Purple (15 Cube)
    • 0.49 lb
  3. Heart Shaped Ice Cube Trays with Lid
    Best for a tray stated to stack

    Heart Shaped Ice Cube Trays with Lid

    Twenty one heart cavities with a lid the maker says is easy to attach, stops spillage in the freezer and keeps food fresh and free from contamination. It is the only listing on this page to use the word stackable, stating the trays stack and do not take up a lot of space. It is also the only one honest about the weakness of the format: a note at the end warns that silicone trays are not rigid like plastic trays and suggests putting the tray on a tray, or using the lid as a base, to carry a filled one. Published at 10.47 by 5.1 by 1.2 inches in its fields, with no size in words anywhere, a heat range of -104 F to 446 F, and a weight field of 0.42 lb.

    • BTYMS
    • 21 Cavity Heart Shaped
    • 0.42 lb
  4. Holographic Chocolate Bar Mold
    Best for a cavity deeper than usual

    Holographic Chocolate Bar Mold

    The one purchase here that wants the drawer depth for the mold rather than for a stack. Three large cavities in a mold published at approximately 30 by 20 by 2.6 cm, which the maker states is thicker and deeper than regular chocolate molds, with dimension fields of 7.88 by 11.82 by 1.0 inches that agree with that sentence in the other unit system. The surface is the selling point: a holographic optical texture stated to create a colorful reflection under light, from nano-textured surface technology rather than any coating. Dishwasher, freezer, oven and microwave safe. At a weight field of 0.73 lb it is the heaviest of these five, and no lid is published, so a filled mold takes nothing on top.

    • SAINT NIEVE
    • Extra Large
    • 0.73 lb
  5. 8-Cavity Chocolate Strip Silicone Rectangle Molds fo...
    Best for eight bars on one flat sheet

    8-Cavity Chocolate Strip Silicone Rectangle Molds fo...

    Eight rectangular bar cavities in a single sheet, and the control for this page: at a published 0.59 inches thick and a weight field of 0.1 lb, the lightest purchase here, it gains nothing at all from a deep drawer. The flexible silicone construction is stated to allow demolding without breaking the bars, and the sheet is dishwasher safe and heat resistant with no figure given. It publishes its overall size twice, as 10.63 by 6.69 by 0.59 inches in a bullet headed dimensions and as 6.0 by 10.0 by 0.5 inches in its fields, which differ by a tenth of an inch on the thickness. No lid, no stacking claim and no cavity depth is published.

    • Vrthske
    • Large
    • 0.1 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
AIERSA Silicone Gummy Molds AIERSA regular 0.66 lb Best for a lid with a published size
Silicone Square Ice Cube Trays with Lids 2 Pack Szxc 2 SET SKY Purple (15 Cube) 0.49 lb Best for two hard lids and two trays
Heart Shaped Ice Cube Trays with Lid BTYMS 21 Cavity Heart Shaped 0.42 lb Best for a tray stated to stack
Holographic Chocolate Bar Mold SAINT NIEVE Extra Large 0.73 lb Best for a cavity deeper than usual
8-Cavity Chocolate Strip Silicone Rectangle Molds fo... Vrthske Large 0.1 lb Best for eight bars on one flat sheet

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for a lid with a published size

AIERSA Silicone Gummy Molds

Two 32 cavity square trays, each with its own lid, and the only listing in this pool that publishes a lid dimension at all. Its last bullet gives the mold as 7.48 by 4.01 by 0.7 inches and then a lid size beginning 7.63 inches, which is also the figure sitting in the depth slot of its dimension fields, so the fields are describing the lid where the mold should be. The lid's purpose is stated rather than implied: it locks in the flavor, keeps the contents fresh longer, and lets you stack the trays in the freezer while you work. Food grade silicone, microwave, oven, dishwasher and refrigerator safe, with a heat range of -40 F to 446 F, and a pipette included. The lid material is never named.

