Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Preserving

Best Pickling Jars With a Food Safe Silicone Seal

The deciding specification is what each listing says about its silicone part: where it sits, how thick it is, whether a spare arrives with it, and what temperature it is rated for.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

Five pickling jars compared on the silicone component each maker publishes, rather than on the glass around it.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. 17oz Glass Jars with Airtight Lids 3 Pack
    Best for a published gasket thickness

    17oz Glass Jars with Airtight Lids 3 Pack

    IUNNUI publishes 2.8mm silicone gaskets under upgraded stainless clamps on three 17oz jars, and states fridge safe but not microwave safe.

    • IUNNUI
    • 17oz*3-Wide Mouth
    • 0.99 lb
  2. 1 Gallon Glass Jars with Airtight Lid
    Best for silicone in two places at once

    1 Gallon Glass Jars with Airtight Lid

    Folinstall publishes a food-grade silicone inner seal inside a stainless lid and a non-slip silicone base, on a 1 gallon jar with a 4.3 inch mouth.

    • Folinstall
    • 1 Gallon
    • Weight not listed
  3. 1 Gallon Glass Jar with Airtight Lid
    Best for a spare seal in the box

    1 Gallon Glass Jar with Airtight Lid

    This Folinstall jar publishes a food-grade seal plus an extra free silicone gasket, usable as an alternative or stacked with the first.

    • Folinstall
    • 1 Gallon
    • 1 lb
  4. Dwbligt 2 Pack Wide Mouth Mason Jars
    Best for carrying a full gallon

    Dwbligt 2 Pack Wide Mouth Mason Jars

    Dwbligt publishes a fresh-lock silicone gasket in a screw lid and a silicone protective cover under the base, with a stainless handle.

    • Dwbligt
    • 1 Gallon, 2 Pack, Square1
    • 7.1 lb
  5. KILNER Fermentation Set
    Best for silicone that does the fermenting

    KILNER Fermentation Set

    Kilner publishes a silicone lid with an air lock to release gases and keep air out, on a 3 liter jar with ceramic weights included.

    • Kilner
    • 3 liters
    • 3.9 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
17oz Glass Jars with Airtight Lids 3 Pack IUNNUI 17oz*3-Wide Mouth 0.99 lb Best for a published gasket thickness
1 Gallon Glass Jars with Airtight Lid Folinstall 1 Gallon not published Best for silicone in two places at once
1 Gallon Glass Jar with Airtight Lid Folinstall 1 Gallon 1 lb Best for a spare seal in the box
Dwbligt 2 Pack Wide Mouth Mason Jars Dwbligt 1 Gallon, 2 Pack, Square1 7.1 lb Best for carrying a full gallon
KILNER Fermentation Set Kilner 3 liters 3.9 lb Best for silicone that does the fermenting

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for a published gasket thickness

17oz Glass Jars with Airtight Lids 3 Pack

IUNNUI publishes 2.8mm silicone gaskets under upgraded stainless clamps on three 17oz jars, and states fridge safe but not microwave safe.

  • For it
  • Publishes a silicone gasket thickness of 2.8mm, the only such figure in this group
  • Upgraded stainless steel clamps are published as the closure
  • States fridge safe and states plainly that it is not microwave safe
  • Eight chalkboard labels, a chalk marker and a cleaning brush are published as included
  • Against it
  • Published 17oz per jar is small for pickling anything whole
  • No dimensions are published in any field
  • No dishwasher instruction is published, only that cleaning is effortless
2 Best for silicone in two places at once

1 Gallon Glass Jars with Airtight Lid

Folinstall publishes a food-grade silicone inner seal inside a stainless lid and a non-slip silicone base, on a 1 gallon jar with a 4.3 inch mouth.

  • For it
  • Publishes two separate silicone parts: a food-grade inner seal and a non-slip base
  • Maker states the inner seal reduces direct food contact with plastic
  • Published 4.3 inch wide mouth with oz and ml markings printed on the glass
  • Removable stainless steel handle is published, and the jar measures 5.9 by 5.9 by 9 inches
  • Against it
  • No weight is published in any field or bullet
  • No washing instruction is published beyond the wide mouth being easy to clean
  • No temperature guidance is published at all
3 Best for a spare seal in the box

1 Gallon Glass Jar with Airtight Lid

This Folinstall jar publishes a food-grade seal plus an extra free silicone gasket, usable as an alternative or stacked with the first.

