Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Baking

Best Banneton Bowl Liners for Proofing Many Portions at Once

The deciding specification is how many portions one purchase proofs at the same time and the diameter each one is stated to fit, because an evening of individual bases needs several small vessels rather than one large basket.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

I compared the number of liners or baskets in each purchase, the stated diameter and depth of each, the material, the published weights and what each listing says about storing and cleaning them, across five banneton liner sets using only each maker's own published text.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. 12-Pack Mini Banneton 5" Round Proofing Basket w/Lin...
    Best for proofing a dozen small portions

    12-Pack Mini Banneton 5" Round Proofing Basket w/Lin...

    Twelve round sugarcane pulp baskets with twelve linen liners, each stated at 5 inches in diameter and 2.7 inches deep for mini boules, dinner rolls and burger buns, with a rigid design the maker states nests together to save counter and storage space. No weight is published for any part of the set.

    • grandtobuy
    • 13cm/5inch
    • Weight not listed
  2. Ziliny 6 Pcs Banneton Bread Proofing Baskets for Sou...
    Best for six rattan baskets and a scraper

    Ziliny 6 Pcs Banneton Bread Proofing Baskets for Sou...

    Six rattan cane proofing baskets with six cloth liners and included scrapers, stated at about 9 by 3 inches, which the same sentence also gives as 23 by 8.5 cm, publishing 2.6 pounds for the whole set. The listing states the scrapers are what makes cleaning the baskets easy.

    • Ziliny
    • 9 Inch
    • 2.6 lb
  3. Honeydak 4 Pcs Silicone Bread Proofing Baskets Oval ...
    Best for folding the baskets away

    Honeydak 4 Pcs Silicone Bread Proofing Baskets Oval ...

    Four collapsible silicone oval baskets in pink, green, purple and yellow, each with a liner, stated to measure 10 by 1.3 inches when folded and rated from minus 100°F to 450°F, with the refrigerator, dishwasher, microwave and oven all named, publishing 2.33 pounds.

    • Honeydak
    • 10.24 x 5.91 x 3.35 inches
    • 2.33 lb
  4. 100Pcs Disposable Banneton Liner & Bread Proofing Ba...
    Best for skipping the laundry

    100Pcs Disposable Banneton Liner & Bread Proofing Ba...

    One hundred non-woven liners with an elastic edge the maker states stretches to 21 inches, supplied in a storage bag with a hang tie, described as disposable in the title and as washable and reusable in the first feature, publishing 0.69 pounds for the pack.

    • ZHIVEZEN
    • 0.69 lb
  5. 3 Pack Proofing Basket Liner
    Best for bannetons you already own

    3 Pack Proofing Basket Liner

    Three round cotton and linen blend liners stated at 9 inches with elastic edges for standard bannetons, machine washable and described as tightly woven to stop dough clinging, publishing 0.09 pounds and no thickness or folded figure for the cloth.

    • Thrymme
    • 9 inches
    • 0.09 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
12-Pack Mini Banneton 5" Round Proofing Basket w/Lin... grandtobuy 13cm/5inch not published Best for proofing a dozen small portions
Ziliny 6 Pcs Banneton Bread Proofing Baskets for Sou... Ziliny 9 Inch 2.6 lb Best for six rattan baskets and a scraper
Honeydak 4 Pcs Silicone Bread Proofing Baskets Oval ... Honeydak 10.24 x 5.91 x 3.35 inches 2.33 lb Best for folding the baskets away
100Pcs Disposable Banneton Liner & Bread Proofing Ba... ZHIVEZEN not published 0.69 lb Best for skipping the laundry
3 Pack Proofing Basket Liner Thrymme 9 inches 0.09 lb Best for bannetons you already own

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for proofing a dozen small portions

12-Pack Mini Banneton 5" Round Proofing Basket w/Lin...

Twelve round sugarcane pulp baskets with twelve linen liners, each stated at 5 inches in diameter and 2.7 inches deep for mini boules, dinner rolls and burger buns, with a rigid design the maker states nests together to save counter and storage space. No weight is published for any part of the set.

