How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A drawer is a box with a fixed lid. The footprint of a baking sheet decides whether it goes in at all, and after that the only figure that matters is the third one, the height the pans take out of the gap between the drawer base and the runners above it. Almost every listing in this pool leads with the two large figures and buries the third.
These five publish 0.5 in, 0.8 in, 1 in, 1.75 in and, in one case, 2.9 in. Four of those can be believed. The fifth belongs to a listing whose own words describe a 17 by 11 inch pan while its dimension fields publish 12.6 by 20.5 by 2.9 in, and a 20.5 in field cannot be a 17 in pan.
The last row is the one worth staring at. Not one of these five publishes an interior figure, so the usable surface is unknown on all of them. One listing elsewhere in this pool does: Nordic Ware publishes an exterior of 17.9 x 12.9 x 1 in and an interior of 17.1 x 12.1 x 1 in, which puts 0.8 in of rim and rolled edge between the two. Nobody else in the pool separates the two numbers.
The Height Figure Is What the Drawer Sees
From Half an Inch to Nearly Two
Boxiki publishes 0.5 in as its third figure. EATEX publishes 0.8 in, Yuiicaov 1 in and GreenPan 1.75 in. Between the first and the last of those sits more than an inch, which in a shallow drawer is the difference between the runners closing and the drawer jamming on the way in. None of the four says what the figure measures.
That silence matters for a stack. If 0.5 in is one Boxiki pan, three of them nested add up to less than the single GreenPan. If it is the whole set flat, then one pan is thinner still and the figure is close to useless for planning. The listing gives 17 x 12 x 0.5 inches in its size field and 12 x 17 x 0.5 in as package figures, and never distinguishes them.
One Field Set That Cannot Be the Pan
GoodCook states 17 x 11 inches in its title and in its first bullet, twice. Its dimension fields publish 12.6 x 20.5 x 2.9 in. A pan the maker calls 17 inches long cannot have a 20.5 in field, and a cookie sheet the same listing describes as having a wider lip on the sides is not 2.9 in deep. The maker’s own words win here, as the house rule requires.
So GoodCook enters this page with a footprint and no usable height. That is not the same as publishing nothing: it is worse, because a buyer reading the fields would plan a drawer around 2.9 in and lose two inches of space for no reason. The pan is kept as a pick because 17 x 11 in and 1.0 lb are credible and it is the only single sheet here rated for a metal spatula.
One Purchase, One Pan or Three
Three Nested Pans Against a Single Sheet
Boxiki and Yuiicaov each supply three pans, EATEX two, and GreenPan and GoodCook one each. For a drawer that is the first decision, because three pans of different footprints do not stack flush: the smaller ones sit inside the larger, but only if the rims allow it, and no listing here publishes a nested stack height.
Yuiicaov describes three sizes at 12, 16 and 17.5 inches and publishes 4.74 lb for the set. Boxiki describes a set of three and publishes 3.79 lb. Both figures are for the purchase, not the pan, so neither tells you what one sheet weighs when you lift it out of a low drawer with one hand.
The Only Nesting Claim in the Pool Is Not a Pick Here
Kikcoin is the one listing of the sixteen that makes the claim a drawer buyer actually wants. It states that matching proportions and rim heights let all three of its pans nest neatly and store compactly, and it names a footprint for each of the three. That is the right sentence in the right place, and it is the sentence no pick here publishes.
It is not a pick because it publishes no height for any of the three pans. The only third figure on the listing is 0.8 in among its package figures, and a carton holding three rimmed pans is not 0.8 in thick. A page ranked on the published height cannot rank a listing that publishes none, however good its storage claim reads.
What the Metal and the Coating Cost You
Uncoated Steel Against Four Nonstick Surfaces
Yuiicaov is the only pick with no coating, stating food grade 18/0 stainless with no chemical coating and a mirror finish. The other four are all coated: Boxiki and EATEX nonstick over carbon steel, GreenPan a ceramic nonstick it states is made without intentionally added PFAS, and GoodCook a scratch resistant nonstick it calls metal spatula safe.
In a drawer that is a wear question rather than a baking one. Pans stacked in a drawer slide against each other every time it opens, and a coating is the part that goes first. Only GoodCook addresses contact with metal at all, and it does so about serving utensils rather than about a neighboring pan.
Handles Add Width the Footprint Does Not Report
EATEX publishes red silicone grip handles and GreenPan oversized gold tone stainless handles. Neither publishes how far the handle projects, so the stated footprints of 17.16 x 11.93 in and 13 x 9 in may or may not include them. GoodCook takes the other route and simply widens the lip on the sides, which adds nothing beyond the pan.
For a compact drawer the difference is real and unmeasured. A silicone grip on a 17.16 in pan could put the true span past 18 inches, and nothing in either listing settles it. Boxiki and Yuiicaov publish no handle at all, which at least means the footprint they publish is the footprint you get.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
The baker with one shallow drawer. Boxiki publishes the smallest third figure here at 0.5 in and supplies three pans at 3.79 lb for the set. Read the figure as a planning floor rather than a promise, because the listing never says whether 0.5 in is one pan or all three.
The cook who wants nothing to peel. Yuiicaov is the only pick with no coating, in 18/0 stainless, rated to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and stated dishwasher safe. Three pans at 17.5 x 13 x 1 in and smaller, and 4.74 lb for the set, which is the heaviest purchase on this page.
The cook who reaches into the drawer with mitts on. EATEX gives two pans with red silicone grips and publishes 17.16 x 11.93 x 0.8 in. It is the lightest multi pan purchase here at 1.98 lb, and the handles are the part no listing measures.
The small batch baker who uses the broiler. GreenPan is a single 13 x 9 in quarter sheet rated to 550 degrees Fahrenheit and stated broiler safe, the highest rating on this page. It asks for hand washing, and at 1.75 in it takes more drawer height than any other pick with a believable figure.
The cook replacing one worn sheet. GoodCook is a single 17 x 11 in pan at 1.0 lb, stated metal spatula safe and dishwasher safe. Ignore its dimension fields entirely and measure the drawer against the 17 by 11 figure the maker states twice in its own words.
What We Could Not Verify
These are the figures a drawer buyer needs and this pool does not publish.
- Not one of the five publishes a nested stack height for a multi pan set.
- Not one of the five publishes an interior dimension, so the usable surface is unknown on all of them.
- No listing states how far a silicone or steel handle projects beyond the rim.
- Boxiki never says whether its 0.5 in figure is one pan, the stack or the carton.
- The GoodCook dimension fields of 12.6 x 20.5 x 2.9 in contradict the 17 x 11 in the same listing states twice.
- GoodCook publishes no oven temperature rating, and no listing in this pool publishes a drawer or cabinet clearance of any kind.