  • For it
  • An extra free silicone gasket is published as included, as an alternative or stacked with the first
  • Published 128 oz capacity, which the same bullet also gives as 3800 ml
  • Stated dishwasher safe, and washable in warm water with a damp cloth
  • Published 3.3 inch mouth with a concave neck the maker says prevents spilling
  • Against it
  • The weight field gives 1 lb, which cannot be a 128 oz glass jar, so it is set aside here
  • The maker calls the seal a silica gel seal in one bullet and silicone in the next
  • No temperature guidance is published

Who should skip this: Skip this if counter or storage space is tight: it has the largest published footprint of the five, 11.9 by 7.7 inches.

4 Best for carrying a full gallon

Dwbligt 2 Pack Wide Mouth Mason Jars

Dwbligt publishes a fresh-lock silicone gasket in a screw lid and a silicone protective cover under the base, with a stainless handle.

  • For it
  • Publishes a fresh-lock silicone gasket in a screw lid and an upgraded silicone protective cover under the base
  • Published 1 gallon capacity, also given as 3785 ml, in a two pack
  • Easy-attach stainless steel handle is published for carrying it full
  • Published 4.3 inch wide opening for filling, scooping and cleaning
  • Against it
  • No dimensions are published in any field
  • No washing instruction is published at all
  • Published weight of 7.1 lb for two jars is the heaviest purchase here

Who should skip this: Skip this if weight matters: at 7.1 lb it is the heaviest of the five published weights.

5 Best for silicone that does the fermenting

KILNER Fermentation Set

Kilner publishes a silicone lid with an air lock to release gases and keep air out, on a 3 liter jar with ceramic weights included.

  • For it
  • The silicone part is the whole lid, with an air lock published to release gases and prevent air entry
  • Published 3 liter capacity, stated as suited to fermenting large batches
  • Ceramic weights are published as included to keep contents submerged
  • A recipe and instruction booklet is published as part of the set
  • Against it
  • Only one jar arrives, where three of the others are multi-packs
  • No mouth opening figure is published
  • No washing or temperature instruction is published anywhere

Our verdict

All five publish a silicone part and they are not the same part. IUNNUI publishes 2.8mm silicone gaskets under stainless clamps, the only thickness figure here. Folinstall publishes a silicone inner seal plus a non-slip silicone base. The second Folinstall jar includes a free spare gasket. Dwbligt publishes a gasket and a silicone protective cover. Kilner publishes a silicone lid with an air lock built into it.

“The glass is not what fails. The seal is.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Where the silicone sits IUNNUI and Dwbligt put it in the lid as a gasket. Folinstall puts it in the lid and under the base. Kilner makes the entire lid out of it.
Thickness published Only IUNNUI, at 2.8mm. The other four name the material and the part but publish no figure for the silicone itself.
Spares and extras One Folinstall jar includes a free spare gasket. Kilner includes ceramic weights and a booklet. IUNNUI includes labels, a marker and a brush.
Temperature guidance Only IUNNUI publishes any, stating fridge safe and not microwave safe. The other four publish nothing about heat or cold.
Capacity published IUNNUI publishes 17oz per jar. Kilner publishes 3 liters. The two gallon jars publish 3785 ml and 3800 ml for the same nominal size.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 30% Where the silicone sitsThe page is about the silicone, and these five put it in four different places, which changes what it is asked to do.
  2. 25% Thickness publishedOne maker publishes a figure and four do not, which is the difference between a specification and a word.
  3. 20% Spare seal includedA gasket is the part that perishes first, and only one listing here sends a second one.
  4. 15% Temperature guidancePickling means hot brine, and only one of these five says anything about temperature in either direction.
  5. 10% Capacity publishedEveryone publishes one, so it separates the group least, but it still decides what fits.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

All five publish a silicone part, and it is a different part on each one. IUNNUI publishes 2.8mm gaskets under stainless clamps. Folinstall publishes a food-grade silicone inner seal in a stainless lid plus a non-slip silicone base. The second Folinstall jar publishes a seal and a free spare gasket. Dwbligt publishes a gasket plus a protective base cover. Kilner’s entire lid is silicone.

Only one figure for the silicone itself exists in this group, and it is IUNNUI’s 2.8mm. Everything else is a material name and a location. Capacities run from three 17oz jars through a 3 liter fermenter to two gallon jars, one published as 3785 ml and the other as 3800 ml, and the mouth openings that are published are 4.3 and 3.3 inches.

