How the Five Compare on the Numbers
One listing in this pool of eight says anything at all about storing the liners between batches, and it says the opposite of stackable: CiCixixi states that its silicone can be rolled for compact storage with no permanent creases. Everything else here is left to its own shape. So the question worth asking is what each purchase becomes once it comes out of the machine.
There are three answers in this pool and they are not close. A flexible flat sheet goes into a pile. A sheet with a raised lip around it does not, because the lip holds the next sheet off the one below. And a rigid plastic tray nests, which is the only genuinely stackable object here, and it is not a liner at all.
The height row is the interesting one and it should be read with suspicion. Those figures come from the dimension fields, which for a flat pack of sheets describe the pack, and three of them cannot be right. Five GUCUJI sheets at 0.8 mm each would be about 0.16 inches, not 0.1. Twenty one CiCixixi pieces cannot be 0.2 inches. One listing outside the five publishes 0.02 inches for eight sheets.
What Stackable Means for a Sheet of Silicone
The One Listing That Addresses Storage
CiCixixi is the only maker in the pool that talks about where the liners go afterwards, and its claim is specific: soft bendable silicone that can be rolled for compact storage with no permanent creases. That is a real property of thicker silicone, and it is also an admission, because a sheet you roll is a sheet that does not want to sit in a tidy flat pile.
It is the largest purchase here by piece count as well: ten edged mats, ten mesh screens and one spatula, at a stated 11.81 by 9.84 inches, rated minus 40 to 428 degrees F and stated dishwasher safe. Twenty one items is a lot of silicone to put somewhere, which is presumably why the storage sentence exists at all.
The Four That Say Nothing and Stack Anyway
GUCUJI and Lova are flat mesh with nothing standing proud of the surface, so a pile of them is a pile. GUCUJI is five sheets of 12.6 inch mesh at a published 0.8 mm, also given as 30 mil, with 1 by 1 mm holes and a stated tolerance of minus 40 to 428 degrees F. Lova is twelve sheets at 14 by 14 inches, trimmed to fit with scissors.
Bright Kitchen breaks the pattern. Its sheets carry a 1/4 inch edge or lip all the way round to hold liquid batter, published at 12.5 inches diameter with a 3 inch center hole and 12.5 by 12.5 by 0.25 inches overall. Four of those do not nest flat: each lip sits on the one below, so the stack is four times a quarter inch rather than four thin sheets.
The One Thing Here That Actually Stacks
Rigid Trays, and Why They Are Not Liners
The NESCO Add-A-Trays are the only rigid item in this pool and the only object that stacks in the sense a buyer means. They are two speckled plastic trays at 13 1/2 inches diameter, made of food grade plastic, sold to expand a 20 or 30 Series machine rather than to line it. A tray nests into the tray below because that is how a stacking dehydrator is built.
That is worth saying plainly because the search behind this page asks for tray liners. A liner is a floppy sheet that sits on a rack, and a tray is a rack. If what you want is more capacity that stores in a column, this is the only answer in the pool, and if what you want is a non stick surface, it is the wrong product entirely.
The Dimension Fields on That Listing Do Not Work
NESCO publishes 4 by 2.5 by 14 inches in its dimension fields against a stated 13 1/2 inch tray diameter, and a round tray of that size cannot be 4 inches across. The 14 inch figure is plausible as the outside of a box holding two trays on edge, and the other two are not describing a tray at all. The published weight of 1.0 lb for the pair is credible.
So for this pick the useful figure is the one written in the bullets rather than the one in the fields: compatible with 13 and a half inch diameter trays, fitting NESCO 20 and 30 Series machines and the FD-37. That is the number to measure against, and the page uses it and discards the rest.
Pieces, Bulk and What You Are Really Storing
Four Sheets or Twenty One Pieces
Piece count drives bulk more than thickness does here. Bright Kitchen and GUCUJI are four and five sheets, which is one machine load for most round dehydrators. Lova is twelve, deliberately, so every rack can be lined in one run without stopping to wash. CiCixixi is twenty one items because it pairs a mat and a mesh screen for each rack and adds a spatula.
Published weights follow the same order and one of them does not. GUCUJI is 0.32 lb for five mesh sheets, Lova 1.23 lb for twelve, Bright Kitchen 1.0 lb for four edged sheets and NESCO 1.0 lb for two plastic trays. CiCixixi publishes 7.5 lb, which is far heavier than twenty one silicone sheets should be and is not used for anything here.
Mesh and Solid Do Not Store the Same Way
A mesh sheet is an open weave with nothing to trap, so it dries fast in a pile and comes apart cleanly. A solid mat with a lip holds a film of whatever it dried, and two stacked wet mats stay wet between them. Only CiCixixi ships both kinds in one purchase, which is the strongest practical argument for its rolling claim.
Cleaning statements matter for the same reason. CiCixixi and Bright Kitchen state dishwasher safe outright, Lova specifies warm soapy water or the top rack, and GUCUJI describes rinsing rather than a machine. NESCO says only that the plastic trays are easy to clean. Nothing in the pool says how long any of them should dry before being put away.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
The kitchen with one shallow drawer. CiCixixi is the only pick whose maker tells you what to do with the pieces: roll them, with no permanent creases. Ten edged mats, ten mesh screens and a spatula at 11.81 by 9.84 inches, rated minus 40 to 428 degrees F.
The kitchen that wants more capacity, not more liners. NESCO Add-A-Trays are two rigid plastic trays at 13 1/2 inches diameter for 20 and 30 Series machines, published at 1.0 lb. They nest into a column and they are not a liner, so read that before ordering.
The kitchen lining every rack at once. Lova is twelve mesh sheets at 14 by 14 inches, trimmed with household scissors to any round or square tray, stated BPA and PFOA free, washable in warm soapy water or on the top rack, at 1.23 lb for the set.
The kitchen drying berries and herbs. GUCUJI is five 12.6 inch mesh sheets at a published 0.8 mm, with 1 by 1 mm holes that hold blueberries on the rack, rated minus 40 to 428 degrees F, at 0.32 lb, and cut to any size with scissors.
The kitchen making fruit leather. Bright Kitchen publishes a 1/4 inch lip around a 12.5 inch disc with a 3 inch center hole, at 12.5 by 12.5 by 0.25 inches and 1.0 lb, dishwasher safe. Four of those stack lip on lip rather than flat.
What We Could Not Verify
These are the figures and statements we went looking for in the manufacturer listings and could not find. Nothing below was estimated, and nothing on this page was measured by us.
- Any storage or stacking statement from seven of the eight listings in this pool.
- A sheet thickness for the CiCixixi, Lova and Bright Kitchen liners, which publish none.
- Real dimensions for the NESCO trays, whose fields read 4 by 2.5 by 14 inches against a stated 13 1/2 inch diameter.
- Why CiCixixi publishes 7.5 lb for twenty one silicone pieces, which is not a figure this page relies on.
- A temperature figure from the Lova and Bright Kitchen listings and the NESCO trays.
- How long any of these should be dried before being stacked or rolled, which no maker addresses.