How the Five Compare on the Numbers
The five picks divide into two groups. The Trellis + Co. kit is the only one with stainless steel lids and stainless steel Pickle Helix coils, and it is the lightest at 0.85 pounds. The Honeydak kit is the only one with jars, six 24 ounce glass jars, and it is the heaviest at 9.92 pounds. The Xileanalee, Eleganttime, and Mfacoy sets are glass weights with grip handles, published at 1.85, 1.89, and 1.85 pounds.
Most of the glass sets do not publish the width, depth, or height of the individual weights. The Xileanalee listing states a 2.75 inch diameter and a 0.8 inch height in the product title and features. The Eleganttime listing states a 2.7 inch diameter. The Mfacoy listing states a 2.76 inch diameter. The Trellis + Co. kit does not publish the coil diameter, so a reader must check the jar mouth before buying.
| Specification |
Trellis + Co. |
Honeydak |
Xileanalee |
Eleganttime |
Mfacoy |
| Material |
316 stainless steel |
Glass and stainless steel |
Glass |
Glass |
Glass |
| Published weight |
0.85 lb |
9.92 lb |
1.85 lb |
1.89 lb |
1.85 lb |
| Number of weights |
3 coils |
6 weights |
4 weights |
4 weights |
4 weights |
| Jars included |
No |
6 jars |
No |
No |
No |
| Lids included |
3 stainless steel lids |
6 stainless steel lids |
No |
No |
No |
| Airlocks included |
3 waterless airlocks |
6 airlocks |
No |
No |
No |
| Published diameter |
not published |
not published |
2.75 in |
2.7 in |
2.76 in |
| Dishwasher stated |
not published |
not published |
Yes |
not published |
Yes |
| Handle type |
Coil |
Not stated |
Grip handle |
Ribbed handle |
Grip handle |
The table does not tell you how any weight performs in a jar. It does not tell you whether a coil holds a cabbage leaf better than a glass disc, or whether a grip handle is easier to pinch. It also does not tell you the diameter of the Trellis + Co. coil or the Honeydak weight, because neither maker publishes those figures. Fit and handling are left to the reader.
Stainless Steel Versus Glass in the Brine
What the makers state about material
The Trellis + Co. listing states that 316 stainless steel is the safest and cleanest material for food, and that commercial fermenting equipment uses stainless steel. The maker also states the Pickle Helix will not displace brine and cause overflow. That is a published claim, not a measurement. The glass sets take the other route: the Xileanalee maker states the glass is non-porous and lead free, and the Mfacoy maker states the glass is lead free and non-porous.
Neither material is measured here. The fact sheet gives no corrosion figure, no brine displacement figure, and no temperature figure. What it gives is the material name and the maker’s stated reason for choosing it. A reader who wants stainless steel has one pick: the Trellis + Co. kit. A reader who wants glass has four picks, and the differences among them are count, handle shape, and published diameter.
Count and coverage
The Trellis + Co. kit includes three coils. The Honeydak kit includes six weights. The Xileanalee, Eleganttime, and Mfacoy sets each include four weights. The Youeon set, which is not among the five picks, includes nine. Count matters when a reader ferments several jars at once, because one weight per jar is the usual arrangement. The Honeydak kit pairs each of its six weights with a jar, a lid, and an airlock.
The Trellis + Co. kit pairs three coils with three lids and three airlocks, but no jars. A reader who already owns wide mouth canning jars can use the kit as is. A reader who does not must buy jars separately. The glass sets are weights only, so a reader supplies jars, lids, and any airlock system. That is the practical difference the table shows.
Fit, Handling, and Cleaning
Published diameters and jar mouths
Three of the five picks publish a diameter. The Xileanalee listing states 2.75 inches. The Eleganttime listing states 2.7 inches. The Mfacoy listing states 2.76 inches. All three are intended for wide mouth mason jars, and the makers name Ball and Kerr as compatible brands. The difference between 2.7 and 2.76 inches is 0.06 inches, which is small but is the only fit figure a reader gets.
The Trellis + Co. kit and the Honeydak kit do not publish a weight diameter. The Trellis + Co. maker states the coils are for wide mouth canning jars. The Honeydak maker states the jars are wide mouth, but the weight diameter is not given. A reader with a regular mouth jar should not assume any of these fit, because no maker states regular mouth compatibility for the five picks.
Handles and cleaning
The Xileanalee maker states an easy grip handle helps remove the weight, and that a fork can retrieve it if it sits deep. The Eleganttime maker states a ribbed handle makes removal easier than other designs. The Mfacoy maker states an easy grip handle. The Trellis + Co. maker states the Pickle Helix is easily removed for a quick bite. The Honeydak maker does not describe a handle.
On cleaning, the Xileanalee and Mfacoy makers state dishwasher safe. The Eleganttime maker does not state dishwasher safe. The Trellis + Co. and Honeydak makers do not publish dishwasher instructions for the weights. The Masontops listing, which is not among the five picks, states top rack dishwasher safe, but that figure does not transfer to these products.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
Buyer who wants stainless steel only. The Trellis + Co. kit is the only pick with 316 stainless steel lids and coils. It is 0.85 pounds and includes three lids, three airlocks, and three coils, but no jars.
Buyer who wants jars included. The Honeydak kit is the only pick with jars. It includes six 24 ounce glass jars, six stainless steel lids, six weights, and six airlocks, and it is the heaviest at 9.92 pounds.
Buyer who wants four glass weights with a grip handle. The Xileanalee set publishes a 2.75 inch diameter and a 1.85 pound total. The maker states the glass is non-porous and dishwasher safe.
Buyer who wants a ribbed handle. The Eleganttime set publishes a 2.7 inch diameter and a 1.89 pound total. The maker states the ribbed handle makes removal easier than other designs.
Buyer who wants foam packed glass weights. The Mfacoy set publishes a 2.76 inch diameter and a 1.85 pound total. The maker states the weights ship in a box with pearl cotton foam.
What We Could Not Verify
Several figures a reader would want are not published by the manufacturers. These are the gaps.
- The diameter of the Trellis + Co. Pickle Helix coil is not published.
- The diameter and weight of an individual Honeydak fermenting weight are not published.
- The width, depth, and height of the Xileanalee weights are not published beyond the diameter and height in the listing text.
- The width, depth, and height of the Eleganttime weights are not published beyond the diameter in the listing text.
- The width, depth, and height of the Mfacoy weights are not published beyond the diameter in the listing text.
- No maker states how much brine a weight displaces or how much downward force it applies.