Explainer
Is canning salt different than regular salt?
Yes. Canning salt is pure salt with no iodine or anticaking additives, and those additives are what change how the salt dissolves and how it colors a jar of pickles.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
Yes. Canning salt is pure salt, sodium chloride with nothing added, while regular table salt carries iodine and an anticaking agent, and those additions are the whole difference. The salt itself is the same mineral. What changes is how it dissolves and what it does to the look of a jar.
That matters most in pickles, brines and fermented vegetables, where a cloudy liquid or a dark tint on the produce gets blamed on the salt. It does not matter for a pot of soup. The rest of this page covers what the additives do, how the grains differ, and how the canners this site has compared handle the volumes involved.
What is actually in each box
Canning salt, sometimes sold as pickling salt, is sodium chloride and nothing else. It is fine grained so it dissolves quickly in a cold brine. Because nothing is added, it does not cloud the liquid in a jar of pickles and it does not darken the surface of the vegetables.
Table salt is sodium chloride plus iodine, usually as potassium iodide, and an anticaking agent such as calcium silicate or sodium ferrocyanide to keep the grains free flowing in a humid kitchen. The iodine is there for thyroid health, not for flavor. The anticaking agent is there so the shaker works.
Kosher salt sits between the two. Most brands add nothing, but the grains are coarse and hollow, so a tablespoon weighs less than a tablespoon of fine canning salt. That weight difference, not the purity, is what throws off a recipe written for one and made with the other.
Why the additives matter in a jar
The iodine in table salt can react with compounds in the produce and leave pickles darker or slightly bitter over weeks in storage. The anticaking agent does not dissolve cleanly, so it hangs in the brine as a haze. Neither makes the food unsafe. Both make the jar look wrong, and appearance is how most people judge a pickle.
In fermented vegetables the effect is more practical. A cloudy brine makes it harder to see whether the batch is working, and a fine, free-flowing salt dissolves into a brine faster and more evenly than a coarse flake. Even distribution is what keeps a crock of sauerkraut from developing pockets of weak brine.
For anything that is not preserved, none of this applies. Salt in a stew, a roast or a pot of beans is salt. Use what is in the cupboard and adjust to taste.
Measuring salt by volume and by weight
Recipes written for canning usually give salt in cups, tablespoons or teaspoons, and those are cooking quantities, not product specifications. A cup of fine canning salt and a cup of coarse kosher salt do not weigh the same, so a brine made by volume from the wrong salt can land too weak or too strong. Weighing the salt removes the guesswork.
The canners this site has compared do not publish salt figures at all, because salt is not part of the appliance. What they publish is capacity, which sets how many jars a batch holds and therefore how much brine you mix. The Best Electric Canners for Pressure and Water Bath Preserving guide lists the NESCO NPC-9 at 9 Quarts and the Presto 02144 at 12 Quarts. The Best Pressure Canners for Large-Batch Home Canning guide lists the Presto 01784 with space for 7 quarts, 20 pints, or 26 half-pints of regular Mason jars.
Those figures tell you the size of the job. They say nothing about what goes in the jar, and no maker on either list publishes a salt specification, because salt is a grocery item rather than a component of the canner.
What to use when you have no canning salt
Kosher salt with no additives is the usual stand-in. Because the grains are larger, use more of it by volume than the recipe calls for, or weigh it against the figure the recipe gives. Sea salt works the same way if it is additive free. Read the label, since some sea salts carry anticaking agents too.
Table salt is the one to avoid for pickles and ferments, not because it is dangerous but because the iodine and the anticaking agent undo the reason canning salt exists. If table salt is all you have and the batch is a quick refrigerator pickle eaten within a week, the haze and the color shift are cosmetic. For a shelf-stable batch, use the pure salt.
Do not cut the salt in a tested canning recipe to make it taste less salty. In fermented vegetables the salt level controls which microbes grow, and in brined pickles it is part of the preservation, not a seasoning you can dial back.
What the compared canners publish about capacity
Salt is not a specification any canner maker lists, so the useful figures are the ones about batch size. The WantJoin water bath canner in the electric guide is listed at 33Qt in its title and described as holding up to 11 one-quart jars, with an adjustable temperature range of 86 to 212 degrees Fahrenheit and a timer range of 30 to 180 minutes. The McSunley Prep-N-Cook is 21.5 Quarts and its rack holds 7 one-quart, 9 one-pint or 12 half-pint jars.
On the pressure side, the All American 921 is 21.5 Quarts and holds approximately 19 pint jars or 7 quart jars. The Siftary is 24 Quarts with a gauge calibrated to 14.5 PSI, and the RVGMBO is 12 Quarts with settings from 15 PSI down to 10 PSI. Those pressure and capacity figures are what the makers publish. None of them publishes anything about salt, and this site has not compared salt across brands.
Match the brine you mix to the number of jars the canner holds, and mix it with a salt you can measure consistently. That is the whole relationship between salt and the equipment.
Common questions
Can I use regular table salt instead of canning salt in pickles?
You can, but the iodine and the anticaking agent can cloud the brine and darken the pickles over storage. The food is still safe. For a shelf-stable batch, pure salt gives a cleaner looking jar, and for a quick refrigerator pickle the difference is mostly cosmetic.
Is canning salt the same as kosher salt?
Not by volume. Both are usually additive free, but kosher salt grains are coarse and hollow, so a tablespoon weighs less than a tablespoon of fine canning salt. A brine measured by volume from the wrong one can come out too weak or too strong. Weigh the salt to be sure.
Does the salt type change how long I process the jars?
No. Processing time comes from the recipe and the canner, not the salt. The WantJoin water bath canner lists a timer range of 30 to 180 minutes, and the pressure canners list their pressure settings, but none of the makers publishes anything about salt affecting time.
Why do my pickles turn dark or cloudy?
The usual cause is table salt, whose iodine can darken the produce and whose anticaking agent leaves a haze in the brine. Hard water and exposure to light can do the same. Switching to pure canning salt removes one of the causes.
Can I cut the salt in a canning recipe?
Not in fermented vegetables or brined pickles. There the salt controls which microbes grow and helps preserve the batch, so it is part of the method rather than a seasoning. Adjust salt in fresh cooking instead, where it is only a matter of taste.
Do canner makers publish anything about salt?
No. Salt is a grocery item, not a part of the appliance, so the makers on both compared guides publish capacity, pressure and temperature figures instead. This site has not compared salt brands, and no salt figure appears in either guide.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.