The deciding specification is what each maker says the lid does, because a tray of water above a bin of loose ice behaves differently in a kitchen that travels.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
I compared the lid claim, release method, trays and cubes supplied, stacking wording and published size across five ice cube tray and bin sets, using each maker's own listing text.
The only listing in the pool that names an RV refrigerator, with four food grade silicone trays around a central bin, secure non spill lids, an odor resistant claim and 0.66 lb published.
An airtight lid seated on a waterproof platform, 64 cubes pressed out push type into the container below, and a stated claim that the ice does not take on freezer odor.
A rigid plastic frame with a silicone bottom, 56 cubes at 1 in across two trays, a dustproof lid with release prongs built in, published at 9.05 by 5.51 by 3.94 in.
Fifty six cubes across two trays released by twisting with TPR comfort grips, a leakproof design, a bin the trays nest onto and a scoop, in a six piece set at 1.57 lb.
A clear plastic bin at 11.5 by 6 by 3.5 in with an integrated handle and an open top. It makes no ice and covers none, and it is the only pick here built to be picked up.
| Model | Brand | Size (Capacity) | Weight | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin | DOQAUS | 8.2*4.5*3.6'' - 4 Pack | 0.66 lb | Best for a freezer in something that drives |
| Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid & Bin | QUELIEN | 2.5x2.5cm | 1.83 lb | Best for the tightest seal described |
| Brigii Ice Cube Tray with Lid & Storage Bin | Brigii | small | 1.59 lb | Best for a tray that holds its shape |
| GORILLA GRIP Space Saving Ice Cube Tray and Bin Set | GORILLA GRIP | Large | 1.57 lb | Best for getting ice out with cold hands |
| iDesign Linus Plastic Fridge and Freezer Storage Org... | iDesign | 11.5" x 6" x 3.5" | 0.66 lb | Best for carrying ice you already have |
The only listing in the pool that names an RV refrigerator, with four food grade silicone trays around a central bin, secure non spill lids, an odor resistant claim and 0.66 lb published.
An airtight lid seated on a waterproof platform, 64 cubes pressed out push type into the container below, and a stated claim that the ice does not take on freezer odor.
A rigid plastic frame with a silicone bottom, 56 cubes at 1 in across two trays, a dustproof lid with release prongs built in, published at 9.05 by 5.51 by 3.94 in.
Fifty six cubes across two trays released by twisting with TPR comfort grips, a leakproof design, a bin the trays nest onto and a scoop, in a six piece set at 1.57 lb.
A clear plastic bin at 11.5 by 6 by 3.5 in with an integrated handle and an open top. It makes no ice and covers none, and it is the only pick here built to be picked up.
DOQAUS is the only listing in the pool that names an RV refrigerator, with four silicone trays, a central bin and secure non spill lids at 0.66 lb. QUELIEN publishes an airtight lid on a waterproof platform and 64 cubes. Brigii pairs a rigid frame with a silicone bottom for 56 cubes at 1 in. GORILLA GRIP twists 56 cubes out with TPR grips. iDesign is an open bin with a handle.
“A lid that keeps dust out is not a lid that keeps water in.”
Lush Food & Drink
Only DOQAUS says so. Its stacking bullet names compact apartment freezers and RV refrigerators directly, and it is the one listing in the seven that mentions a mobile or undersized freezer at all. The other four describe freezer space in general. That does not make them unsuitable, but it does mean the fit has to be worked out from published dimensions, and two of the five publish none.
On these listings, everything. Brigii calls its lid dustproof, which describes keeping things out of the tray. DOQAUS calls its lids secure and non spill, which describes keeping water in. QUELIEN goes furthest and describes the mechanism, an airtight lid seated on a waterproof platform that covers the tray tightly. GORILLA GRIP publishes leakproof without saying whether it means the tray, the lid or the bin.
No listing in the pool says. Brigii and GORILLA GRIP both publish 56 cubes made across two trays, and QUELIEN publishes 64, but a cube count is what the trays produce rather than what the bin stores. Since ice is tipped loose into the bin and then settles, the only way to judge capacity from these listings is the outside dimensions, and DOQAUS and QUELIEN do not publish those either.
