Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Baking

Best Piping Tips for Buttercream Flowers and Borders

The deciding specification is whether the listing prints its tip codes, because a 1M or a 2D is the only thing that lets you follow a tutorial or replace one tip.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

I compared tip counts, printed tip codes, published tip heights, steel grade, what else is in the box and stated dishwasher safety across seven piping tip listings, using only the makers' own text.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. RFAQK 74PCs Icing Piping Bags and Tips Set
    Best for learning to decorate

    RFAQK 74PCs Icing Piping Bags and Tips Set

    A 74 piece kit built on 48 tips in 14 styles, every one numbered on the metal, with a published height range of 0.8 to 1.73 inches plus a pattern chart, booklet, e-book and video course.

    • RFAQK
    • 74pcs
    • Weight not listed
  2. Piping Bags and Tips Set
    Best for skipping the washing up

    Piping Bags and Tips Set

    One hundred disposable 12 inch anti burst bags with 16 stainless tips, two couplers, two bag ties and three plastic scrapers, with an anti-slip textured bag surface.

    • BOOMIBOO
    • 12 INCH 100PCS Piping Bags
    • Weight not listed
  3. 9PCS Large Piping Tips Set
    Best for following a tutorial exactly

    9PCS Large Piping Tips Set

    Nine large tips with every code printed in the listing: 1A, 1E, 1M, 1C, 6B, 195, 356, 853 and 9FT, in food grade stainless with a seamless structure.

    • PJERASR
    • Large
    • Weight not listed
  4. 8Pcs Large Piping Tips Set
    Best for a stated steel grade

    8Pcs Large Piping Tips Set

    Eight large tips in 304 stainless, stated dishwasher safe, with all eight codes printed: 1M, 2F, 4B, 195, 853, 2D, 1A and 6B.

    • ABEJFIC
    • Large
    • Weight not listed
  5. 5PCS Large Piping Tips Set
    Best for a cook who already owns bags

    5PCS Large Piping Tips Set

    Five large stainless tips at 0.07 lb, stated dishwasher safe with a smooth seamless construction, and the only listing in this pool that publishes a weight at all.

    • COKUMA
    • Large
    • 0.07 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
RFAQK 74PCs Icing Piping Bags and Tips Set RFAQK 74pcs not published Best for learning to decorate
Piping Bags and Tips Set BOOMIBOO 12 INCH 100PCS Piping Bags not published Best for skipping the washing up
9PCS Large Piping Tips Set PJERASR Large not published Best for following a tutorial exactly
8Pcs Large Piping Tips Set ABEJFIC Large not published Best for a stated steel grade
5PCS Large Piping Tips Set COKUMA Large 0.07 lb Best for a cook who already owns bags

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for learning to decorate

RFAQK 74PCs Icing Piping Bags and Tips Set

A 74 piece kit built on 48 tips in 14 styles, every one numbered on the metal, with a published height range of 0.8 to 1.73 inches plus a pattern chart, booklet, e-book and video course.

  • For it
  • States that all 48 tips are numbered on the metal, so shapes identify themselves
  • The only listing here that publishes any tip dimension, a height range of 0.8 to 1.73 inches
  • 14 named styles including round, leaf, petal, French, basket weave and open star
  • Includes a pattern chart, a booklet, an e-book in PDF and a video course
  • Against it
  • Does not print the list of 48 codes, so a specific shape cannot be confirmed before buying
  • Publishes no bag count, so how many of the 74 pieces are bags is unknown
  • Names no steel grade, only stainless steel
2 Best for skipping the washing up

Piping Bags and Tips Set

One hundred disposable 12 inch anti burst bags with 16 stainless tips, two couplers, two bag ties and three plastic scrapers, with an anti-slip textured bag surface.

  • For it
  • One hundred disposable 12 inch bags, so no piping bag ever has to be washed
  • Includes two couplers, which none of the three large tip sets provide
  • Adds two bag ties and three plastic scrapers, a complete first kit
  • Bags stated anti burst and able to hold stiff buttercream and melted chocolate
  • Against it
  • Prints no tip codes at all, so its 16 tips cannot be matched to a tutorial
  • Names tip categories rather than shapes or sizes
  • Publishes no bag thickness, so anti burst is a claim with no figure behind it
3 Best for following a tutorial exactly

9PCS Large Piping Tips Set

Nine large tips with every code printed in the listing: 1A, 1E, 1M, 1C, 6B, 195, 356, 853 and 9FT, in food grade stainless with a seamless structure.

