How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Four of these five are smokers. The fifth is a 15 foot roll of door gasket, and it is on this page because the pool held nothing else and because it is labeled for what it is throughout: a sealing tape, not a cooker. It is also the one accessory an offset smoker owner tends to buy second, so it earns a place rather than filling one.
The deciding figure is cooking area, and these four publish it three different ways or not at all. Dyna-Glo states 1890 square inches, Oklahoma Joe’s 1060, Royal Gourmet 823, and PayLessHere states none, offering instead that it serves 6 to 10 people. The largest of those numbers belongs to the second lightest cooker here, which is the thing to understand before reading any further.
The table cannot tell you how much meat fits, because a square inch on a vertical rack and a square inch on a barrel grate are not the same square inch. Dyna-Glo’s 1890 is six shelves stacked in a cabinet 21 inches deep. Oklahoma Joe’s 1060 is two grates in a barrel 35.5 inches deep. Only Dyna-Glo publishes a load per grate, 25 pounds, which is the figure that turns area into capacity.
Cooking Area, Counted Three Ways
1890 Square Inches on an 83 Pound Cabinet
Dyna-Glo publishes the largest area on this page and the lightest of the three cookers that publish an area at all. It does that by going up rather than out: six height adjustable grates in a vertical cabinet, each rated to 25 pounds, with the firebox offset below so direct heat never reaches the food and rising heat does the work.
That is a genuinely different machine from a horizontal offset, and the listing says so, crediting the vertical design with greater efficiency and better smoke flavor. It also means the 1890 figure is shelf area in a cabinet you can wheel through a gate, not a cooking surface you can lay a whole brisket across.
What Oklahoma Joe’s 1060 Buys Instead
Oklahoma Joe’s splits its 1060 square inches into 751 primary and 309 secondary, which is a barrel plus a warming area rather than six shelves. In a chamber its fields put at 64.25 by 35.5 inches, that primary figure is a surface long enough for large cuts laid flat, and it weighs 226.0 pounds, the heaviest here by a wide margin.
Royal Gourmet publishes the most detailed breakdown of the three: 475 square inches of porcelain enameled steel wire grate, 151 in a warming rack, and 197 in the offset smoker box itself. That last figure is honest in a way the others are not, because it counts the smoker chamber separately rather than folding it into a headline.
How Each One Moves Heat and Smoke
Reverse Flow, Baffles and an Adjustable Flue
Oklahoma Joe’s is the only pick with reverse flow, and it is switchable: optional smokestack locations let you run it as a reverse flow cooker or as a traditional offset. Four baffles locked beneath the grates carry heat and smoke along the chamber before it turns back, which is the whole point of the design.
Dyna-Glo controls its draw at the top instead, with an adjustable flue in the smoke stack described as giving additional flavor and temperature control. Royal Gourmet has an air vent that stokes the fire rather than a flue. PayLessHere publishes no damper, no vent and no baffle of any kind, which on an offset is the omission that matters most.
Fuel, Ash and Tending the Fire
Royal Gourmet is the only cooker here publishing a fuel figure: a 2 level height adjustable charcoal pan holding up to 4.4 pounds of coal. Height adjustment is real temperature control, because moving the fuel closer to the grate does what a vent cannot. Oklahoma Joe’s names a large charcoal basket and Dyna-Glo a porcelain enameled chamber, neither with a figure.
Ash is where a long cook is won or lost and three of the four address it. Dyna-Glo has a sliding, removable steel ash pan it says handles large amounts for hours of maintenance free cooking. Oklahoma Joe’s has a firebox door so fuel goes in and ash comes out without opening the main chamber. Royal Gourmet has a side door for both. PayLessHere has nothing.
The Fifth Product Is a Roll of Tape
Why a Gasket Belongs Next to Four Smokers
Offset smokers leak. The firebox door, the chamber lid and the smokestack joint are all steel on steel, and smoke that escapes there is smoke that never touched the meat, plus heat that never held a temperature. None of the four cookers above publishes a word about door sealing, and three of them have a second door in the firebox.
The UNCO roll addresses exactly that gap and its listing is specific about what it does: seal the gap around the grill door so smoke does not leak out and heat stays in, for better temperature management and less fuel. That is the complaint every offset owner has, answered by a product that costs nothing to fit.
What It Actually Publishes
The figures are unusually complete for this pool: 1/2 inch wide, 0.12 inch thick, 15 feet long, enough to cut to length for a door. The material is named as dense polyacrylonitrile, a flame retardant felt with an adhesive backing, and the heat limit is stated at up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit with a note that it does not melt or lift off the metal.
It even publishes a method: clean the area with dish soap, wipe it with alcohol, fit the gasket and leave it 24 hours under pressure. That is more procedural detail than any of the four smokers gives about assembly, and the 500 degree figure is the only temperature number anywhere on this page.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
A cook who wants both airflow designs. Oklahoma Joe’s is the only pick with switchable reverse flow, using optional smokestack positions and four baffles under the grates, across 751 primary and 309 secondary square inches. At 226.0 pounds it is the heaviest here and it is not going up any steps.
Six racks of ribs at once. Dyna-Glo publishes 1890 square inches over six adjustable grates rated to 25 pounds each, in a cabinet 21 inches deep at 83.0 pounds, with an adjustable flue, a sliding ash pan and a thermometer marked with a Smoke Zone. Its bullet size matches its fields exactly.
Grilling and smoking off one cart. Royal Gourmet publishes the clearest breakdown, 475 square inches of grate, 151 of warming rack and 197 in the offset box, with a 2 level charcoal pan holding 4.4 pounds, front and side tables, a shelf rated to 20 pounds and a fabric cover included.
A grill you have to wheel to a picnic. PayLessHere is 35.0 pounds with bottom pulley wheels and a stated 43 inch size for 6 to 10 people. It publishes no cooking area, no vent, no baffle and no ash system, so buy it as a portable charcoal grill rather than as an offset smoker.
A smoker that already leaks. UNCO is not a cooker at all: it is 15 feet of 1/2 inch polyacrylonitrile felt gasket, 0.12 inches thick, rated to 500 degrees Fahrenheit with an adhesive backing and a stated 24 hour cure under pressure. It fixes the problem every smoker on this page ignores.
What We Could Not Verify
Every figure above comes from the makers’ own listings. These are the things we went looking for and could not source.
- PayLessHere publishes no cooking area at all, only that it suits 6 to 10 people, so it cannot be compared with the other three.
- Only Dyna-Glo publishes a load per grate, so the 1060 and 823 square inch figures cannot be turned into a weight of meat.
- No cooker publishes a steel gauge, so heavy gauge steel and porcelain enameled steel are the whole material specification.
- Only Royal Gourmet publishes a fuel capacity, so how long the other three burn between refills is unknown.
- None of the four cookers says anything about door sealing, which is the whole purpose of the fifth product here.
- No listing publishes a warranty period, an assembly time or a temperature range the cooker will hold.