Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

Can canning salt be substituted for kosher?

Canning salt and kosher salt are both salt, but they differ in crystal size and in what else is in the jar, so the swap depends on what you are making.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

Canning salt can be substituted for kosher salt in many canning and pickling recipes, but you have to match the amount by weight rather than by volume, and you have to know whether your kosher salt contains an anti-caking agent. Canning salt is pure fine-grained sodium chloride with no iodine and no anti-caking additives, while kosher salts vary widely in crystal size and some brands add yellow prussiate of soda to keep the crystals free-flowing.

The reason the distinction matters is that salt does two jobs in preserved food. It seasons, and in brines and fermented vegetables it controls which microbes grow. Iodine and anti-caking agents can discolor pickles or cloud a brine, and a coarse kosher crystal dissolves more slowly and packs less salt into a measuring spoon than fine canning salt does. Neither of the canning guides cited on this page publishes salt figures, because salt is an ingredient rather than a specification of the canner, so the numbers below come from the canner makers and describe the equipment, not the seasoning.

What actually differs between the two salts

Both are sodium chloride. The differences are physical and incidental. Canning salt is milled fine and sold without iodine or anti-caking compounds, so it dissolves quickly and leaves a clear brine. Kosher salt is flaked or coarse by design, which makes it easy to pinch and scatter, and its larger crystals mean a tablespoon holds noticeably less salt than a tablespoon of fine canning salt. That volume gap is the single biggest reason a straight spoon-for-spoon swap goes wrong.

Some kosher salts also carry yellow prussiate of soda, an anti-caking agent. In a fresh pickle eaten within weeks it rarely matters. In a long-stored jar or a fermented crock it can contribute to cloudiness or off colors. If you are substituting, read the ingredient line on the kosher salt box: if the only word is salt, you are working with a cleaner swap than if additives are listed.

Match by weight, not by spoon

Because the crystal sizes differ, the reliable method is to weigh. A recipe written for fine canning salt assumes a certain weight per teaspoon; the same teaspoon of coarse kosher salt weighs less, so measuring by volume under-salts the batch. Weigh the salt your recipe calls for, then weigh the kosher salt to the same number. If you have no scale, expect to use more kosher salt by volume than the recipe states, and add it gradually rather than all at once.

This site has not compared salt weights across brands, and the canner makers do not publish anything about salt, so no figure for the volume difference appears here. Treat any specific conversion you see elsewhere as brand-specific. The safe habit is to taste a small batch of brine before you commit a full run of jars to it.

The canners these recipes run in

Salt choice sits inside a larger process, and the equipment sets the limits. The Best Electric Canners for Pressure and Water Bath Preserving guide compares machines that automate the heat side of the job. The NESCO NPC-9 is listed at 9 Quarts with a 9.5-quart removable nonstick inner pot, and the Presto 02144 is a 12-quart digital canner that the maker states handles both pressure canning and water bath canning. The WantJoin water bath canner is listed at 33Qt and the maker states it holds up to 11 one-quart jars.

For stovetop work, the Best Pressure Canners for Large-Batch Home Canning guide covers dial-gauge and weighted-gauge models. The Presto 01784 is listed at 24.3 Quarts and the maker states space for 7 quarts, 20 pints, or 26 half-pints of regular Mason jars. The All American 921 is listed at 21.5 Quarts and the maker states it holds about 19 pint jars or 7 quart jars. Those capacities tell you how much brine you will be mixing per run, which is where salt consistency across jars starts to matter.

Where the swap is safe and where it is not

In a boiling water bath recipe for pickles, relishes, or a simple vinegar brine, kosher salt substitutes cleanly as long as you match weight and avoid additives. The vinegar does the preserving, and the salt is there for flavor and texture. In a fermented crock of sauerkraut or kimchi, the salt concentration is the safety control, so measure carefully and do not guess. In pressure canned low-acid foods, salt is a seasoning only and plays no role in safety, so the swap is the least risky of the three.

Where kosher salt is a poor substitute is in any recipe that specifies canning salt by volume and gives no weight. You then have to convert, and conversion depends on the brand in your hand. If the recipe is a tested one from an extension service, follow its unit exactly or find a version that lists weight.

A practical routine for the swap

Weigh the salt the recipe calls for. Weigh the same amount of kosher salt. Dissolve it fully in the water or vinegar before you pack jars, and look at the liquid: a clear brine is what you want, and haze before processing is a sign to check the salt’s ingredient list. Keep a note of the brand and the weight you used so the next batch repeats.

None of the canner makers whose products appear in the two guides publish salt guidance, and this site has not compared salt brands. What the makers do publish is capacity and, in some cases, jar counts, and those are the figures to plan a batch around. The salt decision is yours to make at the counter, with a scale and the ingredient label in front of you.

Common questions

Does iodized table salt work in place of canning salt?

Iodized table salt will preserve food, but iodine and the anti-caking agents in table salt can darken pickles and cloud brine over storage. Table salt is also fine-grained and packs tightly, so a spoon holds more of it than a spoon of kosher salt. If you use it, weigh it and expect a less clear brine.

Why do some pickle recipes turn out soft when kosher salt is used?

Soft pickles usually come from too little salt in the brine, not from the kosher salt itself. Coarse kosher crystals pack less salt into a measuring spoon, so a volume swap under-salts the batch and the vegetables lose firmness. Weighing both salts to the same figure removes that variable.

Can I use kosher salt in a pressure canner recipe?

Yes. In pressure canned low-acid foods such as meats, broths, and vegetables, salt is a seasoning and plays no part in safety, so kosher salt substitutes freely. Match it by weight if the recipe gives one, and taste the liquid before you fill jars. The Presto 02144 maker states no altitude adjustment is needed for its pressure cycles.

How much brine do I need for a full canner load?

That depends on the canner. The Presto 01784 maker states space for 7 quarts, 20 pints, or 26 half-pints of regular Mason jars, and the All American 921 maker states about 19 pint jars or 7 quart jars. Mix brine to cover the jars you are actually packing, and keep a little extra on hand.

Does the type of canner change how salt behaves?

No. Salt dissolves the same way in an electric canner, a stovetop pressure canner, or a water bath pot. What changes is capacity and how many jars you process per run. The WantJoin water bath canner maker states it holds up to 11 one-quart jars, which sets how much brine you mix at once.

Is pickling salt the same thing as canning salt?

In practice the two names describe the same product: fine, pure sodium chloride with no iodine and no anti-caking agent. Either one substitutes for kosher salt by the same weight-matching method. Check the label, since a few products sold as pickling salt add anti-caking compounds that can haze a brine.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about electric canners