Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

Do you need soup makers?

You do not need a soup maker, since you can make soup in a pot and blend it, but one is a convenient all-in-one if you make soup often: it cooks and blends the soup in one appliance, hands-off. For occasional soup, a pot and a blender (or stick blender) do the same job.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

You do not need a soup maker, because you can make soup perfectly well with a pot (to cook it) and a blender or stick blender (to puree it), but a soup maker is a handy all-in-one appliance if you make soup often. A soup maker is a jug-like appliance that both cooks and blends soup in one unit: you add the ingredients (vegetables, stock, seasonings), select a program, and it heats and cooks the soup and then blends it to your chosen texture (smooth or chunky), largely hands-off, so you get finished soup from one machine without needing a separate pot and blender or transferring hot soup between them. So for people who make soup regularly, it offers convenience, one-pot ease, hands-off cooking, and no messy transferring of hot liquid to a blender. But it is not necessary: a saucepan and a blender (or a stick blender used right in the pot) do exactly the same, cook then puree, so for occasional soup, or if you are happy with that method, you can manage without. So whether you need a soup maker depends on how often you make soup and how much you value the all-in-one convenience over a pot and blender. It is a convenience appliance, not an essential. Our Best Soup Makers compares five of them.

What a soup maker is

A soup maker is an electrical appliance, typically a jug or blender-like container with a heating element and a blending blade, that makes soup by both cooking and blending it in the one unit. You put the ingredients in (chopped vegetables, stock or water, seasonings), choose a setting (such as smooth or chunky soup, and sometimes other programs), and the machine heats and cooks the ingredients for the set time and then blends them (fully for smooth soup, or less/not for chunky), producing finished soup, all without you transferring anything or watching over it. Some also have settings for smoothies, sauces or other blended hot/cold items.

So a soup maker combines the cooking (that you would do in a pot) and the blending (that you would do in a blender) into one hands-off appliance. Understanding this explains the question of whether you need it: since a pot and a blender already do these two steps, the soup maker is about doing them together, conveniently and hands-off, in one machine, rather than being the only way to make soup. Its value is in that all-in-one convenience, which matters more the more soup you make. So whether a soup maker is worth it depends on how much you value cooking-and-blending in one hands-off appliance versus using a pot and blender, as the next sections weigh.

Why it is convenient

A soup maker is convenient, and worth it for regular soup-makers, for several reasons. First, all-in-one and hands-off: you add the ingredients, press a button, and it cooks and blends the soup itself, so you do not have to watch a pot, stir, or do the cooking and blending as separate steps, you can leave it to make the soup while you do other things, and come back to finished soup. This ease and the hands-off operation are the main appeal.

Second, no messy transferring: making soup the traditional way means cooking it in a pot and then transferring the hot soup to a blender to puree (or using a stick blender), and transferring hot liquid to a blender can be messy and a bit risky (hot splashes), whereas a soup maker cooks and blends in the same container, avoiding that transfer entirely, which is cleaner and safer. Third, fewer items and less washing up: one appliance instead of a pot plus a blender (though you still wash the soup maker). And it is simple and quick to use for a fresh homemade soup. So for someone who makes soup often and wants it easy, a soup maker’s one-step, hands-off, no-transfer convenience is a genuine, repeated benefit, which makes it worthwhile. These conveniences are why soup-lovers appreciate a soup maker, even though it is not essential.

When you can manage without

You can manage without a soup maker because a pot and a blender (or stick blender) do exactly the same job. To make soup, you cook the ingredients in a saucepan or pot and then blend it, either transferring to a jug blender, or, more conveniently, using a stick (immersion) blender right in the pot (which also avoids messy transferring and is cheap). This traditional method makes excellent soup and is what most people have always done, so you do not need a dedicated soup maker to make soup.

So if you make soup only occasionally, or are happy cooking in a pot and blending (especially with a stick blender, which gives much of the no-transfer convenience of a soup maker for a fraction of the cost and space), you do not need a soup maker. It is also a single-purpose (or limited-purpose) appliance that takes up space and is another thing to buy and store, which counts against it if you make soup rarely or have a small kitchen, and a stick blender plus a pot is a cheaper, more versatile alternative. So whether you need a soup maker depends on how often you make soup and your existing kit: occasional soup, or contentment with a pot and (stick) blender, means you can do without. So it is a convenience for frequent soup-makers rather than a necessity, with the pot-and-stick-blender method being a strong, cheaper alternative that does the same thing.

