How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A lunch routine needs portions, not a pie, and it needs them to travel. That splits this category in two. DATANYA and RICHSC-PAN sell reusable carbon steel pans with removable bottoms and no lids. Beasea, PACTOGO and LNYZQUS sell disposable foil pans with a lid for every pan, which is the part a lunchbox actually needs.
Pack sizes follow the same split. DATANYA publishes 24 pans, RICHSC-PAN publishes eight pans in three sizes, and the three foil listings publish 50, 10 and 50 pans with a matching lid each. Only the foil listings publish a capacity: 8 oz from Beasea and LNYZQUS, and 5.7 fluid ounces from PACTOGO.
That last row is a warning. The PACTOGO listing says a pack of 10 tart pans with 10 matching dome lids in one sentence and describes a bulk pack of 50 pieces in the next. Nothing reconciles the two, so read the quantity carefully before ordering. It is also the only one of the five that publishes no weight at all.
Portions, and How Many at Once
The reusable packs
DATANYA publishes 24 pans at 3.15 by 0.8 inches each, fluted, in carbon steel with a removable bottom. Twenty four portions is two weeks of lunches for one person or one afternoon for a family, and the removable bottom is what makes a 3 inch shell come out whole rather than in pieces.
RICHSC-PAN takes the opposite approach with three sizes in one purchase: an 11 inch pan at 1.2 inches deep, a 9.4 inch pan at the same depth and six 3.94 inch minis at 0.8 inch. That covers a family quiche on Sunday and six individual tarts for the week, which is a more flexible answer than either extreme.
The disposable packs
Beasea publishes 50 pans and 50 lids at 4.7 inches across the top with the lid on, a 4 inch base and 2 inches tall with the lid. LNYZQUS publishes 50 pans and 50 dome lids at 4.6 by 1.2 inches, 8 oz each. PACTOGO publishes fields of 4.88 by 1.25 inches with an inner top diameter stated as four and three eighths inches and a 3 inch base.
Those are all roughly a 4 inch pan holding around 8 ounces, which is one serving of quiche or a personal pot pie. The differences are the lid shape and the pack size, and the only published capacity difference is PACTOGO’s 5.7 fluid ounces against the 8 oz that both others claim.
The Lid Is the Lunch Feature
What each lid is for
Beasea states that each pan comes with a lid and describes it as both a baking mold and a presentation, so nothing has to be turned out. LNYZQUS publishes clear dome lids and states the pans double as containers rather than only as molds. PACTOGO publishes a clear dome lid per pan and lists freezing, stacking and meal prep as the intended uses.
That is the real argument for foil in a lunch routine: the thing you bake in is the thing that travels, and nothing has to be lifted out of a hot pan or washed afterwards. The two reusable packs publish no lid of any kind, so a tart from either has to be transferred into something else.
What you give up
Foil has no removable bottom because it does not need one, and it also has no fluted rigidity. PACTOGO addresses that directly, claiming its heavy duty foil will not bend or fold in during baking, which is the failure mode of a thin foil pan carrying a wet filling. Neither Beasea nor LNYZQUS makes a rigidity claim.
The reusable pans answer the same question with structure. DATANYA publishes heavy duty carbon steel with large fluted edges, and RICHSC-PAN states that its fluted sides increase surface area to create a crust strong enough to hold the heavy ingredients of a quiche. That is a claim about the pastry rather than the pan, and it is the only one of its kind here.
Heat, Coating and Care
One published temperature range
RICHSC-PAN is the only listing of the five to publish a range: -104 F to -40 C at the bottom and 445 F or 230 C at the top, along with a claim that the pans are non corrosive, stain resistant and dishwasher available. That combination of freezer and oven figures is exactly what a batch routine needs, and four of the five listings do not give it.
DATANYA publishes no temperature at all for a carbon steel pan, and none of the three foil listings publishes one either. Beasea does state that a foil pan can be put directly on the fire as long as it is not empty, which is a heat claim of a different kind and one worth reading twice before trying it.
Release and cleaning
DATANYA publishes the most useful care line in the group: a nonstick surface with a recommendation to brush a layer of oil before use for better demolding. That is an honest note about nonstick coatings on fluted shapes, where the flutes are exactly where a shell tears. RICHSC-PAN states a non stick coating that does not leak and is easy to remove.
The foil packs have no cleaning story because they have no second use. That is the whole proposition: 50 pans and 50 lids at 1.52 pounds from Beasea, which is the lightest published weight per pan in this group and the only one where the washing up figure is zero.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
The cook batching two weeks of tarts. DATANYA publishes 24 fluted carbon steel pans at 3.15 by 0.8 inches with removable bottoms, and advises oiling before use. There are no lids, so plan a container for the finished shells.
The cook feeding a family and packing lunches. RICHSC-PAN publishes an 11 inch pan, a 9.4 inch pan and six 3.94 inch minis, all with loose bottoms, plus the only temperature range here at -104 F to 445 F. It is also the only pick stated dishwasher available.
The cook who wants the lid to come too. Beasea publishes 50 pans and 50 lids at 4.7 inches across the top, a 4 inch base and 8 oz each, at 1.52 pounds for the whole pack. Nothing is washed and nothing is turned out.
The cook freezing ahead. LNYZQUS publishes 50 pans with 50 clear dome lids at 4.6 by 1.2 inches and 8 oz, in thickened food grade aluminum foil. The dome gives headroom over a filling that the flat lids do not.
The cook who wants the pan measured properly. PACTOGO publishes the fullest set of figures of any foil pan here: 4.88 by 1.25 inches in its fields, an inner top diameter of four and three eighths inches, a 3 inch base and a 5.7 fluid ounce capacity. Check the pack count before ordering.
What We Could Not Verify
All the figures above come from the makers’ published text. Here is what is not in it.
- No temperature range from four of the five, including a carbon steel pack.
- No capacity from either reusable pack, so portion size has to be estimated from the diameter.
- No resolution of one listing that states ten pans in one line and fifty in the next.
- No published weight at all from one of the five.
- No foil gauge or thickness from any of the three disposable packs.
- No coating chemistry from either of the two nonstick packs.