  • For it
  • Prints all nine tip codes, the longest published code list of any set here
  • Includes a 9FT that none of the other sets on this page carry
  • Food grade stainless stated, with a smooth seamless structure
  • Stated resistant to staining and easy to clean
  • Against it
  • Publishes no dimensions and no weight at all
  • Names food grade stainless without giving a grade number
  • Does not state dishwasher safe, unlike two rivals here
4 Best for a stated steel grade

8Pcs Large Piping Tips Set

Eight large tips in 304 stainless, stated dishwasher safe, with all eight codes printed: 1M, 2F, 4B, 195, 853, 2D, 1A and 6B.

  • For it
  • Names 304 stainless steel, the only explicit grade on this page
  • Prints all eight codes, including a 2F and a 4B the other sets skip
  • Stated dishwasher safe in plain words
  • Described as suitable for ice cream and cookies as well as cake
  • Against it
  • Publishes no dimensions and no weight
  • Eight tips with no bags, couplers or scrapers included
  • Makes no claim about seams, unlike two rivals here
5 Best for a cook who already owns bags

5PCS Large Piping Tips Set

Five large stainless tips at 0.07 lb, stated dishwasher safe with a smooth seamless construction, and the only listing in this pool that publishes a weight at all.

  • For it
  • The only listing in this pool that publishes a weight, 0.07 lb
  • Stated dishwasher safe and smooth and seamless in construction
  • Described as resistant to rust, corrosion and bending
  • The smallest and simplest purchase here for someone who owns bags already
  • Against it
  • Prints no tip codes, so the five shapes cannot be reordered individually
  • Its feature text is cut off mid-list, so only the round plain tip is confirmed
  • Names no steel grade, only high quality stainless steel

Our verdict

RFAQK is the one to learn from: 48 tips in 14 styles, every tip numbered on the metal, with a height range of 0.8 to 1.73 inches and a booklet, e-book and video course. PJERASR prints nine codes and ABEJFIC prints eight, including 1M, 2D and 195. BOOMIBOO buries 16 unidentified tips in a kit of 100 disposable bags. COKUMA is five large tips at 0.07 lb.

“A shape you cannot name is a shape you cannot reorder.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Codes beat descriptions PJERASR prints nine codes and ABEJFIC eight. A 1M or a 2D matches a tutorial and can be replaced on its own.
Count is not comparable Five, eight and nine tips against 74 and 100 piece kits, where most of the count is disposable bags.
Almost nothing is measured One listing publishes a tip height, 0.8 to 1.73 inches. One publishes a weight, 0.07 lb. None publishes a base diameter.
Steel grade stated twice ABEJFIC names 304 stainless and PJERASR names food grade stainless. The other three say only stainless steel.
Same set, three brands COKUMA, Kaverme and Suuker all describe the same five large tips. Only Suuker gives their codes.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 30% Whether the tip codes are printedA code is how you follow a tutorial and how you replace one broken tip, and it is the only specification these listings reliably could publish.
  2. 25% What is actually in the boxA 74 piece count and a 100 piece count mix disposable bags with tools, so the contents list matters more than the number.
  3. 20% Any published measurementOne listing of seven gives a tip height and one gives a weight, so a maker that measures anything is doing more than its rivals.
  4. 15% Material and cleaning claimsTips live in acidic frosting and go through dishwashers, so a stated grade and a seamless interior are worth having in writing.
  5. 10% Whether the set is genuinely distinctThree listings in this pool describe the same five tips, and paying twice for one set is the easiest mistake to make here.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

There are almost no numbers to compare, and that is the single most useful thing to know before buying piping tips. Of the seven listings looked at, exactly one publishes a tip dimension and exactly one publishes a weight. No maker publishes a tip diameter, a wall thickness, a coupler thread size or an opening width. What they publish instead is a piece count, and sometimes the tip numbers themselves.

Those tip numbers are the figures that actually matter. A 1M, a 2D or a 195 is a standard code that tells you what the tip does, lets you follow a tutorial, and lets you replace one tip rather than a set. PJERASR and ABEJFIC list every code in their sets. Suuker hides its codes in the size field. COKUMA and Kaverme describe shapes in words and never give a code at all.

