Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Baking

Best Silicone Baking Mat Sets for a Family Kitchen

The deciding specification is how many pieces one purchase gives a family kitchen and what kinds they are, because these five run from nine pieces in three bakeware types down to a single full size mat, and two purchases of six pieces here give completely different things.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

Compared the sixteen silicone baking mat listings on the fact sheet by the number of pieces in each purchase, which kinds of bakeware those pieces are, and whether the maker publishes a figure for each one.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. Baking Sheet Tray Cooling Rack with Silicone Baking ...
    Best for cooking three things at once

    Baking Sheet Tray Cooling Rack with Silicone Baking ...

    Nine pieces in three sizes: three rimmed pans, three cooling racks and three mats, rated -40 F to 500 F.

    • EWFEN
    • Standard, Medium, Large
    • 5 lb
  2. M MCIRCO Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack
    Best for knowing what fits what

    M MCIRCO Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack

    The only pick measuring all three kinds: pans at 16 by 12 by 1 inch, racks at 15.16 by 11 by 0.65 inch, mats at 15 by 11 inch.

    • M MCIRCO
    • 16x12x1inch
    • 5.12 lb
  3. Silicone Baking Mat Set of 6
    Best for cake tins and sheet pans together

    Silicone Baking Mat Set of 6

    Six mats in four shapes, each published with its own figure and the pan it is cut for, from a half sheet to an 8.5 in round.

    • Angadona
    • 6-Piece Set
    • 0.97 lb
  4. MMmat Best German Silicone Baking Mat - Half Sheet B...
    Best for replacing two worn liners

    MMmat Best German Silicone Baking Mat - Half Sheet B...

    Two identical half sheet mats at 11.625 by 16.5 in and 0.75 mm, heat resistant to 500 F, at 0.53 lb for the pair.

    • MMMAT
    • 11.625 x 16.5 inches (LxW) *2
    • 0.53 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
Baking Sheet Tray Cooling Rack with Silicone Baking ... EWFEN Standard, Medium, Large 5 lb Best for cooking three things at once
M MCIRCO Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack M MCIRCO 16x12x1inch 5.12 lb Best for knowing what fits what
Silicone Baking Mat Set of 6 Angadona 6-Piece Set 0.97 lb Best for cake tins and sheet pans together
MMmat Best German Silicone Baking Mat - Half Sheet B... MMMAT 11.625 x 16.5 inches (LxW) *2 0.53 lb Best for replacing two worn liners

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for cooking three things at once

Baking Sheet Tray Cooling Rack with Silicone Baking ...

Nine pieces in three sizes: three rimmed pans, three cooling racks and three mats, rated -40 F to 500 F.

  • For it
  • Publishes the largest piece count of these five at nine, across three bakeware types and three sizes
  • States that the sizes can be freely combined and matched, which is what a nine piece set is for
  • States stainless steel pans and racks with no chemical coating on the pan surface
  • States mats of food grade silicone and reinforced fiberglass rated -40 F to 500 F, and four raised feet on each rack
  • Against it
  • Publishes no inch figure for any piece, with a size slot reading only Standard, Medium and Large
  • Its box figure of 1.97 by 5.31 by 5.51 in is smaller than one of the pans it says is inside
  • Publishes no thickness for the mats, where two of these five do
2 Best for knowing what fits what

M MCIRCO Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack

The only pick measuring all three kinds: pans at 16 by 12 by 1 inch, racks at 15.16 by 11 by 0.65 inch, mats at 15 by 11 inch.

  • For it
  • The only pick publishing a figure for every kind of piece it sells
  • States pans at 16 by 12 by 1 inch, racks at 15.16 by 11 by 0.65 inch and mats at 15 by 11 inch
  • States that each rack and mat fits inside the pans, so nothing in the box is orphaned
  • States silicone and reinforced fiberglass rated -40 F to 500 F, with a named washing routine
  • Against it
  • At 5.12 lb it is the heaviest pick here, against 0.53 lb on the MMMAT mats, because the steel is in the box
  • Publishes no thickness for its mats
  • Its own size slot reads 16 by 12 by 1 inch, which is the pan rather than the set
3 Best for cake tins and sheet pans together

Silicone Baking Mat Set of 6

Six mats in four shapes, each published with its own figure and the pan it is cut for, from a half sheet to an 8.5 in round.

  • For it
  • Publishes a mat figure and a pan for each of four shapes, which no other pick here does
  • Covers a half sheet, a quarter sheet, a round tin and a square tin from one purchase
  • States 100 percent imported food grade silicone with an LEGB certificate and BPA free material
  • States use in an oven and a freezer across -40 F to 480 F, and publishes dimension fields that agree with its stated half sheet figure
  • Against it
  • Names four shapes for six pieces and never says which two arrive twice
  • The only pick restricting the dishwasher to the top rack
  • Publishes no thickness and no core material beyond the word silicone
4 Best for replacing two worn liners

MMmat Best German Silicone Baking Mat - Half Sheet B...