  • For it
  • Twelve baskets and twelve linen liners in one purchase
  • States 5 inches in diameter and 2.7 inches deep, a single portion
  • Names mini boules, dinner rolls and burger buns as the intended loaf
  • States the rigid baskets nest together to save counter and storage space
  • Against it
  • Publishes no weight for a basket or for the set
  • Names no washing or wiping step for the pulp baskets
  • Sugarcane pulp is the only material here with no stated reuse life
2 Best for six rattan baskets and a scraper

Ziliny 6 Pcs Banneton Bread Proofing Baskets for Sou...

Six rattan cane proofing baskets with six cloth liners and included scrapers, stated at about 9 by 3 inches, which the same sentence also gives as 23 by 8.5 cm, publishing 2.6 pounds for the whole set. The listing states the scrapers are what makes cleaning the baskets easy.

  • For it
  • Six rattan baskets, six cloth liners and scrapers in one purchase
  • The only listing here that supplies a cleaning tool
  • Publishes 2.6 pounds, so the shipping mass of six baskets is known
  • States the rattan cane finish is durable and splinter free in use
  • Against it
  • Its own size sentence gives 9 by 3 inches and 23 by 8.5 cm, which disagree
  • Publishes no folded or stacked size for six rigid baskets
  • Nine inches is a boule vessel, and no smaller size is offered
3 Best for folding the baskets away

Honeydak 4 Pcs Silicone Bread Proofing Baskets Oval ...

Four collapsible silicone oval baskets in pink, green, purple and yellow, each with a liner, stated to measure 10 by 1.3 inches when folded and rated from minus 100°F to 450°F, with the refrigerator, dishwasher, microwave and oven all named, publishing 2.33 pounds.

  • For it
  • States the baskets fold to 10 by 1.3 inches for storage
  • Rated from minus 100°F to 450°F, the only temperature range published here
  • Refrigerator, dishwasher, microwave and oven all named as safe
  • Four baskets, each supplied with its own liner
  • Against it
  • Its stated cold limit in Fahrenheit and in Celsius do not match
  • The published dimension triple matches one oval basket, not four
  • Oval at 10 inches, so it holds a long portion rather than a round one

Who should skip this: Skip this if counter or storage space is tight: it has the largest published footprint of the five, 10.24 by 5.91 inches.

4 Best for skipping the laundry

100Pcs Disposable Banneton Liner & Bread Proofing Ba...

One hundred non-woven liners with an elastic edge the maker states stretches to 21 inches, supplied in a storage bag with a hang tie, described as disposable in the title and as washable and reusable in the first feature, publishing 0.69 pounds for the pack.

  • For it
  • One hundred liners, the largest count among these five
  • States the elastic edge stretches to 21 inches, so any basket here is covered
  • Supplied in a storage bag with a hang tie, the only bag published here
  • States the liner works as a proofing cover as well as a basket liner
  • Against it
  • Calls the same liner disposable in the title and reusable in the first feature
  • Publishes no diameter, only the stretched maximum
  • Supplies no basket, so it is useless on its own
5 Best for bannetons you already own

3 Pack Proofing Basket Liner

Three round cotton and linen blend liners stated at 9 inches with elastic edges for standard bannetons, machine washable and described as tightly woven to stop dough clinging, publishing 0.09 pounds and no thickness or folded figure for the cloth.

  • For it
  • Publishes 0.09 pounds, the lightest of the four weights published here
  • States elastic edges sized for 9 inch bannetons specifically
  • Machine washable, and the fabric blend is named as cotton and linen
  • States the weave is tight enough to keep the spiral pattern intact
  • Against it
  • Three liners is the smallest count here, so an evening of portions needs more
  • Publishes no thickness and no folded size, only the 9 inch diameter
  • Supplies no basket and no cover

Our verdict

grandtobuy publishes twelve baskets at 5 inches across and 2.7 inches deep, the only listing here sized for a single small portion. Ziliny publishes six rattan baskets with six cloth liners and scrapers at 9 inches. Honeydak publishes four silicone baskets that fold to 10 by 1.3 inches. ZHIVEZEN publishes one hundred disposable liners stretching to 21 inches. Thrymme publishes three 9 inch cotton liners at 0.09 pounds.