Specification RFAQK 74 piece BOOMIBOO kit PJERASR 9 piece ABEJFIC 8 piece COKUMA 5 piece
Tips in the set 48 tips 16 tips 9 tips 8 tips 5 tips
Tip codes printed in the listing not published not published Yes, all nine listed Yes, all eight listed not published
Tips numbered on the metal Yes, all of them not published not published not published not published
Tip height published 0.8 to 1.73 in not published not published not published not published
Tip styles counted 14 styles Star, round, petal, leaf, multi-hole not published not published Round plain, and others unlisted
Piping bags included Anti burst, 12 in 100 disposable, 12 in None None None
Couplers included not published Two None None None
Scrapers and ties included not published Three scrapers, two ties None None None
Steel grade stated not published not published Food grade stainless Stainless steel 304 not published
Dishwasher safe stated not published not published not published Yes Yes
Learning material included Booklet, e-book, video course not published not published not published not published
Published weight not published not published not published not published 0.07 lb
Described as large tips not published not published Yes Yes Yes

What no cell in that table can tell you is the one measurement every buyer needs: the diameter of the tip base, which decides whether it fits a standard coupler or must be dropped straight into a bag. Three of these five are sold as large tips, which by convention means too wide for a coupler, but not one maker publishes the base diameter that would confirm it. RFAQK publishes a height range instead.

Why the Tip Number Is the Real Specification

A Code Is a Shape You Can Reorder

Piping tip codes are an old industry convention, not branding. A 1M is a large open star, a 2D is a large drop flower, a 195 is a French star. Every tutorial, every book and every video refers to them by number, which means a set that prints its codes lets you follow instructions written by someone who has never seen your set. PJERASR prints nine codes and ABEJFIC prints eight.

The second reason is replacement. Tips get dropped, crushed underfoot, or lost down a drain, and a code lets you buy that one shape back for a fraction of a new set. A set described only as containing a round plain tip, an open star, a closed star, a drop flower and a French star tells you the shapes but leaves you guessing which of several sizes of each you were sent.

Where Each Set Sits on That Scale

RFAQK takes the opposite approach and is arguably the strongest of the five on this point: it states that all 48 tips are numbered on the metal itself and ships a pattern chart, a booklet, an e-book in PDF and a video course to read them by. It does not print the list of 48 codes in the listing, so you cannot check for a specific shape before buying, but every tip identifies itself once it arrives.

BOOMIBOO sits at the bottom of this scale. It states 16 stainless tips and names the categories, star tips for rosettes, round for writing and dots, petal for flowers, leaf for leaves and multi-hole for grass, but publishes no codes and no numbering claim. For a kit whose main content is 100 disposable bags, the tips are effectively unidentified accessories rather than a chosen collection.

Sets, Kits, and What You Are Really Buying

Five Tips, or Seventy Four Pieces

These five listings are not the same kind of purchase. COKUMA sells 5 large tips and nothing else, ABEJFIC sells 8, PJERASR sells 9. RFAQK sells a 74 piece kit built around 48 tips in 14 styles with bags and teaching material. BOOMIBOO sells 100 disposable 12 inch bags with 16 tips, two couplers, two bag ties and three plastic scrapers thrown in around them.

If you already own bags, a coupler and a scraper, the large tip sets are the efficient purchase, and the only question is how many shapes you want. If you own nothing, the two kits solve the whole problem in one order. What makes them hard to compare is that a piece count of 74 or 100 mixes disposable bags in with tools, so the counts are not measuring the same thing.

Disposable Bags Against Reusable Ones

BOOMIBOO is explicit that its bags are disposable and go straight in the trash, which for buttercream and melted chocolate is a genuine convenience argument: a piping bag is the single most annoying thing in the kitchen to wash. It states the bags are anti burst, hold stiff buttercream without splitting, and have an anti-slip textured surface. It also states a wide open mouth for filling.

RFAQK also states 12 inch anti burst pastry bags but does not say whether they are disposable or reusable, and does not give a count, so how many bags sit inside the 74 pieces is unanswerable from the listing. Neither maker publishes a bag thickness in microns or mils, which is the figure that actually predicts whether a bag splits under a stiff frosting.

Steel, Seams, and the Two Sets That Look Identical

Grade Stated, and Grade Assumed

ABEJFIC names 304 stainless steel, and PJERASR names food grade stainless without a grade number. RFAQK, BOOMIBOO and COKUMA say only stainless steel. Two of the listings left off this page, Suuker and Kaverme, also name 304 and stainless respectively. Grade matters here for one narrow reason: a tip lives in acidic frosting and goes through a dishwasher, and lower grades pit over time.

Three of the five make a claim about the seam. COKUMA states a smooth, seamless construction, and PJERASR states a smooth seamless structure for precise work. A seam inside a star tip is where frosting catches and where a cleaned tip stays dirty, so this is a more useful claim than it sounds. Only ABEJFIC and COKUMA state dishwasher safe in plain words.

The Same Five Tips Under Three Brands

Three listings in this pool describe what appears to be the same five-tip large set. COKUMA, Kaverme and Suuker all sell five large stainless tips. Kaverme lists them as round plain, open star, closed star, drop flower and French star. COKUMA’s bullet begins the identical list before the text is cut off. Suuker puts codes in its size field rather than its bullets: 1A, 1E, 348, 347 and 356.