  • For it
  • Two trays each with a lid, stated to stack in the freezer
  • The only lid dimension published anywhere in this pool
  • Publishes the mold in words at 7.48 by 4.01 by 0.7 inches
  • Thirty two cavities per tray, with a pipette included
  • Against it
  • Never names what the lid is made of
  • Its field depth of 7.63 inches is the lid, not the mold
  • Publishes no lid thickness, so a stacked figure cannot be worked out
2 Best for two hard lids and two trays

Silicone Square Ice Cube Trays with Lids 2 Pack

Two silicone trays of fifteen cavities each with two hard PP plastic lids, published at 7 by 5 by 1.1 inches per tray, and the only listing here that names the lid material and then limits it: the bullet states plainly that the plastic lids are not heat resistant while the trays work from -40 to 464 degrees. For stacking in a drawer a hard lid is the better surface, because a loaded tray can sit on it without pressing into the cavities below. The cubes are published at 1.4 inches square and the maker gives release tricks, including putting the tray in warm water first. Its dimension fields were read as a carton at 5.0 by 7.0 by 1.1 inches, which is consistent with two trays and their lids.

  • For it
  • Two hard PP lids, the only lid material named here
  • States outright that the plastic lids are not heat resistant
  • Two trays published at 7 by 5 by 1.1 inches with 1.4 inch cubes
  • Gives release tricks, including warm water before twisting
  • Against it
  • Its dimension fields are a carton at 5.0 by 7.0 by 1.1 inches
  • Publishes no lid size and no lid thickness
  • Fifteen cavities per tray, the fewest of the three lidded purchases
3 Best for a tray stated to stack

Heart Shaped Ice Cube Trays with Lid

Twenty one heart cavities with a lid the maker says is easy to attach, stops spillage in the freezer and keeps food fresh and free from contamination. It is the only listing on this page to use the word stackable, stating the trays stack and do not take up a lot of space. It is also the only one honest about the weakness of the format: a note at the end warns that silicone trays are not rigid like plastic trays and suggests putting the tray on a tray, or using the lid as a base, to carry a filled one. Published at 10.47 by 5.1 by 1.2 inches in its fields, with no size in words anywhere, a heat range of -104 F to 446 F, and a weight field of 0.42 lb.

  • For it
  • The only listing here to state the trays are stackable
  • A lid stated easy to attach and to stop spillage in the freezer
  • Suggests using the lid as a base to carry a filled tray
  • Heat range published as -104 F to 446 F
  • Against it
  • Publishes no mold size in words, only dimension fields
  • Does not say whether the lid is the silicone or the PP
  • Warns that the tray is not rigid like plastic
4 Best for a cavity deeper than usual

Holographic Chocolate Bar Mold

The one purchase here that wants the drawer depth for the mold rather than for a stack. Three large cavities in a mold published at approximately 30 by 20 by 2.6 cm, which the maker states is thicker and deeper than regular chocolate molds, with dimension fields of 7.88 by 11.82 by 1.0 inches that agree with that sentence in the other unit system. The surface is the selling point: a holographic optical texture stated to create a colorful reflection under light, from nano-textured surface technology rather than any coating. Dishwasher, freezer, oven and microwave safe. At a weight field of 0.73 lb it is the heaviest of these five, and no lid is published, so a filled mold takes nothing on top.

  • For it
  • Stated thicker and deeper than regular chocolate molds
  • Its stated 2.6 cm agrees with its 1.0 inch field
  • A holographic optical texture from nano-textured surface technology
  • Dishwasher, freezer, oven and microwave safe, and heat resistant to 392 F
  • Against it
  • No lid is published, so nothing stacks on a filled mold
  • At 0.73 lb it is the heaviest of these five
  • Three cavities only, the fewest here

Who should skip this: Skip this if counter or storage space is tight: it has the largest published footprint of the five, 11.82 by 7.88 inches.

5 Best for eight bars on one flat sheet

8-Cavity Chocolate Strip Silicone Rectangle Molds fo...

Eight rectangular bar cavities in a single sheet, and the control for this page: at a published 0.59 inches thick and a weight field of 0.1 lb, the lightest purchase here, it gains nothing at all from a deep drawer. The flexible silicone construction is stated to allow demolding without breaking the bars, and the sheet is dishwasher safe and heat resistant with no figure given. It publishes its overall size twice, as 10.63 by 6.69 by 0.59 inches in a bullet headed dimensions and as 6.0 by 10.0 by 0.5 inches in its fields, which differ by a tenth of an inch on the thickness. No lid, no stacking claim and no cavity depth is published.