“Counts here run from three liners to one hundred.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Portions per purchase Twelve, six, four, three, and one hundred liners with no basket. The count is the one specification all five of these listings publish clearly.
How small a portion gets One listing states 5 inches across and 2.7 inches deep. The rest state 9 or 10 inches, which is a loaf rather than a single portion.
Washed or thrown away Three sets are machine washable, one supplies scrapers, and one calls itself disposable in the title and reusable in its first feature.
What happens after proofing Only the silicone set names the refrigerator, the oven and a temperature range. The pulp and rattan baskets publish nothing about heat at all.
Nobody mentions pizza Not one of the sixteen listings on this sheet names pizza or a dough ball. The nearest is a set naming mini boules, dinner rolls and burger buns.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 30% How many portions one purchase proofs at onceThis is what an evening of individual bases actually asks. grandtobuy publishes twelve baskets and twelve liners, Ziliny six baskets and six liners, Honeydak four baskets each with a liner, Thrymme three liners, and ZHIVEZEN one hundred liners with no basket at all. Those counts are the only figure every one of these five states without ambiguity.
  2. 25% How small a single portion can beA round individual base is far smaller than a boule, and only grandtobuy publishes a basket for one: 5 inches in diameter and 2.7 inches deep, named for mini boules, dinner rolls and burger buns. Ziliny and Thrymme state 9 inches, Honeydak 10 inches on an oval, and ZHIVEZEN states only that its edge stretches to 21 inches.
  3. 20% Whether a basket arrives or only clothThree of the five supply the vessel as well as the lining. grandtobuy supplies twelve sugarcane pulp baskets, Ziliny six rattan cane baskets and Honeydak four silicone ones. ZHIVEZEN and Thrymme supply liners only, which is the right purchase if bannetons are already in the cupboard and the wrong one if they are not.
  4. 15% What happens to the set afterwardsThrymme and Ziliny state machine washing, Ziliny adds scrapers for the baskets, and Honeydak states a shake of excess flour then a stiff brush once any stuck dough has dried. ZHIVEZEN contradicts itself, calling the liner disposable in its title and washable and reusable in its first feature. grandtobuy names no washing step at all, and uses the word clean only of the pulp surface.
  5. 10% Whether anything else is measuredZiliny publishes 2.6 pounds, Honeydak 2.33 and ZHIVEZEN 0.69, all covering a whole multipack. Thrymme publishes 0.09 pounds for three liners and grandtobuy publishes no weight of any kind. Honeydak alone publishes a temperature range, and its two stated cold limits do not convert to each other.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

An evening of individual bases asks one question of a proofing set: how many portions can rise at the same time. The counts here are twelve baskets with twelve liners from grandtobuy, six baskets with six liners from Ziliny, four silicone baskets each with a liner from Honeydak, three cloth liners from Thrymme, and one hundred non-woven liners from ZHIVEZEN with no basket at all.

The second question is how small each vessel gets. grandtobuy is alone in publishing a figure for a single portion, at 5 inches in diameter and 2.7 inches deep. Ziliny and Thrymme state 9 inches, Honeydak states a 10 inch oval, and ZHIVEZEN states no diameter of its own, only that its elastic edge stretches to 21 inches to fit whatever basket you have.

Specification grandtobuy Ziliny Honeydak ZHIVEZEN Thrymme
Portions in one purchase Twelve Six Four One hundred Three
Basket supplied Yes, sugarcane pulp Yes, rattan cane Yes, silicone not published not published
Stated diameter or fit, in 5 9 10, oval stretches to 21 9
Stated depth, in 2.7 3, given also as 8.5 cm field gives 10.24, the oval length not published not published
Stored or folded size stated nests, no figure not published 10 x 1.3 in folded a bag with a hang tie not published
Published weight, lb not published 2.6 2.33 0.69 0.09
What the dimension fields describe carton of twelve, 5.31 x 5.31 x 2.44 in carton of six, 3.15 x 9.84 x 5.91 in one oval basket, 10.24 x 5.91 x 3.35 in pack of one hundred, 0.75 x 19 x 6 in pack of three, 0.28 x 4.03 x 2.79 in
Liner material linen cloth, fabric not named supplied, fabric not named non-woven cotton and linen blend
Cleaning stated no washing step named scrapers included brush once dried, dishwasher washable, or replaced machine washable
Temperature range stated not published not published minus 100°F to 450°F not published not published
Shape round round oval stated to suit most shapes round

What the table cannot tell you is how much dough any of these vessels holds. Not one listing on this sheet publishes a dough weight, a volume or a capacity, so a 5 inch basket and a 10 inch oval can only be compared by the figures printed on them. Nor does any listing here mention pizza, a dough ball or an individual base.

