How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A fermentation weight is a disc that has to get into a jar, sit flat on the vegetables and come back out. Two of those three depend on one figure: the inner diameter of the jar at its tightest point. Most listings in this pool publish the disc instead, which is the wrong end of the problem, because the buyer already owns the jars and the shelf they sit on.
All five picks publish the jar. CREASKING states an inner mouth over 3.5 inches, given also as 90mm. JILLMO and MEOFIENK both require an inner diameter greater than 3.8 inches at the jar’s tightest point. Wagrvuy asks for a body diameter over 11 cm, about 4.3 inches. LELELUK does it differently and names the jars by volume: wide mouth mason at 16oz, 24oz, 32oz and 64oz.
The row nobody fills is how far down the jar the weight sits. Every one of these five publishes a diameter or a mouth requirement and not one publishes a sitting depth, which is the figure that decides whether the brine covers the disc in a tall gallon jar. That is the difference between a ferment that works and one that grows a skin on top.
Two Products Sharing One Category
Gallon Jars and Crocks
Four of these five picks are for large openings. CREASKING publishes the requirement in two units, an inner mouth over 3.5 inches or 90mm, and names the jars it suits, most large mason and gallon jars. MEOFIENK requires a jar opening over 3.8 inches at its tightest point and gives its own disc at 3.7, so the clearance across the whole disc is a tenth of an inch.
Wagrvuy goes furthest and publishes 4.3 inches of ceramic, with a compatibility rule of a body diameter over 11 cm. At that size the disc is wider than a lot of jar mouths, which is why it splits into two semicircles. It also publishes 230 g per half and a glazing step that makes the surface non-porous and dishwasher safe, which bare ceramic is not.
Standard Wide Mouth Mason
The rest of this pool is built for a much smaller opening and the figures there are strikingly consistent. Ten of the sixteen listings describe a disc for a standard wide mouth mason jar at about 2.75 inches, most of them within a few hundredths of an inch of each other, and two of the ten give no figure at all and simply claim a universal wide mouth fit. LELELUK publishes 7cm and 2.75 inches for its own disc.
LELELUK is the pick from that group because it names the jars rather than only the diameter: standard wide mouth mason at 16oz, 24oz, 32oz and 64oz. On a shelf where the jars came from three different boxes, a list of volumes is easier to check than a number you would have to measure, and it publishes 7.1 oz and 202 g per piece as well.
The Figures That Contradict Themselves
Two Pack Weights to Ignore
CREASKING publishes a weight field of 12.0 pounds for two glass discs sized for a gallon jar mouth. Two discs of that size are a pound or two at most, so the figure is discarded here and the listing appears on this page with no usable mass at all. Its jar requirement, published in inches and millimeters, is the reason it still leads.
JILLMO publishes the opposite error. Its four pack states each weight is about 11 to 13 oz, handmade, and then publishes a field of 1.0 pound for the set, which would make each disc four ounces. The same maker’s two pack publishes 2.0 pounds, which fits the per-piece figure much better. Where a listing publishes both, the per-piece figure is the one this page uses.
Fields and Words Disagreeing
Wagrvuy publishes dimension fields of 4.0 by 4.0 by 0.98 inches against its own stated 4.3 inch diameter. The difference matters here more than usual, because the whole question is whether the stone clears an 11 cm opening, and three tenths of an inch is the margin. House rule is that the maker’s sentence wins, so this page quotes 4.3 and records the field.
Three of the five publish dimension fields that are the carton: CREASKING 3.5 by 3.5 by 2.08 inches, MEOFIENK 3.7 by 3.7 by 1.85 and LELELUK 2.75 by 2.75 by 1.38. Those are real figures for a real box and in two of the three cases the first number happens to be close to the disc, which is a coincidence rather than a specification.
Getting It Back Out of a Full Jar
Five Handles, No Figures
All five publish a handle and not one publishes a figure for it. JILLMO publishes a raised handle with the plainest reason anywhere in this pool: it makes each weight easier to place, adjust and lift out even when your hands or the glass are wet. CREASKING publishes a grooved handle with a wavy dot texture it says gives a non-slip grip on wet, slippery hands.
Wagrvuy publishes a hollow center as a focal point for a finger and says it works in the narrow space of a jar. MEOFIENK publishes an ergonomic handle for wet or slippery fingers without naming a shape, and LELELUK publishes a finger-friendly grip for lifting the disc out without disrupting the ferment. Nobody publishes a handle height, which is the figure that would separate these five.
What a Shelf of Ferments Actually Needs
Pack counts here run from two to nine. Four other brands on this fact sheet publish nine piece sets, every one of them a mason jar disc rather than a gallon weight, which is the obvious answer for a shelf running several small jars. What none of them publishes is how many weights one jar wants, and a wide mouth quart jar full of cabbage may want two stacked.
At the other end, LELELUK argues explicitly for two: perfectly portioned for small-batch fermentation, with no need to buy a bulky four piece set, and ideal for minimal storage. For a shelf that runs one or two ferments at a time that is the better purchase, and it is the only listing on this fact sheet to make storage of the weights themselves part of its pitch.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
Gallon jars you have already measured. CREASKING publishes the requirement in both units, an inner mouth over 3.5 inches or 90mm, and names large mason and gallon jars. Ignore its 12.0 pound weight field, which cannot be two glass discs.
Three big ferments at once. MEOFIENK publishes three weights for jar openings over 3.8 inches with the disc itself at 3.7, 12 to 13 oz a piece and 2.68 pounds for the set. No washing method is published.
A crock as well as jars. Wagrvuy publishes a 4.3 inch glazed ceramic stone at 230 g a half, splitting in two to get past a narrower mouth, and is the only dishwasher-safe ceramic here.
Standard wide mouth mason jars. LELELUK names the volumes, 16oz through 64oz, publishes 7cm and 2.75 inches, and 7.1 oz and 202 g per piece. Two weights only, so a busy shelf needs more.
Four gallon jars in rotation. JILLMO publishes 11 to 13 oz a piece, a raised lift handle for wet hands, and a jar opening requirement over 3.8 inches at its tightest point. Its 1.0 pound field contradicts its own per-piece figure.
What We Could Not Verify
Every figure above is a manufacturer’s own published number or sentence. These are the things we went looking for across all sixteen listings and did not find.
- A sitting depth or jar height from any listing, which is what decides whether brine covers the weight in a tall gallon jar.
- A disc diameter for CREASKING or for JILLMO’s four pack, both of which publish only the jar they need.
- A credible pack weight for CREASKING at 12.0 pounds, or for JILLMO’s four pack at 1.0 pound against 11 to 13 oz a piece.
- A thickness from any of the five picks, so how much headroom a disc takes in a jar is unstated.
- A handle height or depth from any listing here that publishes a handle shape.
- Any statement about how many weights a single jar needs, including from the nine piece sets elsewhere in this pool.