  • For it
  • Publishes its overall size twice, in a bullet and in its fields
  • Eight bar cavities in one sheet at a weight field of 0.1 lb
  • Flexible construction stated to demold without breaking the bars
  • Dishwasher safe and heat resistant
  • Against it
  • No lid and no stacking claim, so a deep drawer buys it nothing
  • Its thickness reads 0.59 inches in a bullet and 0.5 in the field
  • Publishes no heat figure, only the words heat resistant

Our verdict

AIERSA supplies a lid with each of two 32 cavity trays and states you can stack them in the freezer, and it is the only listing in this pool to publish a lid dimension. Szxc supplies two hard PP lids and is the only one to say the lids are not heat resistant. BTYMS states its tray is stackable. SAINT NIEVE and Vrthske publish no lid at all, so neither can take anything on top of a loaded tray.

“A deep drawer is only useful if something can go on top.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Three lids, one dimension AIERSA, Szxc and BTYMS all include a lid. AIERSA is the only pick that gives a lid size, beginning 7.63 inches, and that figure also sits in the depth slot of its own fields.
One lid is not heat resistant Szxc states that its two hard PP lids are not heat resistant while the silicone trays work from -40 to 464 degrees. It is the only lid material named on this page.
One maker says stackable BTYMS states the trays are stackable and do not take up a lot of space, and suggests using the lid as a base when carrying a filled tray.
Nobody measures a stack None of the three lidded listings publishes a lid thickness or a stacked height, so the figure a deep drawer actually needs exists on none of them.
One mold wants the depth itself SAINT NIEVE publishes approximately 30 by 20 by 2.6 cm and states it is thicker and deeper than regular chocolate molds. It has no lid, so nothing goes on top.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 35% Whether a loaded tray can take anything on topA deep drawer is bought for stacking and a chocolate mold stacks only if it is covered. AIERSA supplies a lid with each of two trays and states you can stack them in the freezer. Szxc supplies two hard PP lids. BTYMS supplies one lid and uses the word stackable. SAINT NIEVE and Vrthske publish no lid, so a filled tray from either takes nothing above it.
  2. 25% What the lid actually isOnly Szxc names the material, and it names a limit with it: hard PP plastic lids that are not heat resistant, on trays rated from -40 to 464 degrees. A hard lid is the surface a second loaded tray can sit on. AIERSA publishes a lid and never says what it is. BTYMS names silicone and PP for the whole set without assigning either to the lid.
  3. 20% Whether the published figures describe the moldAIERSA puts the lid's 7.63 inches in the depth slot where the mold's 4.01 belongs, which is the most informative error on this page. Vrthske publishes 0.59 inches in a bullet and 0.5 in its field. Szxc's fields are a carton. SAINT NIEVE's 2.6 cm and 1.0 inch agree. BTYMS publishes no size in words at all, so there is nothing to check its fields against.
  4. 12% How much there is to stackTwo purchases bring two trays and three bring one. AIERSA supplies two 32 cavity trays with two lids, which is the only purchase here that can stack loaded without buying a second one. Szxc supplies two fifteen cavity trays and two lids. BTYMS, SAINT NIEVE and Vrthske supply one tray each, at twenty one, three and eight cavities.
  5. 8% Heat, washing and releaseThree publish a heat figure: -40 F to 446 F from AIERSA, -104 F to 446 F from BTYMS, and -40 to 464 degrees from Szxc with the lids excluded. SAINT NIEVE and Vrthske state heat resistance with no figure in the bullet. All five are dishwasher safe, and Szxc and BTYMS both publish release tricks, warm water and a push from underneath.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

Seven live pages already rank this pool: by the published heat range, by published width and depth, by cavity count and cavity size, by the size of the piece that comes out, by what each maker tells you to do with the mold afterwards, by the release instruction, and by the published thickness of the mold. Thickness, footprint, cavities and heat are all taken.

A deep drawer is bought for stacking, and a chocolate mold can only be stacked loaded if something covers it. Three of these five publish a lid and two do not, and of the three with lids only one publishes what the lid measures. That one also puts the lid’s figure in the field where the mold’s should be.

