How the Five Compare on the Numbers
The five systems split into two groups by installation. The BRITA and PUR are dispensers that sit on a counter or shelf and hold a stated number of cups. The iSpring, Waterdrop and Amwater connect to a standard kitchen tap and are rated in gallons. That single difference decides more purchases than any other figure on this page, because a faucet mount cannot fill a pitcher in the refrigerator and a dispenser cannot run water directly from the tap.
Within each group the published numbers separate them further. The BRITA publishes 18.0 inches of depth and the iSpring 12.0 inches of height, so both need planning before they arrive. Published weights run 3.0 pounds for the BRITA, 3.09 pounds for the iSpring and 4.07 pounds for the Waterdrop. The PUR fields read 2.09 by 6.02 by 3.98 inches at 0.5 pounds, which cannot describe a 30 cup dispenser, and the Amwater publishes dimensions but no weight.
The table does not tell you how any of these systems performs in a kitchen. It lists what each maker publishes, and several cells read not published because the listing is silent. It also cannot tell you whether a faucet mount will fit your specific tap, which is the most common reason a countertop filter is returned. Check the faucet type against the compatibility note in each listing before ordering.
Dispensers That Sit on the Counter
The BRITA holds 27 cups
The BRITA X-Large 27 Cup Water Dispenser publishes a 27 cup capacity, second here only to the PUR’s stated 30 cups. It includes one Standard filter rated for 40 gallons or about two months, and the listing states that switching to a Brita system can replace up to 1,800 single use plastic bottles a year. That figure is the maker’s claim, not a measurement made here.
The dispenser publishes 18.0 inches of depth, so it needs a deep shelf or a wide counter space. It is 5.67 inches wide and 10.47 inches tall, and it weighs 3.0 pounds. The listing describes an easy locking lid, a precision pour spigot and a sticker filter indicator that shows when the filter needs changing.
The PUR is the only dishwasher safe body, and its fields do not fit it
The PUR 30-Cup Countertop Water Filter Dispenser publishes fields of 2.09 inches wide, 6.02 inches deep and 3.98 inches tall at 0.5 pounds. Nothing that size holds 30 cups, so those four figures are reported here rather than used, and the maker’s own sentences are used instead. The listing states that the body is dishwasher safe, which no other pick here claims, and that it has a pull down spout and a carrying handle for refills.
The included genuine PUR filter is certified to last for up to 40 gallons or two months of regular use. The listing states the system is NSF certified to reduce chlorine, mercury, copper and zinc. Note that the title and three of the bullets say 30 cup while the variant field reads 18 Cup, so the two published capacity figures disagree.
Faucet Mounted Systems
The iSpring shows you the filter
The iSpring CKC1C is the only pick with a clear housing, which the listing says allows a visual inspection of the filter so you know when it is time for a change. It includes a standard 5 micron carbon block cartridge that the maker states removes 95 percent of chlorine, odors, sand, silt, sediment and rust. That percentage is the maker’s published claim.
The system is 5.0 inches wide, 5.0 inches deep and 12.0 inches tall, and it weighs 3.09 pounds. Installation needs no drilling and no plumber, and the listing states it connects to most standard kitchen taps with the included wrench and adapters. A switch toggles between tap water and filtered water.
The Waterdrop pairs a time with a volume
The Waterdrop CTF-01 is rated for up to 12 months or 8,000 gallons when connected to municipal tap water, and it is the only pick to pair a time with a volume rather than giving one or the other. It uses a five stage process that the listing states reduces colloids, sediments and up to 99 percent of chlorine, and helps reduce heavy metals and hydrogen sulfide. It also enriches water with calcium, magnesium and potassium.
The listing states plainly that the filter does not reduce TDS and that it is not compatible with pull out, handheld, spray style or sensor activated faucets. It is 7.28 inches wide, 15.43 inches deep and 5.91 inches tall, and it weighs 4.07 pounds, the highest published weight here. Installation needs no drilling and no plumber.
Washable and Low Waste
The Amwater needs no power and makes no wastewater
The Amwater Countertop Water Filter uses a composite ceramic filter element that the listing states is washable. It needs no power and produces no wastewater, which no other pick here states. The five stage filtration is published as reducing heavy metals, chemical impurities, sediment and up to 99 percent of chlorine. That percentage is the maker’s claim.
The unit is 4.0 inches wide, 13.6 inches deep and 11.8 inches tall in its published fields. It publishes no weight at all, so it cannot be set against the other four on that figure. Installation is a twist on connection to most standard kitchen taps with included adapters, and the maker states it suits a kitchen, bathroom, RV or office.
What the washable element changes for the owner
A washable ceramic element is a different maintenance routine from a sealed cartridge. The Amwater listing puts 8,000 gallons in its title but no interval in months, so the owner cannot plan a wash or a change by date. The other four picks all publish a service life in gallons or months, which makes their long term upkeep easier to schedule even though their cartridges must be replaced rather than washed.
The Amwater also publishes no weight, so a buyer who needs to know what the shelf is carrying has to look elsewhere. The dimensions it does publish, 4.0 by 13.6 by 11.8 inches, sit between the iSpring’s 12.0 inch height and the Waterdrop’s 15.43 inch depth. Those three figures are what there is to compare.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
Large households that fill pitchers. The BRITA holds 27 cups and includes a filter rated for 40 gallons. Its 18.0 inch depth needs a deep shelf or a wide counter, so measure that space before ordering.
Renters who cannot drill. The iSpring, Waterdrop and Amwater all connect to standard kitchen taps with no drilling. Check your faucet type first, because the Waterdrop listing excludes pull out, handheld, spray style and sensor activated faucets.
Small kitchens with narrow shelves. The PUR is the only pick published as dishwasher safe, and its own words describe a slim body, a pull down spout and a carrying handle. Its dimension fields are too small to be a 30 cup dispenser, so measure the real thing first.
Owners who would rather not buy cartridges often. The Waterdrop is rated for up to 12 months or 8,000 gallons. The iSpring states 6 to 12 months depending on water quality. The BRITA and PUR filters are each rated for about two months.
Buyers who prefer a washable element. The Amwater uses a washable ceramic element and needs no power. Its weight is not published and its only service figure is 8,000 gallons in the title, so confirm the footprint from its 4.0 by 13.6 by 11.8 inch fields before you commit.
What We Could Not Verify
Several figures that would help a buyer compare these five are simply not in the listings. These are the gaps.
- The Amwater listing publishes no weight for the unit.
- The Amwater publishes no interval in months for washing or replacing its element, only 8,000 gallons in its title.
- The BRITA listing does not state how many stages its filter uses.
- The PUR listing does not state the number of stages in its filter.
- The iSpring listing does not publish a replacement cartridge part number.
- No listing states whether any of these systems has been measured for flow rate at the tap.