How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A splatter cover exists so the microwave does not need cleaning, which leaves the cover itself to be washed. That makes the material the deciding question, and these five do not overlap: clear borosilicate glass on one, food grade silicone on another, PP with TPR on a third, PC on a fourth and PP on the fifth. Every one of them names its material outright.
The washing instructions follow, and they are not evenly distributed. Tovolo, GLICPIX and ACTIVITYYA all state a dishwasher. PMQEWZL states a rinse and explains why: a smooth PC surface lets oil come off without scrubbing. Soltina, the glass dome, publishes nothing about washing at all, which is the one blank on this page that matters most.
What the table cannot tell you is how thick any of these walls are. No listing publishes a glass thickness, a silicone gauge or a plastic wall thickness, which on a dome that gets knocked against a turntable is the figure that decides whether it survives. Nor does any listing state a maximum plate diameter the dome will actually clear.
Five Materials, Four Washing Instructions
Glass and Silicone at Opposite Ends
Soltina is the only cover here that is not plastic and it makes that the headline: clear borosilicate glass, a plastic-free glass dome, naturally BPA-free, designed for repeated everyday reheating. It adds a silicone grip on a ceramic screw and states that grip is heat resistant up to 446°F, which it also gives as 230°C, and those two figures do convert to each other.
Tovolo is the opposite material and the opposite claim. Food grade silicone, collapsible, perforated across the dome, and the washing sentence that no other listing here matches: unlike magnetic covers, simply toss this collapsible cover in the dishwasher after use, and sturdy silicone will withstand years of dishwasher use. It also drains, so it doubles as a colander.
Three Plastics and What Each Claims
GLICPIX is the most specific of the three, naming PP plus TPR rather than saying plastic, and stating that it is microwave and dishwasher safe, BPA-free and will not melt in either. It is also the only listing here that publishes both of its heights: 3.4 inches raised to clear a tall container, and 1.1 inches folded for a drawer.
PMQEWZL states PC and builds its cleaning claim on the surface rather than a machine: crafted from smooth PC, it lets oil stains rinse off effortlessly without tough scrubbing. ACTIVITYYA states strong PP plastic, food-safe and BPA-free, and offers both routes, easy to keep clean by hand wash or dishwasher, with large steam vents against condensation.
Where the Heat Figures Are
One Figure With a Unit and One Without
Only two of these five publish a temperature at all. Soltina publishes 446°F and 230°C, and it is careful about what the figure belongs to: the silicone handle, not the borosilicate glass. That is the more useful attribution anyway, because the handle is the part a hand touches straight out of a microwave.
PMQEWZL publishes a range, wide temperature range from -20 to 200, and names neither scale. Read as Fahrenheit it is a modest ceiling; read as Celsius it is a high one, and the listing gives no way to tell. The same bullet mentions refrigerator freezing and sudden temperature changes, so both ends are meant to matter, and neither can be used.
What Nobody Publishes About the Dome
Three of the five publish no temperature figure of any kind. Tovolo states premium food grade silicone that handles high temperatures safely, GLICPIX states the cover will not melt in the microwave or the dishwasher, and ACTIVITYYA states nothing about heat. Those are reassurances rather than specifications, and on a product whose entire life is spent inside a microwave they are thin.
The other shared blank is fit. No listing on this page states the largest plate it will cover, only the dome’s own diameter, and the dome sits over the plate rather than on it. A stated 9.6 inch cover and a stated 12.2 inch cover are both described as fitting most plates, and neither says what most means.
Figures I Did Not Use
A Height Field of 0.1 Inches on Three Listings
Soltina, GLICPIX and PMQEWZL all carry a third dimension field of 0.1 inches. GLICPIX proves it is wrong from its own text, which states the cover pops up to 3.4 inches and folds to 1.1: neither figure is 0.1. Soltina’s dome has a glass wall and dual vents, and PMQEWZL’s has a hammered top, so neither is a tenth of an inch tall either.
Those fields are recorded in the table above because they are what the listings publish, and nothing on this page is ranked on them. Where a maker writes a height into a sentence, as GLICPIX and ACTIVITYYA both do, that sentence is used instead: 3.4 inches raised and 1.1 folded on one, and 5 inches tall on the other.
Two Weights the Sheet Flags
Soltina publishes 2.56 pounds against a field triple of 3.94 by 10.43 by 0.1 inches, and the fact sheet flags the pair as denser than lead. The fault is the height field rather than the weight: a borosilicate glass dome with mats and mitts could well weigh that, and the 0.1 inch figure makes the arithmetic impossible.
ACTIVITYYA is flagged the other way, publishing 0.51 pounds against 11.5 by 11.5 by 5 inches, which the sheet calls far too light for an object that size. Here the dimensions are plausible and the weight is the suspect figure. Tovolo publishes no weight at all, so on this page only two of five weights can be compared, and no comparison is made on them.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
You will not put plastic in a microwave. Soltina publishes a clear borosilicate glass dome stated plastic-free and naturally BPA-free, with dual steam vents, a silicone grip rated to 446°F, and silicone mats and oven mitts included, at a stated 10.43 inches.
You want a cover for every plate size. Tovolo publishes three silicone covers at a stated 8, 10 and 13 inches that nest when collapsed, with perforated venting, a second use as a colander, and the clearest dishwasher claim on this page.
The drawer is full. GLICPIX publishes PP with TPR at 12.2 by 12.2 by 3.4 inches raised and a stated 1.1 inches folded, microwave and dishwasher safe, with a deepened grip handle and perforated steam vents, at 0.48 pounds.
You would rather rinse than load a machine. PMQEWZL publishes a smooth PC dome with a hammered top, stated to let oil rinse off without scrubbing, stackable in a refrigerator, at a stated 9.6 inches. Its temperature range carries no unit.
Your plates are wide and your food is wet. ACTIVITYYA publishes strong PP plastic at a stated 11.5 inches across and 5 inches tall, with large steam vents against condensation, hand wash or dishwasher, and a second life as a cake stand cover.
What We Could Not Verify
These are the figures the five listings do not publish, or publish in a form that cannot be used, and nothing above has been supplied in their place.
- No listing publishes a glass thickness, a silicone gauge or a plastic wall thickness.
- No listing states the largest plate its dome will actually clear.
- Soltina publishes no washing instruction at all, on a glass and silicone assembly.
- PMQEWZL’s temperature range of -20 to 200 carries no unit at either end.
- Tovolo publishes no weight for one cover or for the set of three.
- Three of the five carry a 0.1 inch height field that cannot describe a dome.