How to decide and choose

To decide, consider how often you make soup and how much you value the all-in-one convenience. If you make soup regularly and like the idea of adding ingredients and having the machine cook and blend it hands-off, in one container with no messy transferring, a soup maker is a worthwhile convenience and will be used, especially if you want easy, frequent fresh soup. If you make soup only occasionally, are happy using a pot and a stick blender (which is cheap, versatile and avoids transferring too), or want to avoid another appliance, you can skip it. Many people make great soup with just a pot and a stick blender.

If you buy a soup maker, consider the capacity (enough for your usual batch/servings), the programs (smooth and chunky soup, and any extras like smoothie or sauce settings), the power and build (for cooking and blending well), ease of use, and importantly ease of cleaning (a soup maker with a heating element and blade can be a bit fiddly to clean, so look for one that cleans easily or has a clean setting). So the honest answer is that you do not need a soup maker, since a pot and blender (or stick blender) make soup just as well, but it is a convenient all-in-one appliance if you make soup often, cooking and blending hands-off in one unit with no messy transferring, so it is worthwhile for frequent soup-makers who value that convenience, and optional for occasional ones or those happy with a pot and stick blender. So base the decision on how often you make soup and how much you want the all-in-one ease.

The short answer

You do not need a soup maker, because you can make soup perfectly well with a pot (to cook it) and a blender or stick blender (to puree it), but one is a handy all-in-one appliance if you make soup often. A soup maker is a jug-like machine that both cooks and blends soup in one unit: you add the ingredients, select a program (smooth or chunky), and it heats, cooks and then blends the soup largely hands-off, giving finished soup from one appliance without a separate pot and blender or transferring hot soup between them. So for regular soup-makers it offers real convenience, all-in-one, hands-off cooking, and no messy, slightly risky transferring of hot liquid to a blender, which is why soup-lovers appreciate it. But it is not necessary: cooking soup in a saucepan and blending it, especially with a stick blender used right in the pot (which also avoids transferring, for far less cost and space), does exactly the same job, so for occasional soup or if you are happy with that method you can manage without, and a soup maker is a single-purpose appliance that takes up space. So whether you need a soup maker depends on how often you make soup and how much you value the all-in-one convenience over a pot and (stick) blender: worthwhile for frequent soup-makers, and optional otherwise.

Common questions

Do you need a soup maker?

No, you can make soup with a pot to cook it and a blender or stick blender to puree it, but a soup maker is a handy all-in-one if you make soup often: it cooks and blends the soup in one appliance, hands-off, with no messy transferring of hot soup to a blender. So for regular soup-makers it is a worthwhile convenience, and for occasional soup, or if you are happy with a pot and stick blender, you can manage without. So it depends on how often you make soup and how much you value the all-in-one ease.

What is a soup maker?

An electrical appliance, usually a jug or blender-like container with a heating element and a blending blade, that both cooks and blends soup in one unit. You add the ingredients (vegetables, stock, seasonings), choose a setting (smooth or chunky), and it heats and cooks the soup and then blends it to your chosen texture, largely hands-off, giving finished soup without a separate pot and blender or transferring hot soup. Some also do smoothies or sauces. So it combines the cooking and blending steps into one convenient machine.

Why is a soup maker convenient?

Because it is all-in-one and hands-off: you add the ingredients, press a button, and it cooks and blends the soup itself, so you need not watch a pot, stir, or do the cooking and blending as separate steps, you can leave it and come back to finished soup. It also avoids the messy, slightly risky transferring of hot soup to a blender, since it cooks and blends in the same container, and means one appliance instead of a pot plus a blender. So for frequent soup-makers it offers real one-step, no-transfer convenience.

Can you make soup without a soup maker?

Yes, easily, with a pot and a blender. You cook the ingredients in a saucepan, then blend the soup, either in a jug blender or, more conveniently, with a stick (immersion) blender right in the pot, which avoids messy transferring and is cheap. This traditional method makes excellent soup and is what most people have always done. So you do not need a dedicated soup maker, and a pot plus a stick blender is a cheaper, more versatile alternative that does the same cook-then-puree job, giving much of a soup maker's convenience.

How do you choose a soup maker?

Consider the capacity (enough for your usual batch or servings), the programs (smooth and chunky soup, plus any extras like smoothie or sauce settings), the power and build for cooking and blending well, ease of use, and importantly ease of cleaning, since a unit with a heating element and blade can be fiddly to clean, so look for one that cleans easily or has a clean setting. Match the size and features to how much soup you make, and favor easy cleaning, so the all-in-one convenience is not undone by awkward cleanup.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about appliances