Silicone mats all look identical in a listing photograph, so a first kit is decided by three published figures: the thickness, the size against the pan you already own, and the temperature the maker will stand behind. Two of these five publish a thickness. Three publish a temperature range. Only one writes out a full care sheet.
Published weights run from 0.53 pounds for a pair of MMMAT half sheet mats to 5.12 pounds for the M MCIRCO set, the heaviest of the five, which includes two steel pans and two cooling racks alongside its mats. Stated mat sizes run from an 11.5 by 8.5 inch quarter sheet up to a 28 by 20 inch pastry mat.
| Specification |
M MCIRCO Set |
Folksy Pastry Mat |
MMMAT |
Angadona Set |
Koolstuffs |
| What is in the set |
Two sheets, two racks and two mats |
One pastry mat |
Two half sheet mats |
Six mats in mixed sizes |
Two half sheet mats and one quarter sheet |
| Stated mat size |
15 by 11 inches |
28 by 20 inches |
11.6 by 16.5 inches |
16.5 by 11 and 5 eighths, and 11.5 by 8.5 inches |
16.53 by 11.61, and 11.81 by 8.26 inches |
| Stated thickness |
not published |
0.7 mm |
0.75 mm |
not published |
not published |
| Stated temperature range |
not published |
not published |
Up to 500 F, or 260 C |
Minus 40 F to 480 F |
Minus 40 F to 500 F, avoiding prolonged use at 500 F |
| Reinforcement stated |
Fiberglass |
not published |
not published |
not published |
not published |
| Published weight |
5.12 pounds |
0.75 pounds |
0.53 pounds |
0.97 pounds |
0.61 pounds |
| Pan fit stated |
Mats sized to the pans included |
A table or counter, not a pan |
Fits half sheet pans |
Half sheet fits a 13 by 18 pan, quarter fits a quarter pan |
Half sheet and quarter sheet, stated as actual mat dimensions |
| Cleaning stated |
Easy to clean, no method given |
Cleaned with a cloth |
A cloth, or the dishwasher |
By hand or dishwasher, top rack only |
The dishwasher once cool |
| Freezer stated |
not published |
not published |
Yes |
Yes |
not published |
| Non slip backing stated |
not published |
Yes, an upgraded non slip back |
not published |
not published |
not published |
| Care warnings stated |
not published |
not published |
not published |
not published |
Do not cut, keep off the rack and away from flames, store flat or loosely rolled |
| Silicone origin stated |
not published |
Food grade, origin not named |
German WACKER silicone |
Imported food grade, with a certificate named |
not published |
The table cannot tell you how many bakes a mat survives, because no listing publishes a cycle count. It cannot give a thickness for three of the five, which is the figure that separates a mat that lies flat from one that curls. And it cannot tell you whether the reinforcement is present on the mats that do not mention fiberglass.
Only Two Listings Publish a Thickness
Zero point seven millimeters against zero point seven five
Folksy states 0.7 mm and then makes the comparison itself, saying the mat is almost twice as thick as others at 0.4 mm. MMMAT states 0.75 mm. Those are the only two thickness figures in this pool, and the fact that one of them defines the competition by naming a 0.4 mm alternative tells you the range at stake.
The other three publish nothing. AMYONE and Koolstuffs each publish a 0.1 inch height field, which is roughly two and a half millimeters and is almost certainly the rolled or folded packaging rather than the sheet. Angadona and M MCIRCO publish no figure in either form, so on those you are buying an unknown.
What thickness is claimed to do
Folksy states the consequence directly: a 0.7 mm mat will stay flat on the table and not wrinkle, where a thinner one will. On a pastry mat at 28 by 20 inches, that is the whole product, because a mat that creases under a rolling pin is worse than no mat.
M MCIRCO makes a different structural claim, stating its mats are reinforced with fiberglass, which is the usual answer to curling on a baking sheet. AMYONE, in the same pool, states internal fiberglass reinforcement as well. Between thickness and reinforcement, one of the two is what keeps a mat flat, and only two listings here name either.