Specification IUNNUI Folinstall 1 gallon Folinstall 128 oz Dwbligt Kilner
Where the silicone sits Gasket under a clamp lid Inner seal in the lid Seal in a hinged lid Gasket in a screw lid The whole lid
Thickness published 2.8mm not published not published not published not published
Second silicone part not published Non-slip base not published Protective base cover not published
Spare seal included not published not published One extra gasket, free not published not published
Temperature guidance Fridge safe, not microwave safe not published not published not published not published
Capacity published 17 oz each, three jars 1 gallon, two jars 128 oz, or 3800 ml 1 gallon, or 3785 ml, two jars 3 liters
Mouth opening not published 4.3 in 3.3 in 4.3 in not published
Published weight 0.99 lb not published 1 lb, set aside below 7.1 lb 3.9 lb
Published size not published 5.9 x 5.9 x 9 in 7.7 x 11.9 x 7.4 in not published 5 x 5 x 11 in
Closure Stainless clamps Stainless screw lid Hinged lid Screw lid Silicone lid with air lock
Washing published Easy to clean, wide mouth Wide mouth, easy cleaning Dishwasher safe not published not published
Also in the box Eight labels, marker, brush Removable steel handle One spare gasket Steel handle and base cover Ceramic weights and a booklet

One figure has been set aside rather than used. The Folinstall 128 oz listing carries a weight field of 1 lb, and a glass jar holding 3800 ml cannot weigh that. The figure is left in the table marked for what it is and no comparison on this page rests on it. Nothing else in these five listings contradicts itself, which is unusual for a pool this size.

What the Silicone Is Actually Doing

A gasket, a base, or the whole lid

Four of these five use silicone the ordinary way, as a compressible ring that the lid presses onto the glass. IUNNUI puts it under stainless clamps, Dwbligt under a screw lid, and the two Folinstall jars inside a stainless lid and a hinged lid respectively. In every case the silicone is the part doing the sealing and the metal is just the clamp.

Kilner is the exception and the most interesting case here. Its entire lid is silicone, with an air lock built into it to release fermentation gases while preventing air from entering. That is silicone as a structural component rather than a gasket, and it is the only pick on this page where the material does a job beyond sealing.

Silicone used away from the lid

Two picks publish a second silicone part that has nothing to do with the seal. Folinstall publishes a protective non-slip silicone base stated to keep the jar stable and prevent slipping and scratches. Dwbligt publishes an upgraded silicone protective cover for the same purpose, naming non-slip and non-scratch grip on any countertop.

On a gallon jar that is a sensible place to put rubber, because a full one is heavy and glass on stone is a bad combination. Both makers pair that cover with a stainless steel handle for carrying, so the two features are part of one argument about moving a heavy jar safely rather than about food contact.

The Gasket as a Wear Part

The only spare on the page

A silicone gasket is the part of a preserving jar that fails. It compresses, it hardens, it takes on the smell of whatever was last in there, and eventually it stops sealing. Exactly one listing in this group has thought about that: the Folinstall 128 oz jar states an extra free silicone gasket is included, usable as an alternative or stacked with the first.

That stacking note is worth reading twice, because it suggests the two can be used together to take up slack in an older seal. None of the five publishes a way to buy further gaskets, a part number, or an expected life, so after the spare is used the jar is only as good as its remaining seal.

Thickness as the one comparable figure

IUNNUI publishes 2.8mm gaskets, and it is the only number for a silicone part anywhere on this page. A thicker gasket has more material to compress, which generally means more tolerance for an uneven rim and more to lose before the seal fails. Without the other four publishing a figure, that is a reason to prefer IUNNUI rather than a proof of anything.

What none of the five publishes is hardness, grade or a temperature rating for the silicone. Food-grade is the only quality claim made, by Folinstall twice and by Dwbligt. For a page asked specifically about food-safe silicone, that is the honest ceiling of what these listings support.

Jars Around the Seal

Capacity and what each is for

The capacities split this group by use. IUNNUI publishes three 17oz jars, which suits jams, chopped vegetables and small batches rather than whole cucumbers. Kilner publishes a single 3 liter jar described as suited to fermenting large batches and then decanting into smaller jars, which is a workflow rather than a container.

The two gallon jars are the bulk end. Dwbligt publishes 1 gallon or 3785 ml in a two pack and names large-batch fermenting and sun tea. Folinstall publishes 128 oz or 3800 ml and names kombucha, canning and pickling. The second Folinstall jar publishes 1 gallon in a two pack with figures of 5.9 by 5.9 by 9 inches.