COKUMA was kept here because it is the only listing in the whole pool that publishes a weight, 0.07 lb, and because it states dishwasher safe. Kaverme and Suuker were left out as near duplicates of it rather than as bad products. If the five-tip large set is what you want, treat those three listings as one product and buy whichever names its codes, which is Suuker.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

The complete beginner. RFAQK, for the 48 numbered tips in 14 styles plus a pattern chart, booklet, e-book and video course. It publishes the only tip dimensions on this page, a height range of 0.8 to 1.73 inches, so you know the range of sizes before ordering.

The occasional decorator who hates washing bags. BOOMIBOO, for 100 disposable 12 inch bags with 16 tips, two couplers, two ties and three scrapers. The tips are unidentified and uncoded, so treat them as a starting collection rather than shapes you can reorder.

The cook who follows tutorials. PJERASR, because it prints all nine codes: 1A, 1E, 1M, 1C, 6B, 195, 356, 853 and 9FT. That is the longest code list published by any large set here, and it includes a 9FT that the other sets do not carry.

The buyer who wants steel grade in writing. ABEJFIC, the only set here that names 304 stainless and states dishwasher safe, with eight codes printed: 1M, 2F, 4B, 195, 853, 2D, 1A and 6B. Two large drop flower and petal shapes the smaller sets skip.

The cook who already owns bags and a coupler. COKUMA, five large tips at 0.07 lb, stated dishwasher safe with a seamless construction. It is the smallest and simplest purchase here, and the only one on this page whose weight is published at all.

What We Could Not Verify

These listings publish very little that can be measured. The following were looked for on all seven and not found.

  • No maker publishes the base diameter of a tip, which is what decides whether it fits a standard coupler.
  • No maker publishes a wall thickness, so how easily a tip crushes cannot be compared.
  • Only RFAQK publishes any tip dimension, a height range of 0.8 to 1.73 inches across its 48 tips.
  • Only COKUMA publishes a weight, 0.07 lb, so there is nothing to weigh the other four against.
  • Neither kit publishes a bag thickness or a bag count, so bag durability and quantity are unknown.
  • RFAQK states that all 48 tips are numbered but does not print the list, so a specific shape cannot be confirmed before buying.

Frequently asked questions

Why do tip numbers like 1M and 2D matter so much?+

Because they are a shared convention rather than brand codes. Every decorating tutorial, book and video refers to tips by number, so a set that prints its codes lets you follow instructions written by someone who has never seen your set. Codes also let you replace a single crushed tip instead of a whole set. PJERASR prints nine codes and ABEJFIC prints eight, which is the strongest reason to pick either.

What does large mean on a piping tip set?+

By convention it means the tip is too wide at the base to fit a standard coupler, so it drops straight into the bag and you change tips by changing bags. Three of these five are sold as large tips: PJERASR, ABEJFIC and COKUMA. None of them publishes the base diameter that would confirm it, which is the single most useful measurement missing from every listing in this pool.

Should I buy a kit or just the tips?+

It depends on what you own. If you already have bags, a coupler and a scraper, a large tip set is the efficient purchase and the only question is how many shapes you want. If you own nothing, RFAQK's 74 piece kit or BOOMIBOO's 100 bag kit solves the whole problem at once. The piece counts are not comparable because most of a 100 piece count is disposable bags.

Are the three five-tip sets in this pool the same product?+

They look extremely close. COKUMA, Kaverme and Suuker all sell five large stainless tips, and Kaverme lists them as round plain, open star, closed star, drop flower and French star while COKUMA's bullet starts the same list before the text is cut off. Suuker gives codes instead: 1A, 1E, 348, 347 and 356. Treat the three as one product and buy the one that names its codes.

Does the stainless grade actually matter for piping tips?+

It matters more than for most kitchen tools, because a tip spends its life full of acidic buttercream and then goes through a dishwasher. ABEJFIC names 304 stainless, which is the grade normally used for food contact. PJERASR says food grade stainless without a number. RFAQK, BOOMIBOO and COKUMA say only stainless steel, so there is nothing to compare. Two of the five state dishwasher safe outright.

Why is a seamless tip worth looking for?+

A seam inside a star tip is a crevice, and a crevice holds frosting that a brush cannot reach. That means a tip that looks clean is not, and a seam can also disrupt the shape of the piped line. COKUMA states a smooth seamless construction and PJERASR states a smooth seamless structure. The other three listings on this page make no claim about seams either way.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.