Specification AIERSA Szxc BTYMS SAINT NIEVE Vrthske
Lid included Yes, one per tray Yes, two Yes, one No No
Lid material named not published hard PP plastic, food grade silicone and PP named for the set no lid no lid
Lid size published Yes, beginning 7.63 in not published not published no lid no lid
Stacking stated stack them in the freezer not published stackable, and do not take up a lot of space not published not published
Mold size stated in words 7.48 x 4.01 x 0.7 in 7 x 5 x 1.1 in not published approximately 30 x 20 x 2.6 cm 10.63 x 6.69 x 0.59 in
Dimension fields 4.21 x 7.63 x 0.78 in a carton of 5.0 x 7.0 x 1.1 in 10.47 x 5.1 x 1.2 in 7.88 x 11.82 x 1.0 in 6.0 x 10.0 x 0.5 in
Do the two agree No, the field depth is the lid Yes no words to compare Yes, 2.6 cm against 1.0 in No, 0.59 against 0.5
Cavities Thirty two Fifteen per tray Twenty one Three Eight
Trays per purchase Two Two One One One
Heat range published -40 F to 446 F -40 to 464 degrees, lids not heat resistant -104 F to 446 F -40 F to 392 F stated heat resistant, no figure
Weight field 0.66 lb 0.49 lb 0.42 lb 0.73 lb 0.1 lb

What the table cannot tell you is how tall two loaded lidded trays are together, because only one listing publishes a lid dimension and none publishes a stacked figure. The nearest thing is the Szxc carton at 5.0 by 7.0 by 1.1 inches, which holds two trays and two lids, and the maker never says that is what the figure describes.

Which Three Can Be Stacked Loaded

Two Makers Say It Outright

AIERSA states the purpose of its lids plainly: each mold comes with a lid to lock in the flavor and keep the contents fresh for longer, and you can stack them in the freezer while you work. Two 32 cavity trays arrive with a pipette, so a single purchase gives two stackable loaded trays, which is exactly what a deep drawer and a freezer shelf are for.

BTYMS makes the same claim about the tray rather than the lid: stackable and do not take up a lot of space, with a lid that is easy to attach and stops spillage in the freezer. It also adds a caution the others do not, that a silicone tray is not rigid like plastic, and suggests using the lid as a base to transfer a filled tray.

What the Lid Is Made Of

Szxc is the only listing here that names the lid material and the only one that limits it: two hard PP plastic lids on two silicone trays, with the bullet stating that the plastic lids are not heat resistant while the trays work from -40 to 464 degrees. A hard lid is the better stacking surface and the worse oven companion, and this is the one listing that says so.

AIERSA publishes a lid and never says what it is made from. BTYMS names food grade silicone and PP for the set without assigning either to the lid. For a drawer the distinction matters less than it does in an oven, but a soft lid under the weight of a second loaded tray is not the same object as a hard one.

One Listing Publishes the Lid in the Mold’s Fields

The AIERSA Figures

AIERSA’s last bullet gives two sizes: a mold at 7.48 by 4.01 by 0.7 inches, and then a lid size beginning 7.63 inches. Its dimension fields read 4.21 by 7.63 by 0.78 inches, so the figure in the depth slot is the lid rather than the mold. That is useful rather than broken, because it is the only lid dimension anywhere in this pool.

It also means the drawer figure is readable here and nowhere else: a 0.7 inch mold under a lid whose own thickness is not given, in a field set whose largest number belongs to the lid. We have used the mold figures from the sentence and reported the 7.63 as what the listing says it is.

Two More Pairs That Disagree

Vrthske publishes 10.63 by 6.69 by 0.59 inches in a bullet headed dimensions, and its fields read 6.0 by 10.0 by 0.5 inches. Those are the same mold measured twice with a tenth of an inch between the thickness figures, which is small and still worth knowing when the question is how many sheets fit in a stack.

SAINT NIEVE is the pair that agrees. It publishes approximately 30 by 20 by 2.6 cm and its fields read 7.88 by 11.82 by 1.0 inches, which is the same object in two unit systems. It is also the only listing here whose selling point is the thickness itself: thicker and deeper than regular chocolate molds, for a 3 cavity bar.

The Two Without Lids

A Mold Sold on Being Deeper

SAINT NIEVE is the one purchase here that wants the drawer depth for the mold rather than for a stack. Three large cavities, a holographic optical texture that the maker says reflects color under light, and a nano-textured surface. At a weight field of 0.73 lb it is the heaviest of these five, which is what a thick silicone slab weighs.

No lid is published, so a filled tray travels open and cannot be stacked under anything. For chocolate that is less of a problem than for ice, because a set bar is not a liquid, but it does mean the mold occupies its own full depth in the drawer whether it is loaded or not and nothing goes on top of it.

