Explainer
What is the difference between canning and pickling?
Canning is a heat process that seals food in a jar; pickling is a way of preserving food in acid or brine, and it can be canned or kept in the refrigerator.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
Canning is a preservation method in which filled jars are heated so the food is sterilized and the jar seals, and pickling is a preservation method in which food is kept in acid, usually vinegar, or in a salt brine. The two overlap because pickled food is often canned afterward, but pickling is about the liquid and canning is about the heat and the seal.
What each word actually means
Canning covers two heat processes. In water bath canning, jars are submerged in boiling water, which suits high acid foods. In pressure canning, jars go into a pressure canner at higher temperatures, which is the route for low acid foods. The jar, the lid and the heat do the work: the food is cooked in the jar and the headspace is driven out so the lid pulls down and holds a vacuum.
Pickling is a recipe, not a piece of equipment. Cucumbers, onions, peppers, cabbage and eggs go into a vinegar solution or a salt brine, and the acid or the salt keeps spoilage organisms from growing. A pickle can be made in an hour and stored in the refrigerator, or it can be packed into jars and processed so it sits on a shelf.
The confusion comes from the fact that a jar labeled a pickling jar is usually just a glass jar with a wide mouth and a lid. The Best Pickling Jars for Small Batches and Bulk guide compares five of them, and the makers describe them for both jobs. ComSaf, for example, states that its split type lids and bands help create an airtight seal for daily storage and water bath canning, and it also lists preserving among the uses.
Why acid decides which process you need
The dividing line in canning is acidity. High acid foods, which include pickles, jams, jellies, fruit and tomatoes with added acid, can be processed in a boiling water bath. Low acid foods, which include plain vegetables, meat, fish and stock, need a pressure canner to reach the temperatures that stop the risk of botulism. That is why a pickle recipe and a green bean recipe are not interchangeable even if both end up in the same jar.
Pickling raises acidity, so a properly acidified pickle is a candidate for water bath canning. The vinegar strength and the ratio of vinegar to water in the recipe set that acidity, and the maker of the jar does not set it. A jar that is sold as a pickling jar carries no claim about the recipe inside it.
The five picks in the guide show how little the jar itself decides. The SAJKUERO 32 oz Pickling Jars, 4 Pack, states a 32 oz capacity per jar and describes the jars for canning, pickling and fermenting. The Muxryla 32 oz Pickling Jars, 4 Pack, states a 3.74 inch wide opening and lists pickling cucumbers, fermenting kombucha and storing sauces. Neither maker publishes a vinegar ratio, a processing time or a pressure rating.
Pickling without canning, and fermenting
Not every pickle is canned. Refrigerator pickles go into a jar with a vinegar brine and stay cold, and they are eaten within weeks. Fermented pickles, such as sour dill pickles or sauerkraut, rely on salt brine and time at room temperature, and the acid is produced by the fermentation itself rather than poured from a bottle. Both are pickling, and neither requires a boiling water bath.
Fermenting puts different demands on a jar. The contents produce gas, so the lid has to be able to vent or be opened, and the vegetables need to stay under the brine. The hinged clamp lids on several of the picks are built for a tight seal rather than for venting. The Anwoi 32OZ Wide Mouth Glass Storage Jars, 4 Pack, states a 3.74 inch wide mouth and a rubber gasket hinged lid for a leak proof and airtight seal. The Muxryla set includes extra replacement gaskets, waterproof labels and a reusable marker.
If you plan to ferment, the jar is only part of the setup. The maker statements describe storage and sealing, not gas management. Nothing in the published features of these five picks claims a vent or an airlock.
What the jar makers publish, and what they do not
The published figures are capacities, mouth widths and weights. ComSaf states 32 oz per jar in a 2 pack, a 3 in wide mouth, and a weight of 2.12 lb. SAJKUERO states 32 oz per jar in a 4 pack and a weight of 5.73 lb. Anwoi states 32 oz per jar in a 4 pack, a 3.74 inch wide mouth, and a weight of 2.0 lb. Muxryla states 32 oz per jar in a 4 pack and a 3.74 inch opening. Miuyhji states 16 oz per jar in a 6 pack and describes embossed measurement markings.
What the makers do not publish is just as useful to know. None of the five states a maximum processing time, a pressure rating, a temperature limit for the glass beyond general microwave and dishwasher notes, or a headspace figure. The Miuyhji listing states heat tempered glass that is microwave safe without lids and bands and dishwasher safe, and it states that the jars are packed in layers of styrofoam and heavy cardboard. Those are handling notes, not canning specifications.
So the honest answer to which jar to use for canning versus pickling is that the jar makers describe both uses without publishing the process figures that would separate them. The process comes from a tested recipe, and the jar is the container.
Matching the jar to the job
For refrigerator pickles and quick brines, any of the five works, and the wide mouth matters most because it lets you pack whole cucumbers and get a hand in to clean. The 3 in mouth on the ComSaf and the 3.74 inch mouths on the Anwoi and Muxryla are the figures to compare. For shelf stable pickles, you need a water bath process and a lid that seals, and the ComSaf and Miuyhji listings are the two that name metal lids and bands, which is the hardware a water bath process relies on.
For fermenting, the hinged clamp jars, the SAJKUERO, Muxryla and Anwoi sets, hold a seal and come in 4 packs, which suits running several batches at once. Capacity is the other lever: 32 oz jars hold a quart, and the Miuyhji jars hold 16 oz, so a recipe written for quarts will need twice as many of them.
None of this changes the core distinction. Canning is the heat and the seal. Pickling is the acid or the brine. A jar is a jar, and the maker’s published figures tell you how much it holds and how wide its mouth is, not what you should put in it.
Common questions
Is all pickled food canned?
No. Refrigerator pickles and fermented pickles are pickled without any canning step. They are kept cold or fermented at room temperature and eaten within a set period. Only pickles that are packed into jars and heat processed become shelf stable, and that step is canning applied to a pickled food.
Can you pickle without vinegar?
Yes. Salt brine fermentation makes pickles without vinegar, because the fermentation produces acid. The salt concentration and the temperature do the preserving. Vinegar pickling is faster and more predictable for a beginner, while fermentation takes days to weeks and needs the vegetables kept under the brine.
Do pickling jars have to be a certain size?
The makers publish capacities rather than rules. The picks in the guide range from 16 oz per jar in the Miuyhji 6 pack to 32 oz per jar in the ComSaf, Anwoi, SAJKUERO and Muxryla sets. Match the jar to the recipe batch size and to whether you want whole vegetables or slices.
Does a wide mouth matter for pickling?
It matters for packing and cleaning. The Anwoi and Muxryla listings state a 3.74 inch opening, and the ComSaf listing states a 3 in wide mouth. A wider opening makes it easier to fit whole cucumbers and to reach inside with a cloth, which the makers name as the reason for the design.
Can you reuse canning lids?
The makers do not publish a reuse policy for the lids on these picks. ComSaf states that lids are consumable parts over time and that they should be washed and dried promptly. For a water bath seal, the safe assumption is a fresh lid per batch, but that is a process rule, not a published figure from these listings.
Is fermenting the same as canning?
No. Fermenting uses salt brine and time to grow acid producing bacteria, and it happens in an open or vented container at room temperature. Canning uses heat to sterilize food inside a sealed jar. A fermented pickle can later be canned, but the two steps are separate and use different equipment.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.