Two identical half sheet mats at 11.625 by 16.5 in and 0.75 mm, heat resistant to 500 F, at 0.53 lb for the pair.

  • For it
  • Publishes its half sheet figure twice, as 11.625 by 16.5 in in the size slot and 11.6 by 16.5 inches in a bullet
  • States a 0.75 mm thickness and says plainly that the mats are not made in Germany
  • States heat resistance up to 500 F and gives the same figure as 260 C
  • Publishes 0.53 lb for the pair, the lowest published weight of these five
  • Against it
  • Two identical mats in one shape, so a round or square tin is not covered
  • Names German WACKER silicone but no fiberglass core, where three of these five state one
  • Its 0.53 lb covers two mats, so no per mat weight is available

Our verdict

EWFEN publishes the largest purchase, nine pieces as three rimmed pans, three cooling racks and three mats, and not one inch figure for any of them. M MCIRCO publishes six in the same three kinds and measures all three. Angadona spends six pieces on mats in four shapes, each named for its pan. MMMAT sells two identical half sheet mats and AMYONE a single full size one.

“Six pieces can mean six mats or two pans, two racks and two mats.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Nine pieces down to one EWFEN publishes nine, M MCIRCO six, Angadona six, MMMAT two and AMYONE one. The two purchases of six are not comparable: one is pans and racks and mats, the other is six mats.
Only one measures everything M MCIRCO publishes a figure for its pans, its racks and its mats. EWFEN publishes nine pieces and no inch figure at all, with a size slot reading Standard, Medium and Large.
Two arrive with cooling racks EWFEN and M MCIRCO both supply racks, and both state four raised feet on each one. The other three purchases are mats only, so a rack has to come from somewhere else.
One covers four shapes Angadona publishes a half sheet, a quarter sheet, an 8.5 in round and an 8.625 in square, each with the pan it is cut for. It never says which two of its six pieces are duplicates.
Weight is the tell EWFEN publishes 5 lb and M MCIRCO 5.12 lb against 0.97 lb, 0.53 lb and 0.57 lb on the mat only picks. Steel is the whole of that difference, and every figure covers the purchase rather than a piece.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 30% How many pieces the purchase actually containsA family kitchen runs out of pans before it runs out of mats
  2. 25% Whether every piece is measured, not just namedA nine piece set with no figures cannot be planned around
  3. 20% How many shapes of pan the mats coverA round cake tin is not lined by a half sheet mat
  4. 15% Whether racks and pans come with the matsA rack that fits the pan is worth more than a spare mat
  5. 10% Whether a thickness or a core is publishedFiberglass is what stops a mat curling at the edge

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

A family kitchen does not buy a mat, it buys a quantity of bakeware. So the useful figure on this shelf is the piece count and what the pieces actually are, because a purchase of six can be two pans, two racks and two mats, or it can be six mats in four shapes, and those are not remotely the same purchase. These five run from nine pieces down to one.

EWFEN publishes a pack of nine in three bakeware types and three sizes. M MCIRCO publishes six in the same three types and gives a figure for each. Angadona publishes six, all of them mats, in four shapes with the pan each one fits. MMMAT publishes a set of two identical half sheet mats. AMYONE publishes a single mat cut for a full size pan.

Published specification EWFEN set M MCIRCO set Angadona mats MMMAT mats AMYONE mat
Pieces in the purchase Nine Six Six Two One
Kinds of piece supplied Pans, racks and mats Pans, racks and mats Mats only, in four shapes Mats only, identical One mat
Pan size supplied not published, only Standard, Medium and Large 16 by 12 by 1 in not published, mats only not published, mats only not published, mats only
Rack size supplied not published 15.16 by 11 by 0.65 in not published, no rack not published, no rack not published, no rack
Mat size the maker states not published 15 by 11 in 16.5 by 11.625 in, 11.5 by 8.5 in, an 8.5 in round and an 8.625 in square 11.625 by 16.5 in 24.5 by 16.5 in
Pans the mats are named for not published, only that the mats fit the pans not published, only that each piece fits the pans 13 by 18 in, 13 by 9.5 in, a 9 in round and a 9 in square Half sheet pans Full size sheet pans
Rack feet stated Four raised feet on each rack Four raised feet on each rack not published, no rack not published, no rack not published, no rack
Temperature stated -40 F to 500 F -40 F to 500 F -40 F to 480 F Up to 500 F, which it also gives as 260 C -40 F to 480 F
Thickness the maker states not published not published not published 0.75 mm 0.75 mm
Mat core stated Silicone and reinforced fiberglass Silicone and reinforced fiberglass not published, only imported food grade silicone not published, only German WACKER silicone Silicone internally reinforced with fiberglass
Cleaning method stated Dishwasher safe Warm water, mild soap and a gentle sponge, or the dishwasher By hand or the dishwasher, top rack only A cloth, or the dishwasher Warm soapy water, or the dishwasher
Published weight 5 lb 5.12 lb 0.97 lb 0.53 lb for two mats 0.57 lb for one mat
Dimension fields published not published not published 11.6 by 16.5 by 0.1 in not published 16.5 by 24.5 by 0.1 in
Package figures published 1.97 by 5.31 by 5.51 in for the box 12.3 by 16.2 by 1.42 in for the box not published 2 by 2 by 12 in for the box not published