Pan Fit Is the Figure That Decides
Half sheets, quarter sheets and one pastry mat
Angadona is the most explicit about fit, stating a half sheet mat at 16.5 by 11 and 5 eighths inches for a 13 by 18 inch half size pan, and a quarter sheet mat at 11.5 by 8.5 inches for a quarter size pan. Six mats across those sizes covers most of what a household bakes.
Koolstuffs ships two half sheet mats at 16.53 by 11.61 inches and one quarter sheet at 11.81 by 8.26 inches. MMMAT ships two half sheet mats at 11.6 by 16.5 inches and states they fit half sheet pans. Folksy is not a pan mat at all: at 28 by 20 inches it is a work surface for rolling dough on.
One set states actual mat dimensions
Koolstuffs adds a clause nobody else bothers with: after giving its two sizes, it states that these are actual mat dimensions. That is a response to a real problem in this category, where a mat is described by the pan it suits rather than by its own measurement.
AMYONE in this pool is exactly that problem. Its title states 15 by 21 inches for a two thirds size pan, its size field reads 19.7 inches long by 13.6 inches wide, and its published dimension fields read 13.58 by 19.68 inches. The 15 by 21 figure describes something, and it is not the mat.
Temperature and Care Rules
480 F, 500 F, and a caveat
MMMAT states heat resistance up to 500 F, or 260 C, and adds that the mat is safe in the oven or the freezer. Angadona states minus 40 F to 480 F and oven and freezer use. Amazon Basics, elsewhere in this pool, states oven safe up to 480 degrees F and instructs you not to put the mat directly on an oven rack.
Koolstuffs publishes the widest range and then qualifies it, stating use from minus 40 F to 500 F while advising against prolonged use at 500 F. That is the most honest temperature claim here: a ceiling that is a peak rather than a working figure. M MCIRCO and Folksy publish no temperature range at all.
One listing writes the whole care sheet
Koolstuffs is the only pick that tells you how to own the thing. It states placing the mat flat on a pan and not directly on an oven rack, keeping it away from heating elements and open flames, not cutting on it, using it from minus 40 F to 500 F, storing it flat or loosely rolled to maintain its shape, and putting it in the dishwasher once cool.
The others give fragments. Angadona states hand or dishwasher washing, top rack only. MMMAT states a cloth or the dishwasher. Folksy states cleaning with a cloth. M MCIRCO says its bakeware is easy to clean and never specifies a method for the mats as distinct from the pans.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
Starting from no bakeware at all. M MCIRCO ships two rimmed steel sheets at 16 by 12 by 1 inches, two cooling racks at 15.16 by 11 by 0.65 inches and two fiberglass reinforced mats at 15 by 11 inches. It publishes 5.12 pounds, the heaviest of the five.
Rolling dough on the counter. Folksy states a 28 by 20 inch mat at 0.7 mm thick with an upgraded non slip back, and notes that thinner 0.4 mm mats wrinkle. It publishes 0.75 pounds and arrives with an instruction sheet, a gift box and a hair elastic.
Knowing what the silicone is. MMMAT states German WACKER silicone at 0.75 mm, heat resistant to 500 F or 260 C, safe in the oven or freezer, at 11.6 by 16.5 inches to fit half sheet pans. It publishes 0.53 pounds, the lightest of the five.
Covering every pan you own. Angadona ships six mats, with half sheets at 16.5 by 11 and 5 eighths inches for a 13 by 18 pan and quarter sheets at 11.5 by 8.5 inches. It states minus 40 F to 480 F and top rack dishwasher washing only.
Being told how to look after it. Koolstuffs ships two half sheet mats at 16.53 by 11.61 inches and one quarter at 11.81 by 8.26, states those are actual mat dimensions, and writes out cutting, flame, storage, temperature and dishwasher instructions.
What We Could Not Verify
These are the figures a first kit would want, and that these listings do not give.
- A thickness for the M MCIRCO, Angadona and Koolstuffs mats.
- A temperature range for the M MCIRCO set and the Folksy pastry mat.
- Whether the Folksy, MMMAT, Angadona or Koolstuffs mats contain fiberglass reinforcement.
- Any cycle count or expected life for any mat in this pool.
- Whether the M MCIRCO mats specifically, rather than its pans, may go in a dishwasher.
- What the AMYONE 15 by 21 inch figure is measuring, since its own fields read 13.58 by 19.68.