How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A tart pan is named after the tart, not after the space it occupies, and in a small oven that gap matters. Fox Run sells a nine inch pan and states that it measures 9.6 inches across. Tosnail sells a twelve inch pan and states that it is about 11.75 inches. Both are honest listings, and both mean the figure on the rack is not the figure in the title.
Depth is the second axis and it separates the group cleanly. The three metal round pans sit at 1 inch or 1.1 inches, Tosnail’s smallest pan at 1.1 inches, and the Yamteck ceramic dish publishes 2 inches, which its own listing calls significantly deeper than standard pans. On a rack close to the element, an inch of extra fill height is the difference between a quiche and a tart.
Two of these rows cannot be read across. The published weights cover four pans for CHEFMADE and three for Tosnail against single pans for the other three, so they are not comparable, and the 0.8 pound Tosnail figure covering three pans up to 11.75 inches across is light enough to treat with caution. The other unreadable row is depth on the CHEFMADE set, where the only figure available describes the package rather than the pan.
What the Name on the Box Leaves Out
The two listings that publish both figures
Fox Run does the most useful thing in this pool. It sells a nine inch pan and then states that the pan measures 9.6 inches by 9.6 inches by 1 inch, and that the tarts it makes are 9 inches wide at the bottom and 9.5 inches at the top. Three figures for one pan, and each answers a different question: the rack, the recipe and the serving.
Tosnail is the other. Its set is sold as twelve, ten and eight inches and its own text gives about 11.75 inches, about 10.25 inches and about 7.9 inches across. The word about is the maker’s, not ours. For a compact oven the 11.75 inch figure is the one to measure against, and it is a quarter inch of relief rather than a quarter inch of surprise.
Where the figure is missing
CHEFMADE publishes no pan dimensions at all. The set is sold as 3 inch, four pans, and the only measured figures anywhere in the listing describe a 3.2 by 3.2 by 0.8 inch package. For a mini tart pan that is a small gap in absolute terms, and it still leaves the depth of an individual tart shell unstated, which is the figure a filling recipe needs.
FIDZ PAN publishes 9 by 9 by 1.1 inches and its field figures agree exactly, which is rarer in this category than it should be. What it does not publish is any distinction between the top and bottom of a fluted pan, so the 9 inch figure covers both the rack and the tart. Yamteck publishes 10 by 2 inches and nothing about the interior at all.
Heat, Cold and the Figures Behind Them
The two pans with stated limits
FIDZ PAN publishes the widest stated range of the five: its feature text says the pan holds its shape from -105 F to 600 F. Its own title states a narrower band of 550 to 600 F for the same pan, so the listing gives two different upper figures depending on where you read. This page quotes both rather than picking the friendlier one.
Fox Run states 572 F, which is a converted figure rather than a round one, and it is the only stainless pan here so there is no coating for the number to protect. Between them those two are the only pans of the five with any published ceiling at all. CHEFMADE says only that its silicone coating is safe at high temperature, which is not a figure.
The cold end and the other appliances
FIDZ PAN is also the only listing with a published lower limit, at -105 F. Yamteck states freezer safe without a figure, and adds microwave, dishwasher, oven and air fryer to the same list, which is the broadest appliance claim in this group. CHEFMADE states oven and electric pressure cooker use, which is unusual for a tart pan and follows from its small size.
That appliance list is worth as much as a temperature on a compact cooktop setup, because a small kitchen often bakes in a countertop oven or an air fryer rather than a full range. Yamteck is the only one of the five that names an air fryer, and CHEFMADE the only one that names a pressure cooker. The other three describe an oven and nothing else.
Bases, Materials and Fluting
Removable bottoms and one fixed dish
Four of the five publish a removable bottom, and the phrasing differs in a way that tells you something. Fox Run and Tosnail both call it a drop out bottom for quick cooling. CHEFMADE calls it a precision crafted loose bottom. FIDZ PAN pairs its removable bottom with a leak claim, saying the design helps quiche bake without leakage, which is the failure mode a loose base introduces.
Yamteck is the exception and it is not trying to be a tart pan in the same sense. It is a one piece ceramic dish with dual handles and a non slip base, published at 2.86 pounds, which is more than five times the Fox Run figure. Nothing comes apart, so nothing leaks, and nothing lifts out either: the tart is served from the dish it baked in.
What the metal is
CHEFMADE is the only listing of the five that publishes a gauge, stating 0.6 mm carbon steel with a strengthened edge it says avoids warping. FIDZ PAN and Tosnail both state carbon steel with a nonstick coating and no thickness. Fox Run states stainless steel and mentions no coating at all, which is why its 572 F figure can stand without a coating caveat.
On coating chemistry, two listings are specific. CHEFMADE states a food grade silicone coating that is PTFE and PFOA free. FIDZ PAN states its surface is free of PFOA, BPA and PTFE. Tosnail names a nonstick coating without saying what it is, and the remaining two have no coating to describe, which for some buyers is the whole answer.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
The individual tart baker. The CHEFMADE set gives four 3 inch pans with loose bottoms and publishes 0.6 mm carbon steel, the only gauge figure here. It is also the only pick rated for an electric pressure cooker, which suits a kitchen where the oven is the scarce resource.
The buyer who wants the real diameter. Fox Run states 9.6 by 9.6 by 1 inches for the pan, 9 inches across the tart base and 9.5 inches at the top, and 572 F. In stainless steel with no coating, it is the most completely specified single pan of the five.
The quiche baker who wants depth. Yamteck publishes 10 by 2 inches, twice the depth of the metal pans here, in ceramic with dual handles and a non slip base. There is no removable bottom, and at 2.86 pounds it is the one pick you serve from rather than unmold.
The baker who wants three sizes. Tosnail publishes about 11.75, 10.25 and 7.9 inches across at 1 inch deep, with fluted edges and drop out bottoms. The 11.75 inch pan is the one to measure against a small rack, and all three arrive for a published 0.8 pounds.
The buyer who reads the heat numbers. FIDZ PAN publishes 9 by 9 by 1.1 inches and a range of -105 F to 600 F in its text, against 550 to 600 F in its title. It states a surface free of PFOA, BPA and PTFE, and asks for hand washing to extend the coating’s life.
What We Could Not Verify
Every figure here comes from the makers’ own listings, and these are the ones that are not there.
- No pan dimensions at all from the CHEFMADE mini set, only a package figure.
- No upper heat limit from three of the five, including the ceramic dish.
- No explanation for the two different upper limits inside one listing, 550 to 600 F against 600 F.
- No interior or base diameter from four of the five, so only one tells you the tart size.
- No steel thickness from three of the four metal picks.
- No fill volume in cups for any of the five, including the pan that sells itself on depth.