What the table cannot tell you is which of the six Angadona pieces are duplicated. The listing names four shapes and supplies six mats and never says which two arrive twice, so a family buying it for cake tins may get a second half sheet instead. EWFEN publishes nine pieces and not one figure for any of them, where M MCIRCO publishes a figure for all three kinds.

The Two Purchases That Include Steel

EWFEN Publishes Nine Pieces and No Sizes

EWFEN publishes the largest piece count here, a pack of nine made up of three rimmed baking pans, three cooling racks and three silicone mats in three different sizes. Its own argument is that the sizes can be freely combined and matched, which for a family cooking two things at once is the point of buying nine pieces rather than three.

What it never does is measure any of them. Its size slot reads Standard, Medium and Large, and no bullet gives an inch figure for a pan, a rack or a mat. It states stainless steel pans and racks with no chemical coating, mats of food grade silicone and reinforced fiberglass rated -40 F to 500 F, four raised feet on each rack, and 5 lb.

M MCIRCO Measures All Three Kinds of Piece

M MCIRCO is the only pick that publishes a figure for every kind of piece it sells. Its first bullet states a pack of six: two rimmed baking sheets at 16 by 12 by 1 inch, two cooling racks at 15.16 by 11 by 0.65 inch, and two silicone mats at 15 by 11 inch, and says each rack and mat fits inside the pans.

That is the sentence a family kitchen needs, because a rack that does not sit inside the pan is a rack that lives in a cupboard. It states pure stainless steel, rust and warp resistant, mats of silicone and reinforced fiberglass rated -40 F to 500 F, four raised feet and dense parallel lines on each rack, and a wash in warm water with mild soap and a gentle sponge. It publishes 5.12 lb.

The Purchases That Are All Mat

Angadona Gives Six Mats in Four Shapes

Angadona matches the M MCIRCO piece count and spends all six pieces on mats. Its last bullet publishes a mat figure and a pan for each shape: a half sheet mat of 16.5 by 11.625 in for a 13 by 18 in pan, a quarter sheet of 11.5 by 8.5 in for a 13 by 9.5 in pan, an 8.5 in round for a 9 in round pan, and an 8.625 in square for a 9 in square pan.

Four shapes across six pieces means two of them arrive twice and the listing never says which. It states 100 percent imported food grade silicone with an LEGB certificate, use in an oven and a freezer across -40 F to 480 F, and washing by hand or in the dishwasher on the top rack only, which is the only rack restriction among these five. It publishes 0.97 lb.

MMMAT and AMYONE Sell One Shape Each

MMMAT publishes a set of two identical half sheet mats at 11.625 by 16.5 in in its size slot, and its own bullet repeats the pair as 11.6 by 16.5 inches. It states German WACKER silicone with a plain capitalized note that the mats are not made in Germany, a 0.75 mm thickness, heat resistance up to 500 F which it also gives as 260 C, and 0.53 lb for the pair.

AMYONE goes further and sells one mat, cut for a full size sheet pan, published at 24.5 by 16.5 in with dimension fields that agree. It states food grade silicone internally reinforced with fiberglass, a European standard, the same 0.75 mm thickness as the MMMAT mats, a glossy dense finish, wider coated edges, -40 F to 480 F, and 0.57 lb for the single mat.

What the Piece Counts Do Not Tell You

Where the Published Figures Argue With the Words

The EWFEN box figure cannot be right. It reads 1.97 by 5.31 by 5.51 in, which is smaller than one of the three rimmed baking pans the same listing says are inside it, let alone three pans, three racks and three mats. That figure is treated here as unusable, and no claim on this page rests on it.