A Flat Sheet of Eight Bars

Vrthske is the opposite proposition and the one this page would not recommend buying a deep drawer for. Eight rectangular bar cavities in a sheet published at 0.59 inches, at a weight field of 0.1 lb, which is the lightest of these five. A sheet that thin slides anywhere and gains nothing from depth.

It earns its place as the control. The flexible silicone construction is stated to allow demolding without breaking the bars, the mold is dishwasher safe, and the overall size is published twice over. If the drawer is deep the sheet simply lies at the bottom of it, and nothing in the listing suggests a second one could be stacked on a loaded first.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

You want two loaded trays, stacked. AIERSA. Two 32 cavity trays each with a lid, stated to stack in the freezer, with a mold published at 7.48 by 4.01 by 0.7 inches and the only lid dimension in this pool.

You want a hard lid to stack on. Szxc. Two silicone trays at 7 by 5 by 1.1 inches with two hard PP lids, and the only listing here stating that the lids are not heat resistant.

You want the maker to promise it stacks. BTYMS. A 21 cavity tray with an attachable lid, stated stackable, published at 10.47 by 5.1 by 1.2 inches, with the lid also usable as a base when carrying it filled.

You want a thick bar, not a stack. SAINT NIEVE. Three deep cavities in a mold published at approximately 30 by 20 by 2.6 cm, with a holographic surface texture. No lid is included.

You want eight bars and no bulk. Vrthske. A flat sheet published at 10.63 by 6.69 by 0.59 inches and 0.1 lb, dishwasher safe, with nothing to stack on it.

What We Could Not Verify

These are the specifications we went looking for in all five listings and did not find.

  • A stacked height for two loaded lidded trays, which none of the three lidded listings publishes.
  • A lid thickness from any of the three that include one.
  • What the AIERSA lid is made of, which the listing never names.
  • Any mold dimension in words from BTYMS, whose only figures are its fields.
  • Whether the BTYMS lid is the silicone or the PP named for the set.
  • Why the Vrthske thickness reads 0.59 inches in a bullet and 0.5 in the field.

Frequently asked questions

Can chocolate molds be stacked while they are full?+

Only if something covers them, and three of these five publish a lid. AIERSA states that each mold comes with a lid and that you can stack them in the freezer while you work. BTYMS states the trays are stackable and that the lid attaches easily and stops spillage. Szxc supplies two hard PP lids. SAINT NIEVE and Vrthske publish no lid at all, so a filled tray from either has nothing it can take on top.

Which of these tells me how big the lid is?+

Only AIERSA, and it does so twice over without meaning to. Its last bullet gives the mold as 7.48 by 4.01 by 0.7 inches and then a lid size beginning 7.63 inches, and its dimension fields read 4.21 by 7.63 by 0.78 inches, so the 7.63 figure has taken the slot where the mold's own 4.01 belongs. No listing in this pool publishes a lid thickness, so the height of two stacked loaded trays cannot be worked out from any of them.

Does a soft lid work as a stacking surface?+

Nothing here answers that directly, and only one listing gives you the information to think about it. Szxc names its two lids as hard PP plastic, which is a surface a second loaded tray can rest on. AIERSA never names its lid material. BTYMS names food grade silicone and PP for the set without saying which is the lid, and the same listing warns that silicone trays are not rigid like plastic ones.

Why is a mold with no lid on this page?+

Because the two without lids are the two ends of the argument. SAINT NIEVE wants the drawer depth for itself, publishing approximately 30 by 20 by 2.6 cm and stating it is thicker and deeper than regular chocolate molds, so it occupies its own depth whether loaded or not. Vrthske is a sheet published at 0.59 inches that gains nothing from depth at all, and at 0.1 lb it is the lightest purchase here.

Can the lids go in the oven?+

One listing says no and the rest do not raise it. Szxc states that the plastic lids are not heat resistant, while its silicone trays work from -40 to 464 degrees, which is the only lid limitation published in this pool. AIERSA publishes a range of -40 F to 446 F and BTYMS -104 F to 446 F, both without saying whether the lid is included in the figure. Treating any lid as oven safe on this evidence would be a guess.

How many cavities do these have?+

The spread is wide and it tracks what the mold is for. AIERSA publishes thirty two cube cavities per tray and Szxc fifteen per tray, both aimed at small gummies and cubes. BTYMS publishes twenty one heart cavities. Vrthske publishes eight rectangular bar cavities in one sheet. SAINT NIEVE publishes three, which are the large deep bars its thickness claim is built around.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.