How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A freezer drawer is a fixed slot, so the figure that decides everything is the height, and these five publish 3.5 inches, 3.94, something between 3.94 and 4.37, 5.91 and 5.91. Only one of them is unambiguous. iDesign states 11.5 by 6 by 3.5 inches in its own bullet and publishes the same three figures in its fields, in the same order.
The other four are harder to read. Brigii states 3.94 inches of height and publishes 4.72 in its field. PHINOX publishes the same three numbers in two different orders, so which one is the height is unresolved. Lolytama and OBreezify both publish 5.91 inches, and both describe a bucket measuring 12.8 by 6.89 by 5.91.
What the table cannot tell you is how much ice any of the buckets holds, because neither steel listing publishes a cube count. Lolytama publishes 12 liters and OBreezify publishes nothing but a bucket size, while the two plastic sets both publish 56 cubes and neither publishes a bin volume. Capacity and dimensions are published by different halves of this pool and never by the same listing.
The Height Is the Whole Decision
Three and a Half Inches, or Almost Six
iDesign publishes 3.5 inches and is the only listing here a shallow drawer will certainly take. It is an open-topped transparent bin at 11.5 by 6 inches with an integrated handle, and the listing names freezers, cabinets, cupboards and pantry shelves. What it is not is an ice system: there is no tray, no lid and no cube count anywhere in its five bullets.
At the other end, Lolytama and OBreezify both publish 5.91 inches, which is nearly six inches of drawer gone before anything is put in. Both are stainless buckets and both describe the same bucket dimensions, 12.8 by 6.89 by 5.91 inches. In a freezer drawer that is a footprint you notice as well as a height.
Two Listings That Publish the Same Numbers Twice
PHINOX publishes 4.37 by 7.09 by 3.94 inches in its fields and states 7.08 by 3.94 by 4.37 in its own bullet. Those are the same three numbers in a different order, so the listing publishes both 3.94 and 4.37 as the height and settles neither. For a drawer that gap is the difference between fitting and not, and the safe reading is 4.37.
Brigii is worse because the numbers do not even match. It states 9.05 by 5.51 by 3.94 inches and publishes 5.52 by 9.05 by 4.72, so the first two figures agree to within a hundredth and the third does not agree at all. Its own bullet repeats 3.94 in a space-saving claim, which makes the stated figure the one a person wrote.
What Is in the Box, and What It Costs in Depth
A Bin, or a Bin With Trays In It
PHINOX and Brigii both solve the whole problem in one purchase. PHINOX supplies two 28-cube trays, a lid, a pillar plate, a scoop and a storage bin, and describes a push release: turn the tray upside down on the bin, close the lid and press the middle with both hands. Brigii supplies two stackable trays and a clear bin with release prongs built into the lid.
Both then publish 56 cubes and neither publishes a bin volume, so how much ice the bin holds once the trays are emptied into it is unstated. What the sets cost in a drawer is the trays: PHINOX states they stack, and stacked trays are what makes 4.37 inches rather than the 3.94 the bin alone would need.
The Two Steel Buckets
Lolytama and OBreezify publish the same bucket. Both state 12.8 by 6.89 by 5.91 inches, or 32.5 by 17.5 by 15 cm, in stainless steel, and a third listing in this pool states the same three figures again. What differs is what comes with it: Lolytama supplies the bucket and a handle, and OBreezify adds two 18-slot steel trays with easy release levers, a scoop and a pair of tongs.
OBreezify’s dimension fields read 7.87 by 13.78 by 5.91 inches, which is 20 by 35 by 15 cm and therefore a carton rather than the bucket it states. Lolytama’s fields read 8.66 by 12.6 by 5.91 and match its own words exactly. Neither publishes a weight for the bucket alone: OBreezify’s 3.48 pounds covers five items and Lolytama publishes none.
Lids, Handles and What Nobody Publishes
One Handle and One Open Top
Two of the five publish a handle. iDesign states an integrated handle on an open-topped bin, which is the combination that suits a drawer: nothing to lift off and something to pull. Lolytama states a sturdy handle for carrying the bucket from the freezer to a counter or a patio, which is a different job and needs a lid it does not publish.
The lids are on the plastic sets instead. PHINOX states an airtight lid with a waterproof platform that seals to stop overflow and odor, and Brigii a dustproof lid with release prongs built in. Those lids are functional parts of the ice-making process rather than covers, which is why neither steel bucket has one.
The Listing With No Figures At All
A sixth listing in this pool, the ChefAide three-pack, was left out of this comparison because it publishes nothing to compare. It has no dimension fields, no weight, no stated size, no cube count and no feature bullets at all, on a product its own title describes as an ice cube tray with a lid and a bin. For a drawer page there is no figure to check.
That is worth saying because it is the other way a listing fails a reader. Brigii and PHINOX publish figures that contradict each other, which at least gives you two numbers and a judgement to make. ChefAide publishes none, which leaves a purchase that can only be measured after it arrives.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
A genuinely shallow drawer. iDesign publishes 11.5 by 6 by 3.5 inches in both its fields and its own words, with an open top, transparent walls and an integrated handle, at 0.66 pounds. It publishes no cube count, no lid and no tray: it is a bin and nothing else.
Making and storing ice in one drawer. PHINOX supplies two 28-cube trays, a lid, a pillar plate, a scoop and a bin for 56 cubes of 0.8 inches, in food grade PP at 0.8 pounds. Plan for 4.37 inches rather than the 3.94 it also publishes, and note it is stated not dishwasher safe.
Checking the ice level without opening anything. Brigii supplies two stackable trays and a clear bin with release prongs in the lid, 56 cubes at 1 inch each, at 1.59 pounds. It states 3.94 inches of height and publishes 4.72, so measure the drawer against the larger figure.
Carrying ice out of the kitchen. Lolytama publishes 12.6 by 8.66 by 5.91 inches in both places, 12 liters stated as 12.7 quarts, in stainless steel with a sturdy handle. It publishes no weight, no lid and no cube count, and 5.91 inches is a deep drawer.
A steel set with the trays included. OBreezify supplies two 18-slot steel trays with easy release levers, a bucket stated at 12.8 by 6.89 by 5.91 inches, a scoop and tongs, at 3.48 pounds for the set. Its dimension fields describe the carton rather than the bucket.
What We Could Not Verify
These are the figures the five listings do not publish, and nothing above has been supplied in their place.
- Neither steel bucket publishes a cube count, and neither plastic set publishes a bin volume.
- Brigii states 3.94 inches of height and publishes 4.72 inches in its dimension field.
- PHINOX publishes the same three figures in two different orders, so its height is either 3.94 or 4.37.
- OBreezify’s dimension fields describe a carton rather than the bucket it states.
- Lolytama publishes no weight, no lid and no cube count.
- Only PHINOX says anything about a dishwasher, and what it says is no.