The AMYONE title is the second case. It claims 18 by 26 inches while the size slot and the dimension fields both publish 24.5 by 16.5 in, and since the listing says the mat is cut for a full size sheet pan, the larger pair reads as the pan rather than the mat. This page uses 24.5 by 16.5 in throughout.

Weight Tells You What Is in the Box

The weights here separate the two kinds of purchase more cleanly than the piece counts do. EWFEN publishes 5 lb and M MCIRCO 5.12 lb, against 0.97 lb for six Angadona mats, 0.53 lb for two MMMAT mats and 0.57 lb for the single AMYONE mat. Steel is the whole of that difference.

The figures to be careful with are the per purchase ones. The MMMAT 0.53 lb covers two mats and the AMYONE 0.57 lb covers one, so the lower number is not the lighter mat, and neither listing publishes a per mat weight. Angadona publishes 0.97 lb for six pieces and no figure for any single mat either.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

You are cooking three things at once. EWFEN publishes nine pieces, three rimmed pans, three cooling racks and three mats in three sizes, rated -40 F to 500 F, with four raised feet on each rack. It publishes no figure for any piece.

You want to know what fits what. M MCIRCO publishes two pans at 16 by 12 by 1 inch, two racks at 15.16 by 11 by 0.65 inch and two mats at 15 by 11 inch, and states that each rack and mat fits inside the pans.

You bake cakes and sheet pans both. Angadona publishes six mats in four shapes with the pan each fits, from a 16.5 by 11.625 in half sheet to an 8.5 in round. It washes on the top rack only.

You already own the pans. MMMAT publishes two identical half sheet mats at 11.625 by 16.5 in, 0.75 mm thick in German WACKER silicone, heat resistant to 500 F, and 0.53 lb for the pair.

You have one very large pan. AMYONE publishes a single mat at 24.5 by 16.5 in and 0.75 mm, fiberglass reinforced to a European standard with wider coated edges, rated -40 F to 480 F.

What We Could Not Verify

Six things a reader buying bakeware for a family would want, and no listing among these five supplies.

  • Which two of the six Angadona shapes arrive twice, since four shapes are named for six pieces.
  • Any inch figure at all from EWFEN, for its pans, its racks or its mats.
  • What the EWFEN box figure of 1.97 by 5.31 by 5.51 in actually measures.
  • A per mat weight from any of these five, since every figure covers the whole purchase.
  • A thickness from EWFEN, M MCIRCO or Angadona, where two of these five publish one.
  • Whether the M MCIRCO racks fit any pan other than the two in its own box.

Frequently asked questions

How many pieces does each of these purchases contain?+

EWFEN publishes nine, as three rimmed baking pans, three cooling racks and three silicone mats. M MCIRCO publishes six, as two pans, two racks and two mats. Angadona publishes six, all of them mats, in four shapes. MMMAT publishes two identical half sheet mats. AMYONE publishes one mat cut for a full size sheet pan.

Which one tells me what size everything is?+

M MCIRCO, and only M MCIRCO. Its first bullet publishes two baking sheets at 16 by 12 by 1 inch, two cooling racks at 15.16 by 11 by 0.65 inch and two mats at 15 by 11 inch, and states that each rack and mat fits inside the pans. EWFEN publishes nine pieces with no inch figure anywhere, and a size slot reading Standard, Medium and Large.

Do any of them cover a round or square cake tin?+

One. Angadona publishes an 8.5 in round mat for a 9 in round pan and an 8.625 in square mat for a 9 in square pan, alongside a 16.5 by 11.625 in half sheet and an 11.5 by 8.5 in quarter sheet. The other four are rectangles only, whether they come with pans or not.

Why are two of these so much heavier?+

Steel. EWFEN publishes 5 lb and M MCIRCO 5.12 lb, because both include three or two stainless steel pans and the matching cooling racks. The mat only purchases publish 0.97 lb for six Angadona mats, 0.53 lb for two MMMAT mats and 0.57 lb for the single AMYONE mat. None of the five publishes a weight for one piece.

Which is the best buy if I already own the pans?+

Angadona if the pans are various, MMMAT or AMYONE if they are not. Angadona publishes four shapes with the pan each one fits. MMMAT publishes two identical half sheet mats at 11.625 by 16.5 in. AMYONE publishes a single mat at 24.5 by 16.5 in for a full size pan. Only the last two publish a thickness, both at 0.75 mm.

Which published figures on this page should not be trusted?+

Two. The EWFEN box reads 1.97 by 5.31 by 5.51 in, which is smaller than one of the three rimmed pans the listing says is inside, so it cannot describe the shipment. The AMYONE title claims 18 by 26 inches while the size slot and the fields publish 24.5 by 16.5 in, and the listing says the mat is cut for a full size pan, so the larger pair reads as the pan.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.