How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Seven listings sit in this pool and five of them use the word stackable. That is unusually good coverage for a qualified page, and it raises a better question than whether a thing stacks: what stacks on what. Two of the five mean the tray sits on the bin. Three mean the trays sit on each other. Those are different designs with different freezer consequences.
Two listings were left out. The iDesign Linus bin is an open top fridge organizer with no lid, no tray and no stacking claim, published at 11.5 by 6 by 3.5 inches, and it is a good bin for yogurts rather than an ice system. The ChefAide three pack publishes no dimensions, no weight and no feature text at all, so there is nothing to compare it on.
Two of the five publish a stated size and a dimension field that disagree on which figure is which. Brigii states 9.05 by 5.51 by 3.94 inches while its fields read 5.52 by 9.05 by 4.72, and PHINOX states 7.08 by 3.94 by 4.37 against fields of 4.37 by 7.09 by 3.94. In both cases the numbers are nearly the same set in a different order, and neither maker says which figure is the height.
Two Different Things Called Stackable
A Tray That Sits on the Bin
GORILLA GRIP is the clearest about this arrangement. Its wording is that the ice cube trays are designed to nest on top of the bin to take up less space, and the set is built around it: one bin, two trays with lids and a scoop, six pieces in total. The bin is the base and the trays are the lid, so the whole thing occupies one footprint in the freezer.
Brigii describes the same relationship from the other end. You flip a frozen tray onto the storage bin, press the lid, and the cubes drop into the container underneath, which only works if the tray sits squarely on the bin’s mouth. It also states that the two trays stack on each other, so this set does both things rather than one.
Trays That Sit on Each Other
DOQAUS is the only pick that pushes the idea to four trays. Its listing says the trays stack neatly to save vertical space, and names compact apartment freezers and RV refrigerators as the reason. Four silicone trays plus a central storage container is a column rather than a pair, and it is the lightest set here at 0.66 pounds, which matters when you are lifting three trays off to reach the bottom one.
PHINOX and QUELIEN use almost identical wording, that the tray can be stacked and stored to save space, and neither goes further. Both are two tray sets. Neither says whether the trays stack with the lids on, which is the practical question, because a lid that has to come off first turns a stack into three separate objects on a freezer shelf.
Why a Rigid Frame Matters to a Stack
What Brigii Says About Flimsy Trays
Brigii is the only listing in the pool that explains why construction and stacking are connected. It describes a hybrid: a plastic frame with a silicone bottom, and states that the rigid frame holds its shape for secure stacking while the flexible silicone bottom releases cubes with a press. It then contrasts that with trays it calls flimsy, which is a comparison with an unnamed alternative rather than a measurement.
The argument holds up on its own terms. A tray that flexes cannot carry the weight of another full tray without spilling, and a full 28 cube tray of water is heavy before it freezes. Brigii’s own published weight of 1.59 pounds for the set is the second highest here, which is consistent with a rigid frame rather than a silicone sheet.
Silicone, PP and TPR
DOQAUS takes the opposite approach with four trays made of food grade silicone and a flexible bottom you push from below. That is the easiest release on this page and the least rigid material in a stack, and the listing does not reconcile the two. PHINOX names food grade PP, a rigid plastic, and QUELIEN names only food grade material with a no stick surface.
GORILLA GRIP is a rigid tray with soft touch TPR comfort grips for twisting, and it is the only one that releases ice by twist rather than by press. A twist release needs the tray in your hands, which is a different habit from pressing a lid down over a bin, and it means the tray does not need to sit on the bin at all to work.
What a Stack Costs When You Want Ice
Release Methods and Where the Lid Goes
Three of the five release ice by pressing the lid: Brigii uses built in prongs in the lid, PHINOX asks for both hands on the middle of the lid, and QUELIEN describes pressing the middle of the lid with the tray upside down on the bin. In all three the lid is a tool as well as a cover, so it cannot be left in a drawer, and it is the part of the set that has to survive being pushed on.
DOQAUS releases by pushing the flexible bottom from underneath, and GORILLA GRIP by twisting. Those two leave the lid as nothing but a lid. That is a genuine advantage in a stacked column, because you can pull one tray out and empty it without unstacking anything or hunting for the right lid among four identical ones.
Lids, Seals and the Dishwasher Split
The pool splits cleanly on washing. GORILLA GRIP states dishwasher safe and adds that the trays are third party tested, BPA free and stain resistant. DOQAUS states the whole set is top rack dishwasher safe. PHINOX states in capitals that the tray is not dishwasher safe, and QUELIEN says plainly not to use a dishwasher and to wash by hand.
Brigii says nothing either way, naming only food grade BPA free materials. That leaves two of five that can go in a machine, two that explicitly cannot, and one unknown. PHINOX and QUELIEN both describe an airtight lid on a waterproof platform, which is the tightest seal claim here and also the design most likely to trap water where hand washing has to reach.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
The freezer with one shelf to spare. GORILLA GRIP nests both trays on top of the bin, so the set is one footprint at 10.7 by 6.6 inches. Six pieces, 56 cubes at 28 per tray, cubes stated at 1.3 by 1.3 by 1 inches, and it is dishwasher safe.
The freezer where things get stacked on things. Brigii is the one set that explains its own rigidity, a plastic frame with a silicone bottom stated to hold shape for secure stacking. It publishes 9.05 by 5.51 by 3.94 inches and a 1 inch cube.
The small apartment or RV freezer. DOQAUS runs four silicone trays into a column around a central container, at 0.66 pounds, the lightest set here, and states top rack dishwasher safe. It publishes no cube count, which is the gap you accept for the tray count.
The freezer with a narrow gap. PHINOX publishes 7.08 by 3.94 by 4.37 inches, the smallest stated footprint of the five, with 56 cubes across two trays and a scoop, lid and pillar plate. It must be washed by hand, and the listing says so in capitals.
The cook who wants the limits written down. QUELIEN is the only listing here that publishes a temperature range, stating the trays are safe from minus 4 to 140 degrees F, and it claims 64 cubes, the most on this page. It also says clearly not to put it in a dishwasher.
What We Could Not Verify
These are the figures and statements we went looking for in the manufacturer listings and could not find. Nothing below was estimated, and nothing on this page was measured by us.
- Whether the trays on any of these sets stack with the lids fitted, which is what decides how a stack behaves in practice.
- How many trays high any set is rated to stack, which no listing states even where four trays are supplied.
- A cube count or cube size for the DOQAUS set, which publishes four trays and no capacity at all.
- A stated overall size for the QUELIEN set, whose only published figures are its carton.
- Which of the three published numbers is the height on the Brigii and PHINOX sets, since each states the same figures in a different order from its own fields.
- Whether the Brigii set can go in a dishwasher, which its listing never addresses either way.