How the Five Compare on the Numbers
The five dishes on this sheet split into two groups by published height. The Pyrex C-209 publishes the largest height at 3.35 inches, and the MORA pan follows at 2.5 inches. The LE TAUCI dish is published at 1.7 inches, while the Norpro and GoodCook pans are both published at 1.5 inches. The MALACASA and getstar listings publish no height, so they cannot be placed on that scale.
Weight tells a different story. The Norpro pan is the lightest of the five at 0.53 pounds, and the Pyrex plate is the heaviest at 2.51 pounds. The MALACASA and LE TAUCI sets share a published weight of 1.55 pounds. The GoodCook listing publishes no weight, so a reader comparing heft has four figures to work with, not five.
The table does not tell you how any of these dishes bakes. No maker on this sheet publishes a browning result, a crust color, or a heat distribution figure that can be compared across brands. The table also leaves out the MALACASA and getstar dimensions entirely, because those listings state nothing. A reader who needs a height or a width for either of those two will not find it here or on the listing.
Published Heights and What They Decide
The tall end of the range
The Pyrex C-209 is published at 3.35 inches high, the largest of the five. That figure is the one to weigh if a recipe fills a dish close to the rim. The same listing publishes an 11.77 inch width and a 14.41 inch depth, both the largest here, so the plate also takes the most shelf space of the five.
The MORA pan is published at 2.5 inches high with a 9 inch inside width. That places it between the Pyrex plate and the shorter dishes. The maker states the fluted sides are there for crimping and that the glaze is lead free and cadmium free. No temperature limit is published for this pan.
The short end of the range
The Norpro 3811 and the GoodCook pan are both published at 1.5 inches high. The Norpro listing adds a 6.75 inch base diameter and a 0.5 inch flat rim, which are the figures that decide whether a crust reaches the edge. The GoodCook listing publishes a 10.5 inch width and a 9.6 inch depth instead.
The LE TAUCI dish sits just above them at a published 1.7 inches high and 9 inches in diameter. The maker states it fits a regular 9 inch pie crust bought in a store. That is a fit statement, not a measurement, and it is the only one of its kind on this sheet.
Materials and Stated Limits
Glass, ceramic, and steel
The Pyrex plate is glass and the only one published as hand wash only. The MALACASA, LE TAUCI, MORA, and getstar dishes are ceramic. The Norpro pan is stainless steel and is published as non reactive with acidic fillings such as lemons, berries, rhubarb, and tomatoes. No ceramic or glass listing on this sheet makes that statement.
Temperature limits are published for two products only. The Pyrex plate is stated as oven safe up to 500°F and the LE TAUCI dish as oven safe up to 482°F. The MALACASA, getstar, MORA, and Norpro listings publish no limit, so a reader cannot confirm a maximum from the maker for those four.
Capacity and cleaning
Two listings publish a capacity in ounces. The MALACASA set is titled at 40 ounces and the LE TAUCI set at 36 ounces. The Pyrex, MORA, and Norpro listings publish no capacity, so a reader comparing volume has two figures and three blanks.
Cleaning statements are equally uneven. The MALACASA and Norpro makers state dishwasher safe. The Pyrex maker states hand wash only. The getstar, LE TAUCI, MORA, and GoodCook listings publish no cleaning method on this sheet, which is a gap rather than a restriction.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
Buyer who bakes at high heat. The Pyrex C-209 is the only one published as oven safe to 500°F, and it publishes the largest height at 3.35 inches. It is also the heaviest at 2.51 pounds and the maker states hand wash only.
Buyer who wants two pans in one purchase. The MALACASA set and the LE TAUCI set each ship as a pair and share a published weight of 1.55 pounds. The MALACASA listing states dishwasher safe; the LE TAUCI listing does not publish a cleaning method.
Buyer working from a store bought crust. The LE TAUCI maker states the dish fits a regular 9 inch pie crust bought in a store. It is published at 1.7 inches high and 9 inches in diameter, with a stated 482°F oven limit.
Buyer who wants deeper sides. The MORA pan is published at 2.5 inches high with a 9 inch inside width and fluted edges. It is the second tallest of the five, behind the Pyrex plate at 3.35 inches, and no temperature limit is published.
Buyer baking with acidic fruit. The Norpro 3811 is published as non reactive with lemon, berry, rhubarb, and tomato fillings. It is the lightest of the five at 0.53 pounds and the smallest on width and depth at 9.0 inches each.
What We Could Not Verify
Several figures a reader would want are absent from these listings. The items below are the ones we went looking for and could not source from the makers.
- No published height for the MALACASA or getstar dishes.
- No published temperature limit for the MALACASA, getstar, MORA, or Norpro dishes.
- No published capacity in ounces for the Pyrex, MORA, or Norpro dishes.
- No published weight for the GoodCook pan.
- No published base diameter for the Pyrex, MALACASA, LE TAUCI, MORA, or GoodCook dishes.
- No published cleaning method for the getstar, LE TAUCI, MORA, or GoodCook listings.