How the Five Compare on the Numbers
The first question is whether a cylinder comes in the box, because a soda maker without CO2 is an ornament. SodaStream’s TERRA bundle ships two 60 L Quick Connect cylinders and three bottles. Breville, Aarke and Smeg all state clearly that the cylinder is sold separately. YOCOSODA, the only electric machine here, says nothing about a cylinder at all.
The second question is what you are allowed to put in the bottle. Breville’s FusionCap is built to carbonate juice, tea, cocktails and wine, and to re-fizz flat soda. YOCOSODA claims fruity drinks and cocktails. The other three are water machines where flavor is added afterward, which SodaStream is explicit about, listing flavor drops and syrups as a second step.
One row of that table needs a caveat. The Aarke fields read 6.02 by 16.34 by 10.16 inches, with the largest figure in the depth position and 10.16 as the height. Every other machine here is between 16.5 and 17 inches tall and under 11 deep, so those two figures appear to be swapped, and the shape of the Aarke is better taken from its rivals than from its own data.
The Cylinder Is the Real Purchase
Included, or Not
Only SodaStream ships gas. Its TERRA bundle includes two Quick Connect 60 L cylinders, three bottles and two flavor drops, which is a working setup from the first minute. Breville, Aarke and Smeg all say the cylinder is sold separately, and Breville and Smeg both go further and tell you what fitting to buy, which is the more useful half of that statement.
SodaStream also describes the refill route in detail, naming both an in-store exchange at participating retailers and a mail subscription that ships full cylinders with a return box and a prepaid label. No other listing here says a word about how you refill, which for a consumable purchase repeated every few weeks is a significant omission.
Quick Connect Against Screw In
SodaStream’s TERRA uses a Quick Connect cylinder that clicks in with one push. Breville, Aarke and Smeg all take standard screw-in cylinders, and Breville and Smeg both name the rating: 60 L for Breville, and 400 to 425 g rated at 60 to 80 L for Smeg. Smeg is the only listing here that specifies a cylinder by weight as well as volume.
The trade is between convenience and choice. A push-fit system is easier to change and locks you to one supply chain. A screw thread is the common standard, which means more refill options, and it is also why Smeg’s 60 to 80 L range matters: an 80 L cylinder is a third more water per swap than the 60 L everyone else names.
Only Two Machines Will Carbonate Anything But Water
What the FusionCap Changes
Breville’s InFizz Fusion exists for one reason: its FusionCap is designed to carbonate a drink that already has flavor in it, naming juice, tea, cocktails and wine, and to re-fizz soda that has gone flat. It also states a choice of fast or slow carbonation depending on the drink, and adds a magnetic stainless drip tray, because carbonating juice makes a mess in a way carbonating water does not.
That is a real capability rather than a marketing line. Sugar and pulp foam violently under pressure, which is why most makers tell you to carbonate water first and flavor afterward. YOCOSODA also claims fruity drinks and cocktails, though it publishes no mechanism for handling them, only over 80 flavor options and three carbonation levels.
Flavor After the Fizz
SodaStream takes the other approach explicitly and is honest about the order: fizz the water, then add flavor drops for zero sugar sparkling water or stir in a soda syrup. The bundle includes two bubly flavor drops for that purpose. Aarke and Smeg publish nothing about flavoring at all, and both are sold on the quality of the carbonation and the object itself.
Aarke does publish the one figure nobody else gives: each cylinder produces up to 2000 ounces of carbonated water, which it converts to roughly 167 standard 12 oz cans. SodaStream states 60 liters, or 16 gallons, per cylinder. Those are the only two yield figures in this group, and they are stated in different units, so a direct comparison needs conversion the listings do not provide.
Levers, Knobs, and the One That Plugs In
Four Ways to Control the Bubbles
Every machine here controls carbonation differently. SodaStream counts presses, one slow press for light fizz and more for stronger. Breville varies speed through the cap. Aarke uses a damper controlled lever, which is the only mechanism here described as damped rather than simply pressed. Smeg puts a knob on the front and gives you a continuous range from light sparkle to pronounced fizz.
Smeg’s knob is the most controllable of the four in principle, because it is analog rather than counted, and Aarke’s damper is the one aimed at repeatability. None of the four publishes a carbonation level in grams of CO2 per liter or any other measurable unit, so these descriptions cannot be compared with each other in any objective way.
The Electric Outlier
YOCOSODA is the only machine here that plugs in, and it uses that for three preset carbonation levels selected on a pressure-sensitive touch panel rather than by how hard or often you press. It also states it accepts both pressure-resistant plastic and metal bottles, which is unusual: the other four are built around their own bottle.
What it does not publish is more notable. There is no weight, no cylinder fitting, no cylinder rating, no yield figure and no statement about whether a cylinder is included. For a machine sold on precision, that is a thin specification, and it is the only listing in this pool that does not tell you what gas it takes.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
The household that wants to start today. SodaStream TERRA, the only listing here that includes gas: two 60 L Quick Connect cylinders, three dishwasher safe BPA free bottles and two flavor drops, with a stated 60 liters or 16 gallons per cylinder and a described refill route. The heaviest here at 10.8 lb.
The cook who wants to fizz juice and cocktails. Breville InFizz Fusion, whose FusionCap is built for juice, tea, cocktails, wine and re-fizzing flat soda, with fast or slow carbonation and a magnetic stainless drip tray for the mess that follows.
The buyer who wants to know the yield. Aarke Carbonator 3, which publishes 2000 ounces per cylinder, roughly 167 standard 12 oz cans, through a damper controlled lever in a stainless steel body, with a 27.05 fl oz bottle. Designed in Sweden.
The cook who wants to dial the fizz. Smeg SKC01, with a front knob giving continuous control instead of counted presses, and the only listing that specifies its cylinders by weight, 400 to 425 g rated at 60 to 80 L. The lightest machine here at 3.6 lb.
The person who wants repeatable results without pressing. YOCOSODA, the only electric machine here, with three carbonation levels on a touch panel, a metal nozzle and compatibility with both plastic and metal bottles. It publishes no cylinder information of any kind.
What We Could Not Verify
These are the makers’ own published figures. These are the gaps that mattered.
- No maker publishes a carbonation level in any measurable unit, so light and strong fizz cannot be compared.
- Only two listings publish a yield per cylinder, and they state it in different units.
- YOCOSODA publishes no cylinder fitting, no cylinder rating and no statement on whether gas is included.
- The Aarke published dimension fields put its largest figure in the depth position, so its shape is doubtful.
- Only one listing describes how cylinders are refilled or exchanged.
- Three of the five publish no bottle material, so what the included bottle is made from is unstated.