Getting things in and out

Three publish a mouth opening. Folinstall publishes an extra-wide 4.3 inch opening on its gallon jar and Dwbligt publishes 4.3 inches as well, both naming filling, scooping and cleaning as the reasons. The Folinstall 128 oz jar publishes a 3.3 inch mouth with a concave neck the maker says prevents spilling when filling with preserves.

IUNNUI and Kilner publish no opening figure. IUNNUI describes a wide-mouth design for scooping without spills and Kilner says nothing at all about its opening, which on a fermenting jar that needs ceramic weights lowered into it is the one figure a buyer would want. Neither gap can be filled from these listings.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

Preserver who wants a figure, not a word. IUNNUI publishes 2.8mm silicone gaskets under stainless clamps on three 17oz jars, states fridge safe and not microwave safe, and includes eight labels, a marker and a brush.

Preserver lifting a full gallon off a stone counter. Folinstall publishes a food-grade silicone inner seal, a non-slip silicone base, a removable stainless handle and a 4.3 inch mouth, at 5.9 by 5.9 by 9 inches.

Preserver who expects the seal to wear out. The Folinstall 128 oz jar publishes a free spare silicone gasket, a 3.3 inch mouth with a concave neck, 3800 ml of capacity and a dishwasher instruction.

Preserver filling two gallon jars at a time. Dwbligt publishes a fresh-lock silicone gasket, a silicone protective cover under the base, a stainless handle and a 4.3 inch opening, at 3785 ml per jar.

Preserver fermenting rather than storing. Kilner publishes a silicone lid with a built-in air lock, 3 liters of capacity, ceramic weights to keep contents submerged and a recipe booklet, at 3.9 lb.

What We Could Not Verify

These are the things a question about food-safe silicone should be able to settle, and these listings do not settle them. Nothing has been filled in from outside the fact sheet.

  • Four of the five publish no thickness, hardness or grade for the silicone, only that it is food-grade.
  • No pick publishes a temperature rating for its silicone part, so hot brine is nowhere addressed.
  • No pick publishes a replacement route for the gasket once it perishes.
  • The Folinstall 128 oz listing carries a 1 lb weight field that cannot describe a 3800 ml glass jar.
  • No pick publishes how long the seal lasts or how many cycles it survives.
  • IUNNUI and Kilner publish no mouth opening figure, which on a fermenting jar is the figure that matters.

Frequently asked questions

Which of these publishes an actual figure for the silicone?+

Only IUNNUI, which states 2.8mm silicone gaskets under upgraded stainless steel clamps. That is the single measurement of a silicone part anywhere in this group. The other four name the material and say where it sits, which is useful but not comparable. Folinstall calls its seal food-grade silicone, Dwbligt calls it a fresh-lock silicone gasket and Kilner simply calls the lid silicone.

Does any jar come with a spare seal?+

One does. The Folinstall 128 oz jar states that an extra free silicone gasket is included inside, and that it can be used as an alternative to the fitted seal or stacked together with it. That is the only spare gasket published on this page, and since a gasket is the part that hardens and cracks first, it is a genuine advantage over the other four.

Can any of these take hot brine?+

Nothing here says so. IUNNUI is the only pick that publishes any temperature guidance at all, and it is about the other end: fridge safe, and not microwave safe. The other four publish no heat statement, no cold statement and no rating for the silicone. Pickling usually means pouring warm brine into glass, and these listings leave that entirely unaddressed.

How many silicone parts does each jar actually have?+

Two of them have more than one. Folinstall publishes a silicone inner seal in the lid and a separate non-slip silicone base to stop the jar sliding and scratching. Dwbligt publishes a gasket in the screw lid and an upgraded silicone protective cover under the jar for the same reason. IUNNUI and the second Folinstall jar publish a gasket only. Kilner's lid is itself silicone.

What capacity does each one publish?+

IUNNUI publishes three jars at 17oz each. Kilner publishes a single 3 liter fermenting jar. The two gallon jars publish the same nominal size in different metric figures, Dwbligt stating 1 gallon or 3785 ml and Folinstall stating 128 oz or 3800 ml. The second Folinstall jar publishes 1 gallon in a two pack with dimensions of 5.9 by 5.9 by 9 inches.

Which of these is actually built for fermenting?+

Kilner, and it is the only one that publishes the hardware for it. The silicone lid carries an air lock stated to release gases and prevent air entry, and ceramic weights are included to keep the contents submerged. Dwbligt names fermentation as a use and states the gasket protects ferments, but publishes no air lock and no weights. The rest are storage jars that can be used for pickling.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.