Not in a small freezer. DOQAUS supplies four silicone trays around a central bin, which is more ice per cycle and also four trays to fill level, four lids to seat and four objects competing for shelf space. Brigii and GORILLA GRIP both settled on two trays and a bin that they stack into one block. In a trailer, the block is usually worth more than the extra capacity.
Pushing beats twisting when there is nothing above the tray. QUELIEN and DOQAUS both push from below, and Brigii flips the tray onto the bin and presses prongs in the lid, all of which happen at the height the tray already occupies. GORILLA GRIP twists, using TPR comfort grips, and twisting needs room for your hands and for the tray to flex, which a packed shelf does not always give.
Because iDesign is in the pool and because it answers a question the others do not. At 11.5 by 6 by 3.5 in with an integrated handle, it carries ice you already have from the freezer to a table and back, and it is the only pick with anything to hold. Its open top is published as a feature, which makes it the wrong shape for a shelf that moves and the right one for serving.
Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.
Seven listings sit on the fact sheet and two are left off. ChefAide publishes nothing at all beyond a three pack with a bin, with no dimensions, no cube count and no feature text, so there is nothing to place it against. PHINOX publishes an airtight lid and a waterproof platform in almost the same words QUELIEN uses, and on a page about the lid one of that pair is enough.
What decides this page is the lid. A freezer in a kitchen that moves does not hold a tray level, and every one of these sets is a tray of water sitting above a bin of loose ice. Four of the five below publish something about sealing, in four different words, and the fifth has no lid at all. DOQAUS is also the only listing in the pool that names an RV refrigerator.
| Specification | DOQAUS | Brigii | GORILLA GRIP | QUELIEN | iDesign |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What the maker says about the lid | Secure non spill lids | A dustproof lid with release prongs built in | Leakproof design stated | Airtight lid on a waterproof platform | Open top, no lid at all |
| Odor claim | Odor resistant, food grade silicone | not published | not published | Ice does not absorb odor | not published |
| Trays in the set | Four | Two | Two | not published | none, it is a bin |
| Cubes the set makes | not published | 56, at 28 a tray | 56, at 28 a tray | 64 | not applicable |
| Cube size published | not published | 1 in | 1.3 in and 1 in given | 2.5 by 2.5 cm in the size field | not applicable |
| How ice is released | Flexible bottom, pushed from below | Flip onto the bin and press the prongs | Twist, with TPR comfort grips | Push type, squeezed into the bin | not applicable |
| Size in the maker’s own words | 8.2 x 4.5 x 3.6 in, in a field that also says 4 Pack | 9.05 x 5.51 x 3.94 in | 10.7 x 6.6 in | not published | 11.5 x 6 x 3.5 in |
| Dimension fields on the listing | not published | 5.52 x 9.05 x 4.72 in | 6.6 x 10.7 x 4.3 in | not published | 6 x 11.5 x 3.5 in |
| Published weight | 0.66 lb | 1.59 lb | 1.57 lb | 1.83 lb | 0.66 lb |
| Stacking claim | Trays stack to save vertical space | Rigid frame holds shape for stacking | Trays nest on top of the bin | Trays stack and store | not published |
| Material stated | Food grade silicone and plastic | Plastic frame with a silicone bottom | Food grade BPA free, stain resistant | Food grade, BPA free | Transparent plastic |
| Carrying or serving part | A central bin | A clear storage bin | A bin and an ice scoop | A container the ice is pressed into | An integrated handle |
| Small space named by the maker | Compact apartment freezers and RV refrigerators | not published | not published | not published | not published |
The table cannot tell you how much ice any bin holds, because not one listing in the pool publishes a bin capacity. It gives cube counts for the trays and dimensions for the outside, and leaves the number that matters to a small freezer unstated. It also cannot tell you whether any of these lids holds water in when the tray is tipped rather than carried level, which on a road is the actual test.
QUELIEN publishes the most specific claim, an airtight lid designed with a waterproof platform that covers the tray tightly. DOQAUS publishes secure non spill lids. GORILLA GRIP publishes a leakproof design without describing the lid that achieves it. Brigii calls its lid dustproof, which is a claim about what gets in rather than what gets out, and pairs it with release prongs built into the underside.