How Many Portions One Purchase Proofs

Twelve Small Baskets Against Three Large Liners

grandtobuy publishes the count that suits the job: twelve round baskets and twelve linen liners in one purchase. The material is named as food-grade sugarcane pulp, described as smooth with no splinters and no odor, and the listing states the rigid shape lets the baskets nest together to save counter and storage space. No figure is given for the nested stack.

Thrymme sits at the other end with three liners and no basket. Both figures are honest about what they are: a pack to line bannetons somebody already owns, in a cotton and linen blend, with elastic edges the listing states are sized for 9 inch baskets. For a table of individual portions, three is a start rather than a set.

A Hundred Liners and No Basket

ZHIVEZEN publishes the largest count of these five by a wide margin, one hundred non-woven liners, and it is the listing that needs the most care in reading. It publishes no diameter for a liner, only that the elastic edge stretches to 21 inches, which covers every basket on this page including the 10 inch oval. It arrives in a storage bag with a hang tie.

The contradiction is in its own two sentences. The title calls the liners disposable and the first feature states they can also be washed and reused, with an upgraded fabric of increased thickness. Both can be true of a thick non-woven sheet, but the listing never says how many washes one survives, so the hundred is best read as a stock rather than a lifetime.

What Each Listing Says Its Baskets Measure

Five Inches Across and 2.7 Inches Deep

Only one of these five publishes a vessel for a single portion. grandtobuy states 5 inches in diameter and 2.7 inches deep, and it names the loaves it is for: mini boules, dinner rolls, burger buns and sourdough discard recipes. That is the closest anything on this sheet comes to describing an individual base, and it does so without ever using the word.

Everything else here is a boule vessel. Ziliny and Thrymme both state 9 inches, Honeydak states a 10 inch oval, and ZHIVEZEN states only its stretched maximum of 21 inches. A 9 inch round basket will proof one large portion or several small ones pressed together, which is a different thing from twelve separated portions each holding its shape.

Where Ziliny’s Own Two Figures Disagree

Ziliny states its baskets are about 9 by 3 inches and gives the metric equivalent in the same sentence as 23 by 8.5 cm. The first pair converts cleanly: 9 inches is close enough to 23 cm for a rounded figure. The second pair does not, because 3 inches is nearer 7.6 cm than 8.5, and 8.5 cm is closer to 3.35 inches.

So the depth of a Ziliny basket is published twice and the two figures are not the same. This page uses neither as a comparison anchor. The rest of that listing is more useful: six rattan cane baskets, six cloth liners and scrapers, at 2.6 pounds for everything, which is the heaviest weight figure of the five.

Storage, Cleaning and the Figures That Do Not Add Up

One Set Folds Flat and States a Temperature Range

Honeydak is the only listing here that publishes what its baskets become when put away. Each 10 inch oval silicone basket is stated to measure 10 by 1.3 inches once collapsed, and four of them arrive in pink, green, purple and yellow, each with its own liner. It is also the only listing on this page that publishes any temperature figure at all.

That range is stated as minus 100°F to 450°F, with a Celsius pair beside it. The hot ends agree well enough. The cold ends do not: the Fahrenheit figure and the Celsius figure given for the same limit are not conversions of each other, so the low end of that range is unverified here and nothing above rests on it. The oven, microwave, dishwasher and refrigerator are all named as safe.

Three Weight Figures, One Missing and One Ambiguous Triple

Ziliny publishes 2.6 pounds, Honeydak 2.33 and ZHIVEZEN 0.69, each covering a whole multipack rather than one item. Thrymme publishes 0.09 pounds for three cloth liners, the lightest of the four weight figures on this page and entirely plausible for fabric. grandtobuy publishes no weight of any kind, for a basket or for the carton of twelve, which is the one clear blank on that listing.

