How the Five Compare on the Numbers
The five picks on this page share one published fact: each listing names a thermometer or a temperature sticker in the box. That is the figure that decides the page. Beyond it, the numbers diverge. Published capacities run from 24 ounces on the Mfacoy jars to 40 ounces on the Farielyn-X and Meolibour jars, with the KNEADACE and Snuvid jars at 34 ounces in between. Two picks ship two jars, three ship one.
Weight is published for only three of the five. The Farielyn-X two pack is listed at 0.26 pounds, the KNEADACE kit at 1.98 pounds. That is a spread of 1.72 pounds between the lightest and heaviest pick, and it is the only direct comparison the sheet supports across all five, because width, depth and height are missing for two of them.
| Specification |
Farielyn-X |
KNEADACE |
Snuvid |
Meolibour |
Mfacoy |
| Published capacity |
40 oz, two jars |
34 oz |
34 oz |
40 oz |
24 oz, two jars |
| Thermometer listed |
Yes, two |
Yes |
Yes, strip |
Yes |
Yes, sticker |
| Feeding band listed |
Yes, day marked |
Yes, day marked |
Yes, weekday |
Yes, day marked |
Yes, date marked |
| Cloth cover listed |
Yes, two |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Storage lid listed |
Silicone |
Silicone |
Bamboo |
Silicone |
Metal |
| Published weight |
0.26 lb |
1.98 lb |
not published |
not published |
not published |
| Published width |
not published |
4.13 in |
4.3 in |
2.0 in |
not published |
| Published height |
not published |
6.7 in |
5.7 in |
2.0 in |
not published |
The table does not tell you whether any thermometer is accurate, what range it covers, or how it is attached. No listing on the sheet publishes those facts. It also does not tell you how the jars feel in the hand, because nobody at Lush has used them. The table is a record of what the makers state, nothing more.
What the Thermometer Actually Does in Each Kit
A separate thermometer versus a stick on strip
The Farielyn-X, KNEADACE and Meolibour kits each list a thermometer as a separate item alongside the jar. The Snuvid set lists a thermometer strip with a wheat theme, and the Mfacoy two pack lists a temperature sticker. The difference in form is published. The difference in function is not, because no listing states a range or an accuracy figure for either type.
What is published is the rest of the kit. The Farielyn-X box holds two of everything, including two thermometers. The KNEADACE box holds one thermometer, one cloth cover, one silicone cover that doubles as a base, and one spatula. The Meolibour box holds one thermometer, one cloth cover, one spatula and one dual purpose silicone lid. The Snuvid box adds a bamboo lid for storage. The Mfacoy box adds a metal lid and a long handled spatula.
Where the temperature reading sits relative to the starter
No listing says where the thermometer is placed, whether it stands in the starter, clips to the rim, or sticks to the outside of the glass. That is a real gap. A strip or sticker on the outside of the jar reads the glass, not the dough. A separate thermometer can be placed wherever the baker chooses. The sheet does not settle which of these kits uses which method, so the buyer is left to read the product photos.
The jar shape is published for some. The KNEADACE listing describes a funnel shaped opening. The Snuvid listing describes a spherical shape with a built in groove. The Howasai listing, which is not one of the five picks, describes straight sides. Straight or curved walls change how a strip sits against the glass, but no listing connects wall shape to temperature reading, so that link is not made here.
Capacity, Headroom and the Two Jar Question
How much room the starter has to rise
Published capacities are 24 ounces for the Mfacoy jars, 34 ounces for the KNEADACE and Snuvid jars, and 40 ounces for the Farielyn-X and Meolibour jars. The Brod & Taylor listing, which is not a pick here, states that its 32 ounce jar holds up to 300 grams of fully active starter without overflow. That is the only headroom figure on the sheet, and it belongs to a jar without a thermometer.
For the five picks, headroom is not published. A 40 ounce jar holds more than a 24 ounce jar, and that is the whole of the comparison the sheet supports. The Mfacoy listing says its 24 ounce jar is large enough for 3 loaves of bread. The Howasai listing, again not a pick, says its 50 ounce jar suits several loaves. Nothing equivalent is published for the KNEADACE, Snuvid, Farielyn-X or Meolibour jars.
Why two jars can matter more than one large jar
The Farielyn-X listing states that its two jars let you maintain different sourdough types, such as rye and wheat, or keep one starter on the counter and one in the fridge. The Mfacoy listing does not make that claim, but it does ship two 24 ounce jars. The KNEADACE, Snuvid and Meolibour kits each ship one jar.
Two jars also mean two thermometers in the Farielyn-X box and two temperature stickers in the Mfacoy box. If you rotate starters between counter and fridge, that matters. If you keep one starter and feed it on a fixed schedule, one jar and one thermometer is enough, and the KNEADACE, Snuvid or Meolibour kit covers it.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
You keep two starters at once. The Farielyn-X two pack ships two 40 ounce jars, two thermometers, two cloth covers and two feeding bands. It is the only pick on the page that covers two starters out of one box, and its published weight of 0.26 pounds is the lightest of the five.
You want one large jar and a full tool set. The KNEADACE kit pairs a 34 ounce jar with volume, net weight and feed line marks, a thermometer, a cloth cover, a silicone cover and a spatula. Its published weight of 1.98 pounds is the heaviest of the five picks.
You want two lid options. The Snuvid set ships a cloth cover for fermentation and a bamboo lid for storage, plus a weekday labeled feeding band and a thermometer strip. Its published width and depth are 4.3 inches and its height is 5.7 inches.
You want a feeding calendar on the jar. The Meolibour kit lists a day marked elastic band that slides to record the last feeding date, alongside a 40 ounce jar, a thermometer, a cloth cover and a spatula. Its published weight is not stated.
You have little fridge space. The Mfacoy two pack uses 24 ounce jars, the smallest published capacity of the five, and ships two of them with temperature stickers and date marked bands. Width, depth, height and weight are not published for this one.
What We Could Not Verify
Several facts a buyer would want are absent from every listing on the sheet. These are the ones we went looking for and did not find.
- No temperature range is published for any thermometer, strip or sticker on the sheet.
- No accuracy figure is published for any thermometer, strip or sticker on the sheet.
- No listing states where the thermometer is placed, whether in the starter, on the rim or on the outside of the glass.
- The Farielyn-X listing gives a size string of 2.9 inches by 4.7 inches without saying which figure is the width and which is the height.
- The Meolibour listing publishes 2.0 inches for width, depth and height, which does not describe a 40 ounce jar, and the maker does not explain the figure.
- The Mfacoy listing publishes no width, depth, height or weight, so no size comparison can be made for that pick.