Those are four different promises and none of them is tested against tipping. A dustproof lid and a non spill lid are not the same object, and a leakproof design might refer to the bin. For a kitchen that travels, the QUELIEN wording is the only one that describes a mechanism, a platform pressed against the tray, rather than an outcome.
iDesign is not an ice system. It is a clear fridge and freezer organizer, 11.5 by 6 by 3.5 in, with an open top and an integrated handle, sold for yogurts, cans and packets. It appears here because it is in the pool and because it answers a real question: if the trailer already has trays, a plain bin with a handle moves a heap of loose ice from freezer to counter and back.
What it will not do is keep that ice clean or stop it sliding out on a bend. The open top is stated as a feature, for grabbing what you need and going, and in a moving kitchen that is the exact property you do not want above a freezer shelf. It publishes 0.66 lb, which matches DOQAUS, and it is the only pick here with a handle.
DOQAUS supplies four silicone trays around a central bin. Brigii and GORILLA GRIP each supply two trays and a bin, both making 56 cubes at 28 a tray, and GORILLA GRIP adds a scoop to make a six piece set. QUELIEN publishes 64 cubes and never says how many trays produce them, which is the one count on this page that cannot be turned into a shelf layout.
More trays is not automatically better in a trailer. Four trays is four things to level, four lids to seat and four objects to find room for, and DOQAUS is the only one of the four that does not publish a cube count to justify them. Two trays and a bin is the configuration three of these listings settled on, and it is the one that stacks into a single block.
Four of these five publish a stacking claim and they mean different things. GORILLA GRIP says the trays nest on top of the bin, which is one object. Brigii says a rigid plastic frame holds its shape so the trays stack securely, and pairs that frame with a silicone bottom for release. DOQAUS says the trays stack to save vertical space and names compact apartment freezers and RV refrigerators while doing it.
QUELIEN says the trays can be stacked and stored without describing the structure that allows it, which on an all silicone tray is the claim that needs the most support. iDesign publishes no stacking claim at all, which for an open topped bin is honest: anything stacked on it would sit on the ice.
Brigii’s own sentence gives 9.05 by 5.51 by 3.94 in. Its dimension fields read 5.52 by 9.05 by 4.72. The two long sides agree to a hundredth of an inch and the third figure does not, differing by more than three quarters of an inch. In a trailer freezer, where the usable height is often a single shelf, that is the figure a buyer would be measuring against.
The maker’s sentence is used above because it comes attached to a description of what it measures, the stackable trays and the bin together. The field is recorded beside it rather than discarded, since there is no way to know whether it includes a seated lid. Nothing on this page is ranked on that figure.
DOQAUS publishes 8.2 by 4.5 by 3.6 inches and 4 Pack in the same field, and never says which object the inches describe. Four trays around a central bin cannot all be 8.2 in long inside a set that size, so the figure is most likely one tray. The listing does not say so, and DOQAUS publishes no cube count to cross check it with either.
QUELIEN’s size field is 2.5 by 2.5 cm, which is a cube rather than a product, and it publishes no dimensions for the tray or the bin at all. Between them these two listings show the pattern in this pool: the figures that are published describe whichever part the seller found easiest to measure, and the bin, which is the thing a freezer has to make room for, is never one of them.
A freezer in something that drives. DOQAUS, the only listing here that names an RV refrigerator, with four silicone trays around a central bin, secure non spill lids, an odor resistant claim and 0.66 lb on the shelf.
The tightest seal published. QUELIEN, an airtight lid on a waterproof platform, 64 cubes pressed out push type into the container, and a stated claim that the ice does not take on odor. It publishes no dimensions at all.
A rigid tray that will not fold. Brigii, a plastic frame with a silicone bottom making 56 cubes at 1 in, a dustproof lid with release prongs, published by the maker at 9.05 by 5.51 by 3.94 in.
Getting ice out with cold hands. GORILLA GRIP, 56 cubes across two trays released by twisting with TPR grips, a leakproof design, a bin the trays nest onto, and a scoop in a six piece set at 1.57 lb.
Moving ice you already have. iDesign, a clear bin at 11.5 by 6 by 3.5 in with an integrated handle and an open top. It makes no ice and covers none, and it is the only pick built to be carried.
Every figure above is from the maker’s own listing. These are the things we went looking for and could not source in any of the seven.