Honeydak’s dimension fields carry 10.24 by 5.91 by 3.35 inches, and that triple is the size of a single 10 inch oval basket, not a box holding four of them. The listing never says which it is describing. Since the same set publishes a folded figure in its own words, this page quotes the maker’s sentence and treats the field triple as one basket.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

You are proofing a dozen portions at once. grandtobuy publishes twelve sugarcane pulp baskets with twelve linen liners, each stated at 5 inches in diameter and 2.7 inches deep, and states they nest for storage. It publishes no weight, and names no washing step.

You want rattan baskets and something to clean them with. Ziliny publishes six rattan cane baskets, six cloth liners and scrapers at 2.6 pounds for the set. Its own size sentence gives 9 by 3 inches and 23 by 8.5 cm, two depths that do not match.

You have nowhere to keep six rigid baskets. Honeydak publishes four collapsible silicone ovals stated to fold to 10 by 1.3 inches, each with a liner, at 2.33 pounds, with the refrigerator, oven, microwave and dishwasher all named as safe.

You own bannetons and never want to wash a liner. ZHIVEZEN publishes one hundred non-woven liners stretching to 21 inches in a storage bag with a hang tie, at 0.69 pounds. It calls them disposable in the title and reusable in its first feature.

You own two bannetons and want cloth for them. Thrymme publishes three cotton and linen blend liners stated at 9 inches with elastic edges, machine washable, at 0.09 pounds. It publishes no thickness or folded size for the cloth and supplies no basket.

What We Could Not Verify

These are the figures the five listings do not publish, or publish twice in ways that disagree, and nothing above has been supplied in their place.

  • Not one of the sixteen listings on this sheet names pizza, a dough ball or an individual base.
  • No listing publishes a dough weight, a volume or a capacity for any basket.
  • grandtobuy publishes no weight for a basket or for its set of twelve.
  • Ziliny’s own size sentence gives 9 by 3 inches and 23 by 8.5 cm, which are not the same depth.
  • Honeydak’s stated cold limit in Fahrenheit does not convert to the Celsius figure printed beside it.
  • ZHIVEZEN calls the same liner disposable in its title and washable and reusable in its first feature.

Frequently asked questions

How many proofing vessels does an evening of individual bases need?+

As many as there are portions, which is why the count matters more here than anything else. grandtobuy publishes twelve baskets with twelve liners in one purchase, Ziliny six baskets with six liners, and Honeydak four baskets each with a liner. Thrymme publishes three liners and ZHIVEZEN one hundred, though ZHIVEZEN supplies no basket, so the hundred are only useful with bannetons already in the cupboard.

Is a 9 inch banneton the wrong shape for a single portion?+

It is built for a boule, and four of these five state 9 or 10 inches. Only grandtobuy publishes a smaller vessel, at 5 inches in diameter and 2.7 inches deep, and it names mini boules, dinner rolls and burger buns as the loaves it suits. Nothing on this sheet states a dough weight, so how much a 5 inch basket holds is not published by anyone.

Which of these can go in the refrigerator overnight?+

Only Honeydak answers the question. Its silicone baskets are stated as suitable for the refrigerator, the dishwasher, the microwave and the oven, and it publishes a range from minus 100°F to 450°F. The two cold figures it gives do not convert to each other, so the low end should be read as unverified. The rattan, pulp and cloth items publish nothing about cold storage at all.

Are the disposable liners actually disposable?+

ZHIVEZEN says both things in the same listing. The title calls the one hundred liners disposable, while the first feature states they can also be washed and reused. The material is a thick non-woven fabric rather than paper, which makes both claims plausible, but the listing never says how many washes a liner survives. Treat the hundred as a stock of liners and decide for yourself.

Does a set need scrapers?+

Ziliny is the only one of these five that supplies one, and it puts them at the center of its cleaning claim, stating the included scrapers make clearing the baskets straightforward and protect the rattan over time. No other listing here supplies a tool of any kind. Honeydak instead states a method, waiting for stuck dough to dry then lifting it with a stiff brush.

What does the storage figure on the silicone set mean?+

Honeydak states that each 10 inch oval basket measures 10 by 1.3 inches once collapsed, which is the only folded figure published in this pool. Its dimension fields carry 10.24 by 5.91 by 3.35 inches, and that triple describes a single oval basket rather than the carton holding four. The listing never says which of the two the figures belong to.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.