Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

Can you use a waffle maker with pancake mix?

Yes, you can make waffles from pancake mix, and they come out fine, but they will be softer and less crisp than true waffle batter because pancake mix has less fat and sugar; adding a little extra oil, an egg, and sugar brings them closer to a real waffle.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

Yes, you can use pancake mix in a waffle maker, and it works perfectly well, though the result is a little different from a true waffle. Pancake and waffle batters are close cousins, so pancake mix poured into a hot waffle maker will cook into a waffle shape and taste good. The difference is texture: waffle batter normally has more fat and sugar, which is what gives a waffle its crisp, golden outside, so a plain pancake mix waffle comes out softer and paler, more like a pancake in waffle form. A few easy additions close the gap, and any of the waffle makers in our best waffle makers guide will cook pancake mix without trouble.

Why pancake mix works

Pancake and waffle batters share the same basic ingredients: flour, a raising agent, milk, egg, and some fat. They are similar enough that each can stand in for the other in a pinch, which is why pancake mix makes a serviceable waffle and waffle batter can make pancakes. The waffle maker cooks the mix the same way it cooks any batter, pressing it between hot plates so it sets into the grid shape. So there is nothing stopping you using up a box of pancake mix in the waffle maker, and it is a handy thing to know when you fancy waffles but only have pancake mix in the cupboard.

Why the texture differs

The reason a pancake mix waffle is not quite a true waffle comes down to fat and sugar. Waffle recipes usually contain more butter or oil and a touch more sugar than pancake recipes. The extra fat is what crisps the surface against the hot plates, and the sugar helps it brown and adds a little crunch. Pancake mix, formulated to make soft, fluffy pancakes, has less of both, so a waffle made from it browns less and stays softer, lacking the crisp shell people expect from a waffle. It will still be tasty, just more tender and pale than a waffle made from a proper waffle batter.

Making pancake mix more waffle like

A few small additions turn pancake mix into something much closer to real waffle batter. Stir in a little extra oil or melted butter, which is the single biggest improvement, since the added fat crisps the outside. Add an egg, or an extra egg, for richness and structure, and a spoonful of sugar to help it brown and crisp. A slightly thicker batter than you would use for pancakes also helps it hold the waffle shape and crisp up. With these tweaks, pancake mix produces a waffle that browns and crisps almost like the real thing, and many people keep a box of mix precisely to make quick waffles this way.

How to cook them

Cooking pancake mix in a waffle maker is the same as any waffle batter. Preheat the maker fully and grease the plates lightly if they are not well seasoned, since a thinner, lower fat batter can stick more than a rich one. Pour enough batter to fill the pockets without overflowing, close the lid, and leave it until the steam dies down and the waffle is set and golden, resisting the urge to open it early. Because pancake mix browns less, you may need to leave it a little longer, or set a higher browning control, to get any crispness. Lift the waffle out gently once it releases cleanly.

Tips and things to watch

A couple of points help. Do not make the batter too thin, since runny pancake batter can spread and leak out of the sides of the maker, so aim for a batter that pours but is not watery. Grease the plates if sticking is a problem, as the lower fat content makes pancake mix more prone to it. Expect a softer waffle unless you add fat and sugar, and judge doneness by the steam and color rather than a fixed time. Beyond that, pancake mix is a genuinely useful shortcut for waffles, and with a little extra oil and sugar the difference from true waffle batter becomes small.

The short answer

So yes, pancake mix works fine in a waffle maker, giving a waffle that is tasty but softer and paler than one from proper waffle batter, because pancake mix has less fat and sugar. If you want it crisper and more golden, stir in a little extra oil or butter, an egg, and a spoonful of sugar, keep the batter from being too thin, and cook until the steam dies and the surface colors. It is a handy way to make waffles from what you already have, and with those small tweaks the result is close to the real thing.

Common questions

Can you make waffles with pancake mix?

Yes. Pancake and waffle batters share the same basic ingredients, so pancake mix cooks into a perfectly good waffle in a hot waffle maker. The only difference is texture: because pancake mix has less fat and sugar than waffle batter, the waffle comes out softer and paler, more like a pancake in waffle form. Adding a little oil, an egg, and sugar brings it much closer to a true crisp waffle.

Why are waffles from pancake mix not crispy?

Because pancake mix has less fat and sugar than waffle batter. The extra butter or oil in a real waffle recipe is what crisps the surface against the hot plates, and the sugar helps it brown, while pancake mix is made for soft, fluffy pancakes and has less of both. So it browns less and stays tender. Stirring in extra oil and a spoonful of sugar, and cooking a little longer, adds the missing crispness.

How do you make pancake mix taste more like waffle batter?

Stir in a little extra oil or melted butter, which crisps the outside and is the biggest improvement, add an egg or an extra egg for richness and structure, and a spoonful of sugar to help it brown. Making the batter slightly thicker than for pancakes helps it hold the waffle shape and crisp up. With these additions, pancake mix cooks into a waffle that browns and crisps almost like the real thing.

Will pancake batter leak out of a waffle maker?

It can if it is too thin, since runny batter spreads and can run out of the sides before it sets. Aim for a batter that pours but is not watery, a little thicker than you might make for pancakes, so it fills the pockets and holds its shape. Also avoid overfilling, which forces batter out as the lid closes. A slightly thicker batter both prevents leaks and gives a better waffle.

Do you need to grease the waffle maker for pancake mix?

It is a good idea. Because pancake mix has less fat than waffle batter, it is more prone to sticking, so lightly grease the plates with oil, butter, or non stick spray, especially if the non stick coating is worn. Make sure the maker is fully preheated too, so the batter sets quickly rather than welding on. A rich waffle batter often needs no grease, but the leaner pancake mix benefits from a light coat.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about waffle makers