How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Six listings sit on the fact sheet and one is not on this page. RICCLE describes its pan in almost the same words as the Fimary, with the same metal reinforced silicone frame and the same published 15.3 by 9.2 inches, so putting both here would compare one design with itself. Its cleaning bullet also ends with the phrase effortless cleaning printed twice in a row.
What decides this page is what each maker says about washing, and only two of these five say anything at all. CAKETIME names a dishwasher as allowed. Bake Choice names one and recommends avoiding it. Fimary, Wilton and Aybloom publish no washing method, and Aybloom publishes no feature bullets of any kind, so nothing at all is known about caring for it.
Two rows here are not what they look like. CAKETIME’s figures sit in a package row because its title says 1 Pack, which the data reads as a multipack, and 13 by 9.4 by 0.7 inches is a single pan rather than a carton. Bake Choice publishes fields of 7.87 by 7.87 by 1.97 in, which cannot be a 24 cup mini pan, so its own sentence, 14.8 by 10 by 0.86 inches, is what the table uses instead.
What Each Maker Says About Washing
One Pan Where the Dishwasher Is Listed as a Feature
CAKETIME puts the dishwasher in the same list as the oven. Its high temperature bullet states the pan is safe for use in oven, microwave, dishwasher, fridge and freezer, with a heat range of -104 to 446 degrees Fahrenheit, and a separate bullet says the surface is easy to release and clean and that the pan is impermeable. Silicone is the reason all of that can be true at once.
It also makes a claim nothing else here makes: that the silicone does not stain food, dishes or cookware, and leaves no aftertaste. On a mini pan used for egg bites and chocolate as often as for cake, that is the cleaning claim that matters most. The trade is stated in the same listing: the pan is flexible, so it needs a metal tray underneath before it is filled.
One Pan That Asks You Not To
Bake Choice publishes two cleaning sentences and they point in slightly different directions. One bullet says to wash the pan with warm soapy water before the first use and after each use, and calls the smooth nonstick surface easy to clean. Another recommends hand washing with a soft sponge and states that avoiding the dishwasher helps preserve the coating and keep the baking even.
That is the honest answer for a coated steel pan and almost nobody prints it. It also means the 200 cupcake liners that arrive with the pan are doing real work, because a liner is what keeps batter off the coating in the first place. Bake Choice publishes 1.19 lb, the heaviest pan on this page, and its own size sentence rather than trusting its fields.
The Three That Say Nothing
Silicone With No Instruction At All
Fimary is the odd one. It is food grade silicone on a metal reinforced frame, rated to 450 F or 232 C, stated to go from freezer straight to oven, and stated to release without greasing or spray. Every one of those facts points at a pan that would survive a dishwasher, and the listing never says the word once, in either direction.
Its published cup is identical to the CAKETIME cup, at 1.8 inches across the top and 0.7 inches deep, and its pan is published at 15.3 by 9.2 inches. So two pans in this pool have the same cups, the same material and the same claim of easy release, and only one of them tells you how to wash it. Nothing in the Fimary listing fills that gap.
A Coated Steel Pan and a Pan With No Bullets
Wilton publishes the most about its coating and nothing about washing it. The pan is alloy steel, stated made without PFAS, with a premium easy release coating and extended handles, oven safe up to 450 F, and published at 16 inches long, 10 inches wide and 1 inch deep in the maker’s own sentence. Whether that coating tolerates a dishwasher is simply not addressed.
Aybloom publishes no feature text whatsoever. Its title says nonstick, 24 cups, extended handles and carbon steel, and that is the entire listing. Its dimension fields read 0.9 by 14.8 by 10.12 inches with nothing to say which figure is which, and it publishes 0.6 lb. There is no washing statement to read because there is nothing to read.
What the Material Decides on Its Own
Silicone Does Not Have a Coating to Lose
The split in this pool runs down the material, not down the wording. CAKETIME and Fimary are silicone, so the release surface is the material itself and there is no layer to strip off. That is why CAKETIME can list a dishwasher as a feature and why the absence of a statement on the Fimary is a documentation problem rather than a real risk.
Bake Choice, Wilton and Aybloom are coated steel, where the release surface is a layer applied to the metal and a dishwasher cycle is the standard way of shortening its life. Bake Choice says so. Wilton and Aybloom do not, and a buyer who treats a coated pan the way the CAKETIME listing permits will find out the difference over a few months.
What Each One Costs You in Handling Instead
Easier washing is paid for somewhere. CAKETIME states that because the pan is silicone and flexible, it must be put on a metal tray or cookie sheet before being filled, which is an extra object in the process every time. Fimary answers the same problem with a metal reinforced frame, which is why it publishes 0.74 lb against the CAKETIME 0.41 lb.
The steel pans need no support and give you a coating to protect instead. Wilton publishes 1 lb and extended handles. Bake Choice publishes 1.19 lb and supplies 200 liners. Aybloom publishes 0.6 lb, which is lighter than either silicone pan with a frame and lighter than both steel pans, and publishes nothing to explain how.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
A pan that goes in the dishwasher without an argument. CAKETIME, food safe silicone rated -104 to 446 degrees Fahrenheit and listed as dishwasher safe, with 24 cups at 1.8 in across and 0.7 in deep, each holding 0.6 oz, at 0.41 lb.
Coated steel with the care instruction printed. Bake Choice, a 24 cup pan published at 14.8 by 10 by 0.86 inches and 1.19 lb, with 200 cupcake liners, washed in warm soapy water by hand with a soft sponge rather than in a machine.
Silicone with a frame you can lift full. Fimary, food grade silicone on a metal reinforced frame rated to 450 F or 232 C, published at 15.3 by 9.2 inches and 0.74 lb, with the same 1.8 in cups at 0.7 in deep. It publishes no washing method.
A coating with a stated chemistry. Wilton, alloy steel stated made without PFAS, with a premium easy release coating, extended handles and an oven rating of 450 F, published at 16 by 10 by 1 inches and 1 lb. Washing is not addressed anywhere.
The lightest pan here, and the least documented. Aybloom, 24 cups of nonstick carbon steel with extended handles at 0.6 lb. Its listing carries no feature text at all, so the coating, the temperature limit and the washing method are all unknown.
What We Could Not Verify
Every figure above comes from the maker’s own listing text. These are the things we went looking for and could not source in any of them.
- Aybloom publishes no feature text of any kind, so its coating, its temperature limit and its washing method are all unstated.
- Fimary is silicone with a non stick claim and a 450 F rating and never mentions a dishwasher in either direction.
- Wilton states its coating is made without PFAS and never says whether that coating tolerates a dishwasher.
- Only CAKETIME publishes a cup capacity, at 0.6 oz, so what the other four hold per cup cannot be compared.
- Three of the five publish no cup diameter and no cup depth, so the mini in mini muffin is unquantified on those three.
- Bake Choice publishes dimension fields of 7.87 by 7.87 by 1.97 in that cannot describe a 24 cup